“I'm not looking for a relationship. I'm looking for a distraction.”
— Garrett Graham stating his intentions early in the story.
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
A shy academic with a secret crush makes a deal with the college hockey captain for fake dates, only to discover their undeniable chemistry is anything but pretend.
Synopsis
Hannah Wells, a confident and intelligent college student, has a secret crush but struggles with past trauma around intimacy. To get her crush's attention, she approaches Garrett Graham, the cocky and popular hockey team captain. She offers to tutor him to save his GPA if he pretends to date her to make her crush jealous. Garrett, whose professional hockey dreams are at risk, agrees.
As their tutoring sessions go on, their initial dislike turns into attraction. A "fake date" ends in a real, passionate kiss, blurring their agreement's lines. They start a 'friends with benefits' arrangement, but their feelings grow, leading to jealousy and misunderstandings. Garrett, realizing he loves Hannah, makes a grand gesture to win her over. They reconcile, confess their love, and face their pasts together, starting a new beginning as a couple.
Reading time
450 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Flirty, Humorous, Romantic, Emotional
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy steamy, witty college romance with a 'fake dating' trope and a strong focus on character development and overcoming past trauma.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer low-heat romance, dislike sports settings, or are uncomfortable with characters navigating past sexual assault.
Plot Summary
A Desperate Plea and an Unlikely Alliance
Hannah Wells, a quiet music major at Briar University, has a secret crush on Justin Kohl, a charming football player. Her past trauma makes her hesitant to pursue him. Meanwhile, Garrett Graham, the hockey team captain, faces academic probation due to a failing GPA, which threatens his professional hockey dreams. Desperate, Garrett asks Hannah, known for her academic skill, to tutor him in ethics. Hannah initially refuses, finding Garrett arrogant. After some discussion, Hannah agrees to tutor him, but only if he pretends to date her to make Justin jealous and help her overcome her shyness around men, especially after a traumatic past experience. Garrett, seeing it as his only option to stay on the team, agrees to her terms, starting their unusual arrangement.
Tutoring Sessions and Growing Pains
Their tutoring sessions begin awkwardly. Hannah finds Garrett immature and easily distracted, while Garrett is frustrated by Hannah's rigid study methods. As they spend more time together, Hannah starts to see beyond Garrett's cocky exterior. She notices his genuine passion for hockey and his intelligence, despite his academic struggles. Garrett, in turn, is surprised by Hannah's sharp wit and dry humor, realizing she is not just a quiet bookworm. He also observes her discomfort with physical contact and her guarded nature, which makes him curious. During one session, Garrett comments on Hannah's appearance, which she misinterprets as an insult, leading to an argument that forces them to confront their initial ideas about each other.
The Fake Date and a Real Kiss
Garrett and Hannah attend a party as their first 'fake date' to make Justin Kohl jealous. Hannah feels uncomfortable, but Garrett, surprisingly attentive, tries to make her feel at ease. Justin does notice them, and his reaction gives Hannah a small boost of confidence. Later, after leaving the party, they share a moment outside Hannah's dorm. Garrett kisses Hannah. The kiss is intense and passionate, surprising both of them. It is more than a casual, pretend kiss and creates a spark between them, making them question their agreement and their growing feelings. Hannah is blindsided by its intensity, and Garrett by its raw emotion.
Lines Blur and Feelings Deepen
The unexpected kiss leads to a night of passion at Garrett's apartment. Hannah, despite her past trauma and initial apprehension about physical intimacy, is drawn to Garrett. Their connection is raw and powerful, and they spend the night together. The morning after is awkward but also revealing, as they both deal with what happened. Hannah is scared by the intensity of her feelings and her vulnerability. Garrett is surprised by his deep connection to Hannah. They agree to continue their 'arrangement' while acknowledging the clear shift in their relationship, silently admitting their deal is no longer just about tutoring and fake dating.
Navigating the 'Friends with Benefits' Zone
After their passionate night, Garrett and Hannah decide to start a 'friends with benefits' arrangement, hoping to keep things casual while fulfilling their original deal. However, their physical and emotional connection grows with each encounter. Garrett becomes possessive and openly jealous when other guys show interest in Hannah, especially Justin Kohl. Hannah, despite trying to stay detached, finds herself relying more on Garrett's presence and comfort. They spend more time together outside of tutoring and sex, sharing personal stories and vulnerabilities. This period has a constant push and pull, as they both try to deny the obvious romantic feelings developing between them, fearing commitment and potential heartbreak.
A Confession and a New Threat
As their bond strengthens, Hannah tells Garrett about her past trauma—a sexual assault she experienced in high school. This explains her guarded nature and her previous reluctance towards intimacy. Garrett is deeply affected by her confession, offering her constant support and understanding, which strengthens their emotional connection. He becomes protective of her. Soon after, the hockey team faces a new challenge: a rival player, who has a history of violence and a grudge against Garrett, targets him. This external threat creates tension and puts Garrett under pressure, while also showing his protective instincts towards Hannah.
Jealousy and a Misunderstanding
Garrett's jealousy over Hannah's continued interactions with Justin Kohl reaches a breaking point. He struggles with the 'friends with benefits' label, realizing he wants more than just a casual arrangement with Hannah. A misunderstanding happens when Hannah believes Garrett is still pursuing other girls, leading her to question his sincerity and their evolving relationship. Garrett, frustrated by her doubts and his inability to say his true feelings, acts out. This ends in a heated argument where harsh words are exchanged, and Hannah, feeling hurt and confused, pulls away from him, creating a rift between them. She retreats, fearing she made a mistake by opening up to him.
Garrett's Grand Gesture
After the argument, Garrett is miserable. He realizes he loves Hannah and cannot imagine his life without her. Encouraged by his teammates and his own conscience, Garrett decides to fight for her. He makes a grand, public gesture by showing up at one of Hannah's music performances. In front of an audience, he confesses his true feelings for her, apologizing for his jealousy and his past behavior, and openly declaring his love. This public display of affection and vulnerability deeply moves Hannah, who sees his sincerity and the depth of his feelings, recognizing his love is genuine and strong enough to overcome her fears and past traumas.
Reconciliation and a New Beginning
Moved by Garrett's heartfelt declaration, Hannah accepts his apology and acknowledges her own love for him. They reconcile, officially moving past their 'friends with benefits' arrangement to become a committed couple. Their relationship grows as they navigate college life, Garrett's hockey career, and Hannah's healing process. They learn to communicate openly and support each other through their individual challenges. Hannah finds strength and confidence in Garrett's love, while Garrett finds stability and emotional depth with Hannah. They commit to building a future together, with Garrett pursuing his professional hockey dreams and Hannah continuing her music studies, now with a strong, loving partner by her side.
Facing the Past and Embracing the Future
Later in the story, Hannah confronts her past trauma directly when her assaulter, a former high school acquaintance, resurfaces or is mentioned. With Garrett's support, she finds the courage to process her feelings and seek further healing. Garrett acts as her rock, providing comfort and protection, strengthening their bond. Hannah, with Garrett's help, fully embraces her strength and resilience, no longer letting her past define her present or future. Their relationship is one of deep trust, love, and mutual respect, showing their ability to overcome significant personal obstacles together and build a lasting foundation for their future.
Principal Figures
Hannah Wells
The Protagonist
From a guarded, traumatized individual, Hannah evolves into a confident woman who confronts her past and embraces love and intimacy.
Garrett Graham
The Protagonist
Garrett transforms from a self-centered jock focused solely on hockey to a loving, supportive partner who prioritizes Hannah's well-being and their shared future.
Justin Kohl
The Supporting
Remains largely static, primarily serving as a plot device to advance Hannah and Garrett's relationship.
Sabrina James
The Supporting
Sabrina's character remains consistent as a supportive best friend, with her own story developing in later books.
Logan
The Supporting
Remains a consistent, supportive friend to Garrett throughout the story.
Dean Di Laurentis
The Supporting
Remains a consistent, charming friend, with hints of his future romantic storyline.
John Tucker
The Supporting
Remains a consistent, supportive friend within the hockey team's social circle.
Coach Hayes
The Supporting
His role remains consistent as an authority figure, ensuring the team's success.
Themes & Insights
Healing from Trauma
Hannah's journey is rooted in her recovery from a past sexual assault. The book explores how this trauma affects her ability to trust, engage in intimacy, and form relationships. Garrett's patience, understanding, and support help her heal, showing that love can help overcome deep fear and pain. Her willingness to confide in Garrett and his protectiveness are central to this theme, as seen when she tells him about her past.
“"He was teaching her that being touched could be a good thing. That it could be wanted. That it could be safe."”
Identity and Self-Discovery
Both Hannah and Garrett grow significantly. Hannah learns to reclaim her confidence and confront her fears, moving beyond her identity as a victim to embrace her strength and desire. Garrett, initially defined by his hockey ambitions and cocky persona, discovers a deeper capacity for love, commitment, and emotional openness. Their relationship forces them to confront who they are and who they want to become, individually and as a couple. Garrett's realization that he wants more than casual hookups, and Hannah's journey to embrace intimacy, show this theme.
“"He was a whirlwind, a beautiful, chaotic storm, and she was willingly caught in his eye."”
Challenging First Impressions
The initial dislike and ideas Hannah and Garrett have about each other are central to the plot. Hannah sees Garrett as an arrogant jock, and Garrett views Hannah as a quiet nerd. As they spend time together, their interactions slowly reveal hidden depths, vulnerabilities, and unexpected compatibility. This theme shows the importance of looking beyond appearances and giving people a chance to show their true selves, as seen by their surprise at the intensity of their first kiss and subsequent connection.
“"He was loud and obnoxious and everything she thought she hated in a guy. And yet, she couldn’t stop thinking about him."”
The Nature of Love and Commitment
The transition from a 'fake dating' and 'friends with benefits' arrangement to a committed, loving relationship is a core part of this theme. The book explores the struggles of defining a relationship, the fear of openness, and the eventual realization that true love requires honesty, trust, and support. Garrett's grand gesture and Hannah's acceptance of his love show their commitment to each other, illustrating that love is more than just physical attraction; it is about emotional connection and mutual respect.
“"He wasn't just a distraction. He was the cure."”
Ambition and Sacrifice
Garrett's motivation for the deal stems from his ambition to play professional hockey, an ambition threatened by his academic performance. This theme explores the sacrifices and compromises individuals make to achieve their dreams, and how those dreams can change or be recontextualized when love enters the picture. While Garrett does not abandon his hockey dreams, his relationship with Hannah brings a new dimension to his life, showing that ambition can exist with, and even be strengthened by, personal relationships, as he works harder academically for her.
“"Hockey was his life. But Hannah... Hannah was everything else."”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
Fake Dating Trope
The central premise that brings the two protagonists together.
The 'fake dating' trope is the primary plot device that initiates Hannah and Garrett's relationship. Hannah proposes the arrangement to make her crush, Justin, jealous and to gain confidence, while Garrett agrees to secure tutoring. This setup forces two characters who initially dislike each other into close proximity, creating opportunities for them to discover hidden depths and develop genuine feelings. It provides a convenient, low-stakes reason for their interactions before the romantic tension becomes undeniable, allowing their emotional connection to build organically under the guise of pretense.
Friends with Benefits Arrangement
A temporary relationship status that allows for physical intimacy without immediate commitment.
Following their initial passionate encounter, Hannah and Garrett attempt a 'friends with benefits' arrangement. This device allows them to explore their undeniable physical attraction and deepening emotional connection without explicitly labeling their relationship as romantic or committing to a serious partnership. It serves as a transitional phase where the characters can test the waters, experience intimacy, and grapple with their growing feelings while trying to maintain a sense of detachment. Ultimately, it highlights the futility of trying to keep their profound connection casual, leading to the eventual desire for a committed relationship.
Past Trauma as a Barrier
Hannah's sexual assault trauma creates internal and external conflict.
Hannah's past sexual assault is a significant plot device that creates internal conflict for her and shapes her interactions, particularly regarding intimacy and trust. It explains her guarded nature, her initial aversion to physical contact, and her fear of vulnerability. This trauma serves as a major obstacle to her forming a healthy romantic relationship. Garrett's understanding and patience in the face of this trauma become a testament to his character and the depth of his love, allowing Hannah to slowly heal and trust again, driving her emotional arc.
Academic Probation
Garrett's academic struggles provide the catalyst for seeking Hannah's help.
Garrett's impending academic probation due to his failing GPA is the direct catalyst that forces him to seek out Hannah for tutoring. This device creates the initial conflict and necessity for their interaction. Without the threat to his hockey career, Garrett would likely never have approached Hannah, and their paths might not have crossed in such a significant way. It establishes the stakes for Garrett and provides a practical, believable reason for the 'deal' to be made, setting the entire plot in motion.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“You can't help who you fall for.”
— Hannah Wells reflecting on her feelings for Garrett.
“I'm not a project. I'm a person.”
— Garrett asserting his independence and self-worth.
“Sometimes the best things in life are the ones you don't plan for.”
— Hannah realizing the unexpected nature of her relationship with Garrett.
“I don't do relationships. I do hockey.”
— Garrett's initial stance on prioritizing his career over romance.
“You make me want to be a better man.”
— Garrett expressing how Hannah inspires him to change.
“Love isn't about finding someone perfect. It's about finding someone who makes you want to be better.”
— Hannah sharing her perspective on love with a friend.
“I'm not afraid of commitment. I'm afraid of losing myself in it.”
— Garrett explaining his hesitations about serious relationships.
“Sometimes you have to take a risk to get what you want.”
— Hannah encouraging Garrett to pursue his dreams.
“You're not just a distraction anymore. You're everything.”
— Garrett confessing his deepened feelings for Hannah.
“Hockey is my life, but you're my heart.”
— Garrett prioritizing Hannah alongside his passion for hockey.
“We started as a deal, but we ended up as destiny.”
— Hannah reflecting on how their arrangement evolved into something meaningful.
“I don't need saving. I need someone who stands by me.”
— Hannah asserting her strength and what she truly desires in a partner.
“The heart wants what it wants, even when the mind says it's a bad idea.”
— Garrett grappling with his feelings despite logical reservations.
“In the end, the only deal that mattered was the one we made with our hearts.”
— Narrative reflection on the central theme of the story.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
'The Deal' follows college student Hannah Wells, who tutors hockey team captain Garrett Graham to improve his grades in exchange for him pretending to date her to make her crush jealous. Their fake relationship unexpectedly turns real as they navigate attraction, personal baggage, and Garrett's professional hockey ambitions.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
