“The only thing worse than a bad hair day is a bad hair year.”
— Crimson's internal thoughts about her appearance struggles.

Lisi Harrison (2010)
Genre
Children's / Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
150 min
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
As the Pretty Committee navigates high school crushes and social climbing, Massie must decide if her new love is worth pursuing when a mysterious girl threatens her romance.
Massie Block, leader of the Pretty Committee, wants to improve her social standing and love life by pursuing Landon, a freshman at the Alphas and Deltas Dorms (ADD). She plans her appearance and gossip strategy to impress the ninth-grade crowd, believing that dating a high schooler will confirm her elite status. Her friends, Alicia, Kristen, Dylan, and Claire, are also dealing with their own romantic issues and the pressures of high school. Massie's first interactions with Landon are promising, making her confident she can fit into the high school social scene and secure her new crush.
Massie's plan hits a snag when she sees Landon with an unknown girl who has a bird tattoo. This unexpected event makes Massie jealous and suspicious. Her focus changes from charming Landon to finding out who this rival is and what her relationship with Landon means. The Pretty Committee helps Massie investigate, trying to gather information about Landon's interactions with the mysterious girl. Massie feels she is losing control, fearing her dream of dating a freshman might be taken away.
Alicia Rivera, initially confident in her relationship with Josh Hotz, faces an unexpected problem: she discovers they wear the same clothing size. This revelation shatters her idea of their 'perfect fit,' as she sees it as a major fashion mistake and a blow to her style. Alicia questions her attraction to Josh, believing that sharing clothing sizes means they are incompatible. She begins to consider pursuing a new crush, a ninth-grader, to distance herself from this perceived fashion disaster and improve her social standing.
Kristen Gregory finds herself increasingly bored with her boyfriend Dempsey's focus on soccer. His constant talk about the sport makes her feel ignored. Her dissatisfaction grows as a high school 'hottie' starts to flirt with her. This new attention from an older boy offers Kristen an exciting alternative to Dempsey's predictable conversations. She starts to compare her current relationship with the appeal of a more mature and potentially more interesting high school crush, wondering if it's time to end things with Dempsey.
Dylan Marvil enjoys kissing Derrington, but their romance faces a comical problem when Derrington loses a bet. He has to wear his clothes backward, a fashion choice Dylan finds unappealing and embarrassing. This unexpected event dampens their usual affectionate interactions. Dylan wonders if she can continue to be seen with him, let alone kiss him, while he's dressed so absurdly. The incident challenges her view of Derrington and their relationship, making her question their romantic future.
Claire Lyons is the most resistant member of the Pretty Committee to growing up and moving into ninth grade. She holds onto her eighth-grade identity and her relationship with Cam, seeing the transition to high school as an unnecessary rush. Claire sees no reason to leave her comfortable life and friends for the perceived pressures of high school. Her friends' growing focus on high school boys and social climbing makes Claire feel out of step. She worries that if she doesn't embrace the 'upgrade' to ninth-grade crushes, her friends might leave her behind or outgrow her.
Driven by jealousy and wanting to regain Landon's attention, Massie increases her efforts to learn the truth about the bird-tattooed girl. She uses various tactics, including discreet observation, strategic questioning, and her gossip network. Massie is determined to expose the girl's identity and, if needed, plan to eliminate her as a rival. The Pretty Committee, though sometimes cautious, helps Massie in her mission, caught up in the drama of their leader's romantic pursuit. Massie believes that understanding her competition is key to securing Landon.
After much investigation, Massie and the Pretty Committee finally learn the identity of the girl with the bird tattoo. The revelation comes with a twist that challenges Massie's assumptions and forces her to re-evaluate her perception of Landon and the situation. The girl is not a romantic rival as Massie imagined, leading to a moment of unexpected clarity or confusion for Massie. This discovery changes Massie's strategy and makes her confront the reality of Landon's life beyond her initial, idealized view. The 'hawk' turns out to be something different than Massie expected.
As Massie, Alicia, Kristen, and Dylan pursue their freshman crushes, the dynamics within the Pretty Committee are tested. Their individual romantic dramas and differing enthusiasm for high school social climbing sometimes create friction and distance. Claire, in particular, feels increasingly isolated as her friends embrace the 'high school' mindset while she clings to eighth grade. The girls must navigate their evolving friendships, trying to support each other while pursuing their own desires and adjusting to the pressures of growing up and potentially leaving aspects of their childhood behind.
Following the various romantic mishaps and discoveries, each member of the Pretty Committee assesses their current relationships. Alicia re-evaluates her shallow reasons for potentially breaking up with Josh over clothing size. Kristen considers if the excitement of a new high school boy is worth sacrificing her stable, if boring, relationship with Dempsey. Dylan weighs her feelings for Derrington against her embarrassment over his backward clothes. Massie, having learned the truth about the 'hawk,' must decide how to proceed with Landon. Claire, meanwhile, continues to ponder if she should embrace the change or remain steadfast in her current situation, leading to a period of introspection for all the girls.
The Protagonist
Massie learns that appearances can be deceiving and that true connections are more complex than social climbing. She matures slightly by understanding that not every situation is a competition.
The Supporting
Alicia confronts her shallow judgments about relationships and learns to look beyond superficial compatibility.
The Supporting
Kristen learns to communicate her needs in a relationship and discerns between fleeting excitement and genuine connection.
The Supporting
Dylan learns to accept her boyfriend's quirks and prioritize genuine affection over superficial embarrassment.
The Supporting
Claire grapples with the pressures of growing up and learns to find confidence in her own pace, even if it differs from her friends.
The Supporting
Landon remains largely a catalyst for Massie's plot, revealing that her assumptions about high school boys can be off-base.
The Mentioned
Josh's character arc is not central; he primarily serves as a plot device for Alicia's development.
The Mentioned
Dempsey's arc is not central; he serves as a foil for Kristen's desire for change.
The Mentioned
Derrington's arc is not central; he acts as a catalyst for Dylan's internal conflict.
The Mentioned
Cam's arc is not central; he provides a stable anchor for Claire's character.
The book explores the social pressure on pre-teen girls to quickly adopt high school culture, relationships, and higher social status. Massie and her friends are obsessed with 'upgrading' to ninth-grade crushes, believing it will improve their standing. Claire, in particular, resists this pressure, preferring her comfortable eighth-grade world. This theme appears in their conversations about high school boys, their desire to look and act older, and the internal conflicts that arise when they feel they are not keeping pace with their peers' perceived maturity. It highlights the anxieties and excitement of the transition from middle school to high school.
“Why grow up before you have to? But if she refuses to trade Cam in for a ninth-grade crush, will her friends outgrow her?”
A central theme is the girls' frequent prioritization of superficial traits over genuine connection. Alicia's problem with Josh's clothing size, Kristen's boredom with Dempsey's soccer talk, and Dylan's embarrassment over Derrington's backward clothes all show this. Massie's pursuit of Landon is initially driven by the idea of 'upgrading' her social status rather than a deep connection. The book implicitly questions whether these surface-level concerns truly lead to happiness or if they prevent the girls from appreciating authentic relationships. The 'hawk' mystery also plays into this, as Massie's initial assumptions are based on superficial observations.
“Thought she and Josh Hotz were a perfect fit... until she found out they wear the same clothing size. Ehma-unacceptable!”
Despite their individual romantic dramas and occasional arguments, the bond of the Pretty Committee is a core theme. The girls rely on each other for gossip, advice, and emotional support, even when their personal desires conflict. Massie's friends help her 'stalk' Landon, and they all navigate growing up together. However, the pressure to conform and the pursuit of individual goals sometimes strain these friendships, especially for Claire who feels left behind. The book explores the challenges of maintaining close friendships as individuals develop different priorities and interests during adolescence.
“But if she refuses to trade Cam in for a ninth-grade crush, will her friends outgrow her?”
The 'unknown' of high school and older boys holds a powerful allure for most of the Pretty Committee. Landon, the high school 'hottie' for Kristen, and the general idea of ninth-grade crushes represent a more mature, exciting, and prestigious world. This theme drives much of the plot, as the girls are eager to shed their middle school identities and embrace what they see as the sophistication of high school. The mystery of the bird-tattooed girl also plays into this, representing an unknown element that Massie must confront in her pursuit of Landon.
“Armed with glossy hair, juicy gossip, and enough confidence to impress the ninth grade set, Massie can walk the walk.”
The girls' desire to 'upgrade' their social status and relationships.
The concept of 'upgrading' is used repeatedly, particularly by Massie, to describe her pursuit of a high school boyfriend and higher social standing. It frames relationships and social circles in terms of status and desirability, as if they are products to be traded up for better models. This device highlights the superficial and consumerist mindset the girls sometimes adopt towards their social lives and romantic interests, driving their actions and influencing their judgments about their current boyfriends and friends.
The unknown identity of the girl with the bird tattoo.
The 'hawk' (the girl with the bird tattoo) serves as a central mystery and a source of conflict for Massie. This plot device creates suspense and drives Massie's 'stalking' behavior, providing a clear external obstacle to her romantic goals. The gradual revelation of the 'hawk's' identity and her true relationship with Landon allows for a twist that challenges Massie's assumptions and forces her to confront a reality different from her initial jealous imaginings, adding depth to the plot beyond simple romantic rivalry.
Each Pretty Committee member faces a unique romantic problem.
By giving each of the main characters a distinct romantic dilemma (Alicia's clothing size, Kristen's boredom, Dylan's embarrassment, Claire's resistance to change), the narrative broadens the scope of the 'growing up' theme. These parallel storylines allow the author to explore different facets of adolescent relationships and anxieties, providing variety while still contributing to the overarching theme of transitioning to high school. It also highlights the different ways each girl copes with the pressures of their social circle.
The use of gossip and observation as tools for social maneuvering.
Gossip is a pervasive plot device, acting as both currency and weapon within the Pretty Committee's social world. Massie and Alicia are masters of gathering and disseminating information, using it to understand and manipulate their environment. Massie's 'stalking' of Landon and the bird-tattooed girl is a direct form of surveillance. This device underscores the intense social scrutiny and competitive nature of their peer group, showing how information (or lack thereof) can drive fear, jealousy, and strategic planning in their pursuit of social and romantic success.
“The only thing worse than a bad hair day is a bad hair year.”
— Crimson's internal thoughts about her appearance struggles.
“Being popular is like being a really sparkly, really fragile ornament. Everyone wants to touch you, but if you fall, you shatter.”
— Crimson's reflection on the pressures of popularity.
“Sometimes the person you're looking for is the one you're trying to avoid.”
— Crimson realizing her feelings for a boy she initially disliked.
“A secret isn't a secret if everyone knows it.”
— One of the characters discussing gossip and rumors.
“If you don't know who you are, how can anyone else?”
— A character giving advice about self-identity.
“Love isn't about finding the perfect person, it's about seeing an imperfect person perfectly.”
— A romantic realization by one of the main characters.
“Sometimes the biggest lies we tell are the ones we tell ourselves.”
— A character reflecting on their own self-deception.
“Being different isn't a curse, it's a superpower.”
— A character encouraging another to embrace their uniqueness.
“True friends don't just stick around for the good times, they help you through the bad ones too.”
— A moment of support between friends.
“You can't choose your family, but you can choose how you deal with them.”
— A character dealing with complicated family dynamics.
“The past is like a pair of shoes. You can learn from where they took you, but you can't walk backward.”
— A character's reflection on moving on from past mistakes.
“Even the prettiest packaging can hide something ugly inside.”
— Crimson observing how appearances can be deceiving.
“Sometimes you have to get lost to find your way.”
— A character's journey of self-discovery after a challenging event.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.

Dan Gemeinhart
4.5

Kate O'Hearn
4.4

Jeanne Birdsall
4.4

Jen Wang
4.4

Wendelin Van Draanen
4.3

John Marsden
4.3

Chris Van Allsburg
4.3

Jennifer A. Nielsen
4.2