“There’s a kind of terrible freedom in being a stranger in a strange land. No one knows your past, no one expects anything of you.”
— Lucy contemplating her new life in America after leaving England.
Archivist's Choice
State of the Union
Douglas Kennedy (2005)
Genre
Historical Fiction / Romance
Reading Time
1500 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
A woman who trades her bohemian 60s upbringing for a conventional life in Maine finds her carefully constructed world shattered when a long-buried transgression from her past resurfaces, forcing her to confront the rebellious spirit she thought she'd escaped.
Synopsis
Hannah Buchan, raised by radical counterculture parents in the 1960s, seeks a conventional life, marrying and settling in Maine. Despite her efforts, she feels unfulfilled by the normalcy she craved. A chance encounter in Washington D.C. leads her into an exhilarating but dangerous affair with a prominent political figure. This shatters her carefully constructed life, forcing her to live a double life that eventually implodes. After the affair's inevitable end, Hannah buries the secret, resuming a seemingly ordinary existence for decades. However, the past resurfaces when her former lover publishes a memoir, exposing their relationship. Hannah's life is thrown into disarray as she faces public scrutiny and personal fallout, forcing her to confront the truth of her choices and redefine her life.
Reading time
1500 min
Difficulty
Medium
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Introspective, Romantic, Dramatic, Melancholy
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy sweeping historical romances about women breaking free from societal expectations and the long-term consequences of secret affairs.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer fast-paced thrillers or stories without significant focus on marital infidelity.
Plot Summary
A Childhood in the Counterculture
Hannah Buchan grows up in the chaotic world of 1960s and 70s America, the daughter of celebrated radical painter Martha Buchan and prominent activist George Buchan. Their home is a center for artists, activists, and thinkers, filled with political discussions, artistic projects, and little conventional structure. Young Hannah, despite being in this free-spirited environment, often feels like an outsider. She yearns for the stability her parents reject. She watches their passionate, sometimes tumultuous, relationship and their constantly changing bohemian lifestyle, which creates in her a deep desire for a different life.
Seeking Normalcy: Marriage and Maine
Rebelling against her parents' radical ideals, Hannah chooses a conventional path. She meets Robert 'Rob' Miller, a stable, traditional engineer with a steady job and a desire for a quiet life. They marry and move to a conservative town in Maine, far from her youth's bohemian circles. Hannah embraces domesticity, raising their two children, Sarah and David. She tries to build the 'normal' family life she always wanted, believing she has escaped her unconventional upbringing. However, a sense of unfulfillment begins to stir beneath the surface.
The Cracks in the Facade
Years into her marriage with Rob, Hannah feels increasingly stifled by the routines and expectations of her suburban life. Rob, a good provider, is emotionally distant and resists change, often dismissing her intellectual and creative interests. The small-town mentality and lack of stimulating engagement leave Hannah feeling isolated and restless. She dedicates herself to her children, Sarah and David, but the absence of passion and intellectual connection in her marriage becomes a growing source of quiet despair. The 'normalcy' she sought now feels like a cage.
A Chance Encounter in Washington D.C.
Hannah attends a conference in Washington D.C. for a local community initiative, a rare escape from her routine. There, she unexpectedly meets David 'Dave' Armstrong, a charismatic and intelligent man she briefly knew from her parents' circle in her youth. Dave, now a successful journalist and political commentator, embodies the passionate, engaged world she had left behind. Their reunion sparks an immediate, undeniable connection, reigniting parts of Hannah's personality that had long been dormant under her conventional life. He represents a world of ideas and excitement she deeply misses.
The Affair Begins
The connection between Hannah and Dave quickly intensifies. What begins as intellectual camaraderie soon becomes a passionate affair. They meet secretly in Washington D.C. whenever Hannah can create an excuse to leave Maine, or when Dave's work brings him closer. These stolen moments contrast sharply with her life with Rob, filled with intense conversations, shared laughter, and deep intimacy. Dave sees and appreciates the real Hannah, not just the wife and mother. For the first time in years, Hannah feels truly alive, desired, and intellectually stimulated. This affair, however, carries immense risk and guilt.
A Life Divided
For months, Hannah lives a double life, meticulously planning her secret meetings with Dave while maintaining the facade of her conventional marriage and motherhood in Maine. The emotional strain is immense. She feels exhilarating highs with Dave, understood and cherished, but is plagued by guilt and anxiety upon returning to her family. The stark contrast between the two worlds makes her everyday life with Rob feel even more hollow and suffocating. She grapples with the morality of her actions, her love for her children, and her deep longing for a life that includes both passion and stability.
The Inevitable End
The secret nature of the affair becomes unsustainable. The pressure mounts, and both Hannah and Dave realize they cannot continue indefinitely in this secrecy. Dave, who is also married, pushes for a more permanent future together, asking Hannah to leave Rob. This ultimatum forces Hannah to confront the full implications of her actions. Torn between her deep love for her children, the comfort of her established life, and the intoxicating passion she shares with Dave, she faces an agonizing decision that will irrevocably alter her future. The fear of shattering her family and the potential public scandal weighs heavily on her.
A Choice Made, a Secret Buried
After immense internal turmoil, Hannah makes the excruciating decision to end the affair with Dave. She cannot bring herself to dismantle her family, especially for her children, Sarah and David. She returns to Maine, recommitting herself to her marriage with Rob and her role as a mother, though with a profound sense of loss and unresolved longing. The affair becomes a tightly guarded secret, a hidden chapter in her life, buried deep beneath layers of conventionality. She tries to move on, convincing herself that she made the right choice for her family, but the memory of Dave and their shared passion lingers.
Decades Later: A Life Resumed
Decades pass. Hannah and Rob's children grow up and leave home. Hannah continues her life in Maine, maintaining the appearance of a stable, if unexciting, marriage. She finds solace in small community activities and her relationships with her now-adult children. The affair with Dave Armstrong becomes a distant memory, a ghost from a past life, rarely thought of and never spoken. She believes she has successfully compartmentalized that intense period, living a life of quiet respectability, having seemingly escaped any consequences of her past transgression. Her parents, Martha and George, have also aged, their radical fire dimming somewhat with time.
The Past Resurfaces: Dave Armstrong's Memoir
Hannah's carefully constructed peace is shattered when she learns that Dave Armstrong, now a highly acclaimed and controversial public figure, is publishing a tell-all memoir. As excerpts begin to leak, it becomes terrifyingly clear that the book will detail his passionate affair with a married woman from Maine, thinly veiled but undeniably recognizable. The specific details, the timing, and the emotional resonance within the text leave Hannah in a state of panic. The secret she has guarded for decades, the one transgression in her otherwise 'faultless' life, is about to be dragged into the public spotlight, threatening to destroy everything she has built.
Public Outcry and Personal Fallout
Upon the memoir's release, the media frenzy is immediate and intense. While Hannah is not named directly, the clues are strong enough for local and national media to begin piecing together her identity. Her quiet life in Maine is invaded by reporters, paparazzi, and public scrutiny. Her husband, Rob, her children, Sarah and David, and her parents are all caught in the crossfire, grappling with the shocking revelation. Hannah faces their anger, confusion, and betrayal, as her carefully constructed image of respectability crumbles around her. She is forced to confront the consequences of her past actions, not just for herself, but for everyone she loves.
Confronting the Truth
With her secret exposed, Hannah has no choice but to confront her family directly. She must explain her motivations, her longings, and the choices she made decades ago. This painful process forces her to revisit her past, her relationship with her parents, her marriage to Rob, and her own identity. She grapples with the judgment of others, the pain she has caused, and her own lingering feelings about Dave Armstrong. The public scandal and personal reckonings push Hannah to finally reconcile the different versions of herself — the radical child, the conventional wife, and the passionate woman who dared to transgress.
The Aftermath and Redefinition
In the aftermath of the memoir's publication and the ensuing chaos, Hannah's life is in freefall. Her marriage to Rob is severely strained, her relationships with her children are tested, and her public image is shattered. She experiences intense emotional pain and public humiliation. However, this crisis also becomes an unexpected catalyst for self-discovery. Stripped of her carefully maintained facade, Hannah begins to re-evaluate her life, her choices, and her true desires. She must decide how to move forward, whether to try and salvage what remains, or to forge an entirely new identity in the face of her exposed past. She grapples with forgiveness — both from others and for herself.
Principal Figures
Hannah Buchan Miller
The Protagonist
Hannah evolves from a woman defined by others' expectations to one who must confront her true self and reconcile her past and present identities.
David 'Dave' Armstrong
The Supporting/Catalyst
Dave remains largely static, driven by his ambition and desire to tell his story, acting as a catalyst for Hannah's forced self-reckoning.
Robert 'Rob' Miller
The Supporting
Rob is forced to confront the hidden aspects of his wife's life and the truth of their marriage, leading to a re-evaluation of his own rigidity.
Martha Buchan
The Supporting
Martha's character remains largely consistent, representing the unyielding force of Hannah's past and the ideals she rejected.
George Buchan
The Supporting
George's character remains largely consistent, representing the intellectual and political legacy Hannah attempts to outrun.
Sarah Miller
The Supporting
Sarah is forced to re-evaluate her understanding of her mother and her family history, leading to a more complex view of her parents.
David Miller
The Supporting
David is forced to grapple with the unexpected complexities of his mother's past and the stability of his family.
Themes & Insights
The Search for Identity and Self-Fulfillment
Hannah's life is a constant negotiation between who she is expected to be and who she truly desires to be. She initially defines herself in opposition to her radical parents, seeking a conventional identity. However, this 'normalcy' ultimately stifles her, leading to deep unfulfillment. Her affair with Dave Armstrong is not just about infidelity but about reclaiming a lost part of her intellectual and passionate self. The exposure of her secret forces her to confront her various identities and integrate them into a more authentic whole, moving beyond societal expectations. This is clear when she realizes her 'faultless' life was also a hollow one.
“''She had spent her entire adult life trying to be ordinary, and now, standing on the precipice of exposure, she realized how desperately she had failed to truly live.''”
The Consequences of Choice and Secrecy
The novel explores the far-reaching effects of choices made in haste or passion, and the corrosive nature of keeping deep secrets. Hannah's decision to have an affair and then bury it shapes decades of her life, creating a fragile facade. The eventual exposure of this secret shows that the past is never truly buried; it always resurfaces. The consequences are not just for Hannah, but for her husband, children, and parents, highlighting how individual actions can dismantle entire family structures and public images. The book emphasizes that avoiding immediate pain often leads to greater suffering later.
“''The past, she understood now, was not a closed book but a palimpsest, with old stories always threatening to bleed through the new.''”
Rebellion and Conformity
The tension between rebellion and conformity is central to Hannah's character arc. She grows up in a household that actively rebels against societal norms, pushing her to conform to them. Her marriage to Rob and move to Maine is a direct rebellion against her parents' lifestyle. However, this act of conformity itself becomes a form of rebellion against her own desires, leading to a different kind of entrapment. The affair with Dave is a rebellion against her conventional life, a return to a more passionate, albeit dangerous, form of nonconformity. The novel suggests that true freedom is not in blindly following or rejecting norms, but in authentic self-expression.
“''She had sought normalcy as an antidote to chaos, but had found, instead, a different kind of quiet desperation.''”
The Nature of Love and Marriage
The novel explores the complexities of love and marriage, contrasting different forms of connection. Hannah's marriage to Rob is built on stability, companionship, and shared responsibilities, but lacks emotional and intellectual intimacy. Her affair with Dave, in contrast, is characterized by intense passion, intellectual rapport, and a feeling of being truly seen. The story questions whether one form of love is inherently superior or more 'real' than the other. It explores the idea that long-term marriages can wither without continuous emotional nourishment, and that passion, while intoxicating, can also be destructive. Ultimately, it forces characters to redefine what marriage means to them after betrayal.
“''Love, she realized, could be a quiet, enduring river or a raging, destructive torrent, but both could carve indelible marks.''”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The Tell-All Memoir
A published book that exposes a long-held secret.
Dave Armstrong's memoir serves as the primary catalyst for the story's climax and resolution. It functions as the external force that shatters Hannah's carefully constructed world and forces her to confront her past. This device creates immediate conflict, public exposure, and personal reckoning. Without the memoir, Hannah's secret would likely remain buried, and she would continue living a life of quiet desperation. It is a powerful symbol of the past's inescapable grip and the public nature of personal transgressions when involving public figures.
Flashbacks and Retrospection
Narrative technique that reveals past events and motivations.
The story employs flashbacks and Hannah's internal retrospection to reveal her radical upbringing, her reasons for seeking a conventional life, and the details of her affair with Dave. These moments provide crucial context for her present-day actions and emotional state. They allow the reader to understand the motivations behind her choices, build empathy for her struggles, and gradually uncover the layers of her hidden past, making the eventual exposure of the secret more impactful. It's how the reader comes to understand the 'why' behind her actions.
The Contrasting Settings (New York/D.C. vs. Maine)
Geographical locations that symbolize different lifestyles and values.
The novel uses the contrasting settings of the vibrant, intellectual, and radical environments of 1960s New York (Hannah's childhood) and Washington D.C. (her affair) against the quiet, conservative, and conventional backdrop of Maine (her married life). These settings are more than just locations; they represent different ideologies, lifestyles, and versions of Hannah herself. Maine symbolizes the 'normalcy' she sought but also the emotional stagnation she experienced, while New York/D.C. represents the passion, intellect, and freedom she yearned for. This contrast highlights her internal conflict and the two disparate halves of her existence.
The Unreliable Narrator (Subtle)
Hannah's subjective telling of her own story, influenced by guilt and desire.
While not overtly unreliable, Hannah's narrative is subtly shaped by her own guilt, longing, and desire to justify her choices. Her internal monologue often reflects her struggle to reconcile her actions with her self-image. The reader experiences the story primarily through her perspective, which means her husband Rob and lover Dave are often filtered through her perceptions and biases. This allows for a deeper exploration of her psychology but also encourages the reader to question her self-assessments and the full truth of situations, particularly regarding her feelings about her marriage and the affair.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“America was a land of constant reinvention, a place where you could shed your old skin and try on a new one. Or so she hoped.”
— Lucy reflecting on the American dream and her own aspirations.
“The war had changed everything, not just the men who fought it, but the women who waited, and the country itself.”
— A general observation on the impact of World War II.
“Love, she was learning, wasn't a static thing, but a living, breathing entity that needed constant tending, or it would wither.”
— Lucy's evolving understanding of her relationship with Thomas.
“He carried the war within him, a silent, invisible wound that never truly healed.”
— Describing Thomas's lingering trauma from his time in combat.
“There was a certain intoxicating thrill in defying expectations, in stepping outside the narrow confines of what was considered 'proper'.”
— Lucy's burgeoning sense of independence and rebellion.
“The past was a relentless companion, always at your heels, no matter how fast you ran.”
— Lucy realizing she cannot fully escape her history.
“Happiness, she decided, was often a fleeting moment, best savored when it arrived, for it never stayed long.”
— Lucy's philosophical take on the nature of happiness.
“The greatest battles, she found, were often fought not on battlefields, but within the quiet confines of one's own heart.”
— Lucy reflecting on her internal struggles and moral dilemmas.
“To truly know someone, you had to see them not just in their triumphs, but in their vulnerabilities, in their flaws.”
— Lucy's growing intimacy and understanding of Thomas.
“Sometimes, the most courageous act was simply to keep going, even when every fiber of your being wanted to stop.”
— Lucy's resilience in the face of adversity.
“The landscape of a marriage was ever-shifting, a constant negotiation between two separate souls trying to forge a single path.”
— A mature observation on the complexities of married life.
“The future was an unwritten page, terrifying and exhilarating in equal measure.”
— Lucy's outlook on the uncertainties and possibilities ahead.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
Hannah Buchan struggles with her identity, feeling ordinary and rejecting the radical, liberal lifestyle of her famous painter mother and activist father. She actively seeks a conventional, 'normal' family life in Maine, a direct contrast to her unconventional upbringing in 1960s America.
About the author
Douglas Kennedy is an American-born French novelist and journalist, celebrated for his incisive explorations of contemporary American society and the human condition. His notable works, including 'The Big Picture,' 'State of the Union,' and 'The Pursuit of Happiness,' often delve into themes of ambition, love, and disillusionment with a sharp, accessible style. Kennedy's writing has garnered international acclaim, solidifying his reputation as a keen observer of modern life.
