“The greatest gift you can give someone is your time, because when you give your time, you are giving a portion of your life that you will never get back.”
— Meredith often reflects on the value of presence and connection.

Sign in to track this book
After an unbearable loss, three women—a grieving television star, a rebellious teenager, and a long-absent mother—must confront their pasts and futures to find family.
The novel opens with Tully Hart grappling with grief after losing her best friend, Kate Ryan, to breast cancer. Tully feels lost without Kate, her anchor. Before her death, Kate made Tully promise to be there for her children, especially her rebellious teenage daughter, Marah. Tully, with no experience with motherhood or stable family life, finds this promise difficult. She moves into the Ryan family home to help Johnny, Kate's husband, and their children, Marah, Will, and Lucas. However, her attempts to connect with Marah are met with hostility. Marah blames Tully for not being able to save her mother and struggles with her own grief.
Marah Ryan, devastated by her mother's death, withdraws. She pushes away her father, Johnny, and resents Tully's presence, feeling that no one understands her pain. Seeking an escape from her grief, Marah falls in with a rebellious crowd and starts a relationship with a charming but troubled young man named Travis. Travis introduces Marah to illegal activities, including drug use and petty crime. Marah, desperate for connection and a way to numb her pain, becomes more involved in Travis's life, pushing her further from her family and into dangerous situations. This worries Tully and Johnny.
As Tully struggles with grief and Marah's rebellion, Tully's estranged mother, Dorothy Hart, also known as 'Cloud,' re-enters her life. Dorothy, a former hippie and drug addict, had abandoned Tully throughout her childhood, leaving deep emotional scars. Now, seemingly clean and sober, Dorothy appears to offer support to Tully, who is vulnerable. Tully is wary and holds resentment, but she also wants a mother's presence. Dorothy wants redemption and needs to confront the painful secrets of her past that led to her abandonment of Tully, hoping to build a real connection with her daughter.
Tully, still struggling to connect with Marah and feeling overwhelmed, impulsively agrees to go on a road trip with Dorothy. During their journey, Dorothy slowly reveals her traumatic past. She recounts growing up in an abusive home, her escape into the counterculture movement, and her struggles with drug addiction. She reveals a sexual assault she suffered, which led to Tully's conception. This revelation is devastating for Tully, forcing her to rethink her understanding of her mother's life and the reasons for her abandonment. It is a painful but necessary step towards understanding and possible forgiveness.
While Tully and Dorothy are away, Johnny struggles to manage the household and reach Marah, whose behavior worsens. He tries to be understanding, but Marah's grief and her infatuation with Travis make her resistant. Marah's involvement with Travis escalates, leading her into serious trouble. She starts stealing and participating in other illicit activities to support Travis and their lifestyle. Johnny feels helpless and fears for his daughter's safety and future, realizing he cannot pull her back alone.
Marah's dangerous lifestyle with Travis ends in a car accident. Travis, driving under the influence, crashes the car, injuring both of them. Travis dies at the scene, and Marah is critically injured and rushed to the hospital. The accident shocks the Ryan family and Tully. At the hospital, doctors tell Johnny and Tully that Marah has severe brain trauma and is in a coma, with a grim prognosis. They face the difficult decision of whether to remove her from life support, a choice that mirrors the difficult decisions Kate's family faced during her illness, bringing immense pain.
Overwhelmed by Marah's critical condition, the guilt of not being able to save her, and the resurfacing pain of her own past, Tully reaches a breaking point. Feeling alone and responsible for the tragedies, she attempts suicide by taking an overdose of pills. During this experience, Tully has a vivid spiritual encounter with Kate. Kate appears to her, offering comfort, forgiveness, and a renewed sense of purpose. Kate reminds Tully of their bond and the importance of living and fighting for those she loves, especially Marah. This experience becomes a turning point for Tully, pulling her back from the brink.
After her own near-death experience, Tully dedicates herself to Marah's recovery. She, along with Johnny, Will, and Lucas, stays at Marah's bedside. Slowly, miraculously, Marah begins to improve. Her recovery is long and difficult, requiring extensive therapy. The family supports her, showing their love. Tully, drawing strength from her vision of Kate, becomes a steady presence, helping Marah heal. This period of intense care and shared hope begins to mend the fractured relationships within the family, especially between Tully and Johnny, and prepares for Marah's eventual awakening.
After months of uncertainty, Marah finally wakes from her coma. Her memory is fractured, and she has a long road ahead, but her awakening is hopeful. The family, including Tully and Dorothy, dedicates themselves to her rehabilitation. As Marah slowly regains her abilities, she begins to process the trauma of the accident and the grief of losing her mother. Through therapy and her family's support, Marah starts to heal, physically and emotionally. This period allows for deep conversations, apologies, and forgiveness, especially between Marah and Tully, and between Tully and Dorothy. Old wounds begin to close, and new bonds form, allowing them to move forward.
After Marah's recovery, the Ryan family, now including Tully and Dorothy more permanently, begins to create a new normal. Tully, having embraced her role as a mother figure to Kate's children, finds a sense of belonging and purpose she never had. Dorothy, having confronted her past and earned some forgiveness from Tully, becomes a consistent, though still eccentric, presence in their lives. Marah, though changed, finds strength in her family's love and begins to envision a future for herself. The novel concludes with the family, scarred but united, finding peace, acceptance, and renewed hope after profound loss.
The Protagonist
Tully transforms from a grief-stricken, lost individual into a nurturing, responsible caregiver who embraces the complexities of family.
The Supporting/Protagonist
Marah descends into self-destructive behavior due to grief but ultimately finds healing and forgiveness through her family's love.
The Supporting
Dorothy confronts her painful past, seeking and eventually receiving a measure of forgiveness from Tully, allowing her to become a more present mother.
The Supporting
Johnny grapples with immense grief and the challenges of single parenthood but remains a resilient and loving anchor for his children.
The Mentioned/Supporting (through memories)
Kate's legacy, even in death, continues to guide and inspire Tully and her family towards healing and connection.
The Supporting/Antagonist
Travis's destructive influence leads to a tragic accident, forcing Marah and her family to confront their deepest fears and begin healing.
The Supporting
Will navigates his grief and adjusts to the new family dynamics, finding comfort in the renewed stability.
The Supporting
Lucas adapts to the changes in his family, benefiting from the renewed sense of security and love.
The novel is about grief, specifically how individuals cope with profound loss. Tully's despair after Kate's death, seen in her aimlessness and suicide attempt, contrasts with Marah's rebellious anger and self-destructive behavior. Johnny's quiet struggle to hold his family together while grieving his wife also shows this theme. The book explores how grief can break families and individuals, but also how shared sorrow can lead to deeper understanding and healing, as seen in the family's vigil over Marah.
“You lose the people you love and you have to find a way to go on.”
Motherhood is explored in its various forms: biological, surrogate, and estranged. Tully, who never had a stable mother figure, struggles to keep her promise to Kate to care for her children, eventually becoming a surrogate mother to Marah. Dorothy's return forces a confrontation with the painful legacy of her own failed motherhood, caused by her traumatic past. The novel examines the sacrifices, challenges, and love in maternal bonds, and how family, by blood or by choice, provides support and belonging, especially in times of crisis like Marah's accident.
“Tully knew nothing about family or motherhood or taking care of people.”
Central to the story is the journey towards redemption and forgiveness. Dorothy seeks redemption for abandoning Tully by revealing her traumatic history and trying to be a present mother. Tully struggles to forgive Dorothy but eventually finds understanding. Marah's recovery involves forgiving herself for her reckless behavior and reconnecting with her family. Tully's own near-death experience, where she 'meets' Kate, offers self-forgiveness and a renewed purpose, showing that healing often means letting go of past resentments and embracing second chances.
“where there is life, there is hope, and where there is love, there is forgiveness.”
Each main character deals with their identity. Tully, defined by her friendship with Kate and her career, must redefine herself in Kate's absence and as a caregiver. Marah loses her sense of self in grief and rebellion, only to slowly rediscover who she is during her recovery. Dorothy confronts the 'Cloud' persona of her past to embrace a more authentic self, seeking to be the mother Tully needs. The novel suggests that identity changes through life's challenges, losses, and new relationships, leading to a more complete understanding of oneself.
“Tully Hart has always been larger than life, a woman fueled by big dreams and driven by memories of a painful past.”
The story is told primarily through the perspectives of Tully, Marah, and Dorothy.
The novel employs an interweaving narrative structure, shifting between the viewpoints of Tully, Marah, and Dorothy. This allows the reader to gain deep insight into each character's grief, motivations, and internal struggles. This device is particularly effective in showing how their individual experiences of loss and their complex relationships intersect and influence one another, building empathy for each woman's journey and revealing the full scope of their shared and individual pains and triumphs. It provides a comprehensive understanding of the family's dynamics and history.
Past events and hidden truths are gradually unveiled to explain present behaviors.
The narrative frequently uses flashbacks, particularly through Dorothy's storytelling, to reveal long-held secrets from the past. Dorothy's traumatic history, including her abuse and the circumstances of Tully's birth, is gradually unveiled. This device serves to explain her past actions of abandonment and provides crucial context for Tully's deep-seated emotional wounds. It also highlights the generational impact of trauma and the power of buried truths to shape present relationships. The slow reveal builds suspense and deepens the reader's understanding of the characters' complex motivations.
Tully's suicide attempt leads to a spiritual encounter that provides a turning point.
Tully's near-death experience, where she 'meets' Kate, serves as a powerful plot device for her character's turning point. This spiritual encounter provides her with a sense of peace, forgiveness, and renewed purpose. It's a symbolic manifestation of Kate's enduring influence and a means for Tully to confront her grief, guilt, and the promise she made. The NDE allows for a moment of profound introspection and catharsis, enabling Tully to pull herself back from the brink of despair and fully commit to her new role as a caregiver and a member of the Ryan family.
A symbolic reference to the enduring friendship and connection between Tully and Kate.
The 'Firefly Lane' motif, originating from the previous book, continues to serve as a powerful symbol of the unbreakable bond between Tully and Kate. Even in Kate's physical absence, 'Firefly Lane' represents their shared history, their enduring friendship, and the guiding light Kate continues to be for Tully. It's referenced as a place of origin and comfort, a reminder of the foundational relationship that shapes Tully's life and her eventual commitment to Kate's family. It underscores the theme that some connections transcend even death.
“The greatest gift you can give someone is your time, because when you give your time, you are giving a portion of your life that you will never get back.”
— Meredith often reflects on the value of presence and connection.
“Love isn't a fairy tale. It's a choice. And you have to keep choosing it, every single day.”
— Meredith's advice to her daughter, Leni, about sustaining a relationship.
“Sometimes the hardest thing and the right thing are the same.”
— Meredith grappling with a difficult decision that she knows is necessary.
“You can't go back and change the beginning, but you can start where you are and change the ending.”
— Meredith finding hope and agency in her present circumstances.
“Grief is like the ocean; it comes in waves, ebbing and flowing. Sometimes the water is calm, and sometimes it is overwhelming. All we can do is learn to swim.”
— Meredith processing loss and trying to move forward.
“It takes courage to grow up and become who you really are.”
— A reflection on personal growth and self-discovery.
“The only way to get over a fear is to face it.”
— Meredith encouraging herself or another character to confront their anxieties.
“Home wasn't a place, it was a feeling. It was the people you loved, the ones who knew you even when you were lost.”
— Meredith realizing the true meaning of home beyond a physical location.
“Sometimes you have to be your own hero.”
— Meredith taking charge of her own life and well-being.
“Forgiveness is a gift you give yourself.”
— Meredith considering forgiving someone from her past, and the personal benefit.
“Life is a series of adjustments. Sometimes you have to bend so you don't break.”
— Meredith adapting to unexpected challenges and changes.
“The past, if not reconciled, has a way of repeating itself.”
— Meredith reflecting on the importance of addressing old wounds.
“Hope is a thing with feathers, that perches in the soul, and sings the tune without the words, and never stops at all.”
— Meredith drawing strength from an inner sense of optimism during hard times.
“It's never too late to be what you might have been.”
— Meredith contemplating new possibilities and second chances in her life.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.