“Sometimes the truth is too ugly to look at directly, so we find ways to blur the edges, to soften the blow.”
— Main character discussing perception and reality.
Archivist's Choice
The Best Lies
Sarah Lyu (2019)
Genre
Thriller / Mystery / Young Adult
Reading Time
7 hours
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
After her boyfriend is murdered, a teenage girl must uncover the truth behind her best friend's confession, making her wonder if their deep bond was a haven or a trap.
Synopsis
Remy Tsai's world falls apart when her best friend, Elise, kills Remy's boyfriend, Jack. The story moves between timelines: one shows what led to Jack's death, and the other follows Remy's search for answers afterward. At first, Remy believes Elise's claim of self-defense. But as police investigate, Remy finds a complex web of secrets, manipulation, and an obsessive friendship. She looks back at her past with Elise, remembering their intense bond, Jack's arrival, and the increasingly tense dynamic among the three. Remy discovers that Elise's art and their 'secrets' were more sinister than she realized, showing Elise's possessive and manipulative nature. In the end, Remy uncovers the full truth behind Jack's murder, forcing her to face the dark side of her friendship with Elise and make a difficult choice about loyalty and justice.
Reading time
7 hours
Difficulty
Medium
Pacing
Variable
Mood
Suspenseful, Dark, Unsettling, Intense
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy psychological thrillers centered on toxic female friendships, unreliable narrators, and a non-linear timeline that slowly unravels a dark secret.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer straightforward mysteries, clear-cut heroes and villains, or shy away from stories exploring intense, unhealthy relationships.
Plot Summary
The Aftermath: Jack's Death and Elise's Arrest
The story begins with Remy Tsai reeling from her boyfriend Jack's death. He was shot in the chest, and her best friend, Elise, pulled the trigger. Elise is arrested immediately, and police begin their investigation, asking Remy about what happened before the tragedy. Remy is in shock, struggling to see the Elise she knows—her 'soulmate'—as a killer. The story moves between the present, where Remy is questioned and grieving, and the past, where her intense friendship with Elise and her relationship with Jack began. Remy feels an urgent need to understand what truly happened, not just for the police, but for herself and Elise.
The Beginning of a Friendship
Remy flashes back to the start of her senior year, before Jack and the tragedy. She remembers meeting Elise, a new student who immediately captivated her. Elise is an enigmatic and independent artist. Remy, feeling a bit lost and overshadowed by her high-achieving sister, is drawn to Elise's magnetic personality. Their connection is instant and deep, quickly becoming an intense, almost obsessive friendship. Elise encourages Remy to break free from her insecurities and embrace a more adventurous side. This period includes shared secrets, art projects, and a deep sense of belonging Remy had never felt before, setting up the complex relationship that will define their lives.
Jack Enters the Picture
Remy remembers falling in love with Jack, a kind and stable boy who offered her a sense of normalcy and comfort. At first, Elise is wary of Jack, seeing him as a threat to her exclusive bond with Remy. However, Remy eventually brings Jack and Elise together, hoping her two favorite people would connect. While Jack is initially intimidated by Elise's intensity, he gradually warms to her, and the three start spending time together. This forms a complicated triangle, where Remy often feels torn between the two most important people in her life. The dynamic is fragile, with underlying tensions, especially Elise's possessiveness over Remy.
The Summer of Secrets
The story explores the summer before Jack's death, a key time for Remy, Elise, and Jack. They spend almost every day together, exploring abandoned places, making art, and sharing intimate moments. While seemingly perfect, this period is full of unspoken tensions and shifting loyalties. Elise's influence on Remy grows stronger, often pushing Remy to defy expectations and take risks, sometimes at Jack's expense. Jack, in turn, tries to ground Remy, offering a stability that contrasts with Elise's more chaotic energy. Remy feels increasingly caught in the middle, navigating the competing desires of her best friend and her boyfriend, leading to moments of discomfort and subtle manipulation she struggles to understand at the time.
The Growing Rift
As summer goes on, the cracks in the trio's relationships become clearer. Elise's jealousy of Jack grows, leading to subtle sabotage and open hostility. She questions Jack's motives and manipulates situations to create distance between Remy and him. Remy, torn and often overwhelmed, makes excuses for Elise's behavior, unable to confront the darker parts of their friendship. Jack, increasingly frustrated by Elise's possessiveness and the strain it puts on his relationship with Remy, tries to make Remy see Elise's manipulative tendencies. This period has several arguments and betrayals, pushing Remy to choose between her boyfriend and her best friend, a choice she tries desperately to avoid.
The Truth About the Art
Remy, sifting through her memories and Elise's belongings, starts to put together a disturbing truth about Elise's art. She discovers that many of Elise's celebrated pieces, which Remy thought were spontaneous, were actually carefully constructed narratives, often using Remy's life and secrets without her full consent. This revelation chips away at Remy's idealized image of Elise, making her question the authenticity of their shared creative work and the boundaries Elise had crossed. The art, once a symbol of their bond, now shows Elise's manipulative tendencies and her desire to control the story of their friendship, making Remy wonder how much of their shared history was genuine.
The Escalation
The events leading up to Jack's death are told in fragmented, increasingly tense flashbacks. The animosity between Elise and Jack reaches a peak, fueled by resentment, jealousy, and a desperate struggle for Remy's attention. There are heated arguments, accusations, and physical fights that Remy tries desperately to stop, often failing. Elise's behavior becomes more erratic and possessive, while Jack grows increasingly protective of Remy, fearing Elise's influence. The final confrontation is a chaotic blur of emotions and actions, ending in the fatal gunshot. Remy's memory of this moment is broken, making it hard for her to give a clear account to the police or herself.
The Confession and the Cover-up
Immediately after Jack's death, Remy remembers Elise's panicked confession, claiming self-defense. However, the details are hazy, and Elise quickly urges Remy to back up her story, creating a false narrative for the authorities. Remy, still in shock and fiercely loyal to Elise, goes along with the plan, weaving a web of lies to protect her best friend. This moment of complicity ties Remy even more to Elise, forcing her to face the moral implications of her actions. The memory of this shared secret and the pressure to maintain the lie weighs heavily on Remy, making her question the true nature of their friendship and Elise's control.
Remy's Investigation
Driven by a need for truth, Remy begins her own investigation, sifting through her memories, Elise's belongings, and old conversations. She talks to people who knew Elise before she came to their school, uncovering fragments of a troubled past and a pattern of intense, sometimes destructive, friendships. This process is painful, forcing Remy to re-evaluate every interaction, every shared secret, and every act of loyalty she showed Elise. She starts to see the subtle manipulations and the darker parts of Elise's personality that she had ignored or rationalized. Each new piece of information challenges her view of Elise and the foundation of their friendship.
The Full Picture Emerges
Through her persistent search, Remy finally uncovers the full, devastating truth. She realizes that Elise's friendship was not as pure as she believed; it was a careful manipulation, a way for Elise to control and find an identity through Remy. Jack's death was not just self-defense, but the tragic result of Elise's obsessive jealousy and her inability to share Remy. The 'best lies' were not just the ones they told the police, but the ones Elise had woven throughout their friendship, creating a false reality Remy had willingly lived in. This realization shatters Remy's world, forcing her to confront the deep betrayal at the heart of their bond.
The Confrontation and Confession
Armed with the complete truth, Remy confronts Elise. In a tense and emotional meeting, the full story of Jack's death is revealed. It becomes clear that while there was an argument, Elise deliberately made the situation worse, and the shooting was not purely self-defense, but an act driven by her possessive desire to remove Jack as a rival for Remy's affection. Elise's carefully built facade crumbles, revealing the depths of her manipulation and her psychological instability. This confrontation is a key moment, forcing both Remy and Elise to face the devastating results of their intertwined lives and the lies they maintained.
Testimony and Aftermath
In the final act, Remy must decide how to testify in court. She struggles with the immense pressure to protect Elise versus her moral duty to tell the truth about Jack's death. Ultimately, Remy chooses to reveal the full extent of Elise's manipulation and the true circumstances of the shooting, even though it means betraying her 'soulmate.' Her testimony leads to Elise being held accountable for her actions. The ending leaves Remy changed, scarred by Jack's loss and the shattering of her most intense friendship. She faces a future where she must rebuild her identity and learn to trust again, carrying the weight of the truths she uncovered.
Principal Figures
Remy Tsai
The Protagonist
Remy transforms from a naive, easily manipulated girl into a strong, independent woman who confronts difficult truths and makes a morally courageous decision.
Elise
The Antagonist
Elise remains largely static in her manipulative patterns, but her carefully constructed facade ultimately shatters under the weight of her actions and Remy's revelations.
Jack
The Supporting
Jack's arc is cut short by his death, serving as a catalyst for Remy's journey of discovery and the unraveling of the truth.
Detective Miller
The Supporting
Detective Miller's role is primarily functional, representing the pursuit of justice and providing a framework for Remy's narrative.
Remy's Sister (unnamed)
The Mentioned
No specific arc, as she is primarily a background detail influencing Remy's early motivations.
Themes & Insights
The Dark Side of Obsessive Friendship
The novel explores how an intense bond, initially seen as empowering, can turn into a destructive, co-dependent relationship. Remy and Elise's friendship, while at first giving Remy confidence, ultimately becomes a cage built on manipulation and jealousy. Elise's possessiveness, shown in her reaction to Jack and her control over their shared art, highlights the dangers of blurred boundaries and losing one's identity within a friendship. The tragic outcome shows how unchecked obsession can lead to fatal consequences, even between those who claim to love each other.
“Maybe that’s what a best friend was: someone who knew all your worst secrets and didn’t care.”
Truth vs. Perception
A central theme is the subjective nature of truth and how personal stories can be made, manipulated, and eventually broken. Remy's journey is about uncovering the 'best lies' – not just those told to the police, but the self-deceptions and false realities Elise wove throughout their friendship. The alternating timelines show how memories can be unreliable and how the present can change the past. Remy's struggle to recall the exact events of Jack's death, and her gradual realization of Elise's true nature, illustrate the painful process of telling the difference between perceived reality and the stark truth.
“Memory is a funny thing. You think you know what happened, and then you replay it, and bits start to move around, change color, take on new meaning.”
Identity and Self-Discovery
Remy's journey is one of self-discovery, prompted by trauma. Initially, she defines herself largely through her relationships, first feeling incomplete, then finding a sense of self through Elise's influence, and later through her love for Jack. The breaking of these relationships forces her to confront who she is outside of them. Her investigation into Jack's death becomes an internal search to understand her own involvement, her own desires, and her own moral compass. By the end, Remy emerges with a clearer, though more painful, sense of her independent identity, no longer defined by others' expectations or manipulations.
“I was a blank canvas, and Elise painted me into something new.”
Manipulation and Control
Elise embodies manipulation, using her charisma, artistic talent, and knowledge of Remy's weaknesses to control her. She subtly isolates Remy from Jack, creates stories through her art, and ultimately pressures Remy into covering up a crime. This manipulation is insidious because it pretends to be deep affection and shared experience. The novel shows how easily one can be swayed by a charismatic person, especially when that person fills a deep need for connection and validation. The revelation of Elise's manipulative patterns forces Remy to re-evaluate every part of their shared history.
“She didn't just tell stories; she created them. And sometimes, she made me a character in them without me even knowing.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
Alternating Timelines
The narrative shifts between 'Before' (leading up to Jack's death) and 'After' (the investigation).
This device is crucial for building suspense and revealing information gradually. The 'After' timeline, set in the present, grounds the reader in the immediate aftermath of the tragedy and Remy's grief, while the 'Before' timeline slowly unravels the complex, toxic friendship between Remy and Elise, and Remy's relationship with Jack. This structure allows the author to hint at future events and create dramatic irony, as the reader knows the outcome but not the full path that led there. It also mirrors Remy's own fragmented memory and her process of piecing together the truth.
Unreliable Narrator
Remy's perspective is influenced by grief, trauma, and her deep loyalty to Elise.
Remy's narration is inherently unreliable due to her emotional state, her trauma from Jack's death, and her initial unwavering belief in Elise. As she recounts events, her memories are often hazy, contradictory, or colored by her desire to protect Elise and her own complicity. This device forces the reader to actively question Remy's account and look for subtle clues, mirroring Remy's own journey of re-evaluating her past. The unreliability deepens the mystery and underscores the theme of truth versus perception, as Remy herself struggles to discern the 'best lies' from the painful truth.
Red Herrings and Misdirection
Clues and character actions are presented to mislead the reader about the true culprit or motives.
The novel employs various red herrings, particularly in the early stages of the investigation, to keep the reader guessing about the exact circumstances of Jack's death and Elise's true nature. Initial portrayals of Elise's artistic temperament, her seemingly spontaneous actions, and Remy's loyal defense of her all serve to misdirect. The focus on self-defense as a potential justification for the shooting also acts as a red herring, obscuring the deeper, more manipulative motives that are eventually revealed. This device maintains suspense and enhances the 'thriller' aspect of the story.
Symbolism of Art
Elise's art represents her control, manipulation, and the constructed nature of reality.
Art, particularly Elise's photographs and installations, serves as a powerful symbolic device. Initially, it symbolizes the creative bond between Remy and Elise and their shared escape. However, as the story progresses, it becomes clear that Elise uses her art to manipulate narratives, control perceptions, and even exploit Remy's life for her own creative and psychological ends. The discovery that Elise's 'spontaneous' art was meticulously planned and often based on Remy's secrets underscores Elise's manipulative nature and the theme of constructed reality, revealing how art can be used as a tool of power rather than pure expression.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“The thing about secrets is they don't stay buried forever. Eventually, they claw their way out.”
— Reflecting on the nature of hidden information.
“You can love someone and still not really know them. Maybe that's the scariest part.”
— Considering the complexities of relationships and hidden lives.
“Grief is a strange thing. It makes you do things you never thought you would, say things you can't take back.”
— Experiencing the raw emotions of loss.
“Memory is a tricky thing. It bends and warps, showing you what it wants you to see, not always what was.”
— Questioning the reliability of past recollections.
“We build our lives on stories, some true, some we tell ourselves so often they become true.”
— Examining the narratives people create for themselves.
“The silence after a lie is often louder than the lie itself.”
— Feeling the weight of unspoken truths and deception.
“It's easy to judge from the outside, but you never know what battles someone is fighting on the inside.”
— A moment of empathy and understanding for others' struggles.
“Sometimes the person you think you know best is the one who surprises you the most.”
— A revelation about a close friend or family member.
“Fear can be a powerful motivator, pushing you to do things you never imagined.”
— Under pressure and making difficult choices.
“The past isn't just behind us; it's woven into every fiber of who we are now.”
— Reflecting on the lasting impact of past events.
“There’s a difference between wanting to know the truth and being ready for it.”
— Hesitating before uncovering a difficult reality.
“Sometimes the best lies are the ones we tell ourselves, the ones that let us keep going.”
— Coping with trauma or difficult circumstances through self-deception.
“Trust is a fragile thing. Once broken, it's almost impossible to put back together perfectly.”
— Dealing with betrayal and its aftermath.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
The central mystery revolves around the death of Jack, Remy's boyfriend, who was shot by Elise, Remy's best friend. The police and Remy herself investigate whether Elise acted in self-defense or if there was a more sinister motive behind the shooting, unraveling the complex dynamics of their friendship.
