Biography coming soon.
Archivist's Choice
The Secret Journal of Brett Colton
Kay Lynn Mangum (2004)
Genre
Spirituality / Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
12 Minutes
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
Synopsis
Sixteen-year-old Kathy Colton resents her deceased older brother, Brett, who died of leukemia when she was a toddler, leaving behind a legacy of perfection that overshadows her own life. Her perspective begins to shift dramatically when she unearths Brett's hidden journal, specifically written for her. Through his entries, Kathy discovers the true Brett: not a flawless saint, but a relatable teenager grappling with faith, love, and the harsh reality of his terminal illness. Simultaneously, Kathy is forced to tutor Jason West, the popular Mormon quarterback, an assignment she dreads but which ultimately challenges her preconceived notions about others and her own spiritual path. The novel interweaves Brett's poignant final journey with Kathy's contemporary coming-of-age, exploring themes of grief, family, first love, and the development of personal faith.
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Heartwarming, reflective, emotional, hopeful
Plot Summary
The Weight of a Perfect Brother
Sixteen-year-old Kathy Colton lives in the shadow of her older brother, Brett, who died of leukemia when she was two. Her family constantly idealizes Brett, portraying him as perfect. This fuels Kathy's resentment and feelings of inadequacy. She feels she can never measure up to this impossible standard and is tired of living with the ghost of someone she never knew. Her parents' grief, though decades old, still influences the family, making Kathy feel overlooked and misunderstood. This family pressure affects Kathy's self-perception and her interactions, leading her to create a defensive, often sarcastic, exterior.
A Journal's Discovery
On her sixteenth birthday, a significant milestone for her family, Kathy discovers a hidden journal in Brett's old room. To her astonishment, the journal is not just a personal diary but a series of entries specifically addressed to her, intended to be read when she turned sixteen. This revelation is a shock, suggesting Brett knew he wouldn't live to see her grow up and deliberately prepared this legacy. The journal immediately challenges Kathy's ideas about her brother and sparks a reluctant curiosity about the boy behind the myth, starting her on an unexpected path of discovery.
Tutoring the Quarterback
Adding to Kathy's already difficult life, she is assigned to tutor Jason West, the popular, charismatic, and attractive high school quarterback. This assignment is a source of immediate mortification for Kathy, who sees herself as an outsider and finds interacting with someone so popular daunting. Furthermore, Jason is a devout Mormon, a detail that initially creates a barrier for Kathy, who has skepticism and preconceived notions about his faith. Their initial interactions are awkward, marked by Kathy's defensiveness and Jason's attempts to bridge the social gap. This sets the stage for an unlikely connection.
Brett's Early Entries: A Glimpse of Humanity
As Kathy hesitantly begins to read Brett's journal, the entries reveal a more complex and human brother than the idealized image she's been given. Brett writes about his daily life, his struggles with school, his crushes, and his fears. He expresses frustrations, doubts, and typical teenage anxieties, slowly changing Kathy's perception of him as perfect. These early entries show Brett's vulnerability and humor, creating a connection Kathy never thought possible with her deceased brother. She starts to see him not as a saint, but as a real person, a brother she might have known.
Jason's Patience and Faith
Despite Kathy's initial resistance, Jason West is patient, kind, and genuinely interested in helping her with their tutoring sessions. His good nature and polite demeanor slowly start to break down Kathy's defensive exterior. He doesn't conform to her stereotypes of a 'popular jock' or a 'Mormon,' instead showing sincere faith and an easygoing personality. Jason's consistent kindness and his willingness to engage with Kathy on her own terms make her reconsider her judgments, not just about him, but about people in general and even about faith itself.
The Diagnosis and Its Impact
Deeper into the journal, Kathy reads about the devastating moment Brett received his leukemia diagnosis. His entries shift from typical teenage concerns to the raw fear, confusion, and sadness that accompany such an illness. He writes about the initial shock, the grueling treatments, and the emotional toll on himself and his family. This section of the journal provides Kathy with a firsthand account of her brother's suffering, giving her a deeper understanding of the family's enduring grief and the true battle Brett faced. It is a key moment in her understanding of his short life.
A Friendship Blooms
As the tutoring sessions continue, the initial awkwardness between Kathy and Jason becomes a genuine friendship. They find common ground beyond academics, sharing laughs, insights, and personal stories. Jason's easygoing nature and genuine interest in Kathy help her to open up, a stark contrast to her usual guarded self. Their conversations extend beyond schoolwork, into personal beliefs and experiences. This growing friendship provides Kathy with a much-needed connection and a safe space, allowing her to explore her own identity and feelings without the pressure of her family or the ghost of Brett.
Brett's Spiritual Journey
Amidst his physical decline, Brett's journal entries reveal a spiritual journey. He grapples with questions of life, death, and the existence of God, finding solace and strength in his faith. He writes about moments of doubt and despair, but also about spiritual experiences and a growing conviction in an afterlife. His reflections are mature beyond his years, showing deep introspection and a search for meaning in the face of his impending death. These entries offer Kathy a perspective on faith and resilience that she had previously dismissed or never considered.
Sharing Secrets
Feeling a growing trust and connection with Jason, Kathy begins to share snippets and insights from Brett's journal with him. She finds herself able to articulate the complex emotions and discoveries she's experiencing through her brother's words. Jason listens attentively, offering support and understanding, and sometimes sharing his own spiritual perspectives without being preachy. This act of sharing deepens their bond, as Kathy allows herself to be vulnerable with someone outside her immediate family, and Jason proves himself a trustworthy confidant.
The Final Entries: A Brother's Love
As Kathy nears the end of the journal, Brett's final entries are filled with acceptance and love for his little sister. He offers her advice, encouragement, and reassurance, expressing his wish for her happiness and for her to live a full life. He speaks directly to her, bridging the gap of time and death with his words. These entries show his unconditional love and his desire to guide her even after his passing, leaving Kathy with a sense of connection and comfort she never anticipated.
Confronting Family Grief
Through reading Brett's journal, Kathy understands the depth of her family's grief and how much Brett's death affected them. She realizes that their idealization of Brett was not meant to diminish her, but was a manifestation of their own pain and a way to preserve his memory. This new empathy allows her to see her parents and other family members in a new light, creating a sense of forgiveness and connection. She begins to heal the rift that had grown between them due to her resentment.
Kathy's Transformation
Kathy undergoes a significant transformation. She sheds her cynical exterior, embracing a more open and empathetic perspective on life, faith, and relationships. She no longer feels overshadowed by Brett but cherishes his memory and the unique connection made through his journal. Her friendship with Jason blossoms into a budding romance, built on mutual respect and understanding. Kathy learns to appreciate her family, herself, and the importance of faith, finding peace with her past and optimism for her future. She becomes a more confident and compassionate individual.
Principal Figures
Kathy Colton
The Protagonist
Kathy transforms from a resentful, guarded teenager into an empathetic, open-minded young woman who finds peace with her past and embraces faith and love.
Brett Colton
The Supporting
Though his physical arc is complete, his spiritual and emotional arc, as revealed through his journal, shows his journey from a typical teenager to one who finds peace and deep faith in the face of death.
Jason West
The Supporting
Jason remains largely consistent in his good nature, serving as a catalyst for Kathy's growth and demonstrating the positive influence of faith and genuine kindness.
Mrs. Colton (Kathy's Mom)
The Supporting
Her arc involves a subtle shift as Kathy's understanding of Brett's death and her family's grief allows for a deeper, more empathetic connection with her daughter.
Mr. Colton (Kathy's Dad)
The Supporting
Similar to Mrs. Colton, his arc involves a gradual reconciliation and deeper connection with Kathy as she comes to terms with Brett's legacy and their shared grief.
Mrs. Jensen
The Supporting
Remains a static character, serving as a plot catalyst.
Sarah
The Supporting
Remains a static character, providing friendship and background.
Mark
The Supporting
Remains a static character, providing friendship and background.
Themes & Insights
Grief and Healing
The novel explores the lasting impact of grief on a family and the individual journey of healing. Kathy's family has been stuck in an idealized remembrance of Brett, which, while born of love, inadvertently alienates Kathy. Through Brett's journal, Kathy not only grieves the brother she never knew but also helps her family begin to process their unresolved sorrow in a healthier way. The theme highlights that healing is a process that can take many forms and can be initiated even years after a loss, creating empathy and understanding within the family.
“Sometimes I think the hardest part about losing someone isn't the goodbye, but learning to live with the silence.”
Faith and Spirituality
Faith is a central theme, appearing in different ways for Brett, Kathy, and Jason. Brett's journal chronicles his spiritual journey as he confronts mortality, finding solace and meaning in his beliefs. Jason's Mormon faith is a gentle, positive influence on Kathy, challenging her cynicism and ideas about religion. Kathy's journey involves questioning, exploring, and ultimately embracing a spiritual dimension to life, finding comfort and guidance that she previously lacked. The book suggests that faith can be a powerful source of strength and hope in difficult times.
“Faith isn't about having all the answers. It's about trusting that there's a plan, even when you can't see it.”
Identity and Self-Discovery
Kathy's journey is one of self-discovery. She begins the novel defined by her resentment of her deceased brother's idealized image, struggling to forge her own identity. Through reading Brett's journal, she learns about him, herself, her family, and her place in the world. Her interactions with Jason further challenge her self-perception and help her break down her emotional walls. By the end, Kathy no longer feels overshadowed but embraces her unique identity, finding confidence and purpose through understanding her past and present relationships.
“I used to think I had to be perfect, like Brett. But maybe being myself, with all my flaws, is enough.”
The Power of Connection
The novel shows the importance of human connection, both across time and in the present. Brett's journal is a powerful connection from the past, allowing him to guide and comfort his sister years after his death. Kathy's growing friendship and romance with Jason show the power of genuine, empathetic connection in the present. These relationships help Kathy overcome her isolation and resentment, teaching her the value of vulnerability, understanding, and shared experience. It highlights how connections can bridge divides and foster growth.
“Even though I'm gone, I want you to know you're never alone. We're connected, always.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The Secret Journal
A posthumous journal written by Brett for Kathy.
The secret journal is the central plot device. It serves as Brett's voice from beyond the grave, allowing Kathy to connect with her deceased brother and understand him as a real person, not just an idealized memory. The journal's structure, with entries specifically for Kathy to read at sixteen, creates a direct, intimate communication that drives Kathy's personal growth and the unfolding of the story. It reveals plot details about Brett's life, his illness, and his spiritual journey, directly informing Kathy's transformation and changing her perception of her family's grief.
Dual Narrative (Implicit)
Alternating perspectives between Kathy's present and Brett's past.
The novel employs an implicit dual narrative structure, alternating between Kathy's present-day experiences (her struggles with family, her tutoring with Jason) and Brett's past experiences as revealed through his journal entries. This juxtaposition allows the reader to experience Kathy's journey of discovery simultaneously with the unfolding of Brett's life story. It creates dramatic irony and allows for a deeper understanding of both characters, showing how Brett's past directly influences Kathy's present and future, and how his story helps her navigate her own coming-of-age challenges.
The Unseen Mentor
Brett, through his journal, acts as Kathy's posthumous mentor.
Brett, despite being deceased, functions as a powerful unseen mentor for Kathy. His journal entries provide her with guidance, wisdom, and comfort, addressing issues she faces in her own life. He offers a perspective on life, death, faith, and family that she desperately needs. This device allows for a profound character development for Kathy, as she learns from her brother's experiences and insights, even though he is not physically present. It emphasizes the lasting impact individuals can have on each other, transcending the boundaries of life and death.
The Tutoring Assignment
Kathy's mandatory tutoring of Jason West.
The tutoring assignment is a crucial plot device that forces Kathy out of her comfort zone and into an unexpected relationship. By pairing her with Jason, a character who initially represents everything she resents (popularity, faith, seemingly 'perfect' life), the assignment creates conflict and subsequently, growth. It provides a separate, yet parallel, pathway for Kathy's self-discovery, allowing her to practice vulnerability and build trust outside her family. This relationship serves as a direct counterpoint and complement to her internal journey with Brett's journal.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
The book tells the story of Kathy Colton, who never knew her older brother Brett, as he died of leukemia when she was very young. On her sixteenth birthday, Kathy discovers Brett's secret journal, written specifically for her, which reveals the brother she never had the chance to know. Simultaneously, she navigates a challenging tutoring assignment with the popular quarterback, Jason West.
Similar books
The Power of a Praying Wife
Stormie Omartian
4.3
The Prophetic Imagination
Walter Brueggemann
4.3
The Pursuit of Holiness
Jerry Bridges
4.3
The Secret Daily Teachings
Rhonda Byrne
4.3
The Practice of the Presence of God
Brother Lawrence
4.3
The Poetic Edda
Unknown
4.3
The Power of Myth
Joseph Campbell
4.3
The Portable Dante
Dante Alighieri
4.2