“The only thing worse than being alone is being with someone who makes you feel alone.”
— Macy reflects on her relationship with Brody.

Lisi Harrison (2004)
Genre
Children's / Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
150 min
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
To keep their secret clubroom and maintain their top spot, the Pretty Committee navigates dating, costumes, and boy-brains, using newfound 'ESP' to understand crushes and protect their popularity.
Massie Block, leader of the Pretty Committee (PC), learns about a secret room at Octavian Country Day (OCD) school, called 'The Chill Room.' To earn access, the PC must prove themselves by finding dates for Skye Hamilton's 'Famous Couples' costume party. Massie also needs to convince her former crush, Chris Abeley, to be Skye's date, or they will lose their chance at the room and their popularity. This task makes Massie feel overwhelmed, wondering how to get dates for all PC members and arrange a match between Chris and Skye, all for a secret room.
As Massie worries about the dating problem, the Pretty Committee finds a secret weapon they call 'ESP' (Extra-Sensory Perception). This is not a superpower, but a hidden source of information that reveals how boys think, what they like, and their secret preferences. The girls believe 'ESP' will give them an advantage in finding perfect dates for Skye's party and navigating middle school romance. They decide to test 'ESP,' hoping it will solve their dating issues and help them get into the Chill Room.
Kristen Gregory, a PC member, is happy when 'ESP' identifies a sensitive guy who loves romantic movies, matching her ideal. She focuses on him, imagining a perfect romantic match for the party. However, her excitement fades when she is assigned the 'Bride of Chucky' costume for Skye's 'Famous Couples' party. The contrast between her romantic ideal and the horror costume creates a problem for Kristen, making her wonder how to attract her sensitive crush while dressed as a scary doll.
Alicia Rivera, another PC member, had previously ignored her crush, Josh Hotz, because his room was too clean. But 'ESP' reveals a key detail: it is not Josh who is neat, but his sister. This changes Alicia's view of Josh, making him seem more attractive. With the misunderstanding cleared, Alicia's interest in 'hawt Hotz' returns, and she starts planning how to ask him to the party, now seeing him in a better light.
Dylan Marvil, known for her strict dieting and Jenny Craig past, gets a surprising insight from 'ESP': boys like girls who are not afraid to eat. Encouraged, Dylan stops her restrictive eating and enjoys foods she avoided, especially mozzarella sticks. While she likes the freedom, her new appetite leads to her gaining six pounds. This weight gain causes doubt and regret, making her question if trusting 'ESP' was the right choice, especially when her body image is so important to her.
Claire Lyons, the only Pretty Committee member with a steady boyfriend, Cam, initially thinks finding a date for the party will be easy. However, her own 'ESP,' which she calls 'Claire-voyance,' starts giving her unsettling clues. She senses that Cam is keeping a significant secret from her. Despite his usual sweet gestures, like giving her gummies, the suspicion clouds their relationship, making his gifts taste 'stale.' Claire becomes determined to uncover Cam's secret, fearing it could harm their seemingly stable relationship.
With insights from 'ESP,' the Pretty Committee begins their mission to find dates for Skye's party. Massie tries to get Chris Abeley to be Skye's date, dealing with his hesitation and Skye's own wishes. Kristen tries to charm her sensitive crush despite her Bride of Chucky costume. Alicia approaches Josh Hotz, now knowing the truth about his room. Dylan, despite her weight gain, tries to appear confident in her new eating habits. The girls' efforts, guided by 'ESP,' lead to humorous, awkward, and sometimes successful interactions as they try to match their new 'knowledge' with reality.
Driven by her 'Claire-voyance' and growing suspicion, Claire confronts Cam about his secretive behavior. After some questioning, Cam finally reveals his secret: he has been secretly taking dance lessons to surprise Claire with a special performance at the party. He was embarrassed and wanted it to be perfect, which is why he kept it secret. This revelation clears up the misunderstanding, turning Claire's worry into relief and affection, strengthening their relationship and reminding her that not all secrets are bad.
The night of Skye Hamilton's 'Famous Couples' costume party arrives. The Pretty Committee, with their dates, make their entrance, dressed as various iconic pairs. Massie continues her efforts to ensure Chris and Skye appear as a couple. Kristen, despite her costume, tries to charm her sensitive guy. Alicia and Josh navigate their renewed attraction, while Dylan tries to feel comfortable in her own skin. Claire and Cam enjoy their reconciled relationship, happy that his secret was a pleasant one. The party is the result of their 'ESP'-guided efforts, with varying success and social drama.
After the party, the Pretty Committee thinks about their experiences with 'ESP' and how their date-finding mission turned out. While 'ESP' offered insights, they realize that human emotions and personalities are more complex than any 'secret weapon' can predict. Despite the challenges, they succeed in finding dates and impressing Skye. As a result, they get access to the 'Chill Room' at OCD, solidifying their top status, but also gaining a deeper understanding of friendship, boys, and the unpredictable nature of middle school life.
The Protagonist
Massie learns that while manipulation can achieve short-term goals, genuine connection and understanding are more valuable for long-term satisfaction.
The Supporting
Kristen learns that external appearances (like a costume) don't define her ability to connect with someone, and true attraction goes beyond superficial details.
The Supporting
Alicia learns not to judge people based on superficial details or assumptions, discovering that deeper truths can reveal unexpected attractions.
The Supporting
Dylan confronts her insecurities about body image, learning to trust her instincts and find confidence regardless of societal expectations or temporary weight fluctuations.
The Supporting
Claire learns the importance of communication in a relationship, discovering that perceived secrets can often be innocent and easily resolved through open dialogue.
The Supporting
Cam's arc involves revealing his secret, demonstrating that his intentions are always loving, and reinforcing the trust in his relationship with Claire.
The Supporting
Chris is a static character, primarily serving as a romantic foil and a target for Massie's matchmaking schemes.
The Supporting
Skye serves primarily as a plot catalyst, her party being the main event that drives the Pretty Committee's actions and challenges.
The Supporting
Josh's arc is passive, as he is the object of Alicia's affection and the subject of a misunderstanding that is resolved through 'ESP'.
The Pretty Committee's actions center on keeping and improving their social status. Access to the secret 'Chill Room' is the ultimate sign of top status at OCD, driving Massie's efforts. The girls' attempts to find perfect dates for Skye's party are not just about romance, but about proving their worth and keeping their place at the top of the social ladder. This theme is clear in Massie's manipulation of Chris and Skye, and the other girls' worries about their dates and appearances, all to stay 'in' with the clique.
“The Clique...The only thing harder than getting in is staying in.”
A main theme is the difference between how things look and how they really are. 'ESP' is meant to reveal hidden truths about boys, but the girls often misinterpret or are misled by initial views. Alicia dismisses Josh Hotz for his clean room, only to learn his sister is the neat one. Claire's 'Claire-voyance' makes her believe Cam is hiding something bad, when he is planning a sweet surprise. This theme highlights the risks of judging based on appearances and the importance of looking beyond first impressions to understand people and situations better.
“Extra Sucky Problem is more like it.”
Dylan Marvil's story directly addresses the pressures of body image and the struggle for self-acceptance among young girls. Her past with Jenny Craig and her quick willingness to change her eating habits based on 'ESP' (that boys like girls who eat) shows how external influences affect her self-perception. Her subsequent six-pound weight gain and regret highlight the internal conflict between societal beauty ideals and personal comfort. The theme suggests a journey toward finding self-confidence, rather than relying on external approval or changing trends.
“Will gaining six pounds make her regret trusting her sixth sense?”
The book explores the complex and often confusing nature of middle school relationships, both romantic and friendly. The Pretty Committee's interactions, despite their top status, include manipulation, insecurity, and real moments of friendship. The romantic plots, from Kristen's idealization of a sensitive guy to Claire's worries about Cam's secret, show the challenges of communication, trust, and understanding. The story suggests that relationships are rarely simple and need more than just 'ESP' to navigate successfully.
“How will she ever get her girls suitable dates and melt Chris's heart? She'd need to be a mind reader!”
A coveted, exclusive space representing ultimate social status.
The Chill Room at OCD functions as the primary MacGuffin of the story. Its existence sets the entire plot in motion, as Massie and the Pretty Committee are desperate to gain access. It symbolizes the pinnacle of social power and exclusivity within the school's hierarchy. The quest to earn the right to use this room drives the girls' actions, decisions, and challenges, providing a tangible goal that unites their individual romantic endeavors under a larger, collective ambition for social dominance.
A metaphorical 'secret weapon' providing insights into boys' minds.
The 'ESP' device is a clever narrative conceit. It's not actual psychic power but a metaphorical representation of a supposed 'secret weapon' or system that gives the Pretty Committee insights into what boys think and like. It functions as a catalyst for each girl's individual subplot, guiding their romantic choices and actions. It's a humorous and ironic commentary on the girls' attempts to 'decode' boys, ultimately highlighting that relationships are too complex for any simple formula or 'cheat sheet,' often leading to unexpected or comical results.
A social event serving as the central setting and catalyst for character interactions.
Skye Hamilton's 'Famous Couples' costume party is the pivotal setting and event around which the entire plot revolves. It serves as the deadline for the Pretty Committee's date-finding mission and the ultimate test of their 'ESP' insights. The costume theme itself adds an element of irony and humor, as the girls attempt to embody ideal couples while navigating their own messy romantic realities. The party acts as a crucible where all the individual storylines converge, leading to confrontations, resolutions, and the final assessment of their social success.
“The only thing worse than being alone is being with someone who makes you feel alone.”
— Macy reflects on her relationship with Brody.
“Sometimes you have to break your own heart to save it.”
— Macy makes a difficult decision about her feelings.
“Being popular is like being rich. Everyone wants to be it, but no one really knows what it's like until they are.”
— Macy observes the social dynamics at school.
“Maybe love isn't about finding the perfect person, but about seeing an imperfect person perfectly.”
— Macy contemplates her feelings for a new boy.
“The truth is like a good outfit. It might not always be comfortable, but it always fits.”
— Macy struggles with revealing a secret.
“Friendship isn't about who you've known the longest, it's about who walked into your life, said 'I'm here for you,' and proved it.”
— Macy realizes the value of a new friend.
“You can't erase the past, but you can definitely learn to draw a better future.”
— Macy thinks about moving on from past mistakes.
“Sometimes the biggest risks lead to the biggest rewards, especially when it comes to your heart.”
— Macy considers taking a chance on a new romance.
“Secrets are like glitter. No matter how hard you try to clean them up, a few always remain.”
— Macy deals with the aftermath of a revealed secret.
“It's easy to pretend everything is fine, but it takes courage to admit it's not.”
— Macy confronts her own feelings of unhappiness.
“The best kind of goodbye is the one where you know you'll see them again, even if it's just in your memories.”
— Macy reflects on a difficult farewell.
“Being yourself is the most powerful thing you can ever be. And also the scariest.”
— Macy struggles with authenticity in her social circle.
“Sometimes the person you're looking for is the one who's been right in front of you all along.”
— Macy has an epiphany about a potential love interest.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.

Dan Gemeinhart
4.5

Kate O'Hearn
4.4

Jeanne Birdsall
4.4

Jen Wang
4.4

Wendelin Van Draanen
4.3

John Marsden
4.3

Chris Van Allsburg
4.3

Jennifer A. Nielsen
4.2