““Love isn’t a decision, it’s a feeling. If we could decide who we love, it would be a lot simpler, but a lot less magical.””
— Lexie's internal thoughts on the nature of love and her growing feelings for Rune.
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
A museum curator, unlucky in love, finds romance with a reclusive sculptor, only to discover he hides a dark secret that could shatter her dreams.
Synopsis
Ally Prince, a successful museum curator who has had bad luck with love, moves to Seattle for a new start. She is drawn to Levi Carillo, a private sculptor whose art is key to her new gallery. Their connection quickly grows into the fairytale romance Ally always wanted. However, Levi has a dark past, a secret that threatens their new love. As his old demons return, Levi spirals into darkness, pushing Ally away. Despite the danger, Ally stays by him, determined to help him face his painful memories. Together, they confront the shadows of his past, working to heal and build a future based on their strong love, showing that even the most troubled people can find hope and happiness.
Reading time
295 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Emotional, Intense, Romantic, Dark undertones, Hopeful
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy intense, angsty romance with a focus on healing from trauma, and a strong, supportive female lead.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer light-hearted romance without dark themes or a tortured hero.
Plot Summary
A Fresh Start in Seattle
Ally Prince, a successful museum curator who has always felt unlucky in love, decides to move from New York to Seattle. She takes a job offer to design a new gallery exhibit, looking for a fresh start. Her cousin, Romeo Prince, and best friend, Lexi, already live in Seattle, giving her a sense of familiarity. Ally wants to focus on her career and is not looking for romance, having grown tired of being 'just Ally' – the reliable friend and cousin, but never the one in a relationship. This move is a clear effort to rebuild her life on her own terms, away from past heartbreaks and her friends' seemingly perfect relationships.
Meeting the Enigmatic Sculptor
When she starts her new job, Ally learns that her gallery design centers on the works of a famous but private sculptor, Levi Carillo. Their collaboration is necessary for the exhibit's success, so Ally must find him. She finds Levi to be an intense and quiet man, very private and at first resistant to her presence. Despite his distant manner, Ally is immediately drawn to the strong emotion and depth in his sculptures, which often show pain, loss, and strength. This first professional meeting quickly creates a strong tension between them, suggesting a connection deeper than just art.
Unveiling Levi's Past
As Ally and Levi spend more time together, working on the exhibit, Ally starts to break down Levi's defenses. She learns that his reclusiveness comes from a tragic past, marked by great loss and suffering. He hints at a childhood scarred by abuse and neglect, followed by the devastating murder of his younger sister, Hope. This trauma has left him with severe PTSD, causing nightmares, panic attacks, and an inability to trust or form close relationships. Ally feels more and more sympathy and wants to understand the man behind the pain, even though he constantly tries to push her away and protect her from his darkness.
A Budding, Intense Romance
Against all odds, a strong romance grows between Ally and Levi. Ally's steady patience, kindness, and understanding begin to heal parts of Levi's broken spirit. He, in turn, sees Ally as a source of light and hope, a woman who accepts his darkness with fierce love. Their relationship has strong passion, deep emotional connection, and shared vulnerability. Levi starts to talk about his past, trusting Ally in ways he never has with anyone else. Ally, for her part, finds the life-changing love she always dreamed of, believing Levi is her fairytale, despite the lingering shadows.
The Threat of the Past
Just as Ally and Levi's love is at its strongest, a dark part of Levi's past returns. The man responsible for his sister Hope's murder, Damien, is released from prison on a technicality. This news shatters Levi's fragile peace and brings back his deepest fears and trauma. The idea of Damien being free, unpunished, sends Levi into a desperate desire for revenge. His PTSD worsens, and his protective instincts toward Ally become almost overwhelming, as he fears Damien might target her to hurt him. The shadow of Damien's freedom casts a threatening cloud over their new relationship, threatening to destroy everything they have built.
Levi's Descent into Darkness
Damien's return sends Levi into a dangerous spiral. His trauma resurfaces with terrifying strength, causing him to pull away from Ally emotionally and physically. He becomes fixated on finding Damien, his mind filled with thoughts of revenge. Levi believes that the only way to find peace is to make Damien pay, considering illegal and violent actions. He pushes Ally away, convinced that his darkness will harm or endanger her. He tries to shield her from his internal struggle, but in doing so, he isolates himself, leaving Ally heartbroken and worried for the man she loves, who seems to be falling deeper into a destructive hole.
Ally's Unwavering Support
Even as Levi pushes her away and retreats into his pain, Ally refuses to give up on him. She sees past his anger and self-destructive behavior, recognizing the deeply wounded man she fell in love with. Ally stands by him with steady loyalty and strong determination, reminding him of their love and the hope for a future free from his past. She tries to convince him that revenge will not bring him peace and that she is strong enough to face his demons with him. Her persistence shows her love, as she deals with his changing moods and tries to break through his hardened exterior, offering him a way back to the light.
Confronting the Past
Driven by his desire for revenge, Levi eventually finds Damien. This confrontation is intense and dangerous, pushing Levi to the edge of giving in to his darkest urges. He struggles with the powerful need to hurt the man who destroyed his family, fighting his own morals and the memory of Ally's pleas. The encounter is a key moment, forcing Levi to face the true cost of revenge and whether it will bring him the closure he seeks, or if it will only continue a cycle of violence and pain, further separating him from the life and love he has found with Ally.
A Glimmer of Hope
In a moment of deep realization, fueled by Ally's steady love and his own desperate desire for a different life, Levi makes the hard choice to step back from revenge. He realizes that killing Damien would not bring back Hope, nor would it heal his own wounds; it would only create more pain. This decision is a huge step in his healing, marking a turn from a life consumed by trauma to one embracing the possibility of a future. Ally's presence is vital in this moment, as she provides the stability he needs to pull himself back from the darkness, showing the power of unconditional love and support.
Building a Future Together
Having faced his demons and chosen healing, Levi begins the hard process of truly recovering from his past traumas. This involves therapy, open talks with Ally, and a conscious effort to manage his PTSD. Ally remains by his side, giving constant love, understanding, and encouragement. Their relationship deepens, built on shared vulnerability and strength. They learn to deal with the lingering shadows of his past together, celebrating small successes in his healing. The book ends with Ally and Levi looking toward a future together, committed to their love and the hope that they can continue to build a life filled with peace and happiness, despite the difficulties they have faced.
Principal Figures
Ally Prince
The Protagonist
Ally transforms from a woman yearning for love to one who actively fights for it, demonstrating immense strength and resilience in supporting Levi's healing.
Levi Carillo
The Protagonist/Love Interest
Levi's arc is one of profound healing, moving from a desire for vengeance to choosing a path of love, recovery, and hope.
Damien
The Antagonist
Damien serves as a static antagonist, primarily functioning to trigger Levi's internal conflict and external threats, rather than undergoing personal development.
Romeo Prince
The Supporting
Romeo remains a steadfast and supportive family figure, providing a consistent anchor for Ally.
Lexi
The Supporting
Lexi consistently offers support and friendship, acting as a stable emotional anchor for Ally.
Hope Carillo
The Mentioned
Hope's role is to provide the backstory and motivation for Levi's initial state of being and his journey towards healing.
Themes & Insights
Healing from Trauma
This theme explores the difficult process of recovering from deep psychological wounds. Levi's journey, marked by severe PTSD from his sister's murder and childhood abuse, shows how trauma can lead to isolation, anger, and a desire for revenge. Ally's steady support and the therapy Levi eventually seeks are important in his healing, showing that recovery is possible but needs courage, openness, and outside help. The story highlights that healing is not about forgetting, but about learning to live with pain and choosing life over despair, as seen when Levi decides against revenge.
““Love doesn’t heal all wounds, but it sure as hell makes the scars easier to bear.””
The Power of Unconditional Love
Unconditional love is shown as a force that can break down emotional walls and offer redemption. Ally's love for Levi is selfless; she sees past his darkness and pain to the man beneath, refusing to leave him even when he tries to push her away. Her patience, empathy, and steady presence give Levi the safety and trust he needs to start healing. This theme illustrates how true love is about acceptance, strength, and the willingness to stand by someone through their hardest struggles, guiding them toward light and hope.
““I wasn’t just falling for him; I was falling into him, completely, irrevocably. And he was falling for me too, just as broken and beautiful.””
Revenge vs. Forgiveness/Healing
A main conflict is Levi's struggle between giving in to his desire for revenge against Damien and choosing a path of healing and peace. The story details how destructive vengeance is, showing how it consumes Levi and threatens to destroy his new happiness with Ally. Ultimately, Levi's decision to forgo revenge, driven by Ally's love and his own desire for a different future, emphasizes that true justice and peace are found not in causing more pain, but in breaking cycles of violence and doing the hard work of forgiveness and personal recovery. This choice is a key moment in his character's development.
““Vengeance would taste sweet, but it would leave a bitter aftertaste that would never truly wash away.””
Finding Hope in Darkness
This theme runs through the story, especially through Levi's journey. Despite his deep trauma and the dark parts of his past, Ally represents hope – a light that promises a future beyond pain. The story explores how even in deep despair, love and connection can offer a glimmer of optimism and a reason to fight for a better life. Levi's sculptures, at first born of pain, eventually start to reflect the hope Ally brings. It shows that hope is not the absence of darkness, but the ability to see and work for light within it, making a clear choice for a brighter tomorrow.
““She was my sweet hope, my light in the darkness. And I would fight for her, for us, until my last breath.””
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The Reclusive Artist Trope
A mysterious, talented, but isolated character whose inner world is gradually unveiled.
This device is central to Levi's character. He is initially presented as a brilliant but enigmatic sculptor who shuns society, forcing Ally to actively seek him out and peel back his layers. This trope creates initial intrigue and allows for a slow reveal of his traumatic past, building tension and emotional depth as Ally navigates his guarded nature. It emphasizes the idea that profound creativity often stems from profound pain, and that true connection requires persistence and empathy to penetrate the walls built around a wounded soul.
Past Trauma as a Driving Force
A significant past event that dictates a character's present behavior and motivations.
Levi's past trauma – the murder of his sister and childhood abuse – is the primary catalyst for his reclusiveness, his PTSD, and his initial desire for vengeance. This device explains his complex behavior, justifies his emotional walls, and provides the central conflict he must overcome. It creates high emotional stakes, as his healing is directly tied to confronting and processing these deeply ingrained wounds. The re-emergence of his sister's murderer directly triggers the climax of this device, forcing Levi to choose his path.
The 'Fairytale' Expectation vs. Reality
The protagonist's idealized vision of love confronts a much messier, more challenging reality.
Ally begins the story longing for an 'epic, life-changing romance' – her 'fairytale come true.' This device sets up her initial expectations, which are then challenged by the dark and complicated reality of loving Levi. Their relationship is passionate and transformative, fulfilling her desire for epic love, but it also comes with immense pain, struggle, and the threat of a dangerous past. The story uses this contrast to explore a more mature understanding of love, one that acknowledges that true fairytales often involve confronting deep darkness and fighting for happiness, rather than a simple, problem-free romance.
Art as Emotional Expression
Sculpture serves as a non-verbal outlet for a character's deepest feelings and experiences.
Levi's sculptures are not just beautiful objects; they are a direct manifestation of his internal world. Before he can articulate his pain and trauma verbally, his art communicates his suffering, his grief, and his buried hope. This device allows Ally to connect with him on a profound level before he fully opens up, as she can 'read' his soul through his creations. It underscores the healing power of art and provides a unique insight into a character who struggles with verbal expression, making his creative process integral to his character development and his relationship with Ally.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
““Sometimes the most beautiful things are the ones that hurt the most.””
— A reflection on the pain and beauty intertwined in a deeply emotional relationship.
““You don’t just fall in love once. You fall in love over and over again with the same person.””
— Lexie's understanding of enduring love and commitment to Rune.
““Our love story wasn’t perfect, but it was ours. And that made it the most perfect story of all.””
— Lexie's acceptance of their unique and sometimes difficult journey.
““Hope is the thing with feathers that perches in the soul.””
— An allusion to Emily Dickinson, used to describe the persistent nature of hope within the characters.
““Some people are worth melting for.””
— A sentiment expressing the profound value of a loved one, even if it means personal sacrifice.
““We were two broken souls who found solace in each other’s cracks.””
— Describing Lexie and Rune's connection as two individuals who healed each other.
““Sometimes the greatest strength is not in holding on, but in letting go.””
— A lesson learned about moving forward and releasing past hurts.
““True love isn’t about finding someone perfect, it’s about finding someone who is perfectly imperfect for you.””
— Lexie's realization about the reality of love and accepting flaws.
““Every scar tells a story. And every story makes us who we are.””
— Reflecting on past experiences and how they shape identity.
““You don't get to choose who you fall in love with. It just happens.””
— An observation about the uncontrollable nature of falling in love.
““Even in the darkest of times, there is always a glimmer of hope.””
— A recurring theme of optimism despite overwhelming challenges.
““Sometimes you have to break to truly understand how to heal.””
— The idea that profound pain can be a catalyst for deeper recovery.
““Our souls recognized each other before our eyes ever did.””
— Describing an instant, deep connection between Lexie and Rune.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
Ally Prince feels perpetually unlucky in love, often overshadowed by her friends' romantic successes and her cousin Romeo's fame. She longs for an epic, life-changing romance but feels like her heart has never been truly claimed, leading to a deep sense of loneliness despite her outward success and close relationships.
