“I was born to drown, and she was born to save me.”
— Early reflection on Emma's profound impact on Evan's life.
Archivist's Choice
The Breathing Series
Rebecca Donovan (2013)
Genre
Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
15-20 hours
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
A high schooler, silently enduring abuse, finds love that helps her confront her past, even as new secrets and old heartaches threaten her fragile hope.
Synopsis
Emma Thomas, a high school student, secretly endures years of physical and emotional abuse from her aunt, Carol. She tries to be invisible, excelling in school and sports while hiding her suffering. Her world changes when she meets Evan Matthews, a kind classmate. Their connection grows into a deep romance, showing Emma a life free from fear. However, as she gets closer to Evan, her secret becomes harder to keep. The truth of her abuse comes out during a night of terror, leading to legal action against Carol and a difficult recovery for Emma. With Evan's support, Emma slowly heals, embracing new beginnings while dealing with her past. Their journey includes challenges, like Evan's sacrifice and the return of figures from the past, forcing Emma to face her trauma and fight for a future defined by love, not fear.
Reading time
15-20 hours
Difficulty
Medium
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Emotional, Intense, Romantic, Hopeful, Dark
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy intense, emotional young adult romance with a strong focus on overcoming adversity and healing from trauma.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer lighthearted stories or are sensitive to detailed depictions of child abuse and its aftermath.
Plot Summary
A Life of Silence and Secrecy
Emma Thomas, a high school junior, lives with her Aunt Carol and Uncle George, and their children, Sara and Elizabeth. Aunt Carol abuses Emma physically and emotionally, resenting having to care for her. Uncle George knows but does nothing, and the cousins are either involved or scared. Emma carefully hides her bruises and acts normal at school, doing well in academics and sports, especially swimming. She avoids social interaction, fearing any attention might expose her secret. Her main goal is to get through each day and escape her aunt's cruelty.
Meeting Evan Matthews
Emma's solitary life changes when she meets Evan Matthews, a popular and charming senior. Evan is drawn to Emma's quiet intensity and mysterious nature. Emma tries to push him away and keep her distance, but Evan is persistent and kind. He sees past her guarded exterior, sensing her pain, and slowly breaks down her defenses. Their interactions are full of growing tension and an unspoken understanding; Evan's steady attention makes Emma feel seen and valued in a new way, creating a dangerous hope within her.
A Budding Romance and Growing Fear
As Emma and Evan spend more time together, their friendship becomes a deep, passionate romance. Evan's love shows Emma a different future, one where she might be safe and happy. Yet, this new happiness is always shadowed by her fear of Aunt Carol's reactions and her abuse being found out. She struggles to let Evan get too close, terrified he will discover her secret and either reject her or get caught in her dangerous home life. Her inner conflict grows, as the joy of their relationship clashes with the constant threat of her aunt's increasing violence.
The First Glimpses of Truth
Evan, along with his best friend Josh and his girlfriend Beth, start to notice Emma's odd behaviors: her flinching, her evasiveness about her home life, and occasional unexplained bruises. They become worried, but Emma is good at hiding things. A particularly concerning event happens when Emma has a panic attack, revealing a deep trauma. Though she tries to explain it away, Evan's suspicions are confirmed. He becomes determined to find the truth, sensing Emma is in danger, and his protective instincts emerge, bringing Emma both relief and terror.
A Night of Terror and Exposure
The night of the school dance is a turning point. Aunt Carol, in a fit of rage, brutally attacks Emma, leaving her badly hurt. Evan, who had grown worried after Emma didn't show up for the dance, goes to her house. He finds Emma unconscious and severely injured. The terrible truth of her abuse is finally exposed. Evan immediately calls for help, and Emma is rushed to the hospital. This event shatters Emma's world, bringing her secret to light and starting a series of events that will change her life and the lives of those around her.
Aftermath and Legal Proceedings
After the discovery, Emma is hospitalized, broken both physically and emotionally. Child Protective Services and the police get involved, and Aunt Carol is arrested and charged with child abuse. Uncle George and the cousins are also questioned. Emma is placed in a foster home, at first struggling to adjust to a new place and unwanted attention. The legal process is painful, forcing Emma to relive her trauma. Despite physical healing, the emotional scars are deep, and she finds it hard to trust or feel safe, even in her new, protective surroundings.
The Road to Recovery and Trust
With Aunt Carol in prison, Emma starts her long journey toward recovery. Evan and his family, especially his mother, become Emma's steady support system. Evan's love and patience are vital as Emma deals with severe PTSD, nightmares, and a deep fear of intimacy. She struggles with self-worth and trusting happiness. His mother provides a stable, loving home, something Emma has never known. Slowly, Emma begins to heal, learning to accept love and care, and tentatively rebuilding her life, but her past trauma still casts a long shadow.
New Beginnings and Lingering Shadows
Emma moves in permanently with Evan's family, finding a sense of belonging and safety she never imagined. She continues therapy and regains confidence, doing well in swimming again. Her relationship with Evan deepens, becoming a source of great strength and comfort. However, the lasting effects of her abuse appear in various ways, from panic attacks to difficulties with physical intimacy. The fear that her past could return or that she doesn't deserve happiness often threatens her progress. They face these challenges together, committed to their future.
Evan's Sacrifice and a New Heartache
Evan receives a scholarship to a prestigious university, a dream he worked hard for. However, seeing Emma's fragility and knowing she needs continued support, he decides to defer his enrollment for a year to stay closer to her. While Emma is touched by his sacrifice, she also feels deep guilt and fears she is holding him back. This decision creates new tension in their relationship, as both deal with the weight of his choice and its potential impact on their individual futures, adding complexity to their challenging journey.
The Return of a Figure from the Past
Just as Emma starts to feel more secure, her biological father, Robert, reappears. He had been absent for years, unaware of her situation. His return brings mixed emotions: a desire for a biological connection, but also apprehension and a fear of more abandonment or disappointment. Robert expresses remorse and a wish to build a relationship, explaining his past absence. Emma cautiously begins to get to know him, navigating this new dynamic while balancing her existing relationships and her ongoing healing. His presence offers a glimmer of hope for a more complete family, but also opens old wounds.
Confronting the Past, Embracing the Future
With Evan's steady love, her foster family's support, and the tentative reconnection with her father, Emma finds the strength to confront the last parts of her trauma. She testifies against Aunt Carol, finding her voice and stating her truth. She learns to manage her PTSD, finding healthy ways to cope. She accepts that her past will always be a part of her, but it does not define her. Emma chooses to live, to love, and to thrive, finally believing she deserves happiness. She and Evan look forward to building a future together, a story of resilience and lasting love.
Principal Figures
Emma Thomas
The Protagonist
Emma transforms from a silent victim into a survivor who finds her voice, heals from profound trauma, and learns to accept love and build a future.
Evan Matthews
The Love Interest / Supporting Protagonist
Evan evolves from a typical popular high school student into a dedicated and sacrificial partner, demonstrating immense maturity and unwavering commitment to Emma's healing.
Aunt Carol
The Antagonist
Aunt Carol remains a static character, her abusive nature intensifying until her actions lead to her arrest and imprisonment.
Uncle George
The Supporting / Mentioned
Uncle George remains largely static in his passivity, though his inaction ultimately contributes to the exposure of the abuse.
Josh
The Supporting
Josh develops from a curious friend to a steadfast supporter of Emma and Evan.
Beth
The Supporting
Beth grows from a friendly acquaintance to a deeply empathetic and supportive friend for Emma.
Evan's Mother (Mrs. Matthews)
The Supporting
She remains a consistent source of strength and unconditional love, facilitating Emma's recovery.
Robert
The Supporting / Mentioned
Robert attempts to reconcile with his past mistakes and build a relationship with his daughter, Emma.
Themes & Insights
The Resilience of the Human Spirit
This theme is central, showing Emma's ability to endure horrific abuse and still find the will to survive, love, and thrive. Despite years of torment, Emma never completely gives up hope for a better future, even if it's hidden. Her resilience shows in her ability to keep up appearances at school, do well academically, and later, to actively work on her own healing. Evan's love helps, but her core strength is internal, allowing her to push through flashbacks, panic attacks, and the deep belief that she is unworthy.
“Even in the darkest corners of her mind, a tiny flicker of hope refused to be extinguished.”
The Power of Love and Connection
The power of love to change lives is a main force in the series. Evan's unconditional love for Emma is the main reason for her healing and her ability to face her past. His persistence, patience, and unwavering belief in her worth provide the safe space Emma needs to open up and trust. Beyond romantic love, the theme includes the supportive connections Emma forms with Evan's family and his friends, Josh and Beth. These relationships give her a sense of belonging, family, and normalcy she lacked, showing how real connection can heal deep wounds.
“He didn't just see her scars; he saw the strength that had earned them.”
The Devastating Impact of Abuse and Trauma
This theme explores the lasting effects of child abuse, not just physically, but psychologically and emotionally. The series shows the physical violence Emma endures, but more importantly, it looks at the deep psychological scars: her PTSD, panic attacks, inability to trust, feelings of unworthiness, and constant fear. The story carefully illustrates how trauma shapes Emma's view of the world, her relationships, and her self-perception, even long after the physical abuse stops. It highlights the long journey of healing and the continuous struggle to overcome the past.
“The bruises faded, but the scars on her soul remained, a constant reminder of the torment she had endured.”
The Importance of Speaking Up and Intervention
The series quietly but strongly emphasizes the role of speaking up, both for victims and for those who witness abuse. Emma's years of suffering are prolonged by her silence and the inaction of those around her, like Uncle George. The turning point in her life comes when her abuse is finally exposed, largely due to Evan's persistent concern and eventual discovery. This theme highlights the responsibility of individuals and society to recognize signs of abuse and intervene, showing how silence can continue cycles of violence and trauma. It also champions the courage it takes for a victim to eventually find their voice.
“Silence was a cage, and for years, she had been its prisoner.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
Hidden Abuse
Emma's secret life of abuse concealed behind a facade of normalcy.
This device creates immediate tension and suspense. The reader is aware of Emma's hidden suffering from the outset, which contrasts sharply with her seemingly perfect external life. This secrecy fuels Emma's actions, her guardedness, and her reluctance to engage with others, particularly Evan. It drives much of the initial plot, as Evan and his friends slowly uncover clues, building towards the inevitable revelation. The secrecy also highlights the insidious nature of domestic abuse and the isolation it creates for victims.
The Protective Love Interest
Evan's unwavering love and determination to save Emma.
Evan serves as the archetypal protective love interest. His character is designed to be the antithesis of Emma's abusers, offering unconditional love, safety, and belief. His consistent presence and determination to break through Emma's walls are crucial for her character arc. This device provides the emotional anchor for the story, creating a powerful contrast between the darkness of Emma's past and the hope of her future. Evan's actions, from noticing her bruises to ultimately discovering her abuse, drive the plot forward and initiate her path to healing.
Flashbacks and PTSD
Emma's involuntary memories and psychological responses to past trauma.
This device is used to illustrate the lasting psychological impact of Emma's abuse. Flashbacks, panic attacks, and other symptoms of PTSD are woven into the narrative, providing insight into Emma's internal struggles even after she is physically safe. They serve to remind the reader of the severity of her past and explain her lingering fears, trust issues, and difficulties with intimacy. This device adds depth and realism to her healing journey, showing that recovery is not linear and that trauma leaves deep, persistent scars.
Symbolism of Water/Swimming
Swimming as a metaphor for freedom, escape, and control.
For Emma, swimming is more than just a sport; it's a sanctuary and a metaphor for her inner world. In the water, she finds a sense of control and freedom she lacks in her daily life. It's a place where she can momentarily escape her pain and feel powerful. The act of diving underwater can symbolize her desire to disappear or her struggle to breathe. As she heals, swimming also becomes a symbol of her regained strength, confidence, and her ability to move forward, representing both an escape mechanism and a path to self-empowerment.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Sometimes you have to be apart from people you love, but that doesn't make you love them any less. Sometimes you love them more.”
— Evan contemplating his separation from Emma.
“The hardest part wasn't letting go. It was learning to live without the person you were letting go of.”
— Evan struggling with the aftermath of a difficult decision.
“You can't change the past, but you can ruin the present by worrying about the future.”
— A moment of wisdom shared between characters about moving forward.
“It's funny how the person who hurts you the most is the one who makes you feel the most alive.”
— Emma reflecting on the complexities of her relationship.
“Home wasn't a place, it was a feeling. It was the feeling of being safe, loved, and understood.”
— Emma searching for a sense of belonging.
“You never really know how strong you are until being strong is the only choice you have.”
— Emma facing immense adversity.
“Some people are meant to be in your life, but not forever.”
— A poignant realization about fleeting relationships.
“The only way to get over a fear is to face it head-on.”
— Evan encouraging Emma to confront her past.
“Love isn't always perfect. It's not a fairytale or a storybook. And it doesn't always come easy.”
— A realistic perspective on the nature of love.
“Sometimes the greatest act of love is to let go.”
— A difficult decision made for the well-being of another.
“Every breath you take is a second chance.”
— A hopeful message about new beginnings.
“You don't need a knight in shining armor to save you. You can save yourself.”
— Emma's journey of self-reliance and empowerment.
“Even the darkest night will end and the sun will rise.”
— A recurring theme of enduring hardship for a brighter future.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
Emma Thomas is enduring severe physical and emotional abuse from her aunt and uncle, Carol and Bob, while trying to maintain a facade of normalcy at school. Her central conflict is balancing the need to hide her abuse with her burgeoning feelings for Evan, which challenge her desire to remain invisible.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
