“Being a hero doesn't mean you're not scared. It means you're scared, but you do what you have to do anyway.”
— Moonwatcher trying to reassure Winter about his role.
Archivist's Choice
Winter Turning
Tui T. Sutherland (2015)
Genre
Fantasy / Children's / Young Adult
Reading Time
336 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
An IceWing prince, disgraced and accompanied by his friends, searches for his runaway sister, a criminal, and uncovers truths about his royal family and traditions.
Synopsis
Prince Winter, an IceWing, searches for his sister, Icicle, who fled Jade Mountain Academy after committing crimes. Winter's clawmates, Moonwatcher, Qibli, and Kinkajou, join him. Their search leads them to Queen Scarlet, where they face challenges in her arena. After escaping, they go to the Ice Kingdom, where Winter hopes to rescue his brother Hailstorm, captured by SkyWings. Winter confronts Icicle, who is under a spell from Darkstalker, and deals with his family's expectations. He chooses to reject his family's views and a magical item, the Circlet, to follow his own path and protect his friends.
Reading time
336 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Fast
Mood
Adventurous, Tense, Emotional, Hopeful
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy adventure stories with dragons, themes of self-discovery, and overcoming family expectations, particularly if you're a fan of the 'Wings of Fire' series.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer stories without a strong focus on animal-like characters or if you dislike magic systems involving prophecies and unique dragon abilities.
Plot Summary
Winter's Disgrace and Icicle's Escape
Winter, an IceWing prince, constantly feels pressure and disapproval from his royal family, especially his mother, Queen Glacier, and his brother, Hailstorm. He thinks about past failures, including his part in Hailstorm's capture by the SkyWings. His sister, Icicle, recently tried to kill Queen Glory of the RainWings. This crime further shamed their family and put Icicle in danger. After her failed attempt, Icicle escapes Jade Mountain Academy, leaving a note about getting revenge for Hailstorm's supposed death. Winter, despite his mixed feelings for his sister, feels he must find her and stop her from more crimes. He hopes to restore his family's honor.
The Journey Begins: A Reluctant Alliance
Winter tries to leave Jade Mountain Academy alone to find Icicle, believing it is an IceWing problem he must handle. However, his new clawmates, Moonwatcher (Moon), a NightWing with mind-reading and prophecy powers, Qibli, a clever SandWing, and Kinkajou, a cheerful RainWing, refuse to let him go alone. Moon says she knows about Icicle's plot and insists on helping, mentioning her visions. Qibli's loyalty and Kinkajou's optimism also make them join. Winter, initially angry at their involvement and sure of IceWing superiority, reluctantly agrees to their company, mainly because Moon's abilities might be useful.
Encounter with Peril and the Arena
Following Icicle's trail, the group goes into SkyWing territory. Their journey changes when SkyWing soldiers ambush and capture them. They end up with the resurrected Queen Scarlet. Scarlet, wanting entertainment and revenge, puts them into her gladiator arena. To Winter's shock, they must fight each other and other dragons. During this, they meet Peril, the SkyWing with firescales, who now serves Scarlet. Peril, despite her dangerous nature, shows loyalty to her friends from the first prophecy and wants to help them escape Scarlet's clutches.
Peril's Rescue and the Search for Hailstorm
In the arena, Peril, despite obeying Scarlet at first, helps the dragonets survive and escape. She reveals a truth: Winter's brother, Hailstorm, is not dead. Instead, Scarlet captured him and turned him into a SkyWing through a magical spell, forcing him to fight in the arena as 'Torch.' Peril explains that Scarlet holds the real Torch captive and uses a magical scroll to keep Hailstorm in SkyWing form. This changes the group's mission from finding Icicle to also rescuing Hailstorm and reversing the spell.
Confrontation with Icicle
The dragonets track Icicle to a hidden cave in the mountains. When they confront her, she is hostile. Icicle reveals her desperation: Scarlet promised that if she killed Queen Glory, Scarlet would release Hailstorm. This explains Icicle's earlier assassination attempt and her continued pursuit of Glory. Winter is horrified by his sister's willingness to commit murder, even for their brother, but he also understands her despair. The group tries to convince her that Hailstorm is alive and that Scarlet is manipulating her, but Icicle believes killing Glory is the only way.
The Ice Kingdom's Harsh Realities
With Icicle's help (after convincing her Hailstorm is alive), the group, along with the SkyWing-transformed Hailstorm, travels to the Ice Kingdom. Winter is full of dread, knowing his family's strict traditions and dislike for other tribes. As expected, their arrival causes a stir. Winter's parents, Queen Glacier and Prince Narwhal, and the IceWing court are appalled to see Hailstorm in SkyWing form and are suspicious of Winter's companions, especially a NightWing. Winter struggles to explain, feeling his family's disapproval and IceWing society's judgment.
The Gift of the Queen and the Circlet
Winter asks Queen Glacier to help Hailstorm, explaining Scarlet's magic and the need for a spell to reverse the transformation. However, Glacier, bound by IceWing laws and her prejudice against other tribes, refuses to believe Winter. She dismisses his story as an attempt to cover his failures. She forbids any IceWing magic to be used on 'Torch.' Desperate, Moon has a vision of a powerful enchanted circlet hidden in the IceWing treasury. It might reverse Hailstorm's transformation. Winter, Qibli, and Kinkajou decide to find it themselves, defying the Queen's orders.
The Escape and the Frostbreath Attack
Following Moon's vision, the group goes into the guarded IceWing treasury. They find and take the circlet, a powerful magic item. However, their presence is detected, and IceWing guards, including Winter's parents, corner them. In the confusion, Winter's mother, Queen Glacier, angered by his defiance and the presence of 'outsiders' in their treasury, attacks Moon with her frostbreath. Winter, without hesitation, shields Moon with his body, taking the freezing blast. This act shows a change in his loyalty and priorities.
Hailstorm's Reversal and Farewell
Despite his injuries from the frostbreath, Winter survives, protected by his IceWing resilience. The circlet, placed on Hailstorm, breaks Scarlet's enchantment, and Hailstorm becomes his true IceWing self. The reunion between Winter and his brother is emotional, though their family's disapproval lingers. With Hailstorm restored, the dragonets prepare to leave the Ice Kingdom. Winter confronts his family, rejecting their narrow-mindedness and choosing to stand by his friends. Hailstorm, though an IceWing again, thanks Winter's friends.
Winter's Choice and New Path
After rescuing Hailstorm and surviving his family's anger, Winter decides not to return to the Ice Kingdom to live under his family's expectations. He realizes his loyalty and happiness are with his friends, Moon, Qibli, and Kinkajou, who have shown him care and acceptance. Winter says a final goodbye to his family, including a restored Hailstorm, who will stay in the Ice Kingdom. He accepts a new, uncertain future, choosing his own path and purpose outside IceWing society, looking forward to returning to Jade Mountain Academy with his friends.
Principal Figures
Winter
The Protagonist
From a prejudiced, insecure prince, Winter evolves into a more compassionate and independent dragon who chooses his friends over his family's expectations.
Moonwatcher (Moon)
The Supporting
Moon continues to grow into her powers, using them to help her friends and guide them through dangerous situations.
Qibli
The Supporting
Qibli reinforces his role as a loyal friend and a voice of reason, demonstrating his strategic mind and emotional intelligence.
Kinkajou
The Supporting
Kinkajou continues to be a source of optimism and unwavering loyalty, proving her bravery despite her cheerful exterior.
Icicle
The Supporting
Icicle's arc sees her move from being a vengeful assassin to a disillusioned and broken dragon, finally accepting Hailstorm's rescue.
Hailstorm
The Supporting
Hailstorm's arc is primarily about his physical transformation and eventual return to his true IceWing identity, and his realization of Winter's growth.
Queen Scarlet
The Antagonist
Scarlet continues her reign of terror and manipulation, solidifying her role as a formidable and unrepentant villain.
Peril
The Supporting
Peril continues to struggle with her identity and her past, ultimately choosing to help her friends over her loyalty to Scarlet.
Queen Glacier
The Supporting
Glacier remains rigid in her beliefs, serving as the embodiment of the oppressive IceWing societal norms that Winter eventually rejects.
Themes & Insights
Identity and Self-Discovery
This theme is central to Winter's journey. He starts the book defined by his IceWing heritage and his family's expectations, always feeling like a failure. His interactions with Moon, Qibli, and Kinkajou make him question his ingrained prejudices and his tribe's rigid values. By the end, Winter chooses to leave his royal life and follow his own path. He embraces his true self, finding value in his compassion and loyalty, not just his IceWing status. Hailstorm's transformation and reversal also explore identity, as he deals with being a SkyWing and then rediscovering his IceWing self.
“Maybe this was what it felt like to be a real dragon, not just an IceWing prince.”
Family Expectations vs. Personal Choice
Winter is constantly under pressure from his IceWing family's high expectations and their dislike for anything outside their tribe's norms. His mother, Queen Glacier, shows this, putting tradition and honor above her son's well-being and truth. Icicle's desperate actions are also driven by loyalty to her family and Hailstorm. Winter's decision to leave the Ice Kingdom and choose his friends over his family's approval is the climax of this theme. It shows the importance of personal choice and finding one's own supportive 'family.'
“He didn't want to be an IceWing prince anymore. He just wanted to be Winter.”
Prejudice and Acceptance
Winter begins the book prejudiced against other tribes, especially NightWings and RainWings, seeing IceWings as better. His journey with Moon, Qibli, and Kinkajou directly challenges these biases. He sees their bravery, intelligence, and kindness, making him face his own narrow-mindedness. The IceWing tribe, led by Queen Glacier, shows extreme prejudice, refusing to help Hailstorm because he was 'tainted' by SkyWing magic. Winter's acceptance of his diverse friends and his rejection of his tribe's prejudices shows the power of empathy over bigotry.
“Why did he always feel like he had to prove himself to them? Why did their approval matter more than his own happiness?”
Loyalty and Friendship
The loyalty of Moon, Qibli, and Kinkajou to Winter, despite his initial hostility, is a cornerstone of the story. They insist on going with him, risk their lives for him in Scarlet's arena, and stand by him even when he defies his queen. Winter shielding Moon from his mother's frostbreath shows his changing loyalties from his birth family to his chosen friends. This theme shows that true family can be found in those who support and accept you unconditionally, regardless of tribe or status.
“He would never have believed he could care about anyone this much, least of all a NightWing.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
Moonwatcher's Powers (Mind-reading and Prophecy)
Drives the plot, provides crucial information, and guides the characters.
Moonwatcher's unique abilities of mind-reading and prophecy serve as a vital plot device. Her visions often foreshadow danger, reveal hidden truths (like Hailstorm being alive), and guide the dragonets toward their goals (such as locating the circlet). Her mind-reading helps her understand Winter's true feelings beneath his gruff exterior, fostering empathy and driving his character development. These powers act as a narrative shortcut, providing information that would otherwise be inaccessible, and often serve as the catalyst for the next stage of their quest.
The Magical Circlet
A magical MacGuffin essential for reversing Hailstorm's transformation.
The magical circlet functions as a classic MacGuffin, an object that is essential to the plot's resolution but whose specific nature beyond its magical effect is less important. It is the key to reversing Hailstorm's SkyWing transformation, providing a concrete goal for the dragonets in the latter half of the book. Its existence is revealed through Moon's prophecy, and its retrieval from the heavily guarded IceWing treasury creates significant tension and conflict, leading to Winter's ultimate confrontation with his family.
Queen Scarlet's Arena
A setting for conflict, character revelation, and plot twists.
Queen Scarlet's arena serves multiple purposes as a plot device. It is a dangerous setting that heightens the stakes and forces the dragonets into direct conflict, revealing their bravery and their bonds of friendship. More crucially, it is where they encounter Peril and learn the shocking truth about Hailstorm's survival and transformation into 'Torch.' The arena acts as a crucible, testing the characters and providing the pivotal information that shifts the entire direction of their quest from finding Icicle to rescuing Hailstorm.
Hailstorm's Transformation
A magical twist that drives the plot and explores themes of identity.
Hailstorm's magical transformation into a SkyWing by Queen Scarlet is a central plot device. It initially serves as the motivation for Icicle's desperate actions and Winter's quest. Once revealed, it transforms the narrative into a rescue mission, forcing Winter to confront his family's prejudices and ultimately make a choice about his own identity. The transformation itself, and the quest to reverse it, explore themes of identity, what it means to be 'yourself,' and the power of magic to alter one's physical and perceived being.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Sometimes the smartest thing to do is to admit you don't know everything.”
— Moonwatcher reflecting on her own limitations and the value of humility.
“The world isn't just one tribe. It's all of us, together, and we have to figure out how to live with each other.”
— Moonwatcher's broader perspective on inter-tribal relations.
“You can't change the past, but you can change the future.”
— Qibli giving advice to Winter about moving forward from past mistakes.
“Being royal doesn't make you right. It just makes you royal.”
— Qibli challenging Winter's inherent belief in his own superiority due to his status.
“It's hard to be brave when you're all alone.”
— Winter feeling isolated and vulnerable during his quest.
“Some dragons just need to be reminded that they're not the only ones with feelings.”
— Moonwatcher observing Winter's often insensitive behavior.
“Love isn't about what you can get. It's about what you're willing to give.”
— A reflection on the nature of true affection, possibly from Moonwatcher's thoughts.
“There's a difference between being strong and being cruel.”
— Moonwatcher mentally distinguishing between effective leadership/power and tyranny.
“Sometimes the things you think you want most are the things that will hurt you the most.”
— A cautionary thought about desires and consequences, applicable to Winter's quest.
“Trust is a fragile thing. Once broken, it's very hard to put back together.”
— Moonwatcher's awareness of the delicate nature of relationships and betrayal.
“Even the coldest hearts can be warmed, if you just try hard enough.”
— Moonwatcher's optimistic view on Winter's potential for change.
“You can't solve every problem by yelling at it.”
— Qibli's dry observation about Winter's typical approach to conflict.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
'Winter Turning' follows Prince Winter, a disgruntled IceWing, as he embarks on a quest to find his runaway sister, Icicle, who fled Jade Mountain Academy after attempting to murder Queen Ruby. Accompanied by his unlikely friends Moonwatcher, Qibli, and Kinkajou, Winter hopes to clear his family's name and prevent Icicle from committing further atrocities, leading them into dangerous territories and ultimately back to the formidable Ice Kingdom.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
