BookBrief
Tangerine cover
Archivist's Choice

Tangerine

Edward Bloor (1997)

Genre

Children's / Mystery / Young Adult

Reading Time

360 min

Key Themes

See below

Track Your Reading

Sign in to track this book

A legally blind boy in a strange Florida town learns the truth about his family's secrets and his brother's cruelty while dealing with sinkholes, daily lightning, and an underground fire.

Synopsis

Paul Fisher, legally blind and always overshadowed by his football star brother Erik, moves with his family to Tangerine County, Florida. Paul quickly sees how strange his new home is, with sinkholes and constant lightning storms. At Lake Windsor Middle School, he cannot play on the soccer team because of his IEP. But he gets a new chance when a large sinkhole destroys the school. This makes him transfer to Tangerine Middle School, a tougher, mostly Hispanic school where the championship soccer team, the War Eagles, welcomes him. As Paul does well on the field and makes new friends, he starts to find out the dark secrets behind his family's perfect image, especially about his brother Erik's increasingly cruel actions. He slowly remembers pieces about his eyesight and what really happened in his past. The truth comes out in several confrontations where Paul finally remembers that Erik, with his friend Castor, intentionally sprayed paint into his eyes when he was five. After Erik is linked to a local robbery and a tragic death, Paul's parents must face Erik's destructive behavior. Paul, strengthened by what he now knows and by his friends, confronts his family and accepts the truth, finding his voice and a sense of belonging.
Reading time
360 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Mysterious, Suspenseful, Empathetic, Triumphant
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy stories about overcoming adversity, uncovering family secrets, and finding your place in an unexpected community. Perfect for readers who like sports narratives with a deeper mystery.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer lighthearted stories without themes of bullying, family dysfunction, or crime. Some readers might find the initial setting descriptions a bit slow.

Plot Summary

A New Beginning in Tangerine County

Paul Fisher, legally blind and wearing thick glasses, moves with his family from Houston, Texas, to Lake Windsor Downs, a new development in Tangerine County, Florida. His older brother, Erik, a star football player, gets all their parents' attention, often at Paul's expense. Paul immediately notices the strange things in their new home: a constant muck fire burning underground, daily lightning storms, and the threat of sinkholes. On his first day, Paul sees smoke from the muck fire, and later, a sinkhole destroys the school's portable classrooms. He enrolls in Lake Windsor Middle School, where he feels like an outsider and is always overshadowed by Erik's reputation and mean pranks.

Lake Windsor Middle School and the War Eagles

At Lake Windsor Middle School, Paul tries out for the soccer team, the War Eagles, as goalie. Despite his skill, his IEP (Individualized Education Program), which says he is legally blind, stops him from being allowed to play by the school board. This decision upsets Paul, who suspects his mother's overprotective nature and her wish to avoid problems for Erik's football career played a part. His parents seem more worried about Erik's upcoming football season than Paul's disappointment. Paul's best friend at Lake Windsor, Joey Costello, whose brother Mike died from a lightning strike during football practice, also struggles to fit in.

Transfer to Tangerine Middle School

After a sinkhole destroys the portable classrooms, Paul's parents let him transfer to Tangerine Middle School, a poorer, mostly Hispanic school. Paul eagerly agrees, seeing a chance for a new start. At Tangerine Middle, he meets Victor Cruz, the intense captain of the Tangerine War Eagles soccer team, and Tino Cruz, Victor's younger brother. Paul is immediately accepted onto the team as a goalie, even with his glasses. He quickly earns his new teammates' respect with his skills and bravery, finding a sense of belonging he never had at Lake Windsor.

Life at Tangerine Middle and the Citrus Grove

Paul does well at Tangerine Middle, making new friends and becoming an important part of the soccer team. He learns about the difficulties faced by migrant workers and the constant fight against freezes that threaten the citrus groves, especially the Golden Dawn tangerines grown by the Cruz family. He starts spending time at the Cruz family's farm, helping Tino and Victor protect their trees from frost and pests. During this time, Paul sees the strong community ties and the hard work involved in farming, a sharp contrast to the artificiality of Lake Windsor Downs. He also observes the ongoing rivalry between the Tangerine War Eagles and the Lake Windsor Seagulls.

Erik's Cruelty and the Robbery

Erik's threatening behavior continues to get worse. Paul remembers past instances of Erik's cruelty, especially with Erik's friend Arthur Bauer, who acts as Erik's helper. Erik and Arthur are involved in a series of robberies targeting homes in Lake Windsor Downs, particularly those of football players with expensive equipment. During a school carnival, Paul brings Tino and Victor, but Erik and Arthur insult them, leading to a fight where Erik hits Tino. Later, Erik and Arthur rob Joey Costello's house, stealing his brother Mike's valuable things, and then Paul's house, stealing his new computer, which Paul sees.

The Soccer Championship and a Confrontation

The Tangerine War Eagles, with Paul as their star goalie, have a good season, ending in a championship game against the previously undefeated Lake Windsor Seagulls. In an exciting match, Paul makes important saves, and the War Eagles win the championship, bringing great pride to Tangerine Middle School. After the game, Paul, Tino, and Victor celebrate. However, the victory is clouded by the ongoing tension with Erik. Paul overhears Erik and Arthur talking about their crimes, further confirming his suspicions about their involvement in the robberies. This victory strengthens Paul's place within the Tangerine community.

The Truth About Paul's Eyesight

Paul has always been told that his poor eyesight was from looking at a solar eclipse without proper protection. However, he slowly starts to remember parts of his past. During a talk with his parents, after Tino and Victor confront Erik, Paul finally asks his parents for the truth. His mother reveals that when Paul was five, Erik, driven by jealousy and anger, held Paul's head down while their friend Castor sprayed paint into his eyes with a BB gun. His parents, wanting to protect Erik and avoid scandal, made up the eclipse story and never told Paul the full truth, causing Paul's lifelong trauma and self-doubt.

Confrontation and Consequences

Knowing the truth, Paul confronts Erik directly. Erik attacks Paul in a rage, but Paul stands his ground. The police, already investigating the robberies, connect Erik and Arthur to the thefts after a tip. Arthur Bauer is found with the stolen goods and confesses, naming Erik. Erik is arrested, and the full extent of his criminal actions and violent behavior is revealed. Paul's parents must face the reality of Erik's actions and their own role in covering up Paul's injury. This confrontation is a key moment for Paul, freeing him from years of fear and confusion.

A New Chapter

With Erik's arrest and the truth out, Paul feels a deep sense of freedom. He can finally see clearly, not just physically, but emotionally. He decides to enroll full-time at Tangerine Middle School, leaving Lake Windsor behind for good. His parents, humbled by what they learned, support his decision. Paul's journey ends with him driving to Tangerine Middle with his new friends, ready to embrace who he is and the community that truly accepts him, free from his brother's shadow and the secrets of his past. He is no longer the shy, legally blind boy, but a confident young man ready for the future.

Principal Figures

Paul Fisher

The Protagonist

Paul transforms from a timid, fearful boy who accepts his family's narrative to a courageous individual who uncovers the truth and stands up for himself.

Erik Fisher

The Antagonist

Erik's character remains consistently cruel and unrepentant, culminating in his exposure and arrest.

Mr. Fisher (Dad)

The Supporting

He slowly begins to recognize Erik's true nature and the consequences of his own neglect, leading to a grudging acceptance of Paul's choices.

Mrs. Fisher (Mom)

The Supporting

She gradually confronts her guilt and the consequences of her cover-up, leading to a more honest relationship with Paul.

Tino Cruz

The Supporting

Tino remains a loyal and fierce friend to Paul, helping him find his place and confront his fears.

Victor Cruz

The Supporting

Victor remains a strong, protective leader and friend, helping Paul find his confidence and belonging.

Arthur Bauer

The Supporting

Arthur's character serves as a tool for Erik's destructive behavior, eventually leading to his own arrest and confession.

Luis Cruz

The Supporting

Luis's arc is tragically cut short by Erik's violence, serving as a catalyst for Paul's final confrontation with his family's secrets.

Joey Costello

The Supporting

Joey struggles to adapt to new environments and ultimately retreats to his comfort zone, highlighting the contrast with Paul's journey of adaptation.

Themes & Insights

Identity and Self-Discovery

Paul's journey is about finding his true identity, separate from his family's expectations and the lies about his past. His move to Tangerine Middle School lets him drop the label of 'legally blind kid' and use his talent as a goalie. He finds a community that values him for his skills and character, not his perceived disabilities or his brother's shadow. The truth about his eyesight is central to him understanding himself, as facing this trauma helps him see himself, and his family, clearly for the first time.

“I had always been afraid of Erik. And I had always been afraid of the truth. But now I wasn't. Now I just wanted to know.”

— Paul Fisher

Truth vs. Deception

The novel shows how damaging deception is, especially within the Fisher family. Paul's parents keep a lie about his eyesight to protect Erik, building a foundation of untruths that affects Paul's whole life. This main deception is reflected by smaller deceptions and cover-ups throughout the book, such as the muck fire, the sinkhole, and the robberies. The story's peak involves Paul finding the truth, which, though painful, frees him and reveals the moral decay under Lake Windsor Downs.

“It was amazing. I could see. I could see everything. And it was all true.”

— Paul Fisher

Community and Belonging

The sharp difference between the two communities, Lake Windsor Downs and Tangerine, highlights the theme of belonging. Lake Windsor is marked by shallow behavior, social climbing, and a lack of real connection, where Paul feels like an outsider. Tangerine, despite being poorer, offers Paul a sense of real community, acceptance, and unity among the citrus workers and soccer team. Paul finds his place and a sense of family among the Cruz family and his teammates, where he is valued for his contributions and character.

“I was a Tangerine. I belonged here. I was home.”

— Paul Fisher

The Nature of Evil and Bullying

The novel clearly shows the destructive nature of bullying and evil through Erik Fisher. Erik's actions, from blinding Paul initially to constant verbal abuse, physical attacks, and organizing robberies, show a deep lack of empathy and a cruel desire for power. The book explores how such evil can be allowed by parents who neglect their children and focus on superficial success. Erik's character is a clear warning about what happens when malice goes unchecked and the importance of opposing it.

“Erik Fisher was a psychopath. He was a monster. And I had been living with him my whole life.”

— Paul Fisher

Environmental Decay and Neglect

The setting of Tangerine County contains a sense of environmental decay and neglect, mirroring the moral decay within the community. The constant muck fire, frequent lightning strikes, and recurring sinkholes symbolize the unstable and dangerous base on which Lake Windsor Downs is built. Residents and authorities often ignore or downplay these environmental dangers, reflecting their denial of social and moral problems. The citrus farmers' fight against nature contrasts with the artificial, controlled environment of the new development.

“Something was always burning in Tangerine County. Something was always falling apart.”

— Narrator

Plot Devices & Literary Techniques

First-Person Narration (Paul's Diary/Journal)

Provides intimate access to Paul's thoughts and observations.

The entire novel is told from Paul Fisher's first-person perspective, often framed as entries in his journal or diary. This device allows readers to experience Paul's internal struggles, fears, and gradual revelations directly. It emphasizes his acute observational skills, despite his impaired vision, and builds suspense as he slowly pieces together the truth about his past. This narrative voice makes Paul a highly sympathetic and relatable character, inviting readers to share in his journey of self-discovery and empowerment.

The Muck Fire and Sinkholes

Symbolic representations of underlying corruption and instability.

The persistent muck fire burning underground and the frequent sinkholes are not just environmental quirks of Tangerine County; they serve as powerful symbols. The muck fire represents the festering, unacknowledged problems and corruption beneath the surface of the seemingly perfect Lake Windsor Downs community, particularly the Fisher family's hidden truths. The sinkholes symbolize the sudden, unavoidable collapse of facades and the exposure of underlying instability, mirroring the eventual unraveling of the lies surrounding Paul's past and Erik's criminal activities.

Paul's Glasses and Eyesight

A literal and metaphorical symbol of perception and truth.

Paul's thick glasses and his 'legal blindness' are central to his character and the novel's themes. Initially, they represent his physical vulnerability and the limitations imposed upon him by his family's lie. However, as the story progresses, his physical vision becomes a metaphor for his ability to 'see' the truth. The revelation of how his eyes were damaged is the climax of his journey, allowing him to perceive his family, Erik, and himself with newfound clarity, transcending his physical impairment to gain moral and emotional insight.

The Tangerine vs. Lake Windsor Divide

A social and economic contrast highlighting class, prejudice, and community values.

The stark geographical and social divide between the affluent, artificial Lake Windsor Downs and the hardworking, diverse community of Tangerine Middle School is a crucial plot device. This contrast highlights themes of class prejudice, authenticity, and community values. Lake Windsor represents superficiality, denial, and a focus on appearances, while Tangerine embodies resilience, genuine connection, and hard work. Paul's journey across this divide is central to his personal growth and his discovery of where he truly belongs.

Critical analysis

Notable Quotes

“I can see. I can see everything. I can see the truth.”

— Leo's realization about his vision and the past.

“Sometimes you have to look hard to see the truth.”

— Leo reflecting on his brother's actions.

“We are all afraid of something. What is important is how we act when we are afraid.”

— A lesson Leo learns about courage.

“Your eyes are not glasses, Leo. They are a window.”

— Coach Walski's comment about Leo's 'disability'.

“The truth is like a Tangerine. You have to peel it to get to the good stuff inside.”

— A metaphor used to describe uncovering secrets.

“Some people are just born bad, and there's nothing you can do about it.”

— A character's cynical view of human nature.

“Being blind doesn't stop you from seeing. It just makes you see differently.”

— Leo's internal struggle and eventual acceptance of his vision.

“You can't outrun your past, no matter how fast you are.”

— Reflecting on the consequences of past actions.

“There are two kinds of people in the world: those who run from the storm, and those who run into it.”

— A character's philosophy on facing challenges.

“It's funny how you can live in a place for years and never really see it.”

— Leo's observation about his new environment.

“Sometimes the biggest monsters are the ones you can't see.”

— Referring to internal fears or hidden dangers.

“The truth always comes out, eventually.”

— A common theme throughout the mystery.

“You can pretend all you want, but the truth doesn't care about your pretending.”

— Leo confronting a character about their lies.

“It's a strange thing, to be afraid of the light.”

— Leo's early fear of seeing and remembering.

Quiz

Test Your Knowledge

Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.

10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score

Key Questions (FAQ)

'Tangerine' follows Paul Fisher, a legally blind middle schooler, as his family moves to Tangerine County, Florida. He navigates a new school, joins the soccer team, and uncovers long-held family secrets, particularly concerning his older brother Erik and the true nature of his own vision impairment.

About the author