Edward Everett Hale (1865)
Genre
Historical Fiction
Reading Time
45 min
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
Banished to a life at sea, forbidden to hear his homeland's name, a treasonous lieutenant faces the isolating cost of renouncing the United States, his silent punishment mirroring a nation at war.
The story begins with a framing narrative. The unnamed narrator, an old naval officer, thinks about his long career and the people he has met. He remembers a strange case from his youth, a man named Philip Nolan, whose name was rarely spoken and whose story was kept secret. The narrator hints at a serious wrong committed by Nolan, which led to a unique and severe punishment. He explains that Nolan's story is not widely known because the government hid the details, hoping to bury the memory of such a shameful act. The narrator, however, feels he must share Nolan's tragic tale as a warning.
The narrator describes Nolan's past, detailing his involvement with Aaron Burr's conspiracy in 1807. Philip Nolan, a young, ambitious, but misguided American Army Lieutenant, is implicated in Burr's plans against the United States. During his court-martial for treason, Nolan, in a moment of youthful arrogance and frustration, publicly declares, 'Damn the United States! I wish I may never hear of the United States again!' This impulsive statement, made without truly thinking about its seriousness, seals his fate. The court, shocked by his outburst, sees his words as a profound and unforgivable act of disloyalty, setting the stage for his unusual sentence.
After hearing Nolan's hasty renunciation, the judge, after talking with other officials, announces an unprecedented sentence. Taking Nolan at his word, the court condemns him to live the rest of his days at sea, on various naval vessels, with the explicit instruction that he should 'never hear of the United States again.' This means no one on board can speak of his native country, show him maps of it, or let him read any news or literature about America. The goal is to completely remove the United States from Nolan's life, making his wish a literal and permanent reality. This unique punishment begins immediately, isolating Nolan from the world he once knew.
Nolan's sentence begins immediately. He is moved from ship to ship, serving on various naval expeditions around the world. Each captain receives strict orders about his confinement: Nolan is to be treated with courtesy, but he cannot be given any information about the United States. Maps are kept from him, conversations about America stop when he is present, and he cannot read American newspapers or books. At first, Nolan might have seen this as a minor annoyance, but as years pass, the deep isolation and the constant, deliberate silence about his homeland begin to wear on his spirit. He becomes a living ghost, adrift in a world where a significant part of his identity is forbidden.
As years pass, Nolan's initial arrogance and indifference are replaced by deep and painful remorse. He begins to understand the true weight of his youthful curse. The constant, forced silence about the United States troubles him. He tries subtle ways to get information, asking indirect questions or trying to read the expressions of those around him, but the officers and crew are careful to follow their orders. Nolan's desperation grows, and he starts to show signs of mental and emotional distress, often withdrawing or showing a quiet, deep sadness. His punishment, first meant as a literal fulfillment of his wish, has become a cruel and relentless psychological torture.
One moving incident the narrator describes involves Nolan overhearing a young officer reading aloud from Sir Walter Scott's 'Lay of the Last Minstrel.' The officer, unaware of the specific prohibition, reads a line that mentions America. Nolan's reaction is immediate and strong. He visibly trembles, his eyes wide with pain and longing. This brief, accidental exposure to a piece of his forbidden past deeply affects him, showing the depth of his hidden patriotism and the agony of his isolation. The incident reminds the crew of the severity of Nolan's sentence and the tragedy of his self-imposed exile.
During a naval battle with a French frigate, Nolan, despite his unusual status, shows remarkable courage and strategic thinking. He advises the American captain on the best course of action, using his military knowledge and experience. His actions contribute significantly to the American victory. This display of bravery and loyalty, though not directly linked to his American identity, shows that a core sense of duty and belonging still exists within him. It is a moment where his inherent character shows, suggesting that beneath the 'man without a country,' there remains a man who, perhaps subconsciously, still identifies with the values and spirit of his homeland, even if he cannot speak its name.
Over the decades, some officers, especially Lieutenant Danforth, feel deep pity for Nolan. Danforth, a kind and observant man, understands Nolan's psychological torment. He subtly tries to bring Nolan some comfort and connection, often by reading aloud from classical literature or history that does not directly mention the United States, but which might evoke a sense of shared human experience or the general principles of liberty and nationhood. Danforth also ensures Nolan has access to scientific instruments and books, letting him pursue intellectual interests and maintain his mental abilities, subtly acknowledging Nolan's humanity despite his unique punishment.
Many years later, the narrator, now a senior officer, finds himself on the same ship as an aged and ill Nolan. Nolan, feeling his end is near, calls the narrator to his cabin. He makes a final, heartfelt request: to see a map of the United States. He explains that he has kept a small, tattered flag and an eagle emblem hidden for years, symbols of the country he so foolishly renounced. His cabin is filled with objects he has collected over his long exile, each a subtle, coded reminder of his lost homeland. This moment shows the depth of his repentance and his desperate yearning for reconciliation with the country he scorned.
The narrator, deeply moved by Nolan's plea, brings him a map of the United States. Nolan traces its outline with trembling fingers, his eyes filled with tears. He confesses his deep regret for his youthful outburst, repeating his love for his country. He reveals that his hidden flag and eagle were his only comfort, his secret connection to the land he was forbidden to acknowledge. Nolan dies shortly after, clutching the map and his symbols of patriotism. His final words are a quiet affirmation of his American identity, a poignant end to a life defined by a single, rash statement and decades of deep, self-inflicted exile. The narrator ensures Nolan is buried at sea, draped in an American flag.
The Protagonist
Nolan's arc is one of profound repentance, moving from youthful arrogance and disloyalty to deep, agonizing regret and a desperate, secret patriotism.
The Supporting
The narrator's arc is subtle, primarily involving his deepening understanding of Nolan's tragedy and his resolve to share the story for posterity.
The Supporting
Danforth's arc is static, serving as a consistent figure of compassion and an example of humanity within the strictures of Nolan's punishment.
The Mentioned
Burr's arc is not depicted, as he is merely a historical reference point for Nolan's initial transgression.
The Mentioned
The court's role is fixed, establishing the central conflict and the parameters of Nolan's punishment.
The Supporting
Their individual arcs are not detailed; they collectively represent the unchanging conditions of Nolan's sentence.
This is the main theme, exploring the deep importance of loving and belonging to one's country. Nolan's initial, careless renunciation leads to a life-long punishment meant to strip him of his national identity, making him realize its invaluable worth. His deep, painful remorse and his secret collection of American symbols (flag, eagle) show that national identity is not just a legal status but a fundamental part of one's being. The story emphasizes that true patriotism is a deep loyalty that, once lost, creates an unbearable emptiness, as seen in Nolan's desperate longing for news of home.
“''And for a man to live without a country is to live without a name, without a home, without a purpose in life, without a God in the world.'”
The story clearly shows how a single, rash statement can have irreversible and devastating results. Nolan's casual 'Damn the United States! I wish I may never hear of the United States again!' spoken in anger, becomes the literal plan for his life's punishment. The court takes his words literally, turning a momentary outburst into a permanent reality. This theme warns against the dangers of thoughtless speech and highlights that words, especially those spoken publicly or under oath, carry immense power and can define one's destiny, even if later regretted.
“'Young man, I am sorry for you, but you have renounced your country. You will never hear of the United States again.'”
Nolan's life is a long, painful journey of repentance. His decades of forced ignorance and isolation gradually break down his arrogance, replacing it with deep remorse and a yearning for forgiveness. While his punishment is never officially ended, his final moments, where he openly expresses his love for his country and his regret, suggest a form of personal redemption. He dies a broken man, but one who has accepted his lost identity and found peace in his renewed, though secret, patriotism. The story implies that even the gravest mistakes can be made right through deep and sincere regret, even if the outward consequences remain.
“'Tell me, Captain,' he said, 'that you will bury me in the sea; and I implore you, as you are a Christian man, that you will have my body wrapped in the flag of the United States.'”
The story shows a complex interaction between strict justice and a lack of mercy. Nolan's sentence is a literal fulfillment of his wish, a form of poetic justice. However, the long and absolute nature of his isolation raises questions about the humanity of such a punishment. While the court's decision is legally sound, the psychological torment Nolan endures for decades leads one to consider whether justice, without any room for mercy or change of heart, can become too cruel. Lieutenant Danforth's subtle acts of kindness highlight the human need for compassion even within a harsh sentence.
“'The court has granted your request, sir. You are to have your wish. You will never again hear of the United States.'”
The story is told by an older naval officer recalling events from his past.
The use of a framing narrative, where an unnamed, elderly naval officer recounts Nolan's story, lends credibility and a sense of historical weight to the tale. It allows the author to present a seemingly incredible story as a 'true' recollection, enhancing its emotional impact and moral authority. The narrator's personal connection to Nolan, having witnessed parts of his life and his death, adds an intimate perspective, making the abstract concept of national loyalty more tangible and relatable. This device also allows for reflective commentary on the themes of patriotism and consequence.
Nolan's wish to never hear of the U.S. becomes his gravest punishment.
The central irony of the story lies in Nolan's impulsive wish to 'never hear of the United States again' being granted as his punishment. What he intended as a defiant dismissal becomes the literal and psychological torment of his life. This situational irony highlights the unforeseen and often devastating consequences of one's words and actions. It underscores the idea that sometimes, the most severe punishment is not an imposed suffering, but the literal fulfillment of a foolish desire, turning one's own words into a cage.
Objects like the flag and map represent Nolan's lost and reclaimed identity.
Various objects in the story carry significant symbolic weight. The hidden, tattered American flag and the eagle emblem in Nolan's cabin symbolize his enduring, suppressed patriotism and his desperate longing for his lost identity. They are his secret connection to the country he cannot name. The map of the United States, which Nolan clutches in his final moments, symbolizes his ultimate reconciliation with his homeland and the reclaiming of his national identity. These symbols provide a tangible representation of Nolan's internal struggle and his eventual repentance.
“And the court, for the sake of its own self-respect, must pronounce upon him the sentence, that, as he has said he wishes to live and die an American, he shall have his wish. He shall have no country.”
— The judge delivers the sentence to Philip Nolan after Nolan's outburst.
“He never was permitted to hear the name of the United States. He never saw a newspaper that had been printed in the United States.”
— Describing the strict enforcement of Nolan's sentence.
“And the poor fellow, though he knows it not, is a type of a good many poor fellows that are living at home, and do not think they have a country either.”
— The narrator's reflection on Nolan's plight and its broader implications.
“But a man without a country is a man without a name, without a home, without a friend.”
— A general observation on the consequences of Nolan's sentence.
“I hope, young man, that you may be as true to the flag as your father was, and as I mean to be.”
— An older officer advises a younger one, emphasizing loyalty.
“He was a man of fine talents, of generous impulses, and a noble heart; but he had been led astray by bad company.”
— Describing Nolan's character before his fall.
“And the great lesson of his life is, that a man's country is his all.”
— The narrator's summary of the ultimate moral of Nolan's story.
“He died a good Christian, and a good American.”
— The final assessment of Nolan's character at his death.
“I have been for fifty-five years a man without a country. I have been for fifty-five years a man without a name.”
— Nolan's own words reflecting on his long exile.
“Never hear the name of home again! Never hear the name of country again!”
— Nolan's initial outburst that leads to his sentence.
“And the flag, sir, the flag! It is a grand old flag, and I hope it will wave over a country where every man is free to speak his mind.”
— Nolan expresses his enduring respect for the flag despite his circumstances.
“You may have a country, and you may not. You may have a name, and you may not. But you will never have a home.”
— A grim reflection on Nolan's permanent state of displacement.
“The country is not the soil, nor the government, nor the flag, though these are all parts of it. The country is the people.”
— A deeper philosophical definition of 'country' implied through Nolan's experience.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
Biography coming soon.
