The Voice of Reason 1
Geralt of Rivia, a Witcher, recovers in the temple of Melitele after severe injuries from a striga. Nenneke, the high priestess, cares for him, but Geralt is restless, troubled by nightmares and memories. The framing narrative, 'The Voice of Reason,' mixes his recovery with flashbacks to various monster-hunting contracts. In this first part, Geralt remembers meeting Iola, a silent novice at the temple, and his talks with Nenneke about his calling and the nature of good and evil where monsters are often misunderstood and humans can be more monstrous.
The Witcher
Geralt arrives in Vizima, the capital of Temeria, to deal with a striga terrorizing the city. King Foltest's daughter, Adda, was born cursed and transforms into a monstrous striga at night, preying on people. Geralt learns that Foltest, despite the danger, refuses to let anyone kill her, hoping for a cure. Geralt accepts the contract, but instead of slaying the creature, he aims to lift the curse. He spends a night in the old royal palace, the striga's lair, confronting the creature until dawn, breaking the curse and restoring Adda to human form, though she remains feral.
The Voice of Reason 2
Back at the temple, Geralt continues his recovery and talks with Nenneke. She questions him about the moral ambiguities of his work, especially his involvement in political schemes and the unforeseen results of his actions. Geralt recounts Princess Adda's story, highlighting his decision to save her instead of killing her, despite the risk. He reflects on the Witcher's code and its limits, dealing with the concept of lesser evils and the difficulty of staying neutral in a world full of complex moral choices. Iola, the novice, continues to watch him silently.
A Grain of Truth
While traveling, Geralt finds two dead merchants. Following tracks, he reaches a secluded manor inhabited by Nivellen, a man cursed to look like a beast. Nivellen lives with several monstrous, but seemingly harmless, female companions – a rusalka, a bruxa, and a vampire. He admits to having raped a priestess, leading to his transformation. Geralt first suspects Nivellen, but soon realizes that one of Nivellen's companions, Vereena, a bruxa, is the true monster, responsible for the murders. Geralt confronts and kills Vereena, which breaks Nivellen's curse, restoring him to human form.
The Voice of Reason 3
Geralt continues his recovery, thinking about Nivellen's story. He discusses with Nenneke the blurred lines between human and monster, and how appearances can deceive. He considers how Nivellen, despite his monstrous form, showed more humanity than many 'normal' people, while Vereena, beautiful and alluring, was truly evil. Nenneke challenges Geralt's detached view, urging him to acknowledge the emotional cost of his work. Geralt feels a growing connection with Iola, who, despite her silence, seems to understand him. Geralt wonders if he will ever escape the consequences of his actions.
The Lesser Evil
Geralt arrives in Blaviken and meets the sorcerer Stregobor, who asks for his help. Stregobor believes Princess Renfri, a cursed 'Black Sun' child, will bring destruction and wants Geralt to kill her. Renfri, now a bandit leader known as Shrike, comes to Blaviken, seeking revenge on Stregobor. Geralt tries to mediate, urging Renfri to stop her violent path. However, Renfri plans to massacre the townspeople to draw Stregobor out. Faced with choosing between a potential future evil and an immediate atrocity, Geralt kills Renfri and her gang in the marketplace to prevent the massacre, earning him the name 'Butcher of Blaviken'.
The Voice of Reason 4
The 'Butcher of Blaviken' incident troubles Geralt. He tells Nenneke about the traumatic event, expressing his despair at being forced into a situation where all choices were terrible. He questions the 'lesser evil' idea, feeling that he only chose the most immediate evil. Nenneke tries to comfort him, reminding him of his intention to save innocent lives. Geralt feels the weight of public opinion and the permanent stain on his reputation. Iola, seeing his pain, offers silent comfort, deepening their unspoken bond. Geralt wonders if he will ever escape the results of his actions.
A Question of Price
Geralt attends the wedding feast of Queen Calanthe's daughter, Pavetta, in Cintra. A mysterious knight named Duny, cursed to appear as a hedgehog-like creature, crashes the feast, claiming Pavetta as his bride due to the Law of Surprise, having saved her father years ago. Geralt intervenes when Calanthe's knights attack Duny. Pavetta reveals her love for Duny and her latent magical powers manifest violently. Geralt helps calm the situation, and the curse on Duny breaks when Calanthe accepts their union. As a reward, Duny offers Geralt anything, and Geralt invokes the Law of Surprise, unknowingly claiming the unborn Ciri.
The Voice of Reason 5
As his recovery ends, Geralt thinks about the Law of Surprise and his fated connection to Ciri. He tells Nenneke he is skeptical about destiny, despite his life being shaped by such events. He admits his fear of claiming Ciri, a child he has never met, and the responsibility it brings. Nenneke, who believes in destiny, urges him to accept his fate. Geralt decides to leave the temple and avoid Cintra, hoping to circumvent destiny, but a sense of unease remains, hinting at future events.
The Edge of the World
Geralt and his bard Dandelion journey to a remote valley to investigate a 'devil' stealing crops. They meet Toruviel, an elven archer, and her community, who struggle against human encroachment and the loss of their way of life. They find the 'devil' is a sylvan named Torque, who is being coerced by an ancient entity known as the 'Queen of the Fields' to steal for her. Geralt, seeing the sylvan is not malicious, tries to resolve the situation peacefully. After a confrontation with Torque and the unseen Queen's influence, Geralt and Dandelion leave, letting the sylvan face his fate.
The Last Wish
While fishing, Dandelion accidentally unleashes a djinn from an ancient artifact. The djinn, a powerful elemental, injures Dandelion and causes chaos. Geralt, trying to save Dandelion, seeks help from the sorceress Yennefer of Vengerberg, known for her beauty and magic. Yennefer, recognizing the djinn's power, tries to capture it for herself. A magical battle occurs between Yennefer and the djinn, putting Dandelion's life in danger. To save Yennefer from the djinn's power, Geralt makes his third and final wish: a wish that binds his destiny with Yennefer's, creating a strong, though difficult, bond between them.