“Sometimes you have to accept that you can't control everything, and just let life happen.”
— Sophie reflects on her unexpected pregnancy and life changes.
Archivist's Choice
The Last Anniversary
Liane Moriarty (2006)
Genre
Mystery / Romance
Reading Time
450 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
Sophie inherits an island house tied to an unsolved mystery. She rekindles a past romance and uncovers the hidden lives of the eccentric women around her, making her redefine her own path to happiness.
Synopsis
Sophie Honeywell, always single, inherits a house on Scribbly Gum Island from Connie, her ex-boyfriend Thomas Gordon's great-aunt. Scribbly Gum Island is known for the unsolved Munro Baby mystery: a baby disappeared decades ago, and its parents, Rose and Connie, were acquitted of murder. Sophie moves to the island, joining the eccentric, secretive Gordon family, which includes Thomas, his wife, and their children. As Sophie settles into her new life and reconnects with Thomas, she gets more involved in the family's past and the Munro baby mystery.
Other family members also deal with their own secrets and desires: Grace, a young mother, plans to leave her perfect life; Margie, a housewife, makes a secret deal; and Aunt Rose, one of the original Munro parents, thinks about making independent choices. Sophie eventually finds out the truth about the Munro Baby mystery: Connie, trying to protect her sister Rose, accidentally killed the baby while trying to quiet its constant crying during a stressful, poor time. The family then hid the body and kept up the story of a kidnapping. This discovery brings a complex end to the family's long-held secret, letting them move on. Sophie finds belonging and self-discovery on the island. She chooses her own path, embracing her new family and a future without Thomas, creating her own happy ending.
Reading time
450 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Intriguing, Humorous, Heartwarming, Mysterious
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy character-driven mysteries with a strong focus on family dynamics, quirky characters, and a touch of romance, all set in a charming island community.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer fast-paced thrillers or mysteries with clear-cut villains and less emphasis on domestic drama and personal growth.
Plot Summary
An Unexpected Inheritance and a Mysterious Island
Sophie Honeywell, a single woman in her late thirties, gets an unexpected letter. It says she inherited Connie Gordon's house on Scribbly Gum Island. Connie was the sister of Thomas Gordon's grandmother, and Thomas was Sophie's ex-boyfriend, whom she regrets leaving years ago. The island is known for the unsolved Munro Baby mystery from 1959, where a baby, Alice, was found alone after her parents, Hugo and Electra Munro, disappeared. The island now has the remaining Gordon family: Thomas, his wife Sylvia, his grandmother Rose, his cousin Grace and her husband Callum and their two daughters, and his cousin Margie and her husband Lyle. Sophie, interested in the mystery and a chance to change her life, decides to move to the old house on Scribbly Gum Island. The Gordon family reacts with initial surprise and mixed feelings.
Settling into Island Life and Family Secrets
Sophie arrives on Scribbly Gum Island and immediately experiences the Gordon family's unusual ways. She meets the elegant but quiet Rose, the seemingly perfect Grace who secretly plans to leave, and the plain Margie who has her own strange secrets. Thomas and his wife Sylvia also live on the island. Sophie finds herself reconnecting with Thomas, which brings back old feelings. The islanders are obsessed with the Munro Baby mystery. Sophie quickly learns that Connie, who left her the house, was a key person in the mystery's long-standing story, being one of the first to find the baby. As Sophie starts renovating Connie's house, she finds old letters, photographs, and journals that suggest deeper links between the Gordon family and the Munro tragedy. This indicates the official story might not be complete.
Grace's Desperate Plan Unfolds
Grace, who appears to have a perfect life with her husband Callum and their two daughters, Gabi and Lola, secretly plans to disappear completely. She has saved money, bought a new identity, and arranged for a boat to take her away, leaving everything behind. She feels trapped and overwhelmed by motherhood and marriage, wanting individual freedom she believes she has lost. She tells her aunt Rose her plan. Rose is shocked but eventually understands. Grace's desperation shows a darker side beneath the island's calm surface, revealing that even content lives can hide deep unhappiness and a wish to escape.
Margie's Secret Pact and Financial Woes
Margie, often overlooked and feeling inferior to her glamorous cousin Grace, has money problems. Her husband, Lyle, made bad investments, and they are deep in debt. Margie has secretly agreed to sell a valuable painting belonging to the family, a painting once owned by Hugo Munro. This deal with a mysterious stranger adds more complexity to the family's secrets. Margie acts out of a desperate wish to protect her family and solve their financial issues, even if it means betraying family trust. Her story shows desperation and how far people will go for loved ones, contrasting with Grace's more self-focused pursuit of freedom.
Sophie's Growing Connection to the Past
As Sophie continues to look through Connie's things, she finds more direct evidence linking the Gordon family to the Munro Baby mystery. She discovers old photographs, diary entries, and letters that suggest Connie, Rose, and Verity (Thomas's deceased mother) knew more about the Munros' disappearance than they ever said. The mystery becomes less about a random unsolved case and more about a deeply hidden family secret. Sophie's renovation project accidentally brings up old memories and worries among the Gordons, especially Rose, who gets more upset by Sophie's questions. Sophie also finds herself growing closer to Thomas again, despite his marriage, which complicates her personal life alongside her detective work.
The Truth About the Munro Baby
During a very intense talk, the elderly Rose finally breaks down and tells the truth about the Munro Baby mystery. She confesses that she is Alice Munro, the baby found alone. Her biological parents, Hugo and Electra Munro, were murdered by Connie Gordon. Connie, who had a secret romantic obsession with Hugo, became angry when he rejected her and was about to leave Electra for another woman. In a fit of passion and jealousy, Connie killed them both. Rose was then raised by the Gordon family, who kept the secret to protect Connie and themselves from scandal and legal trouble. This discovery shatters the long-held story of the mysterious disappearance and explains the Gordon family's deep secrets and worries about the case.
Connie's Motive and the Family's Complicity
Rose explains Connie's dark secret in more detail. She says Connie was deeply in love with Hugo Munro. When Connie found out he planned to leave Electra, not for her, but for another woman, her jealousy and possessiveness led to murder. After killing Hugo and Electra, Connie brought baby Alice (Rose) back to the Gordon house. The rest of the family, including Rose's adoptive parents and Verity, were horrified. However, they decided to cover up the crime to protect Connie and prevent a scandal that would ruin their lives. They raised Alice as their own, never telling her the truth until now. This reveals the deep moral compromises the family made and the heavy burden of a secret carried for decades, affecting generations.
Grace's Escape and Its Aftermath
Grace begins her planned escape. She leaves her daughters a note, planning to board a boat and disappear. However, her plan fails when Callum, who suspected something, follows her. A dramatic confrontation happens, and Grace faces the reality of what she is doing and the pain she would cause her children. The intensity of the situation, plus the Munro mystery revelation, makes Grace rethink her choices. She realizes that true freedom might not mean physical escape but confronting her unhappiness and finding ways to combine her desire for individuality with her responsibilities as a mother. She decides to stay, starting the difficult process of fixing her life and relationship with Callum.
Margie's Painting and Resolution
Margie's plan to sell the valuable Munro painting moves forward, but the buyer is less trustworthy than she hoped. The painting, a key piece of evidence in the Munro mystery, is almost lost. However, with the truth about the Munro mystery now out, the painting's meaning changes. It is eventually returned. The family, now dealing with their shared trauma, supports Margie. The financial stress on Margie and Lyle is solved, not by selling the painting, but by a collective effort and new honesty within the family. Margie finds a sense of belonging and worth she lacked, realizing her family values her and she doesn't need desperate measures to feel worthy.
Sophie's New Beginning and Self-Discovery
With the Munro mystery solved and the Gordon family healing, Sophie thinks about her own life. She realizes her initial attraction to Thomas was tied to a past she needed to let go of. While she still cares for him, she understands he is not her future. Instead, Sophie finds new purpose and independence on Scribbly Gum Island. She decides to stay, embracing her new home and its unique community. She starts a small business, using her skills to help others, and makes new friends. Sophie learns that her 'fairy-tale ending' doesn't need a man to complete it, but rather self-acceptance, courage, and creating a life that truly fulfills her, on her own terms.
Principal Figures
Sophie Honeywell
The Protagonist
Sophie evolves from a woman drifting through life, fixated on a past love, to an independent individual who creates her own fulfilling future.
Thomas Gordon
The Supporting
Thomas comes to terms with his past with Sophie and reaffirms his commitment to his present family life.
Grace Gordon
The Supporting
Grace attempts to escape her life but ultimately chooses to stay and confront her unhappiness within her existing family structure.
Margie Gordon
The Supporting
Margie moves from insecurity and desperation to finding validation and support within her family.
Rose Gordon
The Supporting
Rose finally unburdens herself of a lifelong secret, revealing her true identity and the truth behind the Munro Baby mystery.
Connie Gordon
The Mentioned/Catalyst
Connie's past actions are slowly unveiled, revealing her as the perpetrator of the central crime.
Sylvia Gordon
The Supporting
Sylvia's relationship with Thomas is tested by Sophie's return but ultimately endures.
Callum
The Supporting
Callum moves from obliviousness to confronting the reality of his wife's unhappiness, leading to a path of reconciliation.
Lyle
The Supporting
Lyle comes to terms with his financial mistakes and works with Margie towards a more stable future.
Hugo Munro
The Mentioned
His past actions and ultimate demise are revealed as the core of the Munro Baby mystery.
Themes & Insights
Identity and Self-Discovery
The novel looks at how characters define themselves and find personal happiness. Sophie, feeling lost, uses the inheritance to redefine her life beyond past regrets and find her own path on the island. Grace struggles with her identity as a mother versus her desire for individual freedom, leading her to consider leaving her family. Rose's entire identity rests on a lie, and her confession lets her finally live honestly. The characters' journeys show how people constantly change and the courage needed to embrace one's true desires.
“"Sometimes you have to stop waiting around -- and come up with your own fairy-tale ending."”
Secrets and Their Consequences
The entire plot centers on the decades-old Munro Baby mystery secret, which has greatly shaped the Gordon family. Connie's murder secret has long-lasting effects, influencing Rose's identity, family dynamics, and collective anxieties. Grace and Margie also keep important secrets—Grace's escape plan and Margie's painting sale—showing how secrets, even with good intentions, can isolate people and lead to desperate actions. The novel shows that while secrets can protect, they ultimately create huge burdens and prevent real connection and healing.
“"Secrets were like that. They sat in the corners of your mind, like dusty old furniture, until someone came along and started moving things around."”
The Nature of Family
The Gordon family is complex and unusual, connected by love and a devastating secret. The novel examines the sacrifices, loyalties, and betrayals within a family. It shows how family members protect each other even when facing terrible crimes, but also how such protection can lead to decades of suffering. Grace's struggle with motherhood and Margie's efforts to save her family's finances highlight the different pressures in family life. Ultimately, the book suggests that families, though flawed and complicated, also offer fundamental support and belonging.
“"Families were like that, weren't they? They were like old houses, full of strange angles and unexpected secrets."”
Regret and Second Chances
Sophie's story is largely driven by her regret over breaking up with Thomas and her wish for a second chance at love. Her move to Scribbly Gum Island is partly an attempt to revisit this past. However, the novel shows that true second chances are not always about rekindling old relationships but about creating new opportunities for growth and happiness. Grace's attempt to escape and her decision to stay also show a desire for a second chance at a fulfilling life, within her existing situation. The book suggests that while regret is a strong emotion, it can also lead to positive change.
“"You couldn't go back and change the beginning, but you could start where you were and change the ending."”
The Illusion of Perfection
Grace's seemingly perfect life, with her beautiful family and comfortable home, is a clear example of this theme. Beneath the surface, she is deeply unhappy and plans a drastic escape. The calm setting of Scribbly Gum Island itself, with its pretty charm, hides a dark, violent history. The Munro Baby mystery, first presented as a romantic disappearance, is revealed to be a brutal murder. The novel consistently uncovers layers of outward appearances to show the complex, often messy, realities of human experience and relationships.
“"Everyone had secrets, didn't they? Even the people who looked as if they had nothing to hide."”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The Unsolved Mystery
The Munro Baby mystery serves as the central enigma driving the plot.
The famously unsolved Munro Baby mystery from 1959 is the core narrative device that draws Sophie to Scribbly Gum Island and provides the overarching tension of the novel. It acts as a hook, intriguing the reader and propelling Sophie's investigation. The mystery isn't just a plot device for suspense; it's deeply intertwined with the Gordon family's history, secrets, and current dynamics, revealing how a single past event can shape generations. Its eventual resolution unearths long-buried truths and forces the characters to confront their past.
The Inherited House
Connie's house acts as a physical conduit for uncovering family secrets.
The dilapidated house Sophie inherits from Connie Gordon is more than just a setting; it's a treasure trove of clues. As Sophie renovates and explores the house, she uncovers old letters, journals, photographs, and hidden compartments that slowly reveal the truth about Connie's involvement in the Munro mystery. The house itself symbolizes the layers of family history and secrets, with each discovery in its walls bringing Sophie closer to the truth, making it an active participant in the plot's unfolding.
Multiple Perspectives/Interweaving Narratives
The story shifts focus between Sophie, Grace, and Margie, providing diverse insights.
While Sophie is the primary protagonist, the narrative frequently shifts perspective to Grace and Margie. This device allows the reader to understand the internal struggles and secret plans of these supporting characters in parallel with Sophie's investigation. It enriches the themes of individual identity and the hidden lives people lead, demonstrating that every character, even those seemingly peripheral, has a complex inner world and significant plot contributions. This interweaving creates a richer tapestry of island life and increases dramatic irony as the reader learns secrets before other characters.
Symbolism of the Island
Scribbly Gum Island represents both refuge and entrapment, beauty and hidden darkness.
Scribbly Gum Island is a potent symbol. On one hand, it's a picturesque, seemingly idyllic escape that offers Sophie a fresh start and a sense of community. On the other, it represents a place of entrapment for Grace, a site of buried secrets, and a constant reminder of the Munro tragedy that defines the Gordon family. The island's isolation both protects the family's secrets and intensifies the pressures on its inhabitants. Its beauty masks a dark history, reflecting the novel's theme of the illusion of perfection.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“A secret is only a secret if no one knows it.”
— Discussed in relation to the unsolved Munro Baby mystery on Scribbly Gum Island.
“Family is not just about blood; it's about who is there for you when you need them.”
— Sophie finds support from the unconventional family on the island.
“Love doesn't always come in the package you expect.”
— Sophie's evolving relationship with Thomas and her new life.
“The past has a way of shaping the present, whether we like it or not.”
— The historical mystery influences the current lives of the characters.
“Happiness can be found in the most ordinary moments.”
— Characters find joy in daily island life and simple pleasures.
“We all have our own versions of the truth.”
— Different perspectives on the Munro Baby mystery emerge.
“Sometimes the bravest thing you can do is ask for help.”
— Sophie learns to rely on others during her pregnancy.
“A place can hold as many memories as a person.”
— Scribbly Gum Island is filled with history and personal stories.
“Forgiveness is a gift you give yourself.”
— Characters grapple with past mistakes and grudges.
“Life is full of surprises, and not all of them are bad.”
— Sophie's unexpected pregnancy leads to positive changes.
“The heart has its own reasons, which reason does not know.”
— Romantic developments between characters defy logic.
“Every family has its own unique rhythm and chaos.”
— The dynamics of the island's interconnected families.
“Sometimes the questions are more important than the answers.”
— The mystery's unresolved aspects leave room for reflection.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
The novel follows Sophie Honeywell, who inherits a house on Scribbly Gum Island from her ex-boyfriend's aunt, Connie. As Sophie moves to the island, she becomes entangled with the eccentric Munro family, who are connected to the unsolved 'Munro Baby' mystery, while navigating her own romantic regrets and the secrets of island residents like Grace, Margie, and Aunt Rose.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
