“Pretty little liars, all of them. Each with their own secrets, their own lies, their own reasons for being here.”
— Mona's internal thoughts about the girls she's observing.
Archivist's Choice
Hide and Seek
Sara Shepard (2012)
Genre
Mystery / Young Adult
Reading Time
240 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
A murdered girl's twin sister assumes her identity to uncover the dark secrets of their seemingly perfect adoptive family, only to find herself in the killer's crosshairs.
Synopsis
Emma Paxton takes on the identity of her recently murdered identical twin sister, Sutton Mercer, in the wealthy town of Rosewood. Emma wants to find Sutton's killer and learn the truth about her disappearance. As Emma lives Sutton's life, she discovers Sutton's adoptive family is not perfect. Sutton's younger sister, Laurel, is resentful and suspicious, especially when Emma (as Sutton) reconnects with Sutton's ex-boyfriend, Ethan. Emma uncovers many secrets, including her adoptive parents' odd behavior and a hidden past involving another set of twins. The investigation leads her to a shocking truth: Sutton's parents, unaware of the identical twins, adopted only one baby. The other twin, Emma, was left at the hospital. Sutton, after learning about Emma, became obsessed with her twin. The story reveals Sutton was accidentally killed by her adoptive mother, Rebecca, during a fight over Rebecca's long-lost biological child, who she thought was Emma. Rebecca, in grief and guilt, buried Sutton's body. Emma confronts Rebecca, who confesses to the accidental murder and cover-up. The series ends with Rebecca's arrest and Emma dealing with her new identity and her twin's tragic history. Emma decides to continue living as Sutton, seeking the belonging she never had, but questions about her true family and Sutton's secrets remain.
Reading time
240 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Fast
Mood
Suspenseful, Mysterious, Dramatic, Thrilling
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy fast-paced YA mysteries with plenty of twists, secrets, and high-stakes drama, similar to 'Pretty Little Liars'.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer character-driven narratives over plot-driven ones, or if you dislike stories with frequent red herrings and a focus on high school drama.
Plot Summary
A New Beginning, A Familiar Face
Emma Paxton, a foster child from a difficult background, is contacted by Laurel Mercer, who thinks Emma is her dead sister, Sutton. Emma, at first doubtful, agrees to meet Laurel and later the whole Mercer family: Ted, Kristin, and Laurel. Wanting answers about her own past and Sutton's disappearance, Emma decides to pretend to be Sutton. She quickly learns that Sutton's life was not perfect, full of secrets and difficult relationships with her friends, the 'Lying Game' group. Emma's first challenge is navigating Sutton's social circle and her complex relationship with Sutton's boyfriend, Ethan, all while trying to find clues about Sutton's killer.
Unraveling the Lying Game
Emma looks deeper into Sutton's life and discovers the 'Lying Game,' a series of elaborate pranks and tricks Sutton and her friends—Nisha, Charlotte, and Madeline—played. These games often involved manipulating others and sometimes had cruel results. Emma realizes that Sutton's past actions likely created many enemies, making her investigation harder. She struggles to keep up Sutton's persona, especially when faced with inside jokes and shared memories she does not have. The friends are suspicious of 'Sutton's' changed manner, and Emma must constantly improvise to avoid being caught, all while trying to put together the events leading to Sutton's death.
Ethan's Suspicion and Laurel's Resentment
Ethan, Sutton's boyfriend, quickly notices subtle changes in Emma's behavior, making him suspicious. He confronts 'Sutton' several times, forcing Emma to come up with believable excuses. Meanwhile, Sutton's younger sister, Laurel, shows growing resentment towards Emma, believing 'Sutton' is purposely ignoring her or acting strangely. Laurel begins spending time with Thayer, Sutton's ex-boyfriend, which further complicates the relationships within the Mercer home and Sutton's social group. Emma realizes that Laurel's actions might be a cry for attention or even a way to show her grief and anger over Sutton's disappearance or death.
Secrets of the Past
Emma finds a hidden note from Sutton mentioning a secret meeting place and a specific date. Following this lead, Emma discovers a connection between Sutton and a mysterious boy named Ethan, who is not Sutton's boyfriend, but a different Ethan. This discovery adds another layer of complexity to Sutton's life and possible reasons for her murder. Emma also learns about a past incident involving Sutton and a 'blood oath' with her friends, hinting at a shared secret that could be linked to her death. The more Emma uncovers, the more she realizes Sutton's life was a tangled web of secrets and betrayals.
The Mercer Parents' Secret
Emma overhears conversations and finds cryptic documents that suggest Ted and Kristin Mercer, Sutton's adoptive parents, are hiding a major secret about Sutton's biological family. This discovery changes Emma's focus, as she now suspects the parents might be involved or at least know more than they let on about Sutton's disappearance. The secret appears to be deeply rooted in the past and could provide a reason for someone to harm Sutton or even Emma, who is now living Sutton's life. Emma realizes that the perfect appearance of the Mercer family is falling apart, revealing a darker truth.
The Twin Reveal and Confrontation
As Emma gets closer to the truth, her identity is accidentally revealed to Ethan, Sutton's true boyfriend. He confronts Emma, who has to confess the entire story about being Sutton's twin and investigating her murder. This revelation creates a dangerous alliance but also puts Ethan in a risky position. The immediate aftermath involves a tense discussion where Emma tries to convince Ethan of the urgency and danger of her mission. The reveal also raises the stakes, as Emma now has an ally but also someone who could accidentally expose her to the wrong people.
A Near Miss and Escalating Danger
As Emma continues her investigation, she experiences several close calls and direct threats, showing that Sutton's killer knows about her progress and is trying to silence her. These incidents could include anonymous messages, suspicious accidents, or even physical confrontations. The danger grows, making Emma realize that she is not just solving a murder but also putting her own life at risk. She understands that the killer is ruthless and will stop at nothing to keep their secret buried, reinforcing the urgency of her mission to find the truth before it is too late for her.
The Confession and the Betrayal
Emma puts enough clues together to identify Sutton's killer. The confrontation is tense and emotional, revealing a shocking betrayal. The killer is someone closely connected to Sutton and the 'Lying Game' group, making the motive even more personal and tragic. The confession explains the dark side of Sutton's seemingly perfect life, exposing the resentments and jealousies that grew beneath the surface. The killer's identity changes Emma's view of Sutton's life and the people she thought she knew.
The Aftermath and Lingering Questions
With the killer identified, the immediate danger to Emma lessens, but the emotional impact is significant. The Mercer family must deal with the truth about Sutton's death and the secrets they have kept. While the main mystery of Sutton's murder is solved, the ending leaves some lingering questions about Emma's future, her relationship with the Mercers, and the full extent of the family's past. Emma's journey has changed her greatly, but the path ahead remains uncertain as she processes the revelations and considers her next steps.
The Beginning of a New Life?
Emma reflects on her journey as Sutton Mercer. She has found the truth about her twin sister's murder, but in doing so, she has also discovered her own strength and resilience. The experience has opened her eyes to the complexities of family, friendship, and deception. While the immediate threat is gone, Emma must now decide what her future holds. Does she continue to live as Sutton, or does she create her own identity? The book ends with Emma thinking about her place in the world, hinting at the challenges and choices that still lie ahead for her.
Principal Figures
Emma Paxton
The Protagonist
Emma transforms from a hesitant outsider into a confident and determined detective, finding her voice and a sense of belonging.
Sutton Mercer
The Deceased Protagonist / Catalyst
Sutton's character is revealed posthumously, evolving from a seemingly perfect girl to a complex, flawed individual whose secrets led to her demise.
Ethan
The Supporting
Ethan moves from devoted boyfriend to suspicious observer, eventually becoming a trusted, though conflicted, ally to Emma.
Laurel Mercer
The Supporting
Laurel's character grapples with the loss of her sister and the complexities of family secrets, forcing her to mature.
Ted Mercer
The Supporting
Ted's character is revealed to be more complex and morally ambiguous than initially portrayed, driven by a hidden past.
Kristin Mercer
The Supporting
Kristin's character grapples with the weight of her family's secrets, showcasing the emotional toll of deception.
Thayer
The Supporting
Thayer remains largely unchanged, serving as a red herring and a source of conflict for Emma.
Nisha
The Supporting
Nisha's character remains largely static, serving as a representation of the superficiality and potential danger within Sutton's social circle.
Themes & Insights
Identity and Deception
The novel explores how identity can change as Emma takes on Sutton's life. Emma struggles to be her twin, always questioning who Sutton truly was and, by extension, who she herself is. The 'Lying Game' itself reinforces this theme, as Sutton and her friends regularly deceive others, blurring the lines between truth and lies. The entire plot depends on Emma's deception, showing how easily one can be mistaken for another, and the deep impact of living a lie. For example, Emma constantly has to copy Sutton's mannerisms and remember details she was not there for, which challenges her own sense of self.
“How far would they go to keep the truth buried? No one can harm me now, but Emma is still fair game. And if she’s not careful, she’ll end up buried, too.”
Secrets and Consequences
Secrets drive the story. Sutton's life was built on hidden truths—from her biological parents to the elaborate 'Lying Games' she played with her friends. The Mercer family also keeps a major secret about Sutton's past. Each secret, when found, has widespread and often devastating results, leading directly to Sutton's murder and putting Emma in great danger. The book shows how keeping secrets, even with good intentions, can ruin lives and lead to tragic outcomes, such as the Mercer parents' hidden past directly affecting events.
“MY FRIENDS AND I USED TO PLAY LYING GAMES.NOW MY TWIN SISTER IS LIVING ONE.”
Family and Belonging
Emma, a foster child, longs for a sense of family and belonging, which she hopes to find by learning the truth about Sutton and her origins. The Mercer family, though seemingly perfect, is deeply fractured by secrets and unspoken resentments. Laurel's need for attention and the parents' hidden past highlight the complexities and problems within families. The novel questions what truly makes a family—blood ties, shared experiences, or mutual trust—and explores the emotional emptiness left by a lack of real connection, especially through Emma's initial isolation.
“My adoptive parents adored me, and my little sister, Laurel, copied my every move. But now that my long-lost twin, Emma, has taken my place to solve my murder, we’re both learning just how flawed my family really is.”
Trust and Betrayal
Trust and betrayal are central to the mystery. Sutton's murder results from a deep betrayal by someone she knew. Emma constantly struggles to figure out who she can trust, as everyone in Sutton's life seems to be hiding something. The 'Lying Game' itself is a series of betrayals, ruining real connections between the friends. Emma's reliance on Ethan, and the eventual discovery of the killer's identity, shows how easily trust can be broken and the devastating impact of such betrayals within close relationships.
“And if she’s not careful, she’ll end up buried, too.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
First-Person Ghost Narration
Sutton's ghost narrates the story, providing insight and suspense.
Sutton's ghost narrates the entire story in the first person, providing an omniscient yet emotionally involved perspective. This device allows the reader to understand Sutton's past actions and motivations, while also creating a sense of dramatic irony as Sutton watches Emma navigate her life. The ghost's commentary adds a layer of suspense and foreshadowing, as she often hints at dangers Emma faces or expresses frustration at Emma's misinterpretations, making the reader privy to information Emma lacks.
Mistaken Identity
Emma assumes Sutton's identity, driving the central conflict.
The entire premise of the novel hinges on Emma Paxton assuming the identity of her deceased twin sister, Sutton Mercer. This device creates immediate conflict and suspense as Emma must constantly maintain the deception, learning about Sutton's life and relationships on the fly. It also allows for character exploration, as Emma compares herself to Sutton and grapples with the ethical implications of her actions. The mistaken identity is crucial for Emma to infiltrate Sutton's world and uncover the truth about her murder.
The 'Lying Game'
A series of manipulative pranks that expose Sutton's true nature.
The 'Lying Game' is a recurring plot device that refers to the elaborate and often cruel pranks Sutton and her friends engaged in. These games serve to reveal Sutton's manipulative personality and the strained, superficial nature of her friendships. They also provide Emma with clues about potential enemies Sutton made and motives for her murder. Each mention or flashback to a 'Lying Game' incident deepens the mystery and highlights the theme of deception central to the story.
Red Herrings
Multiple characters and clues designed to mislead the reader.
The novel effectively uses red herrings to keep the reader guessing about the killer's identity. Several characters, including Thayer, the Mercer parents, and even Sutton's 'Lying Game' friends, are presented as suspicious, with motives and secrets that could link them to the murder. Clues are often introduced that point in multiple directions, creating a complex web of potential suspects and motives, only to be debunked or recontextualized later in the narrative, enhancing the mystery element.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Some secrets are meant to stay buried. Others... well, they have a way of clawing their way out.”
— A reflection on the nature of secrets within Rosewood.
“Every lie we tell creates a debt. Sooner or later, that debt has to be paid.”
— A general statement about the repercussions of deception.
“You can run, but you can't hide. Not from me.”
— A menacing message from 'A' to one of the girls.
“The truth is a tricky thing. Sometimes it hurts more than the lie.”
— One of the girls contemplating the impact of revealing a secret.
“Rosewood was a town built on secrets, paved with whispers, and haunted by ghosts.”
— A description of the town of Rosewood and its atmosphere.
“We all have a dark side. Some of us are just better at hiding it.”
— A character's internal thought about human nature and hidden aspects.
“Trust is a luxury we can't afford.”
— One of the girls expressing her distrust towards others.
“The past isn't just behind you; sometimes it's right beside you, breathing down your neck.”
— A reflection on how past events continue to affect the present.
“Being pretty doesn't make you innocent. In fact, sometimes it makes you a bigger target.”
— A cynical observation about appearances and vulnerability.
“Silence can be louder than any scream.”
— Referring to the unspoken truths and hidden meanings.
“We were all trapped in this game, and 'A' was the only one who knew the rules.”
— The girls' realization of their predicament against 'A'.
“Sometimes the person you least suspect is the one pulling all the strings.”
— A common theme in mystery, applied to the identity of 'A'.
“No one ever really changes. They just get better at pretending.”
— A character's jaded view on personal transformation.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
The story revolves around Emma, a long-lost twin, who takes the place of her recently murdered sister, Chloe, to investigate Chloe's death. Emma must navigate Chloe's seemingly perfect life, uncover family secrets, and identify the killer before she becomes the next victim.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
