“Sometimes you've gotta work with what you've got.”
— Catherine's mother advises her about dealing with her brother David's autism.
Archivist's Choice
Rules
Cynthia Lord (2006)
Genre
Children's / Young Adult
Reading Time
240 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
When her carefully constructed world of rules for her autistic brother is challenged by new friendships and unexpected crushes, a twelve-year-old girl must redefine what 'normal' truly means.
Synopsis
Twelve-year-old Catherine wants a normal life, which is hard with her autistic younger brother, David, whose behaviors often embarrass her. She makes and enforces 'rules' for David, hoping he will fit in. Her summer changes when she meets Jason, a boy who uses a wheelchair, at David's therapy, and Kristi, a new girl next door. Catherine likes Jason, who communicates with a wordboard. She struggles to balance her desire for a normal friendship with Kristi with her protective feelings and duties toward David. As she navigates new friendships and deals with her family, Catherine thinks about her own biases and what 'normal' means. She learns to see David, Jason, and herself differently, accepting the unique rules and facts of her own life.
Reading time
240 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Heartwarming, Reflective, Hopeful
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy heartwarming middle-grade stories about family, friendship, and understanding differences, with a focus on a sibling's perspective on autism.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer fast-paced adventure stories or books without a strong focus on character development and emotional exploration.
Plot Summary
A Summer of Rules and New Acquaintances
Twelve-year-old Catherine starts her summer making new rules for her autistic younger brother, David, to help him with social situations, like 'A peach is not a funny-looking apple.' Her life centers on David's needs; she often feels embarrassed by his public outbursts and routines. She wants a best friend and a 'normal' life, hoping Kristi, a girl moving in next door, will bring this. Catherine's father works long hours and is often absent. Her mother focuses on David's therapy and care. Catherine also goes to David's occupational therapy, where she meets Jason, a boy who uses a wheelchair and communicates through a book.
Connecting with Jason and Drawing Communication
Catherine is unsure how to talk to Jason at first but soon realizes she can draw pictures in his communication book to represent words, making it easier for him to speak. They connect more as they share jokes and observations. Catherine feels new purpose in helping him. She shows him her drawings, and he likes them. Meanwhile, her friendship with Kristi grows, but Catherine hesitates to say much about David. She fears Kristi's reaction and possible embarrassment, especially after David takes off his pants at a public pool.
Balancing Friendships and Family Secrets
As summer continues, Catherine tries to balance her growing friendship with Kristi with her time with Jason and her duties to David. She feels pulled between wanting to seem 'normal' to Kristi and her real connections with Jason and David. She often makes excuses to Kristi about why she cannot hang out, especially when she is with Jason, or when David's behavior might be an issue. This makes Catherine feel guilty and torn, as she knows she is not being fully honest with Kristi about her life, especially about David's autism and her bond with Jason.
The Dance Dilemma and a Broken Promise
Catherine is happy when Ryan, a popular boy, asks her to the community dance. This feels like a step toward the 'normal' life she wants. However, she has already promised Jason she would be his partner for the dance. Torn between wanting social acceptance and her promise to Jason, Catherine struggles to decide. She tries to find a way to attend both, but the dance times conflict. Her inner struggle grows as she thinks about letting Jason down, a thought that makes her feel guilty, knowing how much he looks forward to special events.
David's Birthday and Catherine's Frustration
David's birthday party is a focus of Catherine's mixed feelings. She loves her brother, but his strict routines and inability to understand social cues often overshadow family events. David insists on a specific cake and gets upset when things do not go exactly as planned. Catherine feels overlooked and unappreciated, sensing her parents' attention is mostly on David. This adds to her desire for a life separate from David's challenges and strengthens her wish for 'normalcy,' making her dance problem even more urgent.
Conflicting Loyalties and a Difficult Choice
Catherine's guilt about the dance increases, and she finally tells Jason, drawing pictures in his book to explain her problem with Ryan's invitation. Jason, using his communication book, shows his disappointment, making Catherine feel worse. She understands how deep her promise to him is and the unique connection they share. The conversation is hard, but it makes Catherine face her priorities and the person she wants to be. This moment changes how she understands loyalty and friendship, beyond surface appearances.
A Moment of Truth with Kristi
Unable to keep her life with David a secret from Kristi, Catherine decides to be honest. She invites Kristi over when David is home, explaining his autism and some of his behaviors. This is a big step for Catherine, as she always feared Kristi's reaction. Kristi is generally understanding, though a little uncomfortable at first. This talk lets Catherine finally be her true self with Kristi, taking a risk that strengthens their friendship by building it on honesty rather than secrecy and embarrassment.
The Dance and a New Perspective
Catherine decides to go to the dance with Jason, keeping her promise. She helps him get ready and makes sure he has his communication book. At the dance, she feels proud and happy with him, realizing their connection is more important than fitting in with the popular group. She sees Jason not as a 'disabled boy' but as a friend with whom she shares a unique bond. This experience changes Catherine's view of what a 'normal' life is, realizing that true happiness comes from real connections and acceptance.
Kristi's Understanding and David's Growth
Kristi, seeing Catherine with Jason at the dance, shows real acceptance and understanding, strengthening their friendship. Later, at home, Catherine watches David, who, in a rare moment, gives her a twig from his collection, knowing it is one of her favorite things. This small gesture from David shows his own way of showing affection and connection, and it moves Catherine deeply. It makes her realize that even though David expresses himself differently, he can love and understand, further solidifying her acceptance of him.
Embracing Her Rules and Her Life
By the end of summer, Catherine understands herself, her family, and her friendships better. She realizes that 'normal' is not about meeting societal expectations but about accepting individuality and real connections. Her rules for David are no longer only about making him 'normal,' but about helping him navigate his world while valuing his unique qualities. Catherine feels good about her role as David's sister, values her friendship with Jason, and builds an honest relationship with Kristi, accepting her life as it is, with all its complexities.
Principal Figures
Catherine
The Protagonist
Catherine transforms from a girl embarrassed by her brother and seeking normalcy to one who embraces her unique family and finds acceptance in genuine connections.
David
The Supporting
David remains largely consistent in his autistic behaviors but occasionally demonstrates subtle moments of connection and empathy, showing his unique way of loving.
Jason
The Supporting
Jason helps Catherine grow by providing a friendship built on mutual understanding and challenging her to be honest, ultimately becoming a catalyst for her self-acceptance.
Kristi
The Supporting
Kristi starts as an idealized friend, then becomes a test of Catherine's honesty, and eventually an accepting, supportive friend.
Mom (Catherine's mother)
The Supporting
Her arc is subtle, showing her continuous struggle and dedication to David, and her growing awareness of Catherine's needs.
Dad (Catherine's father)
The Supporting
His arc is subtle, hinting at his struggles to connect and be present, without a major transformation.
Ryan
The Mentioned
Serves as a plot device to create Catherine's central dilemma.
Melissa
The Mentioned
Melissa's role is largely functional, providing the setting for key character interactions.
Themes & Insights
Identity and Self-Discovery
Catherine's journey is about finding her own identity beyond being David's sister. She thinks about who she is when she is not managing David, and who she wants to be in her friendships. Her inner struggle over the dance invitation—choosing between fitting in with Ryan and keeping her promise to Jason—is central to this theme. By the end, she realizes her true self is one that shows empathy, loyalty, and accepts her unique family, rather than trying to fit a 'normal' idea.
“Maybe normal is a dirty trick. Maybe normal is just a bunch of rules that don't make sense to anyone but the people who made them.”
Acceptance and Empathy
The novel looks at different kinds of acceptance: Catherine's acceptance of David's autism, her mother's dedication, and Catherine's self-acceptance. Her relationship with Jason teaches her to look past physical and communication differences to see the person inside. The times when Kristi accepts David, and when David shows empathy towards Catherine, show the power of understanding and accepting differences. Catherine learns that real connection comes from empathy, not from trying to change people to fit an ideal.
“I used to think the rules were to help David. But maybe they're to help me.”
The Meaning of 'Normal'
Catherine's main struggle is her constant wish for a 'normal' life, which she defines by having a best friend, being invited to dances, and not having an embarrassing brother. However, through her friendship with Jason and her experiences with David, she slowly redefines 'normal.' She realizes that true happiness and connection do not come from following societal norms but from real relationships and accepting life's imperfections. Her decision to go to the dance with Jason, despite social implications, rejects her old definition of 'normal.'
“Normal is a word that means 'average, typical.' But David isn't average. And I don't want to be typical.”
Sibling Relationships and Responsibility
The complex bond between Catherine and David is at the center of the story. Catherine loves David but also dislikes the constant attention he needs and the embarrassment he causes. She feels a strong sense of responsibility for him, making rules and trying to protect him. The book shows the frustrations, sacrifices, and deep, unconditional love that can be in a sibling relationship with autism. Catherine's journey is about finding a healthy balance between her own needs and her role as David's sister, ultimately accepting her unique bond with him.
“I love David. I do. But sometimes I wish he was normal.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
Catherine's Rules
A list of guidelines Catherine creates for David, reflecting her desire for order and normalcy.
Catherine's 'rules' are a recurring motif throughout the book. Initially, they are a literal list she writes for David, attempting to teach him social conventions and prevent embarrassing situations (e.g., 'No toys in the fish tank,' 'Keep your pants on'). As the story progresses, these rules evolve from a tool for control and a yearning for 'normalcy' into a reflection of Catherine's internal state and her growing understanding of acceptance. By the end, the rules symbolize her changing perspective on life's complexities and her acceptance of David's individuality, rather than an attempt to make him conform.
Jason's Communication Book
A tool that enables communication for a non-verbal character, fostering a unique friendship.
Jason's communication book is a crucial plot device. As a non-verbal character, Jason relies on this book to express his thoughts. Catherine's artistic talent allows her to draw new pictures in the book, making communication faster and more nuanced for Jason. This not only facilitates their deep friendship but also highlights the theme of alternative communication and understanding. It allows Jason to be a fully developed character with wit and intelligence, challenging perceptions of disability and providing Catherine with a unique, non-verbal confidant.
Drawing and Art
Catherine's artistic outlet, a means of expression, and a bridge for communication.
Catherine's love for drawing serves multiple purposes. It is her personal escape and a way to process her emotions and observations. More significantly, her drawing skills become the bridge that allows her to communicate effectively with Jason, illustrating words and ideas in his communication book. This artistic connection deepens their bond and allows for a unique form of understanding between them, reinforcing the idea that communication can take many forms beyond spoken words and that art can facilitate profound connections.
The Community Dance
A social event that creates Catherine's central moral dilemma.
The community dance serves as a major plot point, creating Catherine's central conflict. Ryan's invitation represents the 'normal' social life Catherine craves, while her prior promise to Jason represents loyalty and genuine connection. Her struggle over which invitation to accept forces Catherine to confront her deepest desires and values. Her ultimate decision to attend with Jason is a pivotal moment in her character development, symbolizing her shift from seeking external validation to embracing internal integrity and acceptance of her unique life.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“No toys in the fish tank.”
— One of Catherine's rules for her brother David to help him navigate social situations.
“If you can only say one thing, say 'Thank you.'”
— Another rule Catherine creates for David to teach him basic social etiquette.
“”
— Catherine reflects on her friendship with Jason, who uses a wheelchair and communication cards.
“It's okay to be mad, but you can't hurt people.”
— Catherine explains to David how to handle emotions appropriately.
“Sometimes people don't answer because they don't hear you. Other times it's because they don't want to answer.”
— Catherine thinks about communication challenges with both David and Jason.
“I wish everyone had the same chances.”
— Catherine observes how people treat Jason differently because of his disability.
“Looking closer can make something beautiful.”
— Catherine learns to appreciate Jason's artwork and perspective.
“You don't have to be perfect to be a good friend.”
— Catherine realizes this through her interactions with Jason and David.
“Rules change. People change.”
— Catherine comes to understand that flexibility is important in relationships.
“Sometimes the best thing you can do is just listen.”
— Catherine learns this while trying to communicate with both David and Jason.
“Different isn't bad. Different is just different.”
— A key realization Catherine has about her brother and her friend Jason.
“You can't fix everything, but you can try to make things better.”
— Catherine reflects on her role in her family and with her friends.
“The words you choose matter.”
— Catherine thinks about how she communicates with David and Jason.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
'Rules' follows twelve-year-old Catherine as she navigates the complexities of family life with her younger brother David, who has autism. Over the summer, she forms friendships with Jason, a paraplegic boy who uses a communication book, and Kristi, a new neighbor, which challenge her perceptions of normalcy and force her to confront her own prejudices and desires for acceptance.
Similar books
The Remarkable Journey of Coyote Sunrise
Dan Gemeinhart
4.5
The Runaway
Kate O'Hearn
4.4
The Penderwicks in Spring
Jeanne Birdsall
4.4
The Prince and the Dressmaker
Jen Wang
4.4
The Running Dream
Wendelin Van Draanen
4.3
The Rabbits
John Marsden
4.3
The Polar Express
Chris Van Allsburg
4.3
The Runaway King
Jennifer A. Nielsen
4.2