“Every time I think I'm over him, I see him, and it all comes rushing back.”
— Lily thinking about Lo after their breakup.

Krista Ritchie (2013)
Genre
Romance
Reading Time
6 hours 30 min
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
Sex-addicted Lily and alcohol-dependent Loren fake a perfect relationship. They must face whether their deepest addiction is to each other, or if their love can help them escape rock bottom.
Lily Calloway and Loren Hale have been best friends since childhood. Now in college, they live together and maintain a three-year fake relationship. This arrangement covers their severe addictions: Lily's to sex, shown through anonymous hookups, and Loren's to alcohol, which he constantly drinks. They are good at hiding things, making up excuses and alibis to keep their families and friends—especially Lily's sisters Rose and Daisy, and Loren's brother Connor—from finding out about their habits. Their apartment is carefully managed, with Lily's quiet exits and Loren's hidden flasks. They project an image of a stable, loving couple to the outside world, particularly at family gatherings and holidays, where the pressure to keep up appearances is highest.
Their lives nearly fall apart when Loren overdoses and almost dies. This incident forces both Lily and Loren to face the truth about their addictions. While Loren recovers in the hospital, Lily feels guilty and scared, realizing how close she came to losing him. This event, mostly kept secret from their families, starts a more urgent conversation between them about how unsustainable their current life is. It also shows how deeply codependent they are, as they realize they rely on each other not just to hide secrets, but for emotional support in their misery. The fear of losing each other becomes a strong, though temporary, reason to change.
As their fake relationship continues, their families pay more attention. Lily's sisters, Rose and Daisy, who are protective and observant, start to question the lack of closeness they see between Lily and Loren. They suggest double dates and more couple activities, making it harder for Lily and Loren to keep up their act. Similarly, Loren's older brother, Connor, a responsible and caring person, worries more about Loren's erratic behavior and frequent hangovers. These outside pressures force Lily and Loren into more elaborate performances, further draining them and showing the stress their lies put on their relationships with loved ones. The fear of being exposed grows larger than ever.
To keep up appearances and satisfy their urges, Lily continues her anonymous hookups, and Loren continues drinking. However, new people enter their lives, complicating their world. Lily meets a man named Lo; he starts as another one-night stand but shows genuine interest, which unsettles her. Loren, in turn, feels drawn to Daisy (Lily's sister), creating an awkward situation. These outside romantic interests, though often not serious, start to cause unexpected feelings of jealousy and possessiveness between Lily and Loren. The lines between their fake relationship and their deep, codependent bond begin to blur as they realize their connection might be more significant than just a mutual cover-up.
The growing pressure and emotional turmoil lead to an honest confession between Lily and Loren. In a vulnerable moment, they admit the full extent of their addictions and the deep feelings they have for each other that go beyond their fake relationship. They acknowledge that their codependency is not just about hiding their problems; it is about a deep emotional reliance and a love that grew amid their shared pain. This revelation is both scary and freeing. They realize they are at a crossroads: continue their destructive path, or try to build a real relationship based on honesty and a commitment to recovery, understanding that their true addiction might be each other.
After their confession, Lily and Loren decide to try a real relationship, knowing it will mean facing their addictions directly. This decision starts a long and difficult journey. They agree to support each other in getting help, even if it means revealing their secrets. Their first attempts are hard, as old habits are difficult to break. They experience relapses and despair, but their commitment to each other and the hope of a healthier future keeps them going. This phase involves careful steps toward honesty with themselves and each other, acknowledging the huge challenge ahead but also the potential for a genuine connection.
The decision to pursue a real relationship makes Lily and Loren gradually tell their families the truth. This process is painful and met with shock, anger, and heartbreak, especially from Lily's sisters, Rose and Daisy, and Loren's brother, Connor. They struggle to understand how their loved ones could have hidden such deep struggles for so long. The revelations strain family relationships, as trust is broken and difficult talks happen. Lily and Loren face the results of their deception, but they also find unexpected support from some family members who, despite their pain, want to help them heal. This period is important for rebuilding trust and creating a base for real recovery.
Lily and Loren begin their individual recovery paths. Lily attends sex addiction therapy, dealing with the shame and psychological reasons for her compulsion. Loren enters rehab for his alcohol addiction, enduring the physical and emotional withdrawal. These individual journeys are very challenging, marked by intense cravings, emotional breakdowns, and deep self-reflection. However, their commitment to each other remains a strong motivator. They talk openly about their struggles, offering empathy and encouragement. Their shared experience of addiction and their understanding of each other's pain strengthens their bond, making them each other's most important source of support in the difficult healing process.
As Lily and Loren progress in recovery, their real relationship is tested. They learn to navigate intimacy without their addictions, redefining their physical and emotional connection. Trust, which years of lies had damaged, needs to be rebuilt, not just with their families but also between themselves. They set new boundaries and communication patterns, learning to be vulnerable and honest. Relapses, or near-relapses, remind them of their past but also offer chances to strengthen their commitment to sobriety and each other. They discover that building a healthy relationship requires constant effort, self-awareness, and a willingness to face their deepest fears and insecurities, together.
By the end of the book, Lily and Loren have made significant progress in their recovery. While acknowledging that addiction is a lifelong battle, they have healthier ways of coping and a strong support system. Their relationship, once a desperate cover-up, has become a genuine, loving partnership built on honesty, vulnerability, and mutual respect. They have faced judgment, past pain, and the immense challenges of sobriety, emerging stronger individually and as a couple. They understand that their true 'addiction' was indeed each other – not in a destructive, codependent way, but because their bond helped them confront their problems and choose a path toward a healthier, real future together.
The Protagonist
Lily transitions from a secretive, ashamed individual enabling her addiction to someone who confronts her issues, seeks therapy, and learns to build a genuine, healthy relationship based on honesty and self-worth.
The Protagonist
Loren moves from a self-destructive alcoholic hiding behind a fake relationship to someone who enters rehab, confronts his addiction, and commits to a real, sober relationship with Lily.
The Supporting
Rose transitions from a suspicious and protective sister to a supportive, albeit sometimes critical, figure in Lily's recovery journey.
The Supporting
Daisy moves from an observant younger sister with a crush on Loren to someone who understands and supports Lily and Loren's struggles and recovery.
The Supporting
Connor evolves from a worried brother trying to understand Loren's issues to a dedicated and supportive presence during Loren's recovery.
The Supporting
Moffy's role remains largely static, serving as a background character who is unaware of the protagonists' struggles.
The Mentioned
Her character is largely static, representing an external pressure point for Lily.
The Mentioned
His character is largely static, representing an external pressure point for Loren.
The main theme involves Lily's sex addiction and Loren's alcohol addiction, exploring their destructive nature and how they help cope with deeper emotional pain. The book shows the secrecy, shame, and physical/emotional cost of addiction, as seen in Lily's anonymous hookups and Loren's near-fatal overdose. It emphasizes how addiction creates a cycle of self-destruction, isolating people while making them dependent on their chosen problem and, in this case, on each other to keep up appearances.
“"We were two addicts, bound by a lie, and the only way out was to hit rock bottom together."”
The story explores codependency, as Lily and Loren initially rely on each other to hide their addictions, creating a mutually destructive dynamic. Their 'fake' relationship becomes a shield, but also a prison, where they enable each other's worst habits. The theme shows how their deep emotional bond, though born from shared pain, at first stops them from seeking help independently. The book's journey is about changing this toxic codependency into a healthier, supportive relationship built on honesty and mutual recovery, rather than shared secrets.
“"We were each other's drug, the only thing that made the other feel less alone in their brokenness."”
Both Lily and Loren struggle with their true selves versus the images they show the world. Lily, the 'shy' girl, hides her sexual compulsions, while Loren, the 'charming' guy, conceals his alcoholism. The theme explores the burden of living a lie and the emotional cost of not being authentic. Their recovery journey is also a journey toward self-discovery and accepting their true selves, flaws and all. This is clear as they shed their secret lives and begin to confront who they are without their addictions.
“"Who was I without the shame? Who was he without the bottle? We had to find out, together."”
Pressure from both Lily's and Loren's families contributes to their secrecy. Lily's wish to please her seemingly perfect sisters and avoid her mother's judgment, combined with Loren's fear of his strict father and need to maintain an image, drives them deeper into their lies. The theme explores how family dynamics, expectations, and the fear of disappointment can make people hide their struggles, leading to greater pain and disconnection when the truth comes out, as seen in the emotional fallout with Rose, Daisy, and Connor.
“"Our families, they were the reason for the lies, but also the reason we wanted to get clean."”
Beneath the layers of addiction and deceit, the book explores a deep, unconditional love between Lily and Loren. Their journey is one of redemption, showing that even in the darkest situations, love can help heal and change. It is not a magic cure, but a force that motivates them to confront their addictions, seek help, and build a healthier future together. Their love changes from a toxic, codependent bond into a genuine partnership, showing that true connection can lead to personal growth and a chance at a better life.
“"We weren't just addicted to sex and booze. We were addicted to each other. And maybe, just maybe, that was the one addiction that could save us."”
Simultaneous portrayal of two distinct addictions (sex and alcohol) in the protagonists.
This device immediately establishes the core conflict and the unique bond between Lily and Loren. By giving each protagonist a different, yet equally debilitating, addiction, the narrative highlights the universal nature of coping mechanisms while also showcasing their individual struggles. It underscores their shared experience of shame, secrecy, and self-destruction, making their codependency plausible and their eventual journey to recovery a joint effort, rather than isolated battles. This dual perspective allows for a richer exploration of addiction's impact on relationships.
A romantic relationship maintained for external appearances, masking deeper truths.
The 'fake relationship' serves as the central framework for the plot, initially functioning as a convenient cover for Lily and Loren's individual addictions. This device creates inherent dramatic irony, as readers are privy to the truth behind their seemingly perfect coupling, while their families and friends remain oblivious. It also builds tension as the facade becomes increasingly difficult to maintain, leading to near-exposure and escalating stakes. Crucially, it allows for the unexpected development of genuine romantic feelings between the protagonists, transforming a pragmatic arrangement into a complex, real love story.
Alternating chapters narrated by Lily and Loren.
The novel employs alternating first-person perspectives from both Lily and Loren. This device is crucial for providing intimate access to each character's internal struggles, thoughts, and feelings regarding their addictions, their shared secrets, and their evolving relationship. It allows readers to deeply empathize with both protagonists, understanding their motivations, shame, and desires. The dual perspective also highlights the nuances of their codependency and the individual challenges they face, while showing how their perceptions of events and each other can differ, enriching the emotional complexity of their journey.
A critical event that forces characters to confront the severity of their situation.
Loren's near-fatal overdose serves as a significant 'rock bottom' moment for both protagonists. This device is a common narrative turning point in addiction stories, providing a stark, undeniable confrontation with the consequences of their destructive behavior. It shatters any lingering denial and forces Lily and Loren to acknowledge the severity of their addictions and the unsustainable nature of their lives. This traumatic event acts as the primary catalyst for their decision to seek help, change their lives, and explore a real, honest relationship, signaling the shift from enabling to recovery.
“Every time I think I'm over him, I see him, and it all comes rushing back.”
— Lily thinking about Lo after their breakup.
“You're my anchor, Lo. You always have been.”
— Lily confessing her feelings and reliance on Loren.
“He's my poison, and I'm his. We're both addicted to the destruction.”
— Lily reflecting on the tumultuous nature of her relationship with Loren.
“I loved him even when I hated him. Maybe especially then.”
— Lily's internal struggle with her feelings for Loren during a difficult period.
“We were two broken pieces that somehow fit together, making something beautiful, if a little jagged.”
— Lily describing her and Loren's unique bond.
“Some addictions aren't about substances. They're about people. And he was my drug.”
— Lily acknowledging her deep dependence on Loren.
“I'm not going to leave you, Lily. Not ever. Even when you push me away, I'll still be here.”
— Loren reassuring Lily of his unwavering commitment.
“Our love wasn't a choice; it was a necessity. Like breathing.”
— Lily reflecting on the inherent nature of her and Loren's relationship.
“You can't save someone who doesn't want to be saved. But you can stand by them while they try.”
— Lily's realization about supporting Loren through his struggles.
“He saw the cracks in my armor and didn't run. He just helped me put it back together.”
— Lily appreciating Loren's acceptance and support.
“We were a mess. A beautiful, complicated, glorious mess.”
— Lily's affectionate description of their relationship.
“Loving him was like living on the edge of a cliff, exhilarating and terrifying all at once.”
— Lily's internal thoughts about the intense nature of her love for Loren.
“Sometimes, the hardest thing to do is forgive yourself. Especially when you're the one who caused the most pain.”
— Lily's reflection on self-forgiveness after past mistakes.
“Our story wasn't perfect, but it was ours. And that made it more than enough.”
— Lily accepting the unique and flawed journey of her relationship with Loren.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.