BookBrief
Highly Illogical Behavior cover
Archivist's Choice

Highly Illogical Behavior

John Corey Whaley (2016)

Genre

Psychology / Young Adult

Reading Time

240 min

Key Themes

See below

Track Your Reading

Sign in to track this book

An ambitious girl's attempt to 'cure' her agoraphobic classmate for a college psychology project unravels into a web of unexpected friendships, hidden truths, and collapsing emotional walls.

Synopsis

Sixteen-year-old Solomon has been agoraphobic and housebound for three years, content in his isolated world of fantasy and online forums. High school senior Lisa, wanting to get into a good psychology program, decides Solomon is the right subject for her college application essay. She gets into his life, pretending to be his friend to study his condition. She brings along her charming boyfriend, Clark. As Lisa watches Solomon and records her findings, a real, though complicated, friendship starts between the three. Solomon, slowly coming out of his shell, trusts Lisa and forms a strong bond with Clark, who encourages his interests and offers a sense of normalcy. Lisa's initial deceit weighs on her, and as she gets closer to Solomon, she struggles with her manipulative plan. The truth of her project comes out, shattering Solomon's trust and making him feel betrayed. Lisa feels guilty, and their friendship ends. After a time, Clark, who genuinely cares for Solomon, helps bring them back together. Lisa apologizes sincerely, and Solomon, having gained new perspectives and a fragile sense of self-worth from their interactions, starts the hard process of rebuilding his life and their friendship. The novel ends with the three navigating their repaired relationships, suggesting Solomon's slow but hopeful journey toward healing and a more connected future.
Reading time
240 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Heartwarming, Thought-provoking, Humorous, Hopeful
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy character-driven stories about mental health, unique friendships, and the complexities of human connection, especially those with a touch of humor and heart.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer fast-paced thrillers or stories without significant emotional conflict and character introspection.

Plot Summary

A College Plan and an Unexpected Target

Lisa Pray, a driven high school student, wants to get into a good college psychology program. Her guidance counselor suggests she needs a unique extracurricular. Lisa hears a rumor about Solomon, a boy who hasn't left his house in three years because of severe agoraphobia and anxiety, after a panic attack in a crowded mall food court. Seeing a chance, Lisa plans to befriend Solomon and help him, documenting his progress for her college application. She researches agoraphobia and, with her boyfriend Clark's help, prepares to talk to Solomon's parents.

Initial Encounters and a Tentative Agreement

Lisa, with Clark, visits Solomon's house. Solomon's parents, especially his mother, are at first cautious but also want help for their son. Lisa presents her plan, mentioning her interest in psychology and her wish to help Solomon, while hinting at her college goals. Solomon, hearing the talk from his room, is at first against the intrusion. His parents agree to let Lisa try, hoping her presence might encourage him. Lisa begins her visits, slowly trying to build a relationship with Solomon, who at first talks mainly through his bedroom door, showing his deep anxiety about the outside world.

Building Trust and Introducing Clark

Over several weeks, Lisa patiently visits Solomon, talking to him about his interests, which include Star Trek and various niche hobbies. Solomon, though still hesitant, gradually starts to trust Lisa, finding comfort in her consistent presence and non-judgmental attitude. He even lets her into his room, a big step. Lisa, wanting to expand Solomon's social circle, decides to introduce Clark. Clark, with his easygoing personality, quickly gets along with Solomon, bonding over shared interests like video games and sci-fi. Their friendship develops quickly, forming an unexpected trio.

Growing Bonds and Hidden Agendas

The trio spends more time together, playing games, watching movies, and discussing life. Solomon's comfort increases, and he starts to express himself more. He develops a crush on Lisa, misunderstanding her kindness as romantic interest, which makes things awkward for Lisa, who is still with Clark. Meanwhile, Lisa continues to secretly write about Solomon's progress, feeling more guilty about using him for her college application, especially as their friendship deepens. She struggles with the ethical problem of her initial intentions versus the real connection she has formed with Solomon and Clark.

A Breakthrough and a Betrayal

Encouraged by Lisa and Clark, Solomon makes a breakthrough. He manages to step outside his house, first onto the porch, then into the yard, experiencing the world beyond his safe place for the first time in years. This moment is a triumph for everyone, especially for Lisa, who sees her 'project' happening. However, the celebration is short. Solomon accidentally finds Lisa's detailed journal entries, showing her initial reason to use him for her college application. Feeling betrayed, Solomon retreats back into himself, his fragile trust broken, and he refuses to see Lisa or Clark, devastated by the discovery.

The Aftermath and Lisa's Guilt

After the discovery, Solomon completely withdraws, refusing to leave his room or talk to anyone, including his parents, beyond basic needs. He feels foolish and used, believing his progress was just a means to an end for Lisa. Lisa feels guilt and regret. Her college application, which now feels tainted, loses its appeal. She genuinely cares for Solomon and realizes how much harm she has caused. Clark, caught in the middle, tries to help both of them, but Solomon's anger and disappointment are too deep to easily overcome. Lisa thinks about her ambition and the ethical compromises she made.

Clark's Loyalty and a New Perspective

Despite the fallout, Clark stays loyal to both Solomon and Lisa. He understands Lisa's initial intentions but also sees the real friendship that developed. He continues to visit Solomon, talking to him through the door, not pushing him to forgive Lisa but simply offering a consistent, non-judgmental presence. Clark's steady friendship gives Solomon a small bit of hope. Clark also talks to Lisa, helping her process her guilt and encouraging her to apologize sincerely, not just for her actions but for the pain she caused. He reminds her that real connection is more important than any college essay.

A Sincere Apology and a Glimmer of Hope

After some time, and with Clark's subtle encouragement, Lisa writes a heartfelt letter to Solomon, explaining her initial reasons, expressing deep regret for her deception, and acknowledging the real friendship they had formed. She doesn't ask for forgiveness but hopes for understanding. Solomon, still hurt but touched by Clark's continued visits and Lisa's persistent, non-intrusive apology, eventually agrees to see her again. Their conversation is hard, full of raw emotion, but it's a step toward reconciliation. Solomon expresses his pain, and Lisa genuinely listens, accepting the consequences of her actions without defensiveness.

Rebuilding and Moving Forward

The reconciliation is not immediate or easy, but it starts the process of healing. Solomon, with renewed support from his parents and the continued, patient friendship of Clark, and eventually Lisa, starts to tentatively re-engage with the world. He doesn't completely 'cure' his agoraphobia overnight, but he finds the courage to take small steps again, driven by a desire for real connection rather than outside pressure. Lisa, having learned a lesson about ethics and true empathy, revises her college application, focusing on a more honest and compassionate reflection of her experiences, now truly understanding human psychology beyond just a case study.

Principal Figures

Solomon

The Protagonist

Solomon gradually learns to trust and takes courageous steps towards overcoming his agoraphobia, only to face a setback, ultimately finding a more authentic path to healing through genuine connection.

Lisa Pray

The Protagonist

Lisa transforms from an ambitious, somewhat manipulative student to a more empathetic and ethically conscious individual, learning the true meaning of friendship and psychological understanding.

Clark

The Supporting

Clark remains a steady, supportive force, proving the strength of his character and friendship throughout the unfolding drama.

Solomon's Mother (Mrs. Kugel)

The Supporting

She navigates the challenges of supporting a child with severe anxiety, learning to trust outside help while maintaining her unwavering maternal love.

Solomon's Father (Mr. Kugel)

The Supporting

He consistently provides a stable and supportive environment for Solomon, embodying quiet strength and paternal love.

Guidance Counselor (Ms. Miller)

The Mentioned

Serves as an initial catalyst for Lisa's ambition, without direct involvement in the main plot.

Themes & Insights

Identity and Self-Discovery

The novel explores how Solomon, Lisa, and Clark each deal with who they are and who they want to be. Solomon's identity is defined by his agoraphobia, but through his interactions, he starts to redefine himself beyond his condition. Lisa initially bases her identity on ambition and academic success, only to discover a more authentic self through empathy and ethical reflection. Clark, too, strengthens his identity as a loyal and compassionate friend. The characters learn that true identity is not just about external achievements or perceived flaws, but about real connection and self-acceptance.

““Maybe the world was a little less scary than he’d imagined, and maybe he was a little braver than he’d thought.””

— Narrator about Solomon

Ethics of Ambition

A main theme is the moral tightrope Lisa walks as she pursues her college dreams. Her initial plan to 'fix' Solomon for a psychology project raises questions about manipulation, consent, and using human suffering for personal gain. The book shows the dangers of unchecked ambition and the importance of ethical considerations in personal and academic pursuits. Lisa's journey forces her to face the consequences of her actions and to prioritize real human connection over career advancement, leading to a more mature understanding of empathy.

““She had wanted to help Solomon, yes, but she had wanted to help herself more.””

— Narrator about Lisa

The Nature of Friendship and Trust

The evolving relationships between Solomon, Lisa, and Clark make up the emotional core of the story. The book looks at how friendships are built on trust, vulnerability, and mutual respect, and how easily that trust can be broken. Solomon's initial isolation shows his longing for connection, while Clark's steady loyalty shows the power of true friendship. Lisa's betrayal and subsequent remorse show the importance of honesty and the long, hard path to rebuilding trust, showing that real connection is essential for healing and growth.

““Trust was a fragile thing, easily broken, and nearly impossible to put back together perfectly.””

— Narrator

Mental Health and Agoraphobia

The novel provides a sensitive portrayal of agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder through Solomon's character. It shows the debilitating fear, isolation, and social stigma linked with such conditions, showing that mental illness is not a choice or a simple flaw but a complex challenge. The book shows the importance of empathy, patience, and professional help (though Lisa is not a professional) in supporting individuals with mental health issues, and how small steps can be big achievements. It also subtly critiques the societal pressure to 'fix' rather than simply understand and support.

““It wasn’t just about fear of the outside. It was about fear of everything the outside represented.””

— Solomon

Plot Devices & Literary Techniques

First-Person Dual Perspective

Alternating chapters told from Lisa's and Solomon's points of view.

The narrative alternates between Lisa's and Solomon's first-person perspectives. This device allows the reader to deeply understand both characters' internal struggles, motivations, and biases. Lisa's chapters reveal her ambitious drive and moral conflicts, while Solomon's chapters provide insight into his agoraphobia, anxieties, and unique worldview. This dual perspective creates dramatic irony, especially when their interpretations of events or feelings differ, and amplifies the impact of Lisa's eventual betrayal and the subsequent healing process.

The Journal/Case Study

Lisa's secret documentation of Solomon's progress for her college application.

Lisa's meticulously kept journal, intended as a psychology case study for her college application, serves as a crucial plot device. It initially highlights her utilitarian and somewhat detached approach to Solomon, contrasting with the genuine friendship that develops. Its discovery by Solomon is the pivotal moment of betrayal, shattering his trust and driving the story's conflict. The journal symbolizes Lisa's initial ambition and ethical dilemma, and its role in the plot forces both characters to confront difficult truths about manipulation and trust.

Solomon's House

A physical manifestation of Solomon's agoraphobia and his safe haven.

Solomon's house is more than just a setting; it's a character in itself, embodying his agoraphobia. It is his fortress, his safe haven, but also his prison. The gradual opening of its doors and the cautious steps Solomon takes outside symbolize his internal progress and struggle against his fears. The house represents both the comfort of isolation and the barrier to a full life. Its significance is heightened when Solomon retreats fully back into it after Lisa's betrayal, emphasizing the profound impact of the broken trust.

Star Trek References

A recurring motif reflecting Solomon's escapism and search for order.

Solomon's deep love for Star Trek, particularly 'The Next Generation,' is a recurring motif. The show provides him with a sense of order, logic, and an escape from his chaotic internal world. The characters and themes of Star Trek often parallel Solomon's own struggles with fear, exploration, and finding one's place in the universe. It serves as a bonding point with both Lisa and Clark, and its consistent presence underscores Solomon's intellectual curiosity and his longing for a world where problems can be logically solved.

Critical analysis

Notable Quotes

“The world is a terrifying place, and it's okay to be afraid of it.”

— Solomon's perspective on his agoraphobia.

“Sometimes the bravest thing you can do is ask for help.”

— Lisa's realization about her own struggles.

“You don't have to be fixed to be whole.”

— A central theme about accepting imperfections.

“People are like planets. They have their own gravity, and you can get pulled into their orbit without even realizing it.”

— Solomon reflecting on relationships.

“Maybe we're all just trying to find someone who makes us feel less alone in our own heads.”

— Lisa's thoughts on friendship and connection.

“Anxiety isn't a choice. It's a prison, and the key is on the inside.”

— Solomon explaining his condition.

“You can't save people. You can only love them while they save themselves.”

— Clark's insight about supporting others.

“Normal is just a setting on the dryer.”

— A humorous take on societal expectations.

“The hardest part about being broken is pretending you're not.”

— Lisa's internal conflict about her ambitions.

“We're all a little bit broken, and that's what makes us interesting.”

— Solomon finding beauty in flaws.

“Sometimes the people who seem the strongest are the ones hiding the most pain.”

— Observation about Lisa's character.

“You don't have to understand someone to love them.”

— Clark's approach to his friendship with Solomon.

“Fear is a liar. It tells you that you can't when you can.”

— A motivational moment in the story.

“The world outside is overrated. It's what's inside that counts.”

— Solomon's defense of his secluded life.

Quiz

Test Your Knowledge

Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.

10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score

Key Questions (FAQ)

The novel follows sixteen-year-old Solomon Reed, who has severe agoraphobia and hasn't left his house in three years. Ambitious high school student Lisa Praytor decides to 'fix' him as a project to boost her psychology college application, bringing along her boyfriend Clark. As the three form an unexpected friendship, their relationships become increasingly complicated, forcing them to confront their own vulnerabilities and the ethics of Lisa's initial motivations.

About the author