“What do you want, darling?”
— George asks Annabelle what she wants after she's been through a lot.
Archivist's Choice
Match Me If You Can
Susan Elizabeth Phillips (2005)
Genre
Romance
Reading Time
7-8 hours
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
A messy matchmaker determined to prove herself takes on a ruthless sports agent seeking the perfect trophy wife, only to find herself unexpectedly negotiating for his heart.
Synopsis
Annabelle Granger, a chaotic red-haired woman, inherits her late grandmother's Chicago matchmaking business. To save the struggling agency and prove herself, Annabelle aims to land the city's most eligible and difficult bachelor as her client: Heath Champion, a wealthy, driven sports agent. Heath, seeking the 'perfect wife' to complete his image of success, reluctantly agrees to let Annabelle find him a match, despite his skepticism about her methods. As Annabelle learns about Heath's life and introduces him to many women, an attraction sparks between them. Their professional boundaries blur, leading to intimacy and a public scandal that threatens Annabelle's new career and Heath's image. Forced into an alliance, they navigate their feelings while trying to find Heath a wife, ultimately revealing that the perfect match was right in front of them, leading to a romantic gesture and their own happy ending.
Reading time
7-8 hours
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Humorous, Romantic, Witty, Heartwarming
✓ Read this if...
You love a classic enemies-to-lovers trope with a charmingly messy heroine and a stoic, successful hero, set in the world of high-stakes matchmaking and sports.
✗ Skip this if...
You dislike romance novels with a significant power imbalance at the start or prefer plots without a 'fish out of water' element.
Plot Summary
A Matchmaker's Desperate Gambit
Annabelle Granger, a woman prone to mishaps, inherits her late grandmother's struggling matchmaking business, 'The Perfect Match.' Desperate to save it and prove herself, she targets the most eligible and difficult bachelor in Chicago: sports agent Heath Champion. Heath, known for his business sense and planned life, seeks a wife who will enhance his public image. Annabelle, despite her own chaotic life, boldly approaches him, promising to find him the ideal partner. Her methods and appearance clash with Heath's ordered existence, but her determination sparks his interest.
The Unlikely Client
Heath Champion, initially annoyed by Annabelle's persistence, finds her proposal ridiculous. He sees her as unorganized, a contrast to his sophisticated image. However, his need to find a suitable wife quickly – a public declaration he made – and Annabelle's insightful observations about his personality, lead him to reluctantly agree to become her client. He sets high standards, expecting her to fail, yet a part of him is intrigued by her spirit. Annabelle sees this as her one chance to prove her worth and save 'The Perfect Match,' dedicating herself to the task.
The Search for Perfection
Annabelle begins the challenging task of finding Heath his 'perfect' wife. She reviews candidates, but her efforts are complicated by Heath's high standards and demanding attitude. The dates she arranges are a series of socialites, career women, and heiresses, each vetted by Annabelle but deemed unsuitable by Heath. From women who are too ambitious, too demure, or not 'perfect' enough, the process is full of tension and frustration. Annabelle’s attempts to interpret Heath’s vague desires often fail, leading to awkward encounters, further cementing his belief that she is out of her depth.
Unexpected Intimacy
As Annabelle and Heath spend more time together, reviewing candidates and discussing his preferences, a familiarity develops. Annabelle, despite her clumsiness, has good intuition about people, and she starts to break through Heath's facade. Heath, in turn, finds himself intrigued by Annabelle's resilience, humor, and belief in love, even if he dismisses it as naive. Moments of vulnerability begin to surface, revealing glimpses of the real people beneath their professional roles. This growing connection complicates their business arrangement.
A Public Scandal
To get a high-profile date for Heath, Annabelle makes a miscalculation that results in a major public relations problem for him. Her well-intentioned but poorly executed plan leads to an embarrassing public incident that damages Heath's image. Heath is furious, threatening to fire her and sue 'The Perfect Match,' which would destroy her grandmother's legacy. Annabelle is devastated, feeling she has failed. This crisis forces both of them to confront the consequences of their actions and the fragile nature of their professional relationship.
The Reluctant Alliance
After the public relations disaster, Heath, despite his anger, realizes that Annabelle's unique understanding of him might be her greatest asset in controlling the narrative. He reluctantly agrees to a temporary truce, asking her to help him with damage control. They make public appearances and staged interviews, trying to spin the scandal in their favor. This collaboration brings them closer, forcing them to rely on each other. During this time, the facade between them crumbles further, as they see each other's vulnerabilities and strengths under pressure, deepening their unspoken bond.
The Grand Scheme
With her business at risk and Heath's patience low, Annabelle plans a desperate, bold move. She decides to host a highly publicized 'matchmaking event' or 'wife search' competition, framing it as a modern approach to finding Heath his ideal partner. This plan aims to find Heath a wife and generate publicity for 'The Perfect Match,' positioning it as a cutting-edge service. Heath is initially appalled by the idea of such a public spectacle, but Annabelle convinces him it's the only way to recover from the previous scandal and achieve his goal of a 'perfect' wife quickly.
Jealousy and Revelation
As the matchmaking competition goes on, with many women competing for Heath's attention, Annabelle manages the events. However, Heath finds himself distracted and annoyed by Annabelle's interactions with other men. He starts to see her in a new light, not just as his matchmaker, but as an attractive woman. This feeling of jealousy forces him to confront the possibility that his 'perfect wife' might not be among the selected candidates, but the chaotic, red-haired woman beside him, who challenges and excites him like no other.
The Perfect Match is Unveiled
During the final stages of the matchmaking competition, Heath realizes the qualities he truly values in a partner – passion, humor, resilience, and an ability to see beyond his public persona – are all in Annabelle. He understands that his definition of 'perfect' was wrong and that Annabelle, with all her imperfections, is his actual perfect match. He tries to confess his feelings, but Annabelle, hurt by his past dismissals and criticism, is hesitant to believe him. She fears he only sees her as a convenient choice, or that he will revert to his old ways of seeking perfection.
A Grand Romantic Gesture
To win Annabelle's heart and convince her, Heath Champion, the man who plans every detail of his life, must abandon his image and make a grand, public romantic gesture. He must step out of his comfort zone and openly declare his love for Annabelle, acknowledging her unique qualities and admitting his own flaws. This declaration is for Annabelle and for the world, symbolizing his complete acceptance of her and a shift in his values. He must prove he is willing to risk everything, including his reputation, for the woman who truly matches his heart.
Happily Ever After, Annabelle Style
After Heath's heartfelt public declaration, Annabelle finally believes in his changed heart and their future. They embrace a relationship that is far from the 'perfect' image Heath once sought, but is instead passionate and real, filled with laughter, challenges, and support. Annabelle's matchmaking business, 'The Perfect Match,' succeeds, becoming an example of her approach and the power of genuine connection. Heath learns to appreciate the chaos Annabelle brings into his life, finding happiness in her love. Their story concludes with them building a life together, celebrating their imperfect match.
Principal Figures
Annabelle Granger
The Protagonist
Annabelle transforms from a self-doubting 'screw-up' into a confident, successful businesswoman and finds her own true love, learning to embrace her unique qualities.
Heath Champion
The Protagonist/Love Interest
Heath evolves from a man obsessed with superficial perfection to one who values genuine connection and love, accepting Annabelle's imperfections as part of her charm.
Kevin Tucker
The Supporting
Serves as a static character, primarily contextualizing Heath's world.
Annabelle's Grandmother
The Mentioned
Her legacy is the catalyst for Annabelle's journey, inspiring her growth.
Various Matchmaking Candidates
The Supporting
Serve as a foil to Annabelle, demonstrating Heath's evolving understanding of what he truly seeks.
Themes & Insights
The Nature of Perfection vs. Authenticity
The novel explores the contrast between a constructed 'perfect' life and the messy, authentic reality of human connection. Heath Champion pursues a flawless image and a 'perfect' wife, believing these will bring him happiness. Annabelle, with her chaotic life, embodies authenticity. Through their interactions, Heath learns that true happiness and love are found not in flawlessness, but in embracing vulnerability, quirks, and the unexpected. The disastrous dates Annabelle arranges highlight how superficial perfection often lacks genuine spark, ultimately leading him to realize that Annabelle's 'imperfections' are precisely what make her perfect for him.
““He wanted perfection. She was chaos. And somehow, in the swirling mess of her, he found his own truth.””
Self-Worth and Identity
Both Annabelle and Heath deal with self-worth and identity, from different perspectives. Annabelle, having endured failures, struggles with self-doubt. Taking over her grandmother's business is her chance to prove herself and establish her identity. Heath, on the other hand, gets much of his self-worth from his professional success and public image, building an identity of controlled perfection. The narrative shows them challenging these self-perceptions, with Annabelle gaining confidence and Heath learning to value emotional connection over external validation. Their journey helps them both redefine their true worth beyond societal expectations.
““She was a disaster, a magnificent, vibrant disaster, and he was finally ready to admit he liked living in her mess.””
The Illusion of Control
Heath Champion shows a desire for control, planning every aspect of his life, from his career to his relationships. He believes that by controlling his environment, he can ensure success and avoid emotional pain. Annabelle, conversely, is a force of unpredictability, constantly disrupting Heath's ordered world. The plot shows how life, and especially love, often defies control. Heath's attempts to orchestrate his 'perfect match' repeatedly fail, forcing him to surrender to the unpredictable nature of genuine human connection. His eventual surrender to his feelings for Annabelle signifies his acceptance that true happiness lies beyond the illusion of absolute control.
““He thought he knew what he wanted. He thought he could control it. Then Annabelle Granger walked into his life and blew all his meticulously laid plans to hell.””
Love in Unexpected Places
The novel's central theme is that love often blossoms in unexpected circumstances and between unlikely people. Heath Champion is actively searching for a wife among the elite, while Annabelle Granger is merely trying to save her business by finding him one. Neither expects to fall for the other. Their initial antagonism and personality differences make their eventual romance surprising and satisfying. The story emphasizes that true compatibility isn't about shared social standing or superficial traits, but about an inexplicable connection, mutual challenge, and a willingness to see beyond initial judgments. Their journey highlights that love isn't something that can be manufactured or logically sought, but rather something that finds you when you least expect it.
““He didn't want the perfect wife. He wanted the woman who made his perfectly ordered life wonderfully, gloriously imperfect.””
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The 'Perfect' Client
Heath Champion as the ultimate challenge for the matchmaker.
Heath Champion serves as the ultimate 'impossible client' for Annabelle. His impossibly high standards, his cynical view of love, and his controlling nature create constant conflict and comedic situations. This device allows Annabelle to showcase her resilience, intuition, and unique approach to matchmaking. By making him her client, the narrative immediately establishes high stakes for Annabelle's business and personal growth, as his 'perfection' forces her to confront her own perceived imperfections and ultimately challenges his own preconceived notions of love and happiness.
The Struggling Business
Annabelle's grandmother's matchmaking business as a catalyst and motivator.
The failing matchmaking business, 'The Perfect Match,' inherited by Annabelle, acts as a powerful motivator and a ticking clock for her. It provides a concrete goal (saving the business) that drives her actions and forces her to take risks, such as pursuing Heath Champion. This device also connects Annabelle to her past and her grandmother's legacy, adding emotional depth to her journey. The success or failure of the business becomes intertwined with Annabelle's personal growth and her ability to find love, symbolizing her overcoming her own struggles with self-worth.
The Matchmaking Competition/Dates
A series of arranged dates and a public event to find Heath a wife.
The device of a series of disastrous dates and a culminating matchmaking competition serves multiple purposes. It provides comedic relief through the awkward encounters and highlights Heath's impossible standards and Annabelle's sometimes clumsy but well-intentioned efforts. Crucially, it allows Heath to interact with other women who fit his 'ideal' on paper, only to realize that none of them compare to Annabelle. This device directly facilitates Heath's internal realization that his true 'perfect match' is Annabelle, building the romantic tension and demonstrating his evolving understanding of love.
Opposites Attract Trope
The fundamental personality clash between the two protagonists.
The 'opposites attract' trope is central to the novel's romantic dynamic. Heath Champion is meticulous, controlled, wealthy, and cynical, while Annabelle Granger is chaotic, impulsive, struggling financially, and optimistic. Their stark differences create immediate friction, comedic situations, and a compelling 'will they/won't they' tension. This device allows the story to explore how seemingly incompatible individuals can find profound connection and balance in each other, challenging the notion that partners must be similar to be successful. Their journey demonstrates how each character brings out a new, essential side in the other.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“She wanted a man who would make her laugh, who would challenge her, who would look at her like she was the most beautiful woman he’d ever seen.”
— Annabelle's internal thoughts about her ideal partner.
“Sometimes you have to let go of the picture of what you thought life would be like and enjoy the story you’re actually living.”
— A general life lesson learned through the course of the story.
“He didn't just see her. He saw into her.”
— Annabelle's realization about George's understanding of her.
“Life was messy. Love was messier.”
— A reflection on the chaotic nature of life and relationships.
“Maybe what she really wanted was to be wanted.”
— Annabelle's internal struggle with her feelings and desires.
“He was a rock, and she was a storm, and somehow, they fit.”
— A metaphor describing the contrasting personalities of George and Annabelle and their compatibility.
“You don’t have to be perfect to be loved. You just have to be real.”
— A comforting thought or advice shared between characters.
“Sometimes the greatest adventures are the ones you never planned.”
— A reflection on the unexpected turns in life and romance.
“She’d spent her life trying to be what everyone else wanted, and it had left her empty.”
— Annabelle's realization about her past choices and their impact.
“He wasn't her type, and that was precisely the problem.”
— Annabelle grappling with her unexpected attraction to George.
“It wasn't about finding the perfect person, but finding the person who was perfect for you.”
— A key realization about the nature of love and relationships.
“He made her feel safe, and that was a feeling she hadn't realized she was missing.”
— Annabelle's growing comfort and trust in George.
“Sometimes a little chaos is exactly what you need to find your way.”
— A philosophical musing about the role of disorder in personal growth.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
Annabelle's primary goal is to revitalize her late grandmother's struggling matchmaking business, 'Heart to Heart'. She believes that securing Heath Champion, the city's most eligible bachelor, as her client will instantly establish her credibility and make her the most sought-after matchmaker in Chicago.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
