BookBrief
I Wish You All the Best cover
Archivist's Choice

I Wish You All the Best

Mason Deaver (2019)

Genre

Psychology / Young Adult / Romance

Reading Time

329 min

Key Themes

See below

Track Your Reading

Sign in to track this book

Thrown out by their parents for being nonbinary, an anxious Ben finds unexpected solace and burgeoning love with a charismatic classmate while navigating a new school and the complexities of chosen family.

Synopsis

When Ben De Backer, a nonbinary teenager, comes out to their parents, they are immediately kicked out of their home. They move in with their estranged older sister, Hannah, and her husband, Thomas. Ben struggles with anxiety and the pain of their parents' rejection. They decide to keep their nonbinary identity mostly hidden at their new school, only confiding in Hannah, Thomas, and their therapist. Ben's plans for a quiet senior year are disrupted when Nathan Allan, a charming and persistent classmate, befriends them. As their friendship deepens, Ben finds comfort and support in Nathan. Their feelings for each other begin to evolve into romance. Ben grapples with the fear of being open about their identity while navigating their growing relationship with Nathan and slowly finding their voice. Through Nathan's acceptance and Hannah and Thomas's support, Ben confronts their past, embraces their true self, and looks towards a future filled with hope and love.
Reading time
329 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Heartwarming, Emotional, Hopeful, Authentic
✓ Read this if...
You want a heartwarming, emotional story about self-discovery, queer identity, and finding love and acceptance after trauma.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer stories with minimal emotional intensity or want to avoid themes of parental rejection and anxiety.

Plot Summary

Rejection and a New Home

Ben De Backer, a nonbinary high school senior, is thrown out of their house in Georgia by their parents after coming out to them. Their parents, deeply religious and unaccepting, make it clear Ben is no longer welcome. Distraught and suffering from a severe anxiety attack, Ben calls their estranged older sister, Hannah, who lives in North Carolina. Hannah, who Ben hasn't seen in years, immediately agrees to let Ben move in with her and her husband, Thomas. Ben packs a small bag and makes the difficult journey, overwhelmed by the sudden change and the pain of their parents' rejection. Upon arrival, Ben is quiet and withdrawn, struggling to adjust to a new environment and the presence of people they barely know, while trying to process the pain of being disowned.

A Fresh Start, Mostly Hidden

Starting at Northwood High School mid-semester, Ben is determined to remain invisible. Only Hannah, Thomas, and Ben's new therapist, Dr. Albright, know Ben's nonbinary identity and use their correct pronouns (they/them). Ben is terrified of further rejection and the potential for bullying, so they present as female at school. Despite their efforts to blend in, a charismatic and outgoing student named Nathan Allan notices Ben. Nathan, a senior, takes an immediate interest in Ben, initiating conversations and trying to make them feel welcome. Ben is wary, their anxiety making it difficult to trust or engage, but Nathan's persistent kindness slowly begins to chip away at Ben's protective shell, offering a glimmer of unexpected connection in their new, isolating reality.

Unexpected Friendship Blossoms

Nathan continues to reach out to Ben, inviting them to study sessions and eventually to hang out with his friends. Ben, initially hesitant, finds themselves gradually drawn to Nathan's genuine warmth and humor. Nathan is patient with Ben's anxiety, often providing quiet reassurance or a comfortable presence without pressure. They bond over shared interests, like art and movies, and Nathan's easygoing nature helps Ben relax in social situations, something they haven't experienced in a long time. Their friendship deepens, and Ben starts to feel a sense of belonging, a stark contrast to the isolation they felt just weeks prior. This growing connection becomes a source of comfort and stability for Ben as they navigate their new life.

The Art Show and Hidden Feelings

Ben's art class becomes an outlet for their emotions, and their talent is recognized by their teacher, Mrs. Albright (no relation to Dr. Albright). Ben's artwork, often dark and expressive, is chosen for the school's annual art show. This public display of their inner world is both terrifying and validating. Nathan is supportive, encouraging Ben to embrace their artistic voice. As the art show approaches, Ben finds themselves spending more and more time with Nathan, and their feelings for him evolve beyond friendship. Ben realizes they are falling for Nathan, a terrifying prospect given their fear of rejection and the secret of their nonbinary identity, which they still haven't shared with him.

A Confession and a New Chapter

Overwhelmed by their growing feelings for Nathan and the weight of their secret, Ben decides to come out to him. It is a moment filled with anxiety and fear, as Ben anticipates the worst possible reaction. To Ben's relief and surprise, Nathan reacts with immediate acceptance and understanding. He thanks Ben for trusting him and assures them that their identity changes nothing about how he feels. This acceptance is a turning point for Ben, allowing them to finally be their authentic self with someone outside their immediate family. Nathan's loving response deepens their bond, and they share their first kiss, marking the beginning of their romantic relationship.

Navigating a Public Relationship

Ben and Nathan's relationship blossoms, and Ben experiences a happiness they hadn't thought possible. Nathan is supportive, learning about nonbinary identities and consistently using Ben's correct pronouns in private. However, Ben's anxiety about public perception remains, and they continue to present as female at school, asking Nathan to use she/her pronouns for them in front of others. This creates a subtle tension, as Ben navigates the joy of their relationship with the fear of being fully seen. Despite this, Nathan remains patient and understanding, prioritizing Ben's comfort while subtly encouraging them to embrace their true self more openly. Their dates and shared moments become a sanctuary for Ben.

The Prom and a Public Display

As senior prom approaches, Ben is hesitant to attend, fearing the scrutiny and judgment of their peers. However, Nathan's enthusiasm and reassurance convince them to go. Ben, with Hannah's help, chooses an outfit that feels more authentic to them, a subtle deviation from their usual presentation. At prom, surrounded by their classmates, Ben experiences a mix of joy and anxiety. During a slow dance with Nathan, Ben feels a surge of courage and asks Nathan to use their correct pronouns, they/them, in that moment, even in public. Nathan immediately complies, whispering reassurances. This small, yet significant, act of public affirmation marks a major step in Ben's journey towards self-acceptance and visibility, solidifying their trust in Nathan and their relationship.

Confronting the Past

Just as Ben is beginning to feel more secure and happy, they receive an unexpected call from their mother. The call, initially seeming like an attempt to reconnect, quickly turns into a painful reminder of their parents' rejection, as their mother continues to misgender and invalidate Ben's identity. This interaction triggers a severe anxiety attack, bringing back all the trauma of being disowned. Ben is devastated and struggles to cope, feeling like their progress has been undone. Nathan, Hannah, and Thomas rally around Ben, providing unwavering support and helping them process the emotional fallout, reinforcing the love and acceptance they now have in their chosen family.

Finding Their Voice

Following the difficult conversation with their mother, Ben works through their feelings with Dr. Albright and the support of their loved ones. They realize that hiding their identity, even partially, is no longer sustainable for their mental health. As graduation approaches, Ben makes the courageous decision to come out publicly at the ceremony. They inform Hannah and Nathan of their plan, and both are proud and supportive. This decision is a powerful act of self-affirmation, signaling Ben's commitment to living authentically, regardless of external judgment. It shows their growth from a withdrawn, anxious individual to someone ready to embrace their true self fully.

Graduation and a Hopeful Future

On graduation day, Ben walks across the stage, proudly wearing a cap and gown, surrounded by their classmates, Hannah, Thomas, and Nathan. They have arranged for their name to be called with their correct pronouns. As their name is announced, Ben feels a sense of peace and triumph. While their parents are not present, the love and acceptance from Hannah, Thomas, and Nathan fill the void. This public declaration of their identity marks a significant milestone. The book concludes with Ben looking forward to college, their relationship with Nathan, and a future where they can continue to grow and thrive as their authentic self, surrounded by a supportive community that truly wishes them all the best.

Principal Figures

Ben De Backer

The Protagonist

Ben transforms from a deeply anxious and closeted individual to someone who confidently embraces and publicly asserts their nonbinary identity, finding love and a supportive chosen family.

Nathan Allan

The Supporting/Love Interest

Nathan remains a consistent source of support, evolving from a friendly classmate to a deeply committed and understanding romantic partner for Ben.

Hannah De Backer

The Supporting

Hannah re-establishes a loving and supportive relationship with Ben, becoming a key figure in their recovery and self-acceptance.

Thomas

The Supporting

Thomas provides consistent, unwavering support to Ben, solidifying his role as a loving member of Ben's new family.

Dr. Albright

The Supporting

Dr. Albright facilitates Ben's emotional healing and self-discovery, helping them develop coping mechanisms and self-acceptance.

Ben's Parents (Unnamed)

The Antagonist/Mentioned

Their unchanging rejection forces Ben to seek and build a new, accepting family.

Jamie

The Supporting

Jamie moves from initial wariness to a more accepting and friendly relationship with Ben.

Ezra

The Supporting

Ezra consistently provides a friendly and welcoming presence for Ben.

Themes & Insights

Identity and Self-Discovery

The central theme is Ben's journey to understand and embrace their nonbinary identity. After being disowned, Ben initially hides their true self, presenting as female to avoid further rejection. However, through therapy, the support of Hannah, Thomas, and especially Nathan, Ben gradually gains the courage to be authentic. The climax of this theme is Ben's decision to come out publicly at graduation, a powerful act of self-affirmation. This journey shows the struggle and ultimate triumph of living authentically.

"I was Ben De Backer. I was nonbinary. And for the first time in my life, I wasn’t scared of that anymore."

Ben De Backer (narrator)

Family and Chosen Family

The novel contrasts Ben's biological family, who reject them, with their chosen family. Ben's parents disown them due to their nonbinary identity, causing trauma. In contrast, Hannah and Thomas immediately open their home and hearts, providing unconditional love and support. Nathan and his friends also become an important part of Ben's chosen family, offering acceptance and a sense of belonging. This theme emphasizes that family is defined by love and acceptance, not just blood, and that chosen families can provide healing and stability.

"Family wasn't just blood. It was the people who chose to love you, even when you were at your worst."

Ben De Backer (narrator)

Mental Health and Anxiety

Ben's severe anxiety disorder is a prominent theme, made worse by the trauma of parental rejection and the fear of further judgment. The book realistically shows anxiety attacks, social anxiety, and the constant internal battle Ben faces. Therapy with Dr. Albright is important, giving Ben coping mechanisms and a safe space. Nathan's patience and understanding also help Ben manage their anxiety, showing the importance of supportive relationships in mental health recovery. The narrative highlights the impact of trauma on mental well-being and the path to healing.

"My anxiety was a constant companion, a heavy blanket that muffled my world and made every interaction a potential minefield."

Ben De Backer (narrator)

Love and Acceptance

The theme of love, both platonic and romantic, is central to Ben's healing. Nathan's unconditional love and acceptance are important, allowing Ben to come out and embrace their true self without fear. The love from Hannah and Thomas provides a foundation of safety and belonging. This theme explores how genuine love can be a powerful catalyst for healing and self-acceptance, creating an environment where individuals feel safe to be vulnerable and authentic. It contrasts sharply with the rejection Ben experienced, showing the power of being truly seen and loved.

"He didn’t just accept me; he celebrated me. And that was a kind of love I’d never known."

Ben De Backer (narrator)

The Power of Art

Art is an important outlet and a way of expression for Ben throughout the novel. Ben's drawings often reflect their inner turmoil, anxiety, and journey of self-discovery. Their art class provides a safe space for creativity, and their talent is recognized by their teacher. The school art show becomes a moment of vulnerability and validation for Ben, as their personal creations are put on public display. This theme highlights how creative expression can be a coping mechanism and a tool for processing emotions, especially when words fail.

"My art was the only place where I could be truly honest, where the lines and colors could scream what my mouth couldn't."

Ben De Backer (narrator)

Plot Devices & Literary Techniques

First-Person Narrative

Provides intimate access to Ben's internal world.

The story is told entirely from Ben's perspective, using a first-person narrative. This device allows readers to deeply connect with Ben's internal struggles, anxiety, and emotional journey. It provides intimate access to their thoughts, fears, and gradual shifts in self-perception, making their trauma and subsequent healing incredibly personal and impactful. The reader experiences Ben's isolation, their growing trust, and their moments of triumph directly through their own voice, fostering empathy and understanding for their unique experience.

Symbolism of Art

Ben's drawings represent their emotional state and journey.

Ben's artwork serves as a powerful symbol throughout the novel. Initially, their drawings are dark and reflect their anxiety, trauma, and hidden identity. As Ben begins to heal and accept themselves, their art subtly shifts, reflecting their growing hope and self-expression. The art show acts as a symbolic moment of public vulnerability and the first step towards Ben allowing their true self to be seen. Art becomes a non-verbal language for Ben, conveying emotions and experiences that they struggle to articulate verbally, making their internal world visible.

The 'Chosen Family' Trope

Highlights the importance of non-biological relationships for support.

This common narrative device is central to Ben's survival and healing. After being rejected by their biological parents, Ben finds unconditional love, acceptance, and support in their older sister Hannah, her husband Thomas, Nathan, and Nathan's friends. This trope emphasizes that true family is built on love and acceptance rather than blood ties, providing a powerful message of hope and resilience for LGBTQ+ individuals who may face similar familial rejection. The chosen family becomes Ben's sanctuary and the foundation for their new, happier life.

Therapy Sessions

A narrative tool for character development and processing trauma.

Ben's regular therapy sessions with Dr. Albright are not just mentioned but are integrated into the narrative. These sessions serve as a plot device to show Ben's internal processing, allowing the author to reveal Ben's past trauma, anxieties, and emotional growth in a structured way. They provide a realistic portrayal of mental health support and offer a mechanism for Ben to articulate their feelings and develop coping strategies, showcasing their journey of healing and self-acceptance, rather than just telling the reader it's happening.

Critical analysis

Notable Quotes

I wish you all the best, Ben. I really do. I hope you find whatever it is you’re looking for.

Ben's mother says this to him as he leaves home after coming out as nonbinary.

It’s funny how the people who are supposed to love you the most can sometimes hurt you the worst.

Ben reflects on their family's reaction to their identity.

Sometimes, the bravest thing you can do is ask for help.

Nathan encourages Ben to open up about their struggles.

Being nonbinary isn't a choice. It's who I am.

Ben explains their identity to someone who misunderstands.

You don't have to be perfect to be loved. You just have to be yourself.

Nathan reassures Ben about their worth.

Grief isn't just about death. It's about loss. And sometimes, you lose people who are still alive.

Ben contemplates the loss of their relationship with their parents.

It's okay to not be okay. It's okay to feel things. And it's okay to let people help you.

Nathan provides comfort and validation to Ben.

The world isn't going to suddenly become perfect just because you came out. But your world can.

Ben's therapist offers a realistic but hopeful perspective.

Love isn't about fixing someone. It's about loving them, flaws and all.

Ben realizes the nature of true love in their relationship with Nathan.

Sometimes, the strongest people are the ones who aren't afraid to show their weaknesses.

Ben reflects on Nathan's strength and vulnerability.

Your identity is yours, and no one can take that away from you.

Ben finds empowerment in their self-discovery.

It’s hard to rebuild when you feel like your foundation has crumbled.

Ben struggles with the aftermath of their family's rejection.

There’s a difference between being alone and being lonely.

Ben learns to distinguish between solitude and isolation.

Finding your voice is a journey, not a destination.

Ben's journey of self-discovery and expression.

You deserve to be happy, Ben. More than anyone I know.

Nathan expresses his deep care for Ben.

Quiz

Test Your Knowledge

Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.

10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score

Key Questions (FAQ)

"I Wish You All the Best" follows Ben De Backer, a nonbinary teenager who is kicked out of their home after coming out to their parents. They move in with their estranged older sister, Hannah, and her husband, Thomas, navigating severe anxiety and a new school where they initially try to remain closeted, until a friendship with Nathan Allan blossoms into romance.

About the author