“Maybe it wasn't about finding the perfect person, but about finding the person who made your world feel a little more perfect.”
— Main character's internal reflection on love and relationships.
Archivist's Choice
Whatever It Takes
Lindsay Paige (2012)
Genre
Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
120 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
Haunted by the ghost of a lost child and tormented by nightmares, Emily pushes away the only person who wants to help, forcing Jake to choose between honoring her desperate request and saving their fractured love.
Synopsis
Emily and Jake, high school sweethearts, begin their first year of college after a recent miscarriage. Emily is consumed by grief, experiencing nightmares and struggling with the loss of their baby. Jake, in contrast, seems to be moving on, which creates a growing distance between them. Emily feels increasingly isolated and conflicted, even as Jake tries to support her, promising to do whatever it takes to help his 'Sweetness.' As their relationship buckles under the strain, Emily proposes a drastic solution she believes will alleviate her pain. This suggestion forces Jake into a difficult choice, leading to a painful decision that threatens to tear them apart permanently. Ultimately, they must confront their individual grief and find a shared path forward to rebuild their connection.
Reading time
120 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Emotional, Tender, Melancholy, Hopeful
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy emotional young adult romance focusing on grief and relationship challenges.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer lighthearted stories or are sensitive to themes of miscarriage and relationship strain.
Plot Summary
The Weight of Silence
Emily and Jake, high school sweethearts, arrive at college, excited for a new chapter. However, the excitement is muted by their unspoken grief over a recent miscarriage. Emily struggles, plagued by nightmares and a deep sense of loss, often withdrawing. Jake, in contrast, seems to cope well, even enthusiastic about college life, which creates a distance between them. Their friends, Sarah and Mark, are also present, offering some normalcy, but even their presence cannot bridge the growing gap of silence and misunderstanding between Emily and Jake. The difference in their coping mechanisms creates immediate tension.
Nightmares and Whispers
Emily's nightmares become more vivid and frequent, disturbing her sleep and her waking hours. She often wakes up crying, reliving the trauma of her miscarriage. One night, after a particularly bad dream, she finally opens up to Jake, admitting how deeply she's hurting. Jake, though initially seemingly detached, listens patiently, offering comfort and reassurance. He expresses his own sorrow, explaining that he's tried to be strong for her, which led to his outward composure. This conversation marks a small breakthrough, as Emily starts to feel less alone in her grief, and Jake begins to understand the depth of her suffering.
Jake's Promise
Following their emotional conversation, Jake reaffirms his love and commitment to Emily. He promises her that he will do 'whatever it takes' to help her heal and to bring them closer again. Emily, touched by his sincerity, starts to lean on him more, finding comfort in his presence. This promise, made in a moment of raw emotion and desperation, becomes a central theme as Jake navigates Emily's grief. He is determined to support her, but neither of them anticipates the extreme measures Emily might eventually propose, or the strain it will put on their relationship.
A Fragmented Connection
Even with Jake's renewed commitment, Emily's grief is a powerful barrier. She struggles with intimacy, feeling emotionally and physically distant from Jake. Their once strong connection seems fragile, and their conversations often revolve around her pain, leaving little room for shared joy or lightness. Jake tries to be patient and understanding, but he also feels the weight of her sorrow and the strain on their relationship. He tries to get her to do their past activities, like going to parties or studying together, but Emily often declines, preferring solitude. This period shows how isolating deep grief can be.
The First Mention of a Baby
During a quiet evening, while discussing her ongoing struggles and the lingering emptiness she feels, Emily tentatively brings up the idea of having another baby. She frames it as a way to 'fill the void' and to heal from their loss. Jake is visibly surprised by the suggestion. While he loves Emily deeply and wants a family with her in the future, he feels it's too soon after their miscarriage. He expresses his concerns about the emotional and physical toll it might take, and the pressure it would put on them. This is the first time Emily articulates her controversial coping mechanism, and Jake's hesitant reaction hints at deeper disagreements.
A Growing Divide
As the weeks pass, Emily's suggestion of having another baby becomes a persistent desire. She becomes increasingly fixated on the idea, believing it's the only way she can truly move past her grief. She argues that it would be a way to honor their lost child and to start fresh. Jake, however, remains unconvinced and deeply worried. He believes they need more time to heal individually and as a couple before another pregnancy. Their discussions escalate into arguments, with Emily feeling unheard and Jake feeling pressured and misunderstood. The once united front of their relationship begins to crack under the strain of this fundamental disagreement.
Seeking External Comfort
Feeling increasingly isolated by Jake's reluctance, Emily confides in her friend, Sarah, about her desire to have another baby. Sarah, though initially surprised, offers a sympathetic ear, validating Emily's pain without necessarily endorsing her solution. Meanwhile, Jake, struggling with Emily's growing insistence, turns to Mark for advice. Mark, seeing the situation from Jake's perspective, advises caution and emphasizes the importance of both partners being ready. These separate conversations highlight the differing viewpoints and the emotional burden each partner carries, further emphasizing the gap that has opened between Emily and Jake.
The Ultimatum
The tension between Emily and Jake reaches a breaking point. Emily, convinced that having another baby is her only path to healing, presents Jake with an ultimatum: either he agrees to try for another child, or she doesn't see a future for them together. This drastic demand shatters Jake, who is torn between his love for Emily and his deep reservations about rushing into another pregnancy. He feels manipulated and cornered, his earlier promise of 'whatever it takes' now twisted into a painful bind. The emotional weight of this moment threatens to irrevocably damage their relationship.
Jake's Internal Conflict
After Emily's ultimatum, Jake retreats, wrestling with an agonizing decision. He loves Emily deeply and cannot imagine a life without her, yet he is terrified by the prospect of another rushed pregnancy, fearing it might worsen their trauma rather than heal it. He considers the implications for their future, their emotional well-being, and the health of their relationship. He recalls his promise to do 'whatever it takes,' but now questions the true meaning and limits of that vow. This internal struggle shows his deep loyalty and genuine concern for Emily's long-term happiness, even if it means sacrificing his own immediate comfort.
A Painful Decision
After days of agonizing deliberation, Jake makes the difficult decision to agree to Emily's terms. Despite his deep reservations and fears, his love for Emily and his desire to alleviate her suffering outweigh his personal anxieties. He tells Emily that he will go along with her plan, but his concession is tinged with sadness and an underlying sense of dread. Emily, relieved, believes this is the path to her healing, but the moment is bittersweet, as Jake's agreement feels more like a sacrifice than a shared decision. This moment highlights the theme of unconditional love and the potential for self-sacrifice in a relationship.
The Aftermath and Lingering Doubts
Initially, Emily feels a temporary sense of peace and relief after Jake agrees to her plan. She believes she has found the solution to her grief and begins to look towards the future with a renewed, though fragile, hope. However, Jake's quiet unhappiness and internal struggle are clear. He goes through the motions, but his enthusiasm is absent, replaced by a somber resignation. The agreement, while seemingly resolving their conflict, has created a new, silent tension. Emily, while focused on her own healing, slowly starts to notice Jake's subdued demeanor, hinting that her 'solution' might not be a shared one.
A Glimmer of Understanding
As the days turn into weeks, Emily starts to observe Jake more closely. She sees the quiet sadness in his eyes, the forced smiles, and the way he often retreats. The initial relief she felt begins to wane, replaced by a growing awareness of the sacrifice Jake has made. She realizes that her grief, while deep, has led her to make demands that have deeply impacted the man she loves. This realization is a painful but important step in her healing process, as she begins to look beyond her own immediate pain and acknowledge Jake's suffering.
A Shared Path Forward
Moved by Jake's quiet suffering and her own dawning understanding, Emily approaches him with a renewed sense of empathy. She apologizes for her ultimatum and acknowledges the immense pressure she put on him. They finally have an honest, heartfelt conversation about their shared grief, the miscarriage, and their individual ways of coping. Emily expresses her fear of forgetting their lost baby, and Jake reassures her that they will always remember, together. This deep conversation marks a turning point, as they move away from Emily's singular solution towards a shared path of healing, focusing on their relationship first.
Rebuilding Together
Emily and Jake decide to postpone their plans for another baby. Instead, they commit to focusing on rebuilding their relationship, healing from their shared trauma, and supporting each other through their grief. They start attending counseling sessions, talking openly about their feelings, and rediscovering the joy in their connection. This decision strengthens their bond, proving that their love can withstand challenges. They understand that true healing comes from within and from each other, not from replacing what was lost. Their journey together shows resilience and the power of communication.
Principal Figures
Emily
The Protagonist
Emily moves from being consumed by her grief and making desperate demands to recognizing the impact of her actions on Jake and choosing a healthier path to healing.
Jake
The Protagonist/Supporting
Jake grapples with his promise to Emily, navigating the line between support and self-preservation, ultimately showing profound love through sacrifice and open communication.
Sarah
The Supporting
Sarah remains a consistent, supportive friend to Emily, providing an outlet for her thoughts and feelings.
Mark
The Supporting
Mark offers consistent, practical advice and support to Jake as he navigates his relationship challenges.
Themes & Insights
Grief and Loss
The central theme is the isolating experience of grief, specifically after a miscarriage. Emily's struggle with nightmares, withdrawal, and her intense desire to 'replace' her lost baby clearly show her deep sorrow. Jake's seemingly stoic coping mechanism highlights the different ways individuals process loss, and how these differences can create distance in relationships. The story explores the lasting impact of trauma and the difficulty of finding healthy ways to cope, initially showing Emily's desperate attempts to escape her pain rather than confronting it directly.
“The emptiness was a physical ache, a phantom limb where a future should have been.”
Communication and Misunderstanding
The breakdown and eventual rebuilding of communication are important to the story. Initially, Emily and Jake struggle to openly discuss their shared grief, leading to misunderstandings about each other's coping mechanisms. Jake's silence is misinterpreted as indifference, while Emily's withdrawal isolates her further. The climax of their conflict, Emily's ultimatum, directly stems from a lack of true understanding and shared processing. Their eventual decision to seek counseling and engage in honest dialogue shows the power of effective communication in healing and strengthening a relationship.
“We were both hurting, but we were hurting alone, side by side.”
Love and Sacrifice
The theme of love and sacrifice is mainly shown through Jake's devotion to Emily. His promise to do 'whatever it takes' shows his deep love. This promise is tested when Emily makes a demand that goes against his own comfort and readiness. Jake's agonizing decision to agree to her terms, despite his deep doubts, highlights the sacrifices one makes for the person they love. Ultimately, Emily's recognition of his sacrifice and her subsequent change of heart shows that true love also involves mutual understanding and a willingness to compromise for shared well-being.
“I'd walk through fire for her, but this felt like asking me to drown.”
Healing and Growth
The story explores the challenging journey of healing and personal growth after trauma. Emily's initial belief that another baby is the only cure for her grief represents a desire for a quick fix. Her story shows that true healing is a gradual, internal process that requires confronting pain, accepting loss, and rebuilding one's life. Both Emily and Jake grow by learning to communicate more effectively, acknowledging each other's pain, and prioritizing their relationship's health over individual desires. Their decision to seek counseling and work through their issues together shows a mature approach to healing and growth.
“Healing wasn't about forgetting, but about learning to carry the memory without it crushing you.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The Ultimatum
Emily's demand that Jake agree to try for another baby or end their relationship.
The ultimatum serves as the primary turning point and catalyst for the climax of the story. It forces Jake to confront his fears and his promise, creating intense internal and external conflict. This device raises the stakes dramatically, pushing the characters to their emotional limits and forcing a painful decision that could irrevocably alter their future. It highlights Emily's desperation and Jake's deep love and commitment, revealing the true nature of their relationship under extreme pressure.
Recurring Nightmares
Emily's consistent dreams reliving the trauma of her miscarriage.
The recurring nightmares are a powerful symbol of Emily's unresolved grief and trauma. They serve to externalize her internal suffering, making her pain tangible and illustrating the psychological impact of her loss. This device also acts as a narrative trigger, prompting Emily to eventually open up to Jake and driving her desperate desire for a 'solution.' The nightmares underscore the depth of her emotional wounds and her struggle to find peace.
The Promise: 'Whatever It Takes'
Jake's unwavering vow to support Emily through her grief.
Jake's promise to do 'whatever it takes' is a crucial plot device that establishes his character's devotion and sets up the central conflict. It creates a moral dilemma when Emily's 'solution' directly challenges his own comfort and well-being. This promise forces Jake into an impossible position, exploring the limits of love and sacrifice. It ultimately highlights the theme of unconditional love, but also the potential for such a vow to be misinterpreted or exploited in times of extreme emotional distress.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Sometimes the bravest thing you can do is admit you're scared.”
— A friend offering advice to the protagonist facing a difficult decision.
“The future wasn't a fixed point; it was a canvas waiting for us to paint it, brushstroke by hopeful brushstroke.”
— Protagonist contemplating her post-high school plans and dreams.
“It's funny how the people you least expect can be the ones who see you most clearly.”
— Realization about a developing friendship/romance with an unexpected character.
“Heartbreak wasn't the end of the world, but it certainly felt like a preview of it.”
— After a significant romantic disappointment.
“We all have scars, some visible, some hidden deep. They tell our stories.”
— A moment of shared vulnerability between two characters.
“You can't force someone to see your worth. They either do, or they don't. And if they don't, that's their loss, not yours.”
— Advice given to the protagonist about self-worth and unrequited feelings.
“The quiet moments, the ones where nothing grand happened, were often the ones that mattered most.”
— Reflecting on the small, intimate moments in a relationship.
“Growing up isn't about having all the answers. It's about learning to live with all the questions.”
— An adult mentor offering wisdom to the young protagonist.
“Sometimes, 'whatever it takes' meant letting go, not holding on tighter.”
— A pivotal realization about the nature of a challenging commitment.
“The hardest goodbyes are the ones you never truly say, just feel.”
— Protagonist dealing with an unspoken farewell or a fading connection.
“Hope is a stubborn thing. Even when you try to bury it, it finds a way to sprout.”
— After a period of despair, finding a renewed sense of optimism.
“Being brave isn't about not being afraid. It's about doing it anyway.”
— Protagonist facing a fear and pushing through it.
“Our stories aren't written in isolation. They're woven together with the threads of everyone we meet.”
— Reflecting on the interconnectedness of lives and relationships.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
Emily is grappling with profound grief and trauma following the miscarriage of her baby. Her internal struggle is compounded by her perception of Jake's seemingly detached reaction to the loss, leading to conflict within herself and their relationship. She experiences debilitating nightmares and struggles to find a healthy coping mechanism.
