“The thing about being brave is it doesn't mean you're not scared. It means you're scared, but you do it anyway.”
— Stella's advice to Angel on facing fears.

Sara Pennypacker (2012)
Genre
Children's / Young Adult
Reading Time
275 min
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
On Cape Cod, two foster girls, one seeking stability and the other belonging, must unite after a death, navigating a summer of survival, self-discovery, and the dream of finding a true family amidst a gypsy moth invasion.
Ten-year-old Stella found stability living with her Great-aunt Louise on Cape Cod, a welcome change from her unreliable mother, Roxanne. Stella thrives on routine, which Louise, a retired librarian, provided. Their quiet summer changed when Louise took in a foster child, Angel. Angel, also ten, is prickly and guarded, a contrast to Stella's organized nature. The girls mostly ignored each other, with Stella seeing Angel as an unwelcome addition to her world. Stella secretly hoped her mother would return to the Cape and create a stable home, a dream Angel's presence seemed to threaten.
Life continued with strained silence between Stella and Angel, while Louise kept her calm manner. However, subtle signs began to appear that Louise was not well. She became forgetful, sometimes repeating herself, and moved slower. Stella, focused on her routine and quiet resentment of Angel, did not fully notice these changes. Angel, also focused on her own pain and distrust, also failed to see how serious Louise's condition was. The girls were too young and too absorbed in their own struggles to recognize the coming crisis.
One morning, Stella woke to find Louise unresponsive in her bed. Shock turned to horror for both girls. Louise had died peacefully in her sleep. Overwhelmed and scared, Stella, with her planning habit, immediately saw the problem: they were alone, and if anyone found out, they would be separated. Angel, hardened by her past foster care experiences, also understood how uncertain their situation was. Driven by a shared, unspoken fear of being sent away, they decided to keep Louise's death a secret.
After Louise's death, panic and desperate planning took over. Stella, the more analytical girl, suggested they pretend Louise was still alive. Angel, surprisingly, agreed, knowing the alternative was immediate re-entry into the foster system. They moved Louise's body to the basement freezer, a grim act. They began to forge Louise's signature on checks, manage her money, and keep up the illusion of her presence. This secret pact, born of fear, forced them to cooperate, slowly breaking down their earlier dislike.
The summer became a delicate act of deception. Stella and Angel created a system, taking turns answering the phone, making excuses for Louise's absence, and doing chores. Daily tasks, from shopping to paying bills, became high-stakes operations. They faced challenges, such as a nosy neighbor, Mrs. Benson, and the arrival of gypsy moths, whose caterpillars began to destroy the trees. The girls' strengths emerged: Stella's organization kept their money in order, while Angel's street smarts helped them with social situations and unexpected problems.
As the summer went on, gypsy moth caterpillars hatched in huge numbers, eating leaves and creating a constant rain of droppings. The invasion mirrored the internal chaos and decay the girls tried to hide. The bare trees around Louise's house created an exposed landscape, reflecting their own vulnerability. The moths became a real, external threat that isolated them further, as neighbors stayed indoors. This environmental crisis increased their feeling of being alone against the world, adding pressure to their strained deception.
The strain of their deception began to show. Mrs. Benson's questions became more direct, and Stella and Angel struggled to find believable reasons for Louise's long 'absence.' Money started to run out as they realized the limits of Louise's bank account and their ability to forge signatures. The freezer holding Louise's body had problems, creating a new, scary issue that threatened to expose their secret. Arguments between Stella and Angel became more frequent, fueled by stress and their different ways of solving problems, yet they always managed to avoid completely falling apart.
Despite their constant arguments and the pressure, Stella and Angel slowly began to see each other as allies, not rivals. They shared stories of their pasts - Stella's longing for her mother's return, and Angel's traumatic experiences in foster care. They found a mutual desire for a stable home and a family. Moments of unexpected kindness and shared laughter brightened their grim reality. Angel taught Stella practical skills, while Stella helped Angel with reading. Their strengths complemented each other, and a fragile, yet strong, friendship began to grow.
The lies could not last. A social worker made an unscheduled visit, causing a desperate scramble by the girls to keep up the illusion. The freezer finally broke down, forcing them to face the reality of Louise's body. They tried to bury her in the backyard, a physically and emotionally draining task that pushed them to their limits. During this struggle, Mrs. Benson almost discovered them. The weight of their secret, along with the physical and emotional toll, made it clear their time was running out.
Overwhelmed and exhausted, Stella and Angel could no longer keep their deception. The truth about Louise's death and their actions came out. While the details of their confession and the immediate aftermath are difficult, it marked a turning point. They faced the consequences, but the relief of no longer carrying the secret was clear. Authorities became involved, and the girls' stories were heard. Despite the uncertain future, their shared experience had created an unbreakable bond, and they faced what was next together, no longer alone.
The Protagonist
Stella learns to embrace spontaneity and the value of human connection over strict routine, discovering that family can be found in unexpected places.
The Protagonist
Angel learns to trust and open herself to others, finding a sense of family and belonging she never thought possible.
The Supporting (catalyst for plot)
Her death catalyzes the main plot and the girls' character development, even though she is not present for most of it.
The Supporting
Remains largely static, serving as an external plot device to increase tension.
The Mentioned
Does not have an arc within the story, but her influence drives Stella's initial motivations.
The novel shows that family is not only about blood, but about shared experiences, loyalty, and love. Stella initially holds onto the idea of her unreliable mother as her 'real' family, while Angel wants any stable home. Through their desperate partnership after Louise's death, they form a bond stronger than any they've known, creating their own makeshift family. This is clear when they protect each other and share vulnerabilities, leading to their shared desire to stay together, regardless of blood ties.
“Maybe family wasn't about who you were related to, but who you chose to be with, especially when things got tough.”
The girls' extreme reaction to Louise's death—hiding her body and pretending she's alive—is a clear sign of unacknowledged grief and fear. They do not process their loss in a healthy way, instead putting their emotions into a desperate attempt to keep their uncertain lives going. The gypsy moth invasion, with its destruction, acts as a metaphor for the hidden grief and decay inside the house. Only when the truth comes out can they truly mourn Louise and heal.
“It was like the whole world was rotting around them, just like the secret in their basement.”
Stella's world is based on routine and the stability Louise provided. Louise's sudden death shatters this, forcing Stella to face life's unpredictability. Angel's foster care background already highlights this theme, as her life has been a series of unstable placements. Together, they learn that true stability comes not from outside circumstances, but from inner strength and the support of others, even when those others were initially unwanted companions.
“Stella had always thought a plan meant everything would be okay. Now she knew plans could fall apart, just like everything else.”
The central plot involves Stella and Angel's elaborate plan to hide Louise's death. This act, born of fear, forces them into a world of lies and constant vigilance. While it initially helps them survive, it also isolates them and prevents them from grieving. The pressure of maintaining the secret, dwindling resources, and external threats (like Mrs. Benson) show that deception cannot last. Ultimately, revealing the truth, though painful, is a necessary step towards freedom and healing.
“The secret felt like another person living in the house, heavier than any ghost.”
A natural disaster mirroring the internal chaos and decay.
The gypsy moth invasion serves as a powerful extended metaphor. The caterpillars' relentless defoliation of the trees around Louise's house mirrors the hidden decay and chaos within, specifically the secret of Louise's death and the girls' unaddressed grief. The constant rain of caterpillar droppings and the stripped trees create an atmosphere of dread and exposure, reflecting the girls' increasing vulnerability and the sense that their secret is slowly being consumed and revealed. It also acts as an external stressor, further isolating them from the outside world.
A grim repository of their secret and a symbol of their desperation.
The freezer in the basement, where Stella and Angel place Louise's body, is a potent symbol of their desperate act and the chilling reality of their deception. It represents their attempt to freeze time and prevent the inevitable consequences of Louise's death. As the summer progresses and the freezer starts to fail, it becomes a ticking time bomb, physically threatening to expose their secret and adding immense pressure to their already strained situation. Its eventual breakdown forces them to confront the grim truth more directly.
A setting that transforms from a haven to a prison.
Louise's old house on Cape Cod initially represents a haven of stability and routine for Stella, and a temporary refuge for Angel. After Louise's death, however, it transforms into a kind of prison. While it provides shelter and allows them to maintain their secret, it also becomes a place of isolation, fear, and mounting pressure. The house, once a symbol of comfort, becomes a constant reminder of their deception and the grim reality they are trying to hide, trapping them within its walls.
“The thing about being brave is it doesn't mean you're not scared. It means you're scared, but you do it anyway.”
— Stella's advice to Angel on facing fears.
“Sometimes you have to let go of the things you're holding on to so tightly, even if you think they're the only things keeping you safe.”
— Angel reflecting on her grandmother's wisdom about change.
“A secret shared isn't a secret anymore. It's a connection.”
— Angel realizing the power of sharing her past with Stella.
“Home isn't a place. It's the people you're with.”
— Angel's evolving understanding of what home means.
“Grief is like a big wave. It comes and goes, and sometimes it knocks you down, but you always get back up.”
— Stella comforting Angel about her loss.
“You can't choose your family, but you can choose who you let into your heart.”
— Angel thinking about her relationship with Stella and others.
“Sometimes the most important things are the ones you can't see, like trust and hope.”
— Angel pondering the unseen bonds and feelings.
“Being alone isn't the same as being lonely.”
— Angel learning to appreciate solitude and her own company.
“The world keeps turning, even when you feel like yours has stopped.”
— Angel grappling with the continuity of life after a major change.
“It's okay to not be okay. What's not okay is pretending you are.”
— A subtle message about authenticity and vulnerability.
“Sometimes the best way to help someone is just to be there.”
— Stella's quiet support for Angel during difficult times.
“Every ending is a new beginning, even if it doesn't feel like it at the time.”
— Angel coming to terms with the end of her summer and the start of a new life.
“You can't fix everything, but you can always try to make things a little bit better.”
— Angel and Stella's efforts to help the gypsy moths and each other.
“The strongest people aren't the ones who never cry, but the ones who cry and keep going.”
— Angel's internal monologue about resilience.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.

Dan Gemeinhart
4.5

Kate O'Hearn
4.4

Jeanne Birdsall
4.4

Jen Wang
4.4

Wendelin Van Draanen
4.3

John Marsden
4.3

Chris Van Allsburg
4.3

Jennifer A. Nielsen
4.2