BookBrief
Rich Like Us cover
Archivist's Choice

Rich Like Us

Nayantara Sahgal (1985)

Genre

Fiction

Reading Time

12 Minutes

Key Themes

See below

Track Your Reading

Sign in to track this book

During India's Emergency, a privileged woman's comfortable life unravels as her secret affair intertwines with the fate of a young, defiant woman targeted by the regime.

Synopsis

Set against the tumultuous backdrop of Indira Gandhi's Emergency in 1970s India, "Rich Like Us" interweaves the lives of two starkly different women whose fates are irrevocably shaped by the political upheaval. Rose, an elderly Englishwoman, observes the moral decay and corruption from her perch in a wealthy Indian household, reflecting on her past and the compromises made to survive. Her narrative runs parallel to that of Devi, a young, idealistic woman who becomes entangled in the underground resistance movement, facing the brutal realities of political dissent and state oppression. The novel explores themes of power, corruption, resistance, and the personal cost of political tyranny, contrasting the experiences of the privileged and the persecuted as India grapples with a period of authoritarian rule.
Difficulty
Medium
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Thought-provoking, somber, reflective, politically charged

Plot Summary

The Arrival of Sonali

The novel opens with Rose, a British woman who has lived in India for decades, thinking about her life and her late husband, Dev. Her stepdaughter, Sonali, a senior Indian Administrative Service (IAS) officer, arrives in Delhi, transferred from a good position. The political mood is tense, with the Emergency declared by Indira Gandhi. Sonali, known for her honesty, increasingly clashes with the corrupt system and the arbitrary power used. Rose, a more distant observer, tries to keep her quiet life while noticing the subtle changes in her social group and the unspoken worries in the city. The first scenes show the different personalities of Rose and Sonali and the oppressive mood of the Emergency.

Rose's Past and Present

Rose often mixes her current observations with memories of her past, especially her unusual marriage to Dev, an Indian nationalist and businessman. She remembers their early life together, the difficulties of their cross-cultural relationship, and raising Sonali. These memories explain Rose's deep love for India and her special view as an outsider who became an insider. She compares the hopeful early days of India's independence with the current emergency, where democratic freedoms are stopped. Her thoughts show her quiet strength and lasting love for Dev, which shaped her identity and loyalty to her adopted country.

Sonali's Moral Dilemma

Sonali, now in a less powerful government department, faces more and more moral compromises demanded by the Emergency regime. She sees widespread corruption, arbitrary arrests, and forced sterilization campaigns targeting the poor. Her colleagues and bosses, including the cynical Minister Lall, expect her to obey and not question the new order. Sonali struggles with her conscience, torn between her duty as a civil servant and her strong ethical beliefs. Her inner conflict shows the impossible choices people face trying to stay honest in a totalitarian system, making her consider the real cost of speaking out.

The Rise of Corruption

The Emergency allows corruption to grow without limits. The rich and powerful, like Minister Lall and his friends, use the situation for personal gain, getting wealth and influence through illegal means. Businesses are given based on political favoritism, not skill, and disagreement is brutally crushed. Sonali sees this growing corruption with increasing sadness, realizing how deeply it has spread into every part of society. The story shows how authoritarian governments allow and benefit from widespread wrongdoing, creating a clear difference between the stated ideals of the state and the harsh reality of its actions.

Niranjan's Story

A separate story follows Niranjan, a humble street vendor who sells toys and small items. He represents the common people who suffer most from the Emergency's policies, especially the forced sterilization drives. Niranjan's friend, another vendor, is forcibly sterilized, leaving Niranjan traumatized and afraid. This event deeply affects Niranjan, showing the regime's brutality and its disrespect for human dignity. His story adds a touching human element to the abstract political events, showing the terrible impact of state violence on the most vulnerable members of society. His quiet struggle highlights the widespread fear and helplessness felt by ordinary citizens.

Dev's Legacy and Rose's Reflection

Rose often visits the factory and business that Dev, her late husband, built. She thinks about his entrepreneurial spirit, his commitment to ethical business practices, and his vision for an independent and successful India. She compares Dev's idealism and honesty with the current widespread corruption and opportunism. These visits are a way for Rose to connect with Dev's memory and to understand the big changes that have happened in the country since he died. His legacy is a moral guide, showing how much the country has strayed from its initial nation-building ideals and how values have eroded during the Emergency.

The Minister's Demands

Minister Lall, a key figure in the corrupt government, keeps pressuring Sonali. He tries to get her to join him, offering her chances if she supports the government's plans and ignores its wrongs. He represents the tempting power of being complicit and the moral decay that comes with it. Sonali, however, firmly resists him and refuses to give up her principles, even as she knows this puts her career and possibly her freedom at risk. Her interactions with Lall show the clear division between those who profit from the Emergency and those who resist its injustices.

Rose's Intervention

Moved by Niranjan's hardship and the injustice of the forced sterilizations, Rose, despite usually staying detached, decides to act. She tries to help Niranjan by offering support and trying to navigate the complex bureaucracy to prevent more harm. This act of quiet defiance marks a change in Rose's character, showing her inner moral strength and her inability to stay silent when faced with terrible human rights abuses. Her efforts, though small, symbolize the resistance of ordinary citizens against the overwhelming power of the state, even in seemingly small acts of kindness.

Sonali's Arrest

As Sonali continues to resist the corrupt demands of the government and refuses to be silenced, she is eventually arrested. Her arrest is politically motivated, a result of her strong honesty and refusal to compromise. This event is a turning point, symbolizing the suppression of disagreement and the arbitrary nature of justice during the Emergency. Her imprisonment highlights the dangers faced by those who speak truth to power and shows the government's ruthlessness in crushing opposition, even from within its own ranks. Her fate reflects the widespread crackdown on civil liberties.

Rose's Reflection on Sonali's Fate

After Sonali's arrest, Rose thinks deeply about her stepdaughter's choices and what they mean for India's future. She sees Sonali's sacrifice as proof of her moral courage and the lasting spirit of resistance. Rose's inner thoughts explore the personal cost of political honesty and the deep impact of the Emergency on individual lives and the nation's conscience. She finds a new sense of purpose, understanding that even in the darkest times, acts of defiance and holding onto truth are very valuable. Rose's thoughts offer a somber yet hopeful view on the possibility of eventual justice and the lasting power of the human spirit.

The End of the Emergency

Towards the end of the novel, there are hints and then confirmation that the Emergency will soon end. This political change brings a sense of careful hope, suggesting that the period of oppression may soon be over. While the immediate effects of the Emergency, such as Sonali's imprisonment and the trauma inflicted on people like Niranjan, are still deeply felt, the lifting of authoritarian control offers a chance for accountability and the return of democratic freedoms. The story ends on an uncertain but hopeful note, implying that while the scars remain, there is potential for healing and a return to justice, leaving the reader to consider the long-term impact of such a difficult period on the nation and its people.

Principal Figures

Rose

The Protagonist

Rose moves from a position of quiet observation and personal reflection to a more active, albeit subtle, engagement with the injustices of the Emergency, culminating in acts of compassion and support.

Sonali

The Protagonist

Sonali transitions from a respected civil servant navigating bureaucratic challenges to a defiant individual who sacrifices her freedom for her principles, becoming a symbol of integrity against oppression.

Dev

The Supporting

Though deceased, Dev's character arc is reflected in Rose's and Sonali's continued adherence to his values, even as the world around them degenerates, highlighting the enduring power of his principles.

Lall

The Antagonist

Lall's character arc shows his increasing consolidation of power and wealth through unethical means during the Emergency, reflecting the corrupting influence of unchecked authority.

Niranjan

The Supporting

Niranjan's arc represents the tragic impact of the Emergency on the most vulnerable, moving from a struggle for survival to becoming a victim of state brutality, yet also receiving a glimmer of compassion.

Kishore

The Supporting

Kishore's arc remains relatively stable, primarily serving as a witness and confidante, reflecting the struggle of many to navigate the Emergency's complexities without direct confrontation.

The Minister's Wife

The Supporting

Her character arc remains largely static, serving as a symbolic representation of the elite's detachment and complicity, without personal growth or change.

Themes & Insights

Corruption and Power

The novel clearly shows how uncontrolled power leads to widespread corruption. The Emergency creates a situation where ethical standards are ignored, and people like Minister Lall use their positions for personal gain. This theme explores the moral decay that spreads through government, business, and society when democratic systems are suppressed. It highlights how power can corrupt completely, changing a nation's ideals into a system of favoritism and injustice, where the rich benefit at the expense of the poor. The story carefully details how this corruption works, from illegal business deals to stopping disagreement.

“The rich like us, they always get richer. It's the poor who pay the price, always.”

— Narrator/Implied sentiment of the powerful

Integrity vs. Compromise

This theme is central to Sonali's story, as she constantly faces the choice between keeping her ethical beliefs and compromising them for personal safety or career success. Her strong honesty contrasts sharply with the opportunism of characters like Lall. The novel explores the huge pressure individuals face to conform in an authoritarian government and the personal cost of resistance. It suggests that while compromise might offer immediate relief, true honesty is a deeper and ultimately more meaningful path, even if it leads to suffering. Rose's quiet honesty also reflects this theme.

“There were two kinds of people, those who bent and those who broke. Sonali had chosen to break.”

— Narrator

The Price of Dissent

The novel directly shows the severe consequences for those who speak out or act against the ruling power during the Emergency. Sonali's arrest and imprisonment are a strong example of the government's brutal suppression of disagreement. The fear put into ordinary citizens, as seen in Niranjan's story, further illustrates this theme. It explores how authoritarian governments silence opposition through arbitrary arrests, censorship, and threats, forcing individuals to weigh their conscience against their freedom and safety. The story emphasizes that the price of speaking out is often personal suffering and loss, yet it also suggests its deep moral value.

“Silence was the only safe language now, but some truths refused to be silenced.”

— Narrator

Memory and Legacy

Through Rose's frequent memories and thoughts about her late husband Dev, the novel explores the power of memory and the lasting influence of legacy. Dev's ideals and ethical business practices are a moral guide, showing the clear difference between India's past vision and its current reality under the Emergency. This theme suggests that while political situations may change, the values and principles of past generations can continue to inspire and inform resistance. Memory becomes a form of resistance, a way to preserve truth and honesty against a government that tries to rewrite history.

“Dev's India, the one he had dreamed of, was being buried, brick by brick, under this new edifice of fear and greed.”

— Rose (internal thought)

The Human Cost of Authoritarianism

This theme focuses on the terrible impact of the Emergency on the lives of ordinary people. Through characters like Niranjan, the novel exposes the human cost of policies such as forced sterilization and arbitrary arrests. It shows how big political stories often hide the individual suffering and trauma caused by state power. The dehumanizing effects of authoritarianism are shown through the loss of dignity, the spread of fear, and the destruction of personal freedoms. The novel emphasizes that behind the headlines and political talk, there are real people whose lives are permanently changed by oppressive governments.

“The city had learned to live with its fears, like a chronic disease that slowly consumed the spirit.”

— Narrator

Plot Devices & Literary Techniques

Dual Narrative Perspective

Alternating viewpoints of Rose and Sonali.

The novel primarily uses a dual narrative perspective, alternating between the viewpoints of Rose and Sonali. This allows for a multifaceted exploration of the Emergency. Rose's perspective, as an older British woman deeply ingrained in India's past, offers a reflective, often historical, and emotionally resonant view. Sonali's perspective, as a younger, principled Indian civil servant, provides an immediate, politically charged, and morally conflicted view of the current events. This juxtaposition enriches the understanding of the period and its impact on different generations and cultural backgrounds, highlighting both personal and systemic struggles.

Flashbacks

Rose's memories of her late husband, Dev.

Flashbacks are frequently employed through Rose's memories of her late husband, Dev, and their life together. These recollections serve multiple purposes: they provide historical context for India's post-independence ideals, establish Dev's character as a moral benchmark, and deepen Rose's emotional connection to the country. By contrasting the idealism of the past with the corruption of the present, the flashbacks underscore the thematic decay of values during the Emergency. They also offer insight into Rose's character, revealing her quiet strength and enduring love, and enriching the emotional depth of the narrative.

Symbolism of the City (Delhi)

Delhi as a character reflecting India's state.

Delhi itself functions as a symbolic character in the novel, reflecting the state of the nation. Its streets, government buildings, and social gatherings become backdrops that mirror the political and moral climate. The city's atmosphere shifts from one of initial idealism to one shrouded in fear, surveillance, and corruption during the Emergency. The physical spaces and social interactions within Delhi symbolize the erosion of democratic freedoms and the pervasive sense of unease. The city thus acts as a microcosm of India, showcasing the impact of the regime on its people and its soul.

Irony

Contrasting declared ideals with harsh realities.

Irony is a pervasive device, often highlighting the stark contrast between the declared ideals and justifications of the Emergency regime and the brutal realities of its implementation. For instance, the government's rhetoric about 'discipline' and 'progress' is juxtaposed with the arbitrary arrests, forced sterilizations, and rampant corruption. The title 'Rich Like Us' itself carries a layer of irony, referring to the privileged who benefit from the system while the majority suffer. This device effectively underscores the hypocrisy and moral bankruptcy of the authoritarian rule, making the injustices more poignant and impactful for the reader.

Critical analysis

Notable Quotes

Quiz

Test Your Knowledge

Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.

10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score

Key Questions (FAQ)

'Rich Like Us' by Nayantara Sahgal explores the lives of two women whose paths diverge significantly during a period of political turmoil. The novel contrasts the opportunities for the corrupt with the oppression faced by the poor and critical, highlighting how the Emergency profoundly impacts their individual destinies.

About the author