“When you loved someone, you didn’t just stop. You didn’t just forget. You took a piece of them with you, and you hoped that one day, you’d run into them again.”
— Blaire reflects on her past relationship with Rush.
Archivist's Choice
Under the Lights
Abbi Glines (2016)
Genre
Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
320 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
A small-town girl, haunted by her past, must choose between her childhood crush and the rebellious football star who understands her, as their histories create a dramatic love triangle.
Synopsis
Willa returns to Lawton, a small Southern town. She carries past mistakes and wants forgiveness from her family. She tries to keep everyone distant, especially Brady, her childhood crush and the town's star quarterback. Brady struggles to accept the changed Willa, all while dealing with his jealous girlfriend, Emily. Gunner, another former friend and football star from a powerful family, offers Willa support. He sees past her defenses in a way Brady cannot. Willa's past secrets, especially her connection to Rome, are revealed, and a love triangle develops. The homecoming dance brings public humiliation for Willa, making Brady more jealous and leading to an ultimatum from Emily. Brenda, Willa's mother, shares important truths, which leads to a reconciliation. Brady must choose between Emily and his feelings for Willa. Gunner confesses his love for Willa. Willa makes a difficult decision, choosing a new beginning with the person who truly understands and accepts her, leaving the past behind.
Reading time
320 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Dramatic, Romantic, Emotional, Angsty
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy angsty young adult romance with a love triangle, themes of redemption, and small-town drama.
✗ Skip this if...
You dislike love triangles, prefer less dramatic plots, or are looking for a story without common YA romance tropes.
Plot Summary
Willa's Return and the Weight of the Past
Willa is back in Lawton, Alabama, after a difficult time when her mother, Brenda, sent her away for rebellious behavior, including a relationship with Rome. She lives with her grandfather, Pop, because her mother will not let her in the house. Most of the town, including her mother, sees her as a 'town whore' and a disappointment. Her only supporters are her grandfather and her friend, Emily. Willa tries to act tough, but the constant judgment, especially from her mother, hurts her deeply. She meets Brady Higgens, her childhood friend and crush, who is now the star quarterback and dating Emily. She also sees Gunner Lawton, another childhood friend and football star, known for being reckless and a womanizer. He shows a surprising protective side towards Willa.
Brady's Conflicted Feelings and Emily's Jealousy
Brady Higgens, even though he is with Emily, feels drawn to Willa. He remembers the innocent girl she once was and struggles to connect that image with how the town sees her now. His attempts to talk to Willa often turn into arguments, as Willa pushes him away, believing he judges her like everyone else. Emily sees the clear tension and history between Brady and Willa and becomes more jealous and insecure. She makes pointed comments to Willa, reminding her of her past mistakes and reputation, which isolates Willa more and widens the gap between the three former friends.
Gunner's Unexpected Support and Growing Connection
Gunner Lawton does not avoid Willa's reputation. He seems to understand the pain beneath her tough exterior. He often steps in when others are mean to her, and his presence gives Willa a sense of protection and acceptance she rarely finds. Their conversations are playful but also very honest. Gunner, despite his playboy image, shows he understands Willa's struggles, especially her difficult relationship with her mother. He encourages her to stop letting others' opinions define her. Slowly, Willa starts to relax around him, finding comfort in his unexpected support.
The Homecoming Dance and Public Humiliation
The Homecoming dance becomes important for Willa. She attends despite her hesitation, hoping for a normal night. However, a group of popular girls, led by a particularly mean one, publicly shames her, making negative comments about her past. Willa feels deeply hurt and retreats from the dance floor. Gunner sees this and is angry at the unfairness. He confronts the girls, defending Willa and making it clear their behavior is wrong. This public defense makes Gunner Willa's protector and strengthens their bond, as Willa sees he truly cares.
Brady's Jealousy and Emily's Ultimatum
Brady's feelings for Willa become clear to him, especially after seeing Willa and Gunner grow closer. He feels regret for not being there for Willa when she needed him and is jealous of Gunner's easy connection with her. Emily, tired of Brady's divided attention and his obvious lingering feelings for Willa, confronts him. She tells him to choose her and commit fully to their relationship, or she will leave. This makes Brady face his mixed emotions and the truth about his relationship with Emily, which he realizes is not as strong as he once thought.
The Truth About Rome and Willa's Past
Willa finally tells Gunner the full story of her past relationship with Rome. She reveals that Rome was abusive and controlling, and her 'rebellious' behavior was largely an attempt to escape his control and the trauma. She explains that her mother's harsh judgment and sending her away felt like more punishment, not protection. Gunner listens without judgment, offering comfort and understanding. This confession is a big step for Willa, as she finally shares her deepest pain with someone who truly believes and supports her, which strengthens their emotional connection.
Brenda's Revelation and Reconciliation
After seeing Willa's struggles and the impact of her own harshness, Brenda finally faces her own past. She tells Willa that she also had a difficult experience as a teenager, which led to her becoming pregnant with Willa's older sister. This past trauma made her react with extreme fear and anger when Willa started down a similar path with Rome. This revelation helps Willa understand her mother's reasons, though it does not excuse her actions. The two have an honest, emotional conversation that leads to a much-needed reconciliation, a healing moment for their family.
Brady's Choice and Emily's Reaction
Brady realizes he can no longer deny his feelings for Willa and that his relationship with Emily is not real. He breaks up with Emily. The breakup is hard, and Emily is hurt and angry. She confronts Willa, publicly accusing her of stealing Brady and repeating her past mistakes. This confrontation, however, no longer affects Willa in the same way. With Gunner's support and her reconciled mother, Willa stands firm, refusing to let Emily's words define her. Brady then tells Willa his intentions, expressing his desire to be with her and to make up for lost time.
Gunner's Confession and Willa's Dilemma
As Brady openly pursues Willa, Gunner, who has been a steady source of support and a growing romantic interest, tells her his true feelings. He says he loves her and has fallen for the strong, resilient woman she has become, seeing past her reputation to her true self. This confession puts Willa in a difficult position. She has deep affection and history with Brady, but Gunner has been her anchor and protector during her hardest times, understanding her in a way no one else has. She is torn between the two men, both of whom now openly declare their love.
Willa's Decision and a New Beginning
After much thought, Willa makes her decision. She realizes that while her history with Brady is strong, Gunner has seen her at her worst, loved her despite her past, and helped her heal. She chooses Gunner, recognizing that his unconditional acceptance and deep understanding are what she truly needs. Brady, though heartbroken, accepts her choice. Willa and Gunner start a new chapter. Willa finally feels truly loved, accepted, and free from her past. She looks forward to a future where she is defined by her strength and the love she shares, not by others' judgment.
Principal Figures
Willa
The Protagonist
Willa transforms from an ostracized, defensive young woman haunted by her past to a self-assured individual who embraces love and forgiveness.
Gunner Lawton
The Supporting/Romantic Interest
Gunner evolves from a seemingly shallow playboy to a devoted, understanding partner, demonstrating his true capacity for love and commitment.
Brady Higgens
The Supporting/Romantic Interest
Brady learns to acknowledge his true feelings and make difficult decisions, even if it means hurting others, to pursue genuine love.
Brenda
The Supporting
Brenda moves from a judgmental and estranged mother to one who understands, forgives, and reconciles with her daughter.
Pop
The Supporting
Pop remains a constant source of unwavering love and support, providing stability amidst Willa's turmoil.
Emily
The Supporting/Antagonist
Emily's character arc shifts from supportive friend to jealous rival, ultimately losing her relationship with Brady.
Rome
The Mentioned
Rome's influence on Willa's life is revealed to be a source of trauma, which she eventually overcomes.
Willa's Older Sister
The Mentioned
Her story helps Willa understand her mother's past and facilitates their reconciliation.
Themes & Insights
Identity and Self-Acceptance
Willa's main struggle is to define herself apart from the 'bad girl' label given by her town and mother. She deals with past mistakes and the trauma of her relationship with Rome. She learns to define herself by her own strength, not by others' judgments. Her journey involves dropping her tough act and accepting herself, flaws and all, especially through Gunner's acceptance and her eventual reconciliation with her mother. This theme shows that internal validation is more important than how others see her.
““I was tired of being the girl everyone whispered about. I was tired of letting their words define me.””
Forgiveness and Reconciliation
This theme appears in many ways: Willa's struggle to forgive herself, her mother's journey to forgive Willa and herself, and the eventual reconciliation between mother and daughter. Brenda's revelation of her own traumatic past helps explain her harshness, allowing Willa to forgive her mother and for them to begin healing their broken relationship. Forgiveness is not about approving actions but about letting go of resentment and allowing for a new start, which is important for Willa's emotional health.
““Sometimes, the hardest person to forgive is yourself.””
Love and Loyalty vs. Reputation
The book shows how love and loyalty can go beyond what society judges. Brady struggles with his desire for Willa versus his fear of public opinion, initially choosing the safer path with Emily. In contrast, Gunner consistently supports Willa, seeing past her 'bad girl' image to the vulnerable, strong woman inside. His loyalty and acceptance eventually win Willa's heart. This shows that true love values understanding and support over external perception. The story highlights how shallow reputation is compared to real connection.
““He didn't care what anyone else thought of her. He just saw her.””
The Impact of Small-Town Gossip and Judgment
Lawton, Alabama, acts almost like a character itself, with its gossip and judgmental attitudes deeply affecting Willa. The town's memory of her past mistakes creates an isolating environment, making it hard for Willa to move forward. The public shaming at the Homecoming dance and Emily's constant jabs directly show this theme. The book critiques how small communities can hold onto stories, preventing people from growing and healing, and shows the strength needed to overcome such scrutiny.
““In a town like Lawton, your past followed you like a shadow you could never outrun.””
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
Love Triangle
A central romantic conflict involving Willa, Brady, and Gunner.
The love triangle between Willa, Brady, and Gunner is the primary romantic plot device. It creates tension and drives much of the character development and difficult choices. Brady represents Willa's past, a familiar comfort and longing, while Gunner embodies acceptance, understanding, and a passionate present/future. This device forces Willa to confront her true desires and what she values most in a partner, ultimately leading her to choose the love that offers genuine healing and unconditional acceptance over nostalgic comfort.
Flashbacks/Recollections
Brief mentions and internal thoughts about past events to reveal character backstory.
While not full flashbacks, the narrative frequently employs brief recollections and internal monologues from Willa and Brady about their shared childhood and Willa's traumatic past with Rome. These moments are crucial for revealing the backstory, explaining characters' motivations, and building empathy. They gradually unveil the truth behind Willa's reputation and her mother's harshness, adding depth and complexity to the plot without disrupting the present-day narrative flow.
The 'Bad Girl' Trope Subversion
Initial presentation of Willa as a 'bad girl' to later reveal a deeper, more nuanced truth.
The novel initially presents Willa as the stereotypical 'bad girl' with a tarnished reputation, echoing the town's perception. This trope is then subverted as the narrative gradually reveals the underlying trauma, abuse (from Rome), and misunderstanding that led to her past behavior. This device challenges the reader to look beyond superficial judgments and empathize with Willa's struggles, reinforcing the theme of not judging a book by its cover and highlighting the devastating impact of societal labels.
Confidant Character (Pop and Gunner)
Characters who provide emotional support and a safe space for the protagonist.
Pop and, later, Gunner serve as confidant characters for Willa. Pop offers unconditional love and a safe home, allowing Willa to be vulnerable without judgment. Gunner evolves into a romantic confidant, being the first person Willa fully trusts with the traumatic details of her past with Rome. These characters are vital for Willa's emotional development, providing the necessary support for her to process her trauma, confront her fears, and ultimately heal. They act as anchors for her in a sea of judgment and misunderstanding.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Some truths were too painful to ever be told.”
— Blaire grapples with secrets and their impact.
“Sometimes the person you were meant to be with was the one you least expected.”
— Blaire considers her evolving feelings for someone unexpected.
“He might have broken my heart, but he hadn't broken my spirit.”
— Blaire's determination after a heartbreak.
“Every time I thought I had him figured out, he would do something that completely threw me.”
— Blaire's confusion over Rush's unpredictable behavior.
“The past was a heavy burden, but it was also a part of who we were.”
— Characters confront their pasts and how they shape them.
“Love wasn’t always easy. Sometimes it was messy and complicated, but it was always worth fighting for.”
— A reflection on the struggles and rewards of love.
“He was my addiction, my drug, and I couldn't get enough.”
— Blaire's intense attraction to Rush.
“Sometimes you had to hit rock bottom to truly appreciate what you had.”
— A character's realization after facing a difficult situation.
“Secrets had a way of tearing people apart, no matter how well they were kept.”
— The destructive nature of hidden truths.
“I wanted to hate him, but my heart just wouldn't let me.”
— Blaire's conflicting emotions towards Rush.
“You couldn't run from fate forever. Eventually, it always caught up to you.”
— Characters realizing they cannot escape their predetermined paths.
“He was the storm, and I was the calm, but together, we were a hurricane.”
— A metaphor for the dynamic and powerful connection between two characters.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
"Under the Lights" is a young adult romance novel centered around a dramatic love triangle involving former childhood friends Willa, Brady, and Gunner in the small southern town of Lawton. Willa is trying to redeem herself from past mistakes, while Brady, the town's golden boy, struggles with the changed person she has become. Gunner, another football star, understands Willa's complexities in a way Brady can't, leading to a tangled web of secrets, heartbreak, and self-discovery.
About the author
Abbi Glines is a New York Times bestselling author known for her contemporary romance novels. Her "Too Far" series, including "Until Friday Night" and "Never Too Far," has garnered significant popularity. Glines is celebrated for her emotional storytelling and relatable characters, captivating readers with tales of love and resilience.
