“The past is never really gone, is it? It just waits for you to stumble back into it.”
— Erin contemplates the resurgence of an old murder case.
Archivist's Choice
To Catch a Killer
Sheryl Scarborough (2017)
Genre
Thriller / Mystery / Young Adult
Reading Time
360 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
Haunted by her mother's unsolved murder, a teen forensic enthusiast finds herself the prime suspect in a new homicide, forcing her to race against time to unmask a killer who might be closer than she ever imagined.
Synopsis
Fourteen years ago, Erin Blake was found as a toddler next to her murdered mother. The case is unsolved and links her name to a national tragedy. Now a teenager, Erin's life is again shattered when she finds her biology teacher's body. Erin believes her mother's killer has struck again. She keeps her suspicions secret from the police, fearing they will not believe her and to protect her own cold-case investigation into her mother's death. Her FBI agent uncle inspired Erin to become a skilled amateur forensic investigator.
As Erin investigates the new murder, she finds connections to her mother's past. She realizes the killer targets those close to her. The police, however, begin to see Erin as their main suspect because of circumstantial evidence. Desperate to clear her name and find the real killer, Erin enlists the help of her crush, Journey Michaels, who is also under suspicion. Together, they race against time, unraveling betrayals and long-held secrets. They unmask a killer with a personal vendetta before Erin becomes the next victim and is wrongly accused.
Reading time
360 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Fast
Mood
Suspenseful, Intriguing, Determined, Dangerous
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy fast-paced YA thrillers with a determined amateur sleuth, cold cases, and a touch of romance.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer intricate, character-driven mysteries over plot-heavy suspense or find protagonists who withhold information from the police frustrating.
Plot Summary
A Gruesome Discovery and Lingering Shadows
Fourteen-year-old Erin Blake's life is marked by a tragic past: as a toddler, she was found next to her murdered mother. Her father's identity is unknown, and the case is unsolved. Now, a high school student living with her mother's best friend, Cynthia, and Cynthia's son, Spam, Erin finds herself in the spotlight again when she discovers her biology teacher, Mr. K, dead. The scene immediately reminds her of her mother's murder, especially the precise placement of the victim's hands. Erin, who secretly studies cold cases and forensic science, suspects a connection. She withholds some details from the police, fearing her suspicions about her mother's killer returning will make her seem unreliable or implicate her.
Suspicion Mounts and a Search for Answers
The police, led by Detective Miller, begin their investigation into Mr. K's death. Erin finds herself under scrutiny because of her history and her presence at the crime scene. Despite the pressure, Erin secretly continues her own investigation, driven by the chilling similarities to her mother's murder. She confides in her best friend, Spam, and her crush, Journey Michaels. Both become involved in her search for answers. Erin's uncle, an FBI agent named Alex, unknowingly supports her forensic interests, but she keeps her personal investigation hidden from him. As she investigates, Erin starts to find inconsistencies and links between the two cases, confirming her belief that the same killer is responsible.
A Shared Past and a Growing Alliance
As the investigation into Mr. K's murder continues, Journey Michaels also becomes a person of interest. He had problems with Mr. K and was known to be at school after hours. This shared situation forces Erin and Journey to work together. They form an alliance to clear their names and find the truth. They begin to combine their resources and observations, with Journey providing information from his interactions with Mr. K and Erin using her forensic knowledge. Their collaboration strengthens their bond, changing their relationship from a distant crush to a partnership in a high-stakes murder investigation. They realize that working together gives them a better chance against the growing evidence.
Unraveling Clues and Dangerous Connections
Erin and Journey's investigation leads them to discover that Mr. K had a hidden past and connections to people Erin's mother knew. They find old yearbooks and photographs. These show that Mr. K, whose real name was Mr. Kincaid, had attended the same college as Erin's mother, Tabitha, and her best friend, Cynthia. This discovery is a breakthrough, providing a concrete link between the two seemingly separate murders. They also find evidence suggesting Mr. K was blackmailing someone, possibly related to events from their college days. These revelations strengthen Erin's belief that her mother's killer is still active and that Mr. K's murder is directly tied to the cold case, not a random act of violence.
A Killer's Message and Escalating Threats
As Erin and Journey continue their investigation, the killer targets them. Cryptic messages and planted evidence start to appear, seemingly designed to frame Erin for Mr. K's murder. A specific piece of evidence, a locket belonging to Erin's mother, is found at a location connected to Mr. K. This makes Erin a main suspect to the police. This escalation confirms Erin's theory that the killer is trying to implicate her and is aware of her private investigation. The danger becomes real, forcing Erin and Journey to work faster and more discreetly. They realize they are racing against time not only to find the killer but also to protect Erin from false accusations and harm.
Betrayal and a Shocking Revelation
Through research and piecing together clues, Erin and Journey uncover the truth: the killer is Cynthia, Erin's adoptive mother and her biological mother's best friend. The motive comes from a long-held secret and resentment. Cynthia was having an affair with Erin's biological father, who was Mr. Kincaid (Mr. K). Tabitha, Erin's mother, found out about the affair and threatened to expose them. Cynthia, in a fit of rage, murdered Tabitha to protect her secret and her relationship with Mr. Kincaid. Years later, Mr. Kincaid, now Mr. K, threatened to expose Cynthia's past. This led her to murder him as well, using the same method to make it appear as if the original killer had returned, thus deflecting suspicion from herself.
Confrontation and a Desperate Escape
Armed with the truth, Erin confronts Cynthia, who first pretends innocence but quickly shows her manipulative nature. Cynthia tries to gaslight Erin, but Erin presents the evidence she and Journey gathered. Realizing she is exposed, Cynthia's calm breaks, and she becomes violent, trying to silence Erin permanently. A tense chase follows, with Erin trying to escape Cynthia and get the evidence to the authorities. Spam, Cynthia's son and Erin's best friend, is caught in the middle, struggling to understand the loving mother he knows and the killer Erin is exposing. Journey arrives, having followed Erin, and helps her during the confrontation, further strengthening their bond.
The Truth Revealed and Justice Served
The confrontation ends with Cynthia being apprehended by the police. They arrive just in time, alerted by Erin's earlier calls or Journey's actions. The evidence Erin and Journey collected is presented, supporting Erin's accusations. Cynthia's guilt in both Tabitha's and Mr. K's murders is proven. The long-unsolved mystery of Erin's mother's death is finally closed, bringing peace to Erin's past. While the emotional scars remain, Erin finds a new sense of closure and understanding about her identity and history. The experience strengthens her bond with Journey and Spam, and she begins to heal from the trauma that has overshadowed her entire life.
Principal Figures
Erin Blake
The Protagonist
Erin transforms from a haunted girl secretly investigating her past into a proactive detective who exposes a killer and finds closure.
Journey Michaels
The Supporting/Love Interest
Journey evolves from a detached individual into a committed and protective partner, learning to trust and fight for Erin.
Cynthia
The Antagonist
Cynthia maintains her facade of a loving mother until her true identity as a calculating killer is exposed.
Spam
The Supporting
Spam transitions from an oblivious best friend to someone who must confront the painful truth about his mother and stand by Erin.
Detective Miller
The Supporting
Detective Miller's suspicion of Erin gradually shifts as more evidence is uncovered, leading him to the real killer.
Mr. K (Mr. Kincaid)
The Mentioned/Victim
As a victim, Mr. K's past is slowly revealed, exposing his connection to Erin's biological parents and the killer.
Tabitha Blake
The Mentioned/Victim
As a victim, Tabitha's past is slowly uncovered, revealing the betrayal that led to her death.
Alex
The Supporting
Alex remains a supportive but largely unaware figure, serving as an inspiration for Erin's forensic pursuits.
Themes & Insights
Identity and Self-Discovery
Erin's identity is shaped by her mother's unsolved murder. Her search for the killer is linked to understanding who she is and where she comes from. She struggles with the 'Erin Blake' name, tied to tragedy, and tries to define herself beyond it. The revelations about her biological father and the true nature of her mother's death make her rethink her family and her place in the world, leading to a clearer sense of self.
“My name, Erin Blake. Not just a name, but a story. The girl found next to her murdered mother. I wanted to rewrite it.”
The Nature of Truth and Deception
The novel shows how easily truth can be hidden and how deception can look like care. Cynthia, a seemingly loving adoptive mother, is a calculating killer who has maintained a lie for over a decade. Erin's journey involves sifting through layers of lies and constructed appearances to uncover the reality. The theme highlights the danger of trusting appearances and the strength needed to seek uncomfortable truths, even from unexpected sources.
“The hardest truths are always hidden in plain sight, disguised as love or loyalty.”
Justice and Vengeance
Erin is driven by a desire for justice for her mother, but her pursuit also borders on personal revenge against a killer who has avoided capture for so long. The story contrasts the formal legal process, shown by Detective Miller, with Erin's personal, often reckless, search for answers. The novel suggests that true justice involves both legal consequences for the perpetrator and emotional closure for the victim's loved ones, which Erin eventually achieves.
“It wasn't just about solving a case anymore; it was about making them pay for what they did to my mother.”
The Burden of the Past
Erin's past is not just a memory; it affects much of her present. The trauma of her mother's murder, the unanswered questions, and the public interest in her story weigh heavily on her. The discovery of Mr. K's body brings back this burden, forcing her to confront unresolved grief and fear. The novel shows how past events can continue to shape individuals, influencing their choices and relationships until they are addressed.
“Some pasts don't stay in the past. They follow you, breathe down your neck, until you turn around and face them.”
Trust and Betrayal
A main theme is the impact of trust and betrayal. Erin struggles with trusting others because of her traumatic past. Her journey reveals the ultimate betrayal by Cynthia, someone she considered a loving mother figure. This betrayal shatters Erin's world, forcing her to re-evaluate all her relationships. Conversely, her growing trust in Journey and Spam, and their support, shows the power of genuine connection in the face of deceit.
“How do you ever trust anyone again when the person who raised you, who swore to protect you, was the monster all along?”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The Cold Case
Erin's mother's unsolved murder, which serves as the foundational mystery and her primary motivation.
The cold case of Tabitha Blake's murder is the driving force behind Erin's character and the plot. It establishes Erin's unique background, her fascination with forensics, and her deep-seated need for answers. The re-emergence of similar crime scene details in Mr. K's murder immediately connects the past to the present, transforming Erin's personal quest into an active investigation. This device creates immediate stakes and a personal investment for the protagonist, ensuring the reader is deeply engaged in uncovering the long-buried truth.
Parallel Murders
The striking similarities between Tabitha's and Mr. K's murders, particularly the hand placement, linking the two cases.
The narrative explicitly draws parallels between the method and presentation of the two murders, especially the victim's hands being arranged in a specific, almost ritualistic, manner. This device immediately signals to both Erin and the reader that the cases are connected and likely involve the same perpetrator. It acts as a crucial clue, guiding Erin's investigation and solidifying her conviction that her mother's killer has returned. It also creates a sense of dread and urgency, as the killer's signature is now active again.
Amateur Detective vs. Official Investigation
Erin's secret forensic investigation running parallel to the police's official inquiry.
This device highlights Erin's unique skills and determination while creating tension and conflict. Erin, with her forensic hobby, often uncovers clues or makes connections that the police initially miss or dismiss. Her secrecy from Detective Miller and even her uncle Alex adds to the suspense, as she navigates the dangers of her investigation without official backing. This contrast allows for different perspectives on the evidence and showcases Erin's intelligence and resilience in pursuing the truth outside conventional channels, often putting her in direct opposition to authority.
The Red Herring
Journey Michaels' initial status as a primary suspect in Mr. K's murder.
Journey Michaels is cleverly introduced as a potential suspect due to his contentious relationship with Mr. K and his presence at the school after hours. This misdirection serves to heighten the mystery and divert attention from the true killer. It also forces Erin and Journey to collaborate, as they both need to clear their names, thus strengthening their bond and driving the plot forward. The red herring effectively builds suspense and makes the eventual revelation of the real culprit more surprising and impactful.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Sometimes the people you trust the most are the ones with the darkest secrets.”
— Erin begins to suspect those close to her.
“Fear has a way of making you see things that aren't there, and ignoring the ones that are.”
— Erin reflects on her own anxieties during the investigation.
“Grief is a strange beast. It can make you strong, or it can tear you apart.”
— Erin considers the impact of loss on the characters.
“Every small town has its ghosts, and ours just decided to wake up.”
— Erin describes the unsettling atmosphere of her hometown.
“You can't outrun your history, especially when it's buried right in your backyard.”
— Erin realizes the deep roots of the crime.
“The truth is rarely simple, and often, it's the last thing you want to hear.”
— Erin uncovers complex motives and revelations.
“Sometimes, the only way to heal is to face the monsters, real or imagined.”
— Erin confronts her fears and the killer.
“Silence can be louder than any scream when it's hiding something terrible.”
— Erin reflects on the suppressed secrets in the town.
“It's not about finding the killer; it's about understanding why.”
— Erin shifts her focus from just identification to motivation.
“Even the clearest memories can be twisted by time and pain.”
— Erin questions the reliability of past testimonies.
“We all have a breaking point. The question is, what happens after you reach yours?”
— Erin considers the psychological toll of the events.
“Sometimes, the most dangerous lies are the ones we tell ourselves.”
— Erin realizes her own self-deception about certain people.
“Justice isn't always about punishment; sometimes it's about setting things right.”
— Erin considers the broader implications of solving the case.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
"To Catch a Killer" follows Erin Blake, a teenager whose past is defined by a national tragedy: at age two, she was found next to her murdered mother, a case that remains unsolved. Fourteen years later, she discovers her biology teacher's body, triggering her secret cold-case investigation into her mother's death, as she suspects the same killer has resurfaced. When police evidence implicates her, she teams up with Journey Michaels to find the real culprit.
