“The heart wants what the heart wants, even if it’s inconveniently packaged in a man you’re supposed to hate.”
— Main character grappling with her unexpected attraction to her rival.
Archivist's Choice
Changing Lanes
Kathleen Long (2013)
Genre
Romance
Reading Time
264 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
When her meticulously planned perfect life implodes with a runaway fiancé, a lost job, and termite-ridden dream home, Abby Halladay discovers that embracing the beautiful mess of imperfection might just lead her to the life she truly needs.
Synopsis
Abby Halladay lives by a meticulously crafted plan, believing it will lead her to a perfect life, including her job as a syndicated columnist, her fiancé Fred, and their upcoming wedding in Paris, New Jersey. Her carefully constructed world crumbles when Fred abandons her for Paris, France, her column is canceled, and her dream home is infested with termites. Forced to return to her parents' home and drive her father's taxi, Abby finds her perfect life has become a complete disaster. As she navigates these misfortunes, Abby slowly begins to shed her rigid need for perfection. Through new friendships and confronting her past, she discovers that the messy, imperfect life she once dreaded might actually be the one she truly needs, ultimately embracing imperfection and finding the promise of a second chance in a new direction.
Reading time
264 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Heartwarming, Hopeful, Reflective, Humorous
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy heartwarming stories about finding unexpected joy and second chances after life throws you curveballs.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer high-stakes drama or intricate plot twists over character-driven emotional journeys.
Plot Summary
The Perfect Plan Unravels
Abby Halladay, a syndicated columnist known for her 'Perfect Life' column, is meticulously planning her wedding to her fiancé, Fred, at a charming bed and breakfast in Paris, New Jersey. She is also on the verge of buying her dream home. Everything in Abby's life is precisely organized and controlled, from her career to her relationship. She believes in planning every detail to ensure a perfect outcome. However, this carefully constructed facade begins to crack when Fred unexpectedly announces that he is leaving her and flying to Paris, France, to 'find himself,' abandoning their wedding plans and leaving Abby in shock.
A String of Misfortunes
Following Fred's abrupt departure, Abby's professional life takes a hit when her 'Perfect Life' column is canceled by her editor, who deems it unrelatable given Abby's recent personal turmoil. To add to her woes, her dream home, which she was just about to purchase, has a severe termite infestation, making it uninhabitable and forcing her to abandon the sale. With no job, no fiancé, and no home, Abby's carefully curated perfect life has completely disintegrated, leaving her feeling lost and without direction.
Return to the Nest
With nowhere else to go, a humiliated Abby must move back into her childhood home with her well-meaning but often overbearing parents, Carol and Frank Halladay. The transition is difficult for Abby, who prides herself on her independence and success. Her father, Frank, a retired cab driver, offers her a temporary solution to her financial woes: driving his old cab, 'The Yellow Submarine,' for a local taxi company. This proposition is a stark contrast to Abby's former professional life and further highlights the extent of her current predicament, challenging her ideas of success and happiness.
Life Behind the Wheel
Driving her father's cab, Abby reluctantly navigates the streets of her hometown. Initially, she views the job as a temporary setback and an embarrassment. However, as she picks up various passengers, each with their own unique stories, Abby slowly begins to gain new perspectives. She meets a wide array of characters, from a cynical, aspiring writer to an elderly woman with deep wisdom, whose lives are far from the 'perfect' ideal she once championed. These encounters subtly start to chip away at Abby's rigid worldview.
A New Friendship Blossoms
Among her new colleagues at the taxi company, Abby frequently encounters Mitch, another cab driver. Unlike Fred, Mitch is laid-back, humorous, and genuinely kind. He doesn't conform to Abby's previous expectations of a partner, but he offers her genuine friendship and support without judgment. Mitch encourages Abby to loosen up, laugh at herself, and embrace the unexpected. Their conversations often challenge Abby's perfectionist tendencies and help her to see the value in spontaneity and imperfection, beginning to open her heart to new possibilities.
Confronting the Past
Months after Fred's departure, he unexpectedly returns to town, briefly re-entering Abby's life. Their reunion is awkward and confirms for Abby that their relationship was built on a foundation of shared aspirations for a 'perfect' life rather than genuine connection. She realizes that Fred's quest for self-discovery in Paris, France, mirrors her own internal struggles, but that they are now on different paths. This encounter provides Abby with much-needed closure, allowing her to fully let go of her idealized past with Fred and focus on her own healing and growth.
Embracing Imperfection
As Abby continues to drive the cab, she finds herself increasingly enjoying the freedom and unpredictability of her new life. She learns to appreciate the small, everyday moments and the genuine connections she makes with people. Her once-rigid plans give way to a newfound openness to experience. She starts writing again, but this time, her column, 'Changing Lanes,' reflects her current reality, celebrating the beauty and humor in life's imperfections and the lessons learned from unexpected detours. This shift marks a significant personal transformation for Abby.
Family Reconnections
Living back home allows Abby to reconnect with her parents on a deeper level. She begins to understand their perspectives and appreciate their unwavering support. Her initial frustration with their well-meaning interference transforms into a newfound respect and love. She sees her father, Frank, not just as a retired cab driver, but as a man of quiet wisdom and resilience, and her mother, Carol, as a source of unconditional love. This period of shared living strengthens their family bonds and helps Abby appreciate the comfort and security of home.
A New Direction
Inspired by her experiences driving the cab and the stories of her passengers, Abby begins writing a new column, tentatively titled 'Changing Lanes.' Unlike her previous 'Perfect Life' column, this new endeavor embraces the messy, unpredictable, and often humorous aspects of everyday existence. Her editor, initially skeptical, is impressed by the raw honesty and relatability of Abby's new writing. The column resonates with readers who are tired of unattainable ideals, finding solace and humor in Abby's journey of self-discovery and acceptance of imperfection, signaling a new professional path for her.
The Promise of a Second Chance
Having shed her need for perfection, Abby realizes that true happiness is not found in meticulously planned outcomes but in genuine connection and embracing life's detours. She develops deep feelings for Mitch, the kind and unassuming cab driver, recognizing his genuine character and the comfort of their shared understanding. The story concludes with Abby fully embracing her imperfect, yet deeply fulfilling life: her new column thriving, her family relationships strengthened, and a promising future with Mitch. She has truly changed lanes, finding her own version of a perfect life, one built on authenticity and love.
Principal Figures
Abby Halladay
The Protagonist
Abby transforms from a control-freak obsessed with perfection to a woman who embraces imperfection, spontaneity, and finds genuine happiness in unexpected places.
Mitch
The Supporting/Love Interest
Mitch remains a steady, supportive presence, representing the alternative to Abby's former life and eventually becoming her romantic partner.
Fred
The Antagonist (initially)/Mentioned
Fred's role is to initiate Abby's journey by leaving her, and his brief return serves to confirm Abby's growth and their ultimate incompatibility.
Carol Halladay
The Supporting
Carol's relationship with Abby evolves from one of gentle tension to mutual understanding and appreciation.
Frank Halladay
The Supporting
Frank's role is primarily to be a steady support for Abby and to provide the means for her transformation through the cab.
Mr. Henderson
The Supporting/Mentioned
Mr. Henderson's character serves as a professional gatekeeper, first closing a door on Abby's old life and then opening one for her new path.
Various Passengers
The Mentioned
The passengers collectively serve as catalysts for Abby's personal growth, broadening her worldview and inspiring her new column.
Themes & Insights
Embracing Imperfection
The central theme of the novel is Abby's journey from a rigid pursuit of a 'perfect' life to the acceptance and celebration of imperfection. Initially, Abby believes that happiness lies in meticulously planned outcomes and an unblemished public image. Her carefully constructed world crumbles, forcing her to confront the reality that life is messy and unpredictable. Through her experiences driving a cab and interacting with diverse individuals, Abby learns that true joy and connection are found in embracing flaws, spontaneity, and the unexpected detours of life. This is evident when she starts writing her 'Changing Lanes' column, which champions the beauty of an imperfect existence, a stark contrast to her previous 'Perfect Life' column.
“Sometimes the best-laid plans go awry, and sometimes that's exactly what you need.”
The Illusion of Control
Abby's initial character is defined by her need for control, believing that by planning every detail, she can prevent unhappiness and achieve her ideal life. Her engagement, career, and even her dream home are all part of this meticulously crafted illusion. The unraveling of her life – Fred's departure, her column's cancellation, the termite infestation – shatters this illusion. The story highlights that life is inherently unpredictable and that attempting to control every variable often leads to greater disappointment. Abby's growth comes from letting go of this need for control and trusting in the process of life, even when it is messy.
“She had built her entire world on the premise that if you planned perfectly, nothing could go wrong. Life, it turned out, had other ideas.”
Second Chances and New Beginnings
The novel explores the power of second chances, both in romance and in life generally. Abby is given a second chance at happiness and a different kind of success after her initial plans fall apart. Her move back home, her unexpected job as a cab driver, and her new column all represent opportunities for a fresh start. The relationship she develops with Mitch is also a second chance at love, built on authenticity rather than societal expectations. The story emphasizes that failures and setbacks are not ends but rather moments that can lead to more fulfilling and genuine paths.
“It wasn't the life she'd planned, but it was becoming the life she needed.”
Redefining Success and Happiness
Abby's journey forces her to redefine what success and happiness mean to her. Initially, success is equated with a high-profile career, a perfect fiancé, a dream home, and a flawless public image. Her fall from this perceived ideal forces her to question these superficial markers. Through her interactions with ordinary people and her experiences in the cab, she discovers that genuine happiness comes from authentic connections, personal growth, and finding joy in the everyday, rather than adhering to external standards. Her new column, 'Changing Lanes,' is a testament to this redefined understanding of fulfillment.
“Maybe the perfect life wasn't about having everything in its place, but about finding joy in the chaos.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The Yellow Submarine (Cab)
A symbolic vehicle that transports Abby on her physical and emotional journey.
The old, slightly battered yellow cab, inherited from Abby's father, serves as a powerful symbol of her transformation. Initially, it represents her fall from grace – a stark contrast to her previous glamorous life. However, as she drives it, 'The Yellow Submarine' becomes a vessel for self-discovery. It literally 'changes lanes,' taking Abby to new places and introducing her to diverse people whose stories broaden her perspective. It allows her to shed her polished persona and embrace a more authentic, grounded existence, becoming a tool for her personal and professional rebirth.
The 'Perfect Life' vs. 'Changing Lanes' Columns
A literary device that highlights Abby's internal and external transformation.
The contrast between Abby's two columns directly mirrors her character arc. The 'Perfect Life' column, with its emphasis on meticulous planning and flawless execution, represents Abby's initial, superficial worldview. Its cancellation symbolizes the collapse of her old identity. The 'Changing Lanes' column, born from her experiences as a cab driver, reflects her newfound acceptance of imperfection, spontaneity, and the beauty of life's detours. This device effectively illustrates her shift from an idealized, controlled existence to an authentic, resilient embrace of reality, providing a tangible measure of her growth.
The Paris (New Jersey) vs. Paris (France) Motif
A geographical and symbolic contrast highlighting Abby's initial illusions versus her eventual reality.
The recurring mention of 'Paris' serves as a significant plot device. Abby's planned wedding in 'Paris, New Jersey' signifies her desire for an idealized, romantic life, albeit one that is a local, perhaps less authentic, imitation of grand dreams. Fred's flight to 'Paris, France' to 'find himself' is a catalyst for Abby's breakdown, representing a pursuit of an external, often cliché, form of self-discovery. This contrast underscores Abby's journey from chasing an idealized, controlled version of happiness to finding genuine fulfillment in her own, imperfect reality, rooted in her local community.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Sometimes the biggest detours lead to the most beautiful destinations.”
— A reflection on life's unexpected turns and their positive outcomes.
“He looked at her like she was the only thing in a crowded room worth seeing, and a shiver went down her spine.”
— Describing a moment of intense connection and recognition between the protagonists.
“Forgiveness wasn't about forgetting; it was about choosing to let go of the anger.”
— A character's internal struggle with past grievances and the path to healing.
“You can plan your life down to the last second, but fate always has a mischievous grin and a different set of directions.”
— Commenting on the unpredictability of life despite best-laid plans.
“Some silences are more eloquent than any words could ever be.”
— Referring to a comfortable, understanding silence between two people.
“It wasn't about being perfect; it was about being perfectly imperfect together.”
— A realization about the nature of a true, accepting relationship.
“The past is a road you can visit, but you can't live there.”
— Advice given about moving on from past mistakes or hurts.
“True strength isn't about never falling, but about getting up every single time you do.”
— A character's internal monologue about resilience and perseverance.
“He had a way of making her feel seen, truly seen, for the first time in a long time.”
— The protagonist's experience of feeling deeply understood by her love interest.
“Love isn't always a smooth highway; sometimes it's a winding country road with unexpected bumps and breathtaking views.”
— A metaphor for the unpredictable and often challenging journey of love.
“Sometimes the person you least expect is the one who changes everything.”
— Reflecting on how an unlikely individual can have a profound impact.
“The best kind of adventure is the one you never saw coming.”
— A character embracing the unexpected twists and turns in her life.
“He didn't just hear her words; he heard the unspoken fears beneath them.”
— Demonstrating a deep level of empathy and understanding from one character to another.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
Abby's meticulously planned 'perfect life' unravels when her fiancé, Fred, abandons her for Paris, her syndicated column is canceled, and her dream home is infested with termites. This forces her to confront the complete collapse of her carefully constructed future.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
