“The house was a good house, a happy house, before the DeFeos.”
— George Lutz reflecting on the history of the house before their family moved in.
Archivist's Choice
The Amityville Horror
Jay Anson (1977)
Genre
Thriller / Mystery
Reading Time
315 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
In a house where a family was murdered, the Lutz family's new beginning turns into a 28-day nightmare of paranormal terror, forcing them to leave their home and face the truth that evil has a new address.
Synopsis
In December 1975, George and Kathy Lutz, with Kathy's three children, buy their dream home at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York. They do not know the house was the site of the DeFeo murders just a year before, where Ronald DeFeo Jr. killed his entire family. Almost immediately, the family experiences terrifying and unexplainable paranormal events. Father Mancuso tries to bless the house but an unseen force violently warns him away. George changes, becoming cold, distant, and obsessed with the cold. Strange smells, sounds, and physical events trouble the house. Missy, the youngest child, makes an imaginary friend named Jodie, who describes herself as a pig. Walls ooze green slime, windows slam shut, and objects move on their own. The children are especially targeted, having nightmares and physical attacks. As the demonic presence grows, the family's sanity and safety are at risk. After 28 days of constant terror, the Lutzes have to leave the house, abandoning their belongings and convinced the home is possessed by an evil entity.
Reading time
315 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Fast
Mood
Terrifying, Suspenseful, Dark, Unsettling
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy 'true story' horror, haunted house narratives, or psychological thrillers based on alleged real events.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer supernatural stories with clear explanations or are easily disturbed by graphic descriptions of alleged demonic activity and child endangerment.
Plot Summary
The DeFeo Murders and the House on Ocean Avenue
The story begins by detailing the horrific past of 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, Long Island. On November 13, 1974, Ronald DeFeo Jr. murdered his entire family—his parents and four younger siblings—as they slept. DeFeo later said voices in the house told him to commit the murders. This event casts a long shadow over the property, setting the stage for the supernatural events that follow. The house, despite its appearance, becomes known for evil, a fact its next residents will soon learn.
The Lutz Family's Dream Home
In December 1975, George and Kathleen Lutz, with Kathy's three children—Daniel, Christopher, and Missy—find their 'dream home' in Amityville. The real estate agent tells them about the DeFeo murders, but they are drawn to the large, Dutch Colonial house and its low price. They decide to move in, believing they can overcome the house's past and create a happy new life. They see the lower price as a result of the murders, not a sign of something worse. Their optimism quickly fades as unexplainable events begin.
Immediate Disturbances and Father Mancuso's Warning
Almost immediately after moving in, the Lutz family experiences unsettling events. Doors slam, windows open, and an intense cold fills certain rooms. Kathy's Catholic priest, Father Mancuso (a made-up name for Father Pecoraro), tries to bless the house. A powerful, unseen voice commands him to 'GET OUT!' He also feels a slap and develops a severe fever and blisters. His phone calls to the Lutzes are full of static, stopping him from fully warning them. These early events suggest the house is not just haunted, but actively hostile.
George's Transformation and the Fly Infestation
George Lutz begins to change. He becomes constantly cold, obsessed with keeping fires burning, and often wakes at 3:15 AM—the exact time of the DeFeo murders. He grows more irritable and distant. At the same time, the house has a strange fly problem, especially in the sewing room, despite it being winter. The flies appear from nowhere, defying explanation and adding to the growing sense of dread and uncleanliness, further isolating the family.
Missy's Imaginary Friend and the Red Room
Four-year-old Missy Lutz develops an 'imaginary friend' named Jodie, whom she describes as a pig-like creature with glowing red eyes. Missy's talks with Jodie become more unsettling, hinting at an evil influence. The family also finds a small, hidden red room in the basement, which they did not know about. Their dog, Harry, refuses to go near the house and especially avoids the red room, showing extreme fear. This room gives off a strong feeling of evil, suggesting it may be a center for the malevolent presence.
Kathy's Terrors and the Oozing Walls
Kathy Lutz faces increasing physical and emotional torment. She has nightmares, feels unseen hands touching her, and smells a foul, sulfurous odor. Once, she sees a demonic face with glowing red eyes staring from the dark. The house walls begin to 'bleed' green slime, and black stains appear on fixtures. These events show a deeper intrusion of the supernatural, moving beyond poltergeist activity to something more insidious and physical, directly attacking Kathy and the house.
The Children's Ordeal
The children are also affected by the house's evil. Daniel and Christopher have nightmares, see glowing red eyes, and report being pushed by unseen forces. Daniel says he was levitated in his bed. Missy continues to talk to Jodie, whose influence seems to grow, making her act strangely. Their fear and distress increase, showing the widespread nature of the haunting and the danger it poses to the whole family, especially the most vulnerable members. The children's experiences add a layer of tragic helplessness.
The Increasing Intensity and Physical Manifestations
The supernatural activity grows dramatically. Objects are thrown, furniture moves, and phantom footsteps are heard throughout the house. George and Kathy see a large, cloaked figure with glowing red eyes in the doorway. Doors and windows open and close on their own. The house becomes filled with disembodied voices, growls, and screams. These increasingly violent and clear events leave no doubt in the Lutzes' minds that they are dealing with a powerful, evil entity determined to drive them out or worse.
The Final Night and Escape
On the 28th day, the terror reaches its peak. The house explodes in paranormal activity: severe cold spots, flying objects, and the clear presence of multiple entities. George describes being attacked by an unseen force, while Kathy is tormented by terrifying visions. The family is traumatized and exhausted. Realizing their lives are in danger and they cannot fight the evil, George and Kathy decide to flee, leaving most of their belongings behind. They escape with only the clothes they are wearing, convinced the house is completely possessed.
Aftermath and Public Scrutiny
After fleeing, the Lutzes find safety with Kathy's mother. They immediately contact paranormal investigators, including Ed and Lorraine Warren, to help them understand and confirm their experiences. Their story quickly gains public attention, attracting both believers and skeptics. The book details their attempts to cope with the trauma and the subsequent investigations, which reportedly confirm an evil force. The Lutzes' account sparks national interest in the Amityville haunting, securing its place in popular culture as a chilling ghost story.
Principal Figures
George Lutz
The Protagonist
Transforms from a rational, loving family man into a tormented, withdrawn individual on the brink of collapse, ultimately forced to choose his family's safety over the house.
Kathy Lutz
The Protagonist
Endures increasing psychological and physical torment, ultimately becoming a terrified but determined mother who prioritizes her family's escape.
Father Mancuso (Father Pecoraro)
The Supporting
Serves as an initial witness and victim of the house's malevolence, confirming the spiritual nature of the haunting.
Missy Lutz
The Supporting
Becomes a conduit for the house's malevolent entity, demonstrating its ability to prey on the innocent.
Daniel Lutz
The Supporting
Witnesses and experiences terrifying phenomena, contributing to the family's collective trauma and fear.
Christopher Lutz
The Supporting
Endures frightening experiences in the house, adding to the children's collective ordeal.
Jodie
The Antagonist
Acts as a constant, subtle manifestation of the house's evil, primarily through its interaction with Missy.
Ronald DeFeo Jr.
The Mentioned
His past crime serves as the foundational trauma that enables the subsequent haunting.
Themes & Insights
The Corrupting Power of Evil
This theme explores how evil forces can not only cause terror but also subtly corrupt people and places. George Lutz's change from a practical, loving husband to an irritable, distant, and constantly cold man is a key example. The house itself becomes a physical sign of this corruption, 'bleeding' green slime and attracting flies, showing widespread decay. The story suggests that long exposure to such evil can change one's very being, making escape a matter of spiritual and psychological survival, as seen in George's growing obsession with the cold and his violent outbursts.
“The house was alive, and it wanted them out... or worse.”
The Invasion of the Domestic Space
The story effectively uses the fear of one's home, usually a safe place, becoming a source of terror. The Lutz family's 'dream home' quickly turns into a nightmare, with every part of domestic life invaded. From the children's bedrooms where they are levitated and attacked, to the kitchen where objects fly, and the walls that ooze slime, the house stops being a safe haven. This theme highlights how vulnerable a family is when their most private space is compromised, making the horror deeply personal and inescapable, as the evil operates within their daily lives.
“This was their dream house, but it had become their worst nightmare.”
The Struggle Between Faith and Demonic Influence
Kathy Lutz's Catholic faith and her reliance on Father Mancuso add a spiritual dimension to the conflict. Father Mancuso's violent encounter during the house blessing immediately shows the demonic nature of the haunting. The failure of religious rites to cleanse the house, and the direct attack on the priest, suggest a powerful, deep-seated evil that resists traditional spiritual measures. This theme explores the limits of faith against overwhelming demonic power and the spiritual battle inherent in the Lutzes' fight for survival, emphasizing that this is more than just a ghost story, but a battle for souls.
“Get out! Get out! It was a guttural, demonic roar.”
The Fragility of Reality and Perception
The book constantly blurs the lines between reality and illusion, making both characters and readers question what is real. The unexplained events, George's personality changes, and the children's interactions with 'Jodie' challenge normal understanding. George's initial doubt and the family's attempts to explain the events show how hard it is to accept the truly unexplainable. This theme highlights the psychological toll of the haunting, as the family's grasp on normal life breaks down, leading to deep terror and ultimately, forced escape from a reality they can no longer understand or control.
“They were living in a nightmare, but it was a nightmare that was real.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The 'True Story' Claim
The book's assertion of being a non-fiction account.
The most significant plot device is the book's framing as a 'true story.' This claim immediately heightens the reader's sense of dread and suspense, making the horrific events recounted feel more immediate and terrifying. It blurs the line between fiction and reality, inviting readers to believe that such supernatural occurrences are possible. This device taps into primal fears by suggesting that the extraordinary can intrude upon the ordinary, lending a chilling credibility to every strange occurrence and making the horror more impactful.
Rising Action through Escalation
The gradual increase in intensity and malevolence of the haunting.
The narrative meticulously builds tension through a relentless escalation of paranormal activity. It begins with subtle disturbances like cold spots and strange smells, progresses to poltergeist activity with slamming doors and moving objects, and culminates in terrifying physical attacks, demonic manifestations, and the psychological torment of the family. This gradual but consistent increase in intensity prevents the reader from becoming desensitized and maintains a constant state of dread, mirroring the Lutzes' own increasing terror and desperation.
The Unreliable Narrator (George Lutz's Transformation)
George's deteriorating mental state influences his perception and reactions.
While the book is written from an omniscient perspective, George Lutz's internal struggle and transformation serve as a form of unreliable narration. His growing irritability, obsession with cold, and constant waking at 3:15 AM show him becoming increasingly unhinged. This suggests that the house isn't just causing external phenomena but actively manipulating his mind, making his judgment and reactions questionable. This adds a layer of psychological horror, as the reader wonders if George's perceptions are entirely trustworthy, further disorienting the experience.
The Hidden 'Red Room'
A newly discovered, sinister room in the basement.
The discovery of the small, hidden 'red room' in the basement serves as a potent symbol and a focal point for the house's evil. Its previous concealment and the immediate sense of dread it imparts, combined with the family dog's extreme fear of it, establish it as a place of concentrated malevolence. This device adds a layer of mystery and foreboding, suggesting deeper, ancient evils at play within the house's very foundations, and provides a tangible, albeit terrifying, representation of the unseen forces.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“For God's sake, get out!”
— The infamous voice that the Lutzes claimed to hear coming from the house.
“He saw Kathy's face contorted in a silent scream, her eyes wide with terror.”
— George Lutz witnessing his wife's reaction to an unseen horror in the house.
“A cold, clammy hand seemed to brush against his face.”
— George experiencing a physical manifestation of a presence.
“The feeling of an oppressive weight, a suffocating presence, was constant.”
— Describing the pervasive sense of dread felt by the family.
“The red room. It was always there, behind the stairs, waiting.”
— Referring to the mysterious red room in the basement, a source of unease.
“Flies. Thousands of them. Even in winter.”
— One of the inexplicable phenomena observed in the house.
“Something evil was in that house, something that wanted to stay.”
— George's growing conviction about the malevolent entity.
“The crucifix turned itself upside down.”
— A chilling incident involving religious iconography.
“He could hear the Pig. Always the Pig.”
— George hearing the sounds of a demonic pig, one of the more bizarre elements.
“Sleep was no escape. The nightmares were worse.”
— Describing the psychological torment experienced by the family, even in their sleep.
“The house was alive. And it hated them.”
— A summation of the Lutzes' belief about the sentient evil within the house.
“Thirty days. That's all it took for our lives to be shattered.”
— George reflecting on the short but devastating time they spent in the house.
“We were not just victims of a haunting; we were victims of a murder.”
— George's belief that the house was attempting to kill them.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
The book chronicles the 28-day ordeal of the Lutz family – George, Kathy, and their three children – after they move into a large Dutch Colonial house in Amityville, New York. This house was the site of the horrific DeFeo murders a year prior, and the Lutzes soon experience a barrage of terrifying paranormal phenomena that ultimately forces them to flee.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
