Sarah Dessen (2015)
Genre
Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
8-10 hours
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
After her charismatic but troubled brother's drunk-driving accident lands him in jail, an invisible Sydney finds her voice and a sense of belonging within the warm, chaotic embrace of a new family and the quiet gaze of Mac, who finally sees her for who she truly is.
Sydney Stanford begins her junior year at Jackson High, a public school, after being pulled from her private school, Perkins Day, due to her brother Peyton's legal troubles. Peyton, charismatic but troubled, is in jail for a drunk-driving accident that severely injured a boy named David Ibarra. Sydney feels invisible and constantly overshadowed by Peyton's reputation, both good and bad. Her parents are consumed by Peyton's situation, often neglecting Sydney's needs. She struggles to fit in at Jackson, feeling like an outsider, and finds herself seeking refuge in a local pizza place, unaware that this act will soon change her life.
While at a local pizza place called the 'Chatham's', Sydney meets Layla Chatham, a friendly girl who works there. Layla immediately takes a liking to Sydney, inviting her into their chaotic but warm family. Sydney is initially hesitant, still burdened by her family's issues and her own feelings of inadequacy. However, Layla's genuine kindness and the lively atmosphere of the Chatham's pizza place, which is run by Layla's family, offer Sydney a welcome distraction from her home life. This initial encounter is the beginning of Sydney's gradual integration into a community that sees her for who she is, not just as Peyton's sister.
Sydney becomes a regular at Chatham's, drawn in by Layla and her family. She quickly notices Mac Chatham, Layla's older brother, who is quiet, observant, and works at the pizza place. Unlike the superficial interactions she's used to, Mac genuinely sees Sydney, engaging her in thoughtful conversations and offering her a sense of calm and understanding. Their connection deepens over shared shifts and late-night talks, as Sydney finds herself opening up to Mac in ways she hasn't with anyone else. Mac's steady presence and attention make Sydney feel truly seen and valued, creating a budding romantic interest.
Sydney learns about Rosie, another member of the Chatham family who lives with them. Rosie has a past that includes a period of estrangement from her family and a difficult relationship, leading her to feel like an outcast. Sydney empathizes with Rosie, recognizing similar feelings of being misunderstood and judged, though for different reasons. Rosie's story helps Sydney understand that everyone carries burdens and that acceptance often comes from shared vulnerability. Their growing bond provides Sydney with another source of support and a sense of not being alone in her struggles, further solidifying her place within the Chatham family.
Peyton's phone calls from jail are a constant source of tension and emotional drain for Sydney's family. Her mother remains deeply invested in Peyton's well-being, often dropping everything to cater to his demands or anxieties. Sydney finds these calls difficult, as they remind her of the accident, David Ibarra's suffering, and her own feelings of neglect. She struggles with her conflicting emotions towards Peyton—love for her brother, but also resentment for the chaos he has brought into their lives. The calls worsen the existing family strain, making it harder for Sydney to find peace at home.
Layla convinces Sydney to attend the Jackson High school dance. Though initially reluctant, Sydney decides to go, hoping to experience a normal teenage event. At the dance, Sydney meets June, a quirky and kind girl who also works at Chatham's. June's outgoing personality and genuine interest in Sydney help her feel more comfortable and accepted at school. This experience, along with Layla's steady friendship, is a turning point for Sydney. She realizes that she can form new connections and find her own place, separate from her brother's shadow, and slowly starts to shed her invisible persona.
As Sydney's perspective broadens, she begins to critically examine Peyton's actions and the story her parents have created around his 'mistake.' She seeks out information about David Ibarra, the boy Peyton injured, and is deeply affected by the true extent of his suffering. This confrontation with reality forces Sydney to acknowledge the severity of Peyton's choices and the lasting consequences. She realizes that her parents' protective stance has prevented them from fully facing the truth, and this realization creates a rift between her and their denial, strengthening her resolve to seek her own truth and justice.
Sydney and Mac's connection grows into a deeper, more romantic relationship. Mac's quiet strength, understanding nature, and genuine affection provide Sydney with a safe haven amidst the turmoil of her family life. He encourages her to express her feelings and helps her see her own worth, independent of Peyton. Their shared moments, whether working at Chatham's or simply talking, become invaluable to Sydney. This relationship is important for Sydney's self-discovery, as it's the first time she feels truly loved and seen for who she is, without the shadow of her brother's past.
Mrs. Chatham, the matriarch of the Chatham family and the heart of the pizza place, becomes a significant figure in Sydney's life. Despite her own declining health, Mrs. Chatham offers Sydney wisdom and unconditional acceptance. She sees Sydney's goodness and helps her navigate her complex emotions, particularly regarding Peyton and her family. Sydney witnesses Mrs. Chatham's resilience and love for her family, which inspires her. However, Mrs. Chatham's increasing illness also brings a sense of impending loss, making Sydney cherish their time together even more and highlighting the fragility of life and relationships.
Empowered by her new friendships and her relationship with Mac, Sydney finally confronts her parents. She expresses her feelings of neglect and the unfairness of their constant focus on Peyton. She challenges their story surrounding Peyton's 'mistake' and expresses her desire for them to acknowledge the full impact of his actions. This confrontation is difficult but necessary for Sydney, as it marks a significant step in her journey of self-advocacy. She asserts her right to be seen and heard, demanding that her parents recognize her as an individual with her own needs and experiences, not just as Peyton's sister.
Peyton is eventually released from jail, and his return home creates a complicated dynamic. While Sydney's parents are overjoyed, Peyton struggles to adjust to life outside, still grappling with his own issues and showing limited remorse for his actions. Sydney finds it difficult to reconcile the brother she loves with the person who caused so much pain. His presence reintroduces tension into the household, and Sydney realizes that while he is physically free, the emotional scars remain, and their family's healing journey is far from over. She continues to navigate her relationship with him, seeking a balance between love and self-preservation.
By the end of the novel, Sydney has grown significantly. She has found her voice, established strong, healthy relationships with the Chathams, and learned to prioritize her own well-being. She makes choices that reflect her newfound independence and self-worth, no longer defined by Peyton's shadow. Her experiences have taught her the importance of empathy, truth, and self-acceptance. Sydney looks forward to a future where she can pursue her own dreams and maintain the genuine connections she has forged, understanding that while family ties are strong, her identity is ultimately her own to shape.
The Protagonist
Sydney transforms from an invisible, self-doubting girl into a confident, self-advocating young woman who finds her own voice and place in the world.
The Antagonist/Catalyst
Peyton remains largely unchanged in terms of accepting full responsibility, serving as a catalyst for Sydney's growth rather than undergoing significant personal transformation himself.
The Love Interest/Supporting
Mac remains a consistent, supportive force, helping Sydney to grow and find her own strength.
The Supporting
Layla remains a steadfast and supportive friend, providing a consistent source of joy and acceptance for Sydney.
The Supporting
Mrs. Chatham's role is primarily to offer wisdom and a stable, loving environment, though her declining health adds a poignant layer to the story.
The Supporting
Rosie offers a parallel narrative of overcoming past mistakes and finding acceptance, providing solidarity for Sydney.
The Supporting
They slowly begin to acknowledge Sydney's feelings and needs, though their primary focus remains on Peyton.
The Mentioned
David's struggle remains off-page, serving as a constant reminder of the consequences of Peyton's actions.
The novel explores Sydney's journey to find her own identity separate from her brother's shadow. Initially, she feels invisible and defined by Peyton's actions, but through her friendships with Layla, Rosie, and her relationship with Mac, she begins to understand her own worth. Her new experiences at Jackson High and Chatham's allow her to develop her own voice, interests, and sense of self, moving from being 'Peyton's sister' to simply 'Sydney.' This is particularly evident when she starts to challenge her parents' narrative about Peyton.
“Maybe it was about the way you saw yourself. Or maybe it was about the way others saw you. And for me, I realized, it was about both.”
The Stanford family is a central focus, showing the complexities of love, loyalty, and enabling behavior. Sydney's parents are so consumed by Peyton's legal troubles and emotional needs that they inadvertently neglect Sydney. The novel portrays how one family member's actions can ripple through the entire unit, causing strain, resentment, and a skewed sense of reality. The contrast with the warm, accepting Chatham family highlights the Stanford's dysfunction and Sydney's longing for a healthier family connection.
“Sometimes, I thought, family was a thing you had to get through, a thing you survived. But other times, it was a thing that held you up, that made you stronger.”
A core theme is Sydney's search for a place where she feels truly accepted and belongs. At home, she feels like an outsider, constantly overshadowed. The Chatham family and their pizza place become her sanctuary, offering unconditional acceptance and a sense of community she's never experienced. Layla, Mac, and Mrs. Chatham see Sydney for her inherent goodness, not for her brother's mistakes. This newfound belonging empowers Sydney to confront her family's issues and embrace her true self.
“It was like the Chathams had a little space for everyone, even for someone like me, who didn't quite know where she fit anymore.”
The novel explores the painful distinction between confronting uncomfortable truths and living in denial. Sydney's parents actively deny the severity of Peyton's actions and the true extent of David Ibarra's injuries, creating a protective but ultimately unhealthy narrative. Sydney's journey involves peeling back these layers of denial, first by seeking information about David and then by directly challenging her parents' perspective. This theme highlights the importance of facing reality, no matter how difficult, for genuine healing and growth.
“I was learning that the truth was not always what you wanted it to be, and sometimes, it was much harder to face than a lie.”
A symbolic safe haven and catalyst for Sydney's growth.
Chatham's, the family-run pizza place, serves as a central hub and a crucial plot device. It acts as a symbolic safe haven for Sydney, a place where she can escape the emotional turmoil of her home life. More importantly, it is the setting where she meets the Chatham family, forging new friendships and her first genuine romantic connection. The warm, chaotic, and accepting atmosphere of Chatham's directly contrasts with the strained environment of Sydney's home, facilitating her personal growth and her journey toward self-discovery and belonging.
The inciting incident that drives the entire narrative.
Peyton's incarceration for drunk driving is the inciting incident that sets the entire plot in motion. It forces Sydney to transfer schools, disrupts her family's dynamics, and isolates her. This event creates the void in Sydney's life that she then fills with the Chatham family. It also serves as the constant backdrop against which Sydney's personal growth is measured, as she grapples with its implications and her family's reaction to it. Without Peyton's actions, Sydney's journey would not have begun.
A recurring internal state reflecting Sydney's feeling of being overlooked.
The motif of Sydney feeling 'invisible' is a persistent internal plot device that guides her actions and reactions throughout the novel. It represents her deep-seated insecurity and the neglect she experiences from her parents. This feeling drives her initial shyness and reluctance to engage, but also fuels her desire to find a place where she is seen and valued. Her journey is largely about shedding this invisibility, culminating in moments where she actively asserts her presence and voice, proving to herself and others that she is anything but invisible.
A symbolic object representing hope and the search for protection.
The 'Saint Anything' charm, which Sydney receives, functions as a symbolic plot device. It represents the hope of finding protection and guidance when facing overwhelming challenges, especially when conventional help feels absent. It also signifies the idea that sometimes, you need to rely on an unknown, generalized source of strength when specific solutions aren't clear. The charm serves as a tangible reminder of her journey and her search for a sense of security and belief in something larger than herself.
“I wondered if that was how it was for all first loves. They were like a well-oiled machine that was suddenly left to rust. It still had all the parts, but it just didn't work anymore.”
— Sydney reflects on her brother Peyton's past relationship and how things change.
“It's like I'm trying to hold on to something that isn't even there anymore. And I know I should just let go. But I can't.”
— Sydney struggles with her feelings about her brother's situation and her family's dynamic.
“Maybe it was the way things always worked. You didn't get to choose everything. You just got to choose what you did with what you got.”
— Sydney considers the limitations and choices in her life.
“The thing about being a younger sibling is that you're always trying to catch up. Always trying to prove yourself.”
— Sydney reflects on her role as the younger sister to Peyton.
“Sometimes, the best way to figure out who you are is to spend time with people who already know.”
— Sydney finds comfort and understanding with Layla and the Chatham family.
“It was just a kiss. But it felt like a promise. A promise that things could be different.”
— Sydney's first kiss with Mac, marking a turning point.
“You can't fix other people. You can only fix yourself.”
— A realization Sydney has about her family's problems and her own agency.
“Everyone had their own definition of normal, and hers had been a little off-kilter for a while now.”
— Sydney feels out of place after her brother's arrest and her family's reaction.
“It's funny how you can live in a house your whole life and still not really know the people in it.”
— Sydney observes the disconnect within her own family.
“Sometimes, the best way to get over someone is to get under someone else. Or, you know, just get on with your life.”
— Layla offers advice to Sydney about moving on.
“Maybe it was okay to not have all the answers. Maybe it was okay to just be, for a little while.”
— Sydney finds peace in the present moment, rather than worrying about the future.
“The hardest part about saying goodbye wasn't the actual goodbye, but the knowledge that you'd never really say hello again.”
— Sydney contemplates the finality of certain endings.
“It was the kind of quiet that meant everything and nothing all at once.”
— Describing a moment of significant silence, often between characters.
“Sometimes, all you needed was a fresh start. A new place. New people. A new chance to be whoever you wanted to be.”
— Sydney considers the possibility of a new beginning.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
Biography coming soon.
