“The heart wants what it wants, even when the head knows better.”
— Early on, the protagonist reflects on her enduring feelings for a man she knows is trouble.
Archivist's Choice
To Catch a Cheat
Kelley St. John (2007)
Genre
Literary Fiction / Romance
Reading Time
550 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
After a string of unfaithful boyfriends, a cynical Marissa creates a website to expose serial cheaters, only to bring back her first love, who wants to prove not all men give in to temptation.
Synopsis
Marissa, a talented single woman in her thirties, has become cynical about love after several relationships with unfaithful men. To deal with her frustration, she starts 'Catch a Cheat,' a website meant to expose serial cheaters. The site quickly becomes popular, allowing others to share their stories. However, her mission is disrupted by the unexpected return of Josh Miller, her first boyfriend from high school. Josh, now successful and charming, wants to prove to Marissa that not all men cheat and that true love still exists. Marissa investigates a claim against Josh on her website, leading them to spend more time together, and their old feelings return. Together, they uncover the truth behind the accusation, making Marissa question her biases and the purpose of 'Catch a Cheat.' Marissa must then decide whether to continue exposing cheaters or to embrace a renewed romance with Josh, which would change her understanding of love and trust.
Reading time
550 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Hopeful, Romantic, Reflective, Contemporary
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy stories about second chances, overcoming past heartbreak, and the complexities of modern romance, with a touch of investigative intrigue.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer high-stakes thrillers or stories without romantic elements, or if you're not interested in exploring themes of trust and forgiveness.
Plot Summary
The Genesis of 'Catch a Cheat'
Marissa Dubois, a graphic designer in Chicago, is recovering from another failed relationship, this time with her seemingly perfect boyfriend, Kevin. This betrayal confirms her belief that all men are unfaithful, a conviction from a history of being cheated on, including by her own father. Wanting both release and connection, Marissa decides to turn her frustration into a project: a website called 'Catch a Cheat.' The site is a forum for women to anonymously share stories and proof of their cheating partners, aiming to create a database of serial philanderers and warn others. Her best friend, Chloe, is at first skeptical but eventually supports Marissa's effort, even helping with the technical parts of the site. Marissa puts her effort into the project, seeing it as a way to take back some control over her romantic life.
First Submissions and Growing Traction
Within weeks, 'Catch a Cheat' becomes popular. Marissa is surprised by the number of submissions from women nationwide, all sharing painful stories of betrayal. The site's anonymous nature lets women express their frustrations and share proof without fear, creating a strong sense of unity among users. Local news outlets notice the unique idea, leading to interviews with Marissa, where she explains her goal to expose serial cheaters and empower women. The increased media attention further boosts the site's growth, making 'Catch a Cheat' a growing online trend. Marissa finds purpose in her work, feeling like she is making a real difference in other women's lives, even as her personal cynicism about men deepens.
The Blast from the Past: Josh Miller
Among the many submissions, Marissa finds a familiar name: Josh Miller. Her heart races as she realizes it is the same Josh Miller who was her first serious boyfriend in high school, the one who broke her heart when he suddenly moved away. The submission, detailing an alleged affair, completely shatters her good memories of him as her 'one good guy.' This revelation is a double blow: it confirms her belief that even good men cheat, and it brings back unresolved feelings and questions about their past. Marissa struggles with the ethics of handling this personal connection to a submission on her anonymous site, feeling anger, sadness, and a strange curiosity.
Josh's Reappearance and Initial Confrontation
Shortly after the submission, Josh Miller, now a successful architect, contacts Marissa. He is angry about the post on 'Catch a Cheat,' strongly denying the infidelity claims. He explains that the woman who submitted him is an ex-girlfriend with a grudge, and the story is made up to ruin his reputation. Josh expresses his shock and disappointment that Marissa, of all people, is behind such a site, and demands she remove his name. Marissa, still hurt by their past and hardened by recent experiences, is at first skeptical and defensive. Their first interactions are tense, a mix of old unresolved feelings and new accusations. Josh, however, is persistent, determined to prove his innocence to Marissa and, in doing so, rekindle their connection.
Investigating the Claim
Despite her deep cynicism and past pain, Marissa cannot completely ignore Josh's pleas. She quietly investigates the claims against him, checking information and looking closely at the details in the submission. She talks with Chloe, who, always practical, encourages Marissa to stay objective. Marissa looks through public records and social media, trying to find the truth. Her investigation uncovers inconsistencies in the accuser's story, raising doubts about the claims. This process makes Marissa face her own biases and the possibility of her website being misused. The more she investigates, the more she realizes that not all stories are simple, and that her platform, while well-intentioned, could be used as a weapon.
Reconnecting with Josh
As Marissa continues her investigation into the claims against Josh, their interactions become more frequent and less hostile. They meet for coffee and then for dinner, at first discussing the website and the false accusations, but gradually moving to conversations about their shared past. They remember their teenage romance, their old dreams, and the pain of their sudden separation. Josh explains the circumstances of his family's sudden move, which he could not control, and expresses regret for not being able to say goodbye properly. Marissa, in turn, shares her own experiences with infidelity, explaining how 'Catch a Cheat' began. These conversations start to soften Marissa's hardened exterior, as she sees a vulnerability and sincerity in Josh that she had not seen in years.
Unraveling the Truth
Marissa's investigation eventually finds clear evidence that the submission against Josh was indeed fabricated. She discovers that the accuser had a history of making false claims and had other reasons for trying to damage Josh's reputation, likely from a bitter breakup and professional jealousy. The proof comes from verifiable timelines and alibis that contradict the accuser's story. This discovery is a major turning point for Marissa. It not only clears Josh's name but also makes her seriously re-evaluate the idea behind 'Catch a Cheat' and her own deep belief about men. She feels a deep sense of guilt for initially doubting Josh and for the potential harm her platform could cause if not properly checked.
The Website's Dilemma and Marissa's Crisis of Faith
The discovery of Josh's innocence puts Marissa into an ethical crisis about 'Catch a Cheat.' She realizes the immense power her platform holds and its potential for malicious use, harming innocent people. She discusses her dilemma with Chloe, who helps her think of ways to add stricter verification processes and safeguards to prevent future false accusations. Marissa begins to question her entire worldview, admitting that her cynicism had made her blind to complexities and individual differences. The website, once a source of empowerment, now feels like a burden, making her confront the complexities of truth, justice, and forgiveness. She understands that while her intentions were good, the execution needed significant changes to ensure fairness.
A Renewed Romance
With Josh's name cleared and Marissa's understanding of him restored, their relationship becomes romantic. Their old spark returns, fueled by shared history and a new appreciation for each other's strength. They spend more time together, going on dates, sharing intimate conversations, and rediscovering their deep connection. Josh is patient and understanding, helping Marissa slowly drop her emotional guard and believe in the possibility of a loyal, loving relationship. Marissa, in turn, finds herself falling in love with him again, realizing that he is not just a reminder of her past, but a real hope for her future. Their rekindled romance marks a significant step in Marissa's journey of healing and trusting again.
Redefining 'Catch a Cheat'
Inspired by her personal journey and the ethical challenges she faced, Marissa decides to change 'Catch a Cheat' from an exposure site to a more helpful platform. She rebrands it as 'True Connections' (or a similar name), shifting its focus from shaming cheaters to helping people navigate relationships, heal from betrayal, and build healthier partnerships. The site now offers resources for counseling, articles on communication and trust, and forums for sharing stories of recovery and growth. While still acknowledging the pain of infidelity, the emphasis is now on moving forward and encouraging positive change. This transformation reflects Marissa's own shift from a cynical victim to a hopeful advocate for healthy love, showing her growth and commitment to responsible online community building.
A Future Together
Marissa and Josh's relationship becomes a committed partnership. Marissa has fully accepted that not all men cheat, and that true love, built on honesty and trust, is possible. Josh proves to be the steady, loving partner she always wanted, consistently showing his loyalty and affection. They make plans for their future together, discussing living arrangements and long-term goals. The novel ends with Marissa finding genuine happiness and contentment, both in her personal life with Josh and in her changed professional endeavor. She has not only found love but has also become a more mature, empathetic, and hopeful individual, leaving behind the bitterness that once defined her. Her journey is one of healing, forgiveness, and the discovery that true connection requires vulnerability and a willingness to believe.
Principal Figures
Marissa Dubois
The Protagonist
Marissa evolves from a bitter, cynical woman seeking revenge to a hopeful individual who learns to trust again, both in love and in the goodness of people, ultimately transforming her website into a platform for healing.
Josh Miller
The Love Interest / Supporting
Josh starts as an unfairly maligned character, then becomes the catalyst for Marissa's healing, ultimately proving that not all men cheat and securing his place as her loyal partner.
Chloe
The Supporting
Chloe remains a constant and supportive friend, witnessing and encouraging Marissa's transformation without undergoing a significant personal arc of her own.
Kevin
The Mentioned
Kevin's role is static; he is a catalyst for Marissa's actions, but does not undergo personal development within the story.
The Accuser (Josh's ex-girlfriend)
The Antagonist / Mentioned
This character's actions drive a key plot point but she does not have a personal arc, remaining a static antagonist.
Themes & Insights
The Nature of Trust and Betrayal
This theme looks at how past betrayals can shape a person's outlook and ability to trust. Marissa's deep cynicism comes from a history of infidelity, making her believe that all men are untrustworthy. The novel details her struggle to overcome this ingrained distrust, especially when faced with Josh's innocence. The theme concludes with her realizing that trust is not a general assumption but a choice, built on individual experience and a willingness to be vulnerable. The false accusation against Josh highlights the complexities of betrayal — not just the act, but the act of being falsely accused.
“Every man I've ever known has proven me right. They all cheat.”
Healing from Past Wounds
The novel is about Marissa's journey to heal from the emotional scars of infidelity. Her creation of 'Catch a Cheat' is an initial, though flawed, way to cope with her pain. Josh's return, her first love and a symbol of her lost innocence, forces her to confront these unresolved feelings. Healing is shown as a gradual process, requiring self-reflection, forgiveness (of others and herself), and a willingness to challenge old beliefs. By the end, Marissa learns to let go of her bitterness and embrace a more hopeful view of love and relationships, showing that healing is possible even after deep hurt.
“I thought exposing them would make me feel better, but it just kept me stuck in the past.”
The Ethics of Online Vigilantism and Justice
This theme explores the moral complexities of creating a platform for public shaming and exposure. Marissa's 'Catch a Cheat' website raises questions about due process, the potential for false accusations, and the impact on people's lives. The false submission against Josh makes Marissa confront the ethical implications of her platform, showing the fine line between seeking justice and enabling mob mentality. The novel examines the responsibility of content creators and the need for verification and fairness in online communities. Marissa's eventual change of the website reflects a more mature understanding of justice, moving from punishment to constructive healing.
“There's a difference between exposing a truth and ruining a life with a lie.”
The Power of Forgiveness and Second Chances
Forgiveness is a main theme, appearing in various forms. Marissa must learn to forgive the men who hurt her, not for their sake, but for her own emotional freedom. More importantly, she must forgive Josh for their past separation, and herself for her initial distrust of him. The novel supports the idea of second chances, not just in romantic relationships, but also in personal growth. Josh's unwavering belief in clearing his name, and his willingness to pursue Marissa despite her cynicism, embodies the spirit of a second chance at love. This theme shows that letting go of grudges is essential for moving forward and building new, healthier connections.
“Sometimes, the hardest person to forgive is yourself, for not seeing the truth sooner.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The 'Catch a Cheat' Website
A central online platform that drives the plot and serves as a catalyst for Marissa's journey.
The 'Catch a Cheat' website is the primary plot device, acting as both the source of Marissa's initial mission and the catalyst for the story's central conflict. It brings Josh back into her life, creates the ethical dilemma she must resolve, and ultimately becomes a symbol of her personal transformation. The website's evolution from a platform of exposure to one of healing mirrors Marissa's own arc, making it an integral, dynamic element of the narrative rather than just a backdrop.
The False Accusation
A pivotal event where Josh is wrongly submitted to Marissa's website, creating immediate conflict and driving the plot.
The false accusation against Josh is a crucial plot device. It immediately creates high stakes and personalizes the ethical dilemma of Marissa's website. This event forces Marissa to confront her own biases, investigate the truth, and ultimately leads to her reconnection with Josh. Without this specific incident, Marissa's deeply ingrained cynicism might never have been challenged, and the central romance would not have had its primary obstacle and catalyst for resolution. It directly propels the narrative forward.
The First Love Trope
The reintroduction of a beloved past relationship to challenge present beliefs and rekindle romance.
The reintroduction of Josh, Marissa's first love, serves as a powerful plot device. It leverages the emotional weight of a past, idealized romance to challenge Marissa's current jaded worldview. By bringing back the one 'good guy' she remembers, the story creates a compelling reason for her to reconsider her beliefs about men. This trope allows for both nostalgic reflection and a fresh start, providing a strong emotional foundation for their rekindled relationship and facilitating Marissa's personal growth and healing.
Marissa's Cynicism
The protagonist's deeply ingrained distrust of men due to past betrayals, driving her actions and internal conflict.
Marissa's pervasive cynicism about men is a foundational plot device. It explains her motivation for creating 'Catch a Cheat' and establishes her character's initial emotional state. This cynicism acts as an internal barrier to her happiness and a significant obstacle to her rekindling a relationship with Josh. The entire narrative arc is structured around the gradual dismantling of this cynicism, making it a powerful force that shapes her decisions, reactions, and ultimate transformation throughout the story.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“There's a fine line between playing a game and being played.”
— As the protagonist gets deeper into her scheme, she starts to question her own motives and control.
“Revenge is a dish best served... complicated.”
— A humorous twist on the classic adage, highlighting the messy reality of her plan.
“Sometimes the biggest betrayals come from the people we trust the most.”
— The protagonist grapples with the pain of being deceived by someone close to her.
“A good lie needs a kernel of truth to truly take root.”
— She observes the effectiveness of her own manipulations and those of others.
“The thrill of the chase is only half the fun; the other half is catching what you're after.”
— The protagonist savors the anticipation and execution of her elaborate plan.
“Forgiveness isn't about forgetting; it's about letting go of the anger.”
— A moment of introspection where she considers the path to healing.
“You can't truly move on until you've confronted what held you back.”
— She realizes the necessity of facing her past to build a future.
“The most dangerous game is the one you play with your own heart.”
— As romantic feelings resurface, she acknowledges the risk to her emotional well-being.
“Sometimes, the best way to win is to change the rules.”
— She devises an unconventional approach to achieve her goals.
“Every secret has a shelf life, and eventually, they all expire.”
— She considers the inevitable unraveling of her carefully constructed deceptions.
“Love isn't always logical, and sometimes that's its greatest strength and its greatest weakness.”
— She muses on the irrationality of her own romantic attachments.
“The past is never truly past; it's always lurking, waiting for its moment to resurface.”
— Old wounds and unresolved issues continually impact the present narrative.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
The book follows Marissa, a beautiful and talented woman in her thirties who has grown disillusioned with romance due to a history of being cheated on. In response, she creates a website to expose serial cheaters, which unexpectedly reconnects her with her first boyfriend, who aims to prove that not all men are unfaithful.
