“Magic is real, but it's not a solution for everything.”
— A general theme about the limitations of magic.
Archivist's Choice
Other
Karen Kincy (2010)
Genre
Fantasy / Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
360 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
In a town where shapeshifting is a death sentence, Gwen's secret life as an owl becomes entangled with a serial killer targeting Others and a seductive fox-spirit who challenges everything she thought she knew about love and loyalty.
Synopsis
Gwen, a closeted shapeshifter in a small, prejudiced town, secretly turns into an owl to escape her ordinary life. Her secret is at risk when werewolves move into the national forest, increasing tensions and leading to the murder of an 'Other.' When police prejudice hinders the investigation, Gwen realizes a killer is targeting those with paranormal abilities. She teams up with Tavian, a Japanese fox-spirit who encourages her to embrace her true nature, creating a romantic conflict with her human boyfriend, Zack. Gwen must navigate her new powers, a dangerous love triangle, and the growing threat of a serial killer, all while keeping her identity hidden, to unmask the murderer before she becomes the next victim.
Reading time
360 min
Difficulty
Medium
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Suspenseful, Romantic, Mysterious, Tense
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy YA urban fantasy with shapeshifters, a murder mystery, and a love triangle.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer fantasy without strong romantic subplots or are looking for high-fantasy world-building.
Plot Summary
A Secret Life and a New Threat
Gwen, a teenager in Klikamuks, Washington, secretly turns into an owl. This power, inherited from her family, is a secret because of widespread prejudice against 'Others' — people with paranormal abilities. She often flies at night, enjoying the freedom of her owl form. Her boyfriend, Zack, does not know her true nature, and Gwen struggles with wanting to tell him but fearing his rejection. Her life changes when a new werewolf pack, led by Caleb, moves into the national forest near her town, immediately increasing anti-Other feelings among humans.
First Murder and Growing Fear
The tense atmosphere in Klikamuks turns deadly when a local shapeshifter, a young woman Gwen knows, is found brutally murdered. The police investigation is slow and seems prejudiced, leading Gwen to suspect that the victim's 'Other' status is preventing justice. This murder scares the hidden supernatural community, and Gwen begins to think this is not an isolated incident but the work of a serial killer targeting Others. The event makes Gwen confront the real dangers of her identity and the vulnerability of her kind in a hostile world.
Meeting Tavian and a Challenging Alliance
Driven to find answers and protect her community, Gwen starts her own quiet investigation. During her search, she meets Tavian, a mysterious and attractive Japanese fox-spirit (kitsune). Tavian, also investigating the murders, immediately senses Gwen's 'Other' nature and reveals his own. He challenges Gwen's cautious approach to her powers, encouraging her to fully embrace her shapeshifting instead of hiding it. Their first interactions involve suspicion, attraction, and a shared goal, forming a difficult alliance as they both seek the killer.
A Second Victim and Intensified Hunt
Gwen's fears are confirmed when another 'Other' is found murdered, with similar details to the first victim. This second killing solidifies her belief that a serial killer is preying on the supernatural community in Klikamuks. Their mission becomes urgent, and Gwen and Tavian increase their efforts to find the killer's identity and motives. They combine their resources and unique abilities; Tavian's knowledge of the supernatural world is useful, and Gwen's local insights and owl form provide unique ways to gather information.
Zack's Suspicions and Relationship Strain
As Gwen spends more time with Tavian, her secret behavior and growing emotional distance make Zack suspicious. He notices her frequent absences, her preoccupation, and subtle changes in her mood. Gwen struggles to maintain her act, torn between her feelings for Zack and her growing bond with Tavian, who understands her 'Other' nature in a way Zack cannot. The pressure of her double life, along with the increasing danger, strains her relationship with Zack, making her consider the real cost of her secrets.
Unmasking the Killer's Modus Operandi
Through careful investigation and Tavian's sharp insight, Gwen and Tavian begin to understand how the killer operates. They realize the victims are not chosen randomly but are targeted for specific 'Other' traits or powers. This suggests a deeper, more sinister motive than simple prejudice. The killer seems to be systematically eliminating individuals with particular supernatural abilities, pointing to a calculated and dangerous person rather than a random bigot. This discovery narrows their search and adds a chilling layer to the murders.
Confrontation with Caleb and the Werewolves
In their hunt for clues, Gwen and Tavian enter Caleb's werewolf pack territory. They confront Caleb, who, despite his initial dislike of humans, is also worried about the murders, as they threaten the fragile peace and safety of all Others. This confrontation leads to a tense exchange of information, where Gwen and Tavian learn more about the local supernatural dynamics. While not fully trusting, the werewolves become reluctant allies, providing more protection and information in the increasingly dangerous Klikamuks.
A Near Miss and Personal Danger
The investigation turns terrifying when Gwen herself becomes a target. She barely escapes an attack, realizing the killer has identified her as an 'Other' and is actively hunting her. This near-death experience makes the danger very real, strengthening her resolve while also showing her vulnerability. It becomes clear that time is running out, and she must unmask the killer before she becomes the next victim. The attack also forces her to rely more on Tavian and her own shapeshifting abilities for survival.
The Killer's Identity Revealed
After a series of deductions, close calls, and piecing together evidence, Gwen and Tavian finally uncover the shocking identity of the serial killer. The killer is revealed to be someone unexpectedly close to the human community, a person who has hidden their true nature and motives behind a normal appearance or even anti-Other views. The revelation is a deep shock, showing the hidden nature of prejudice and the depths of human evil, even among those thought to be allies or neutral.
Climax and Confrontation
The story's climax shows Gwen and Tavian confronting the serial killer in a tense and dangerous fight. The battle is fierce, requiring Gwen to fully use her owl form and Tavian to use his Kitsune abilities. They fight not just for their own lives, but for the safety of all Others in Klikamuks. The confrontation forces Gwen to overcome her fears and fully accept her identity as a shapeshifter, using her powers with skill and determination. The fate of the supernatural community depends on their success.
Aftermath and New Beginnings
After the confrontation, the killer is defeated, ending the terror in Klikamuks. Gwen, though shaken, emerges stronger and more confident in her identity as an 'Other'. She faces the difficult task of navigating her relationships, especially with Zack, who now must deal with the truth of her shapeshifting abilities, and Tavian, with whom she has formed a deep and undeniable bond. The town of Klikamuks, though still prejudiced, has been forced to confront the hidden world within its borders, suggesting a future where the lines between human and Other may become less rigid, or at least more recognized.
Principal Figures
Gwen
The Protagonist
Gwen transforms from a fearful, closeted shapeshifter into a confident individual who embraces her powers and identity, making difficult choices about her future and relationships.
Tavian
The Supporting/Romantic Interest
Tavian helps Gwen grow into her powers and accepts the dangers of their shared world, solidifying his role as a protector and partner.
Zack
The Supporting/Romantic Interest
Zack confronts the reality of Gwen's 'Other' identity, forcing him to either accept or reject a world beyond his understanding.
Caleb
The Supporting
Caleb evolves from a perceived antagonist to a cautious and valuable ally, demonstrating that not all 'Others' are a monolithic threat.
The Serial Killer
The Antagonist
The killer's actions escalate throughout the story, culminating in a final confrontation with Gwen and Tavian.
Gwen's Mother
The Supporting
Her character reinforces the dangers of being an 'Other' and the importance of family secrets.
The Sheriff
The Mentioned
Represents the institutional prejudice that 'Others' face.
Themes & Insights
Prejudice and Discrimination
The novel explores the widespread and dangerous prejudice against 'Others' in Klikamuks. This theme is seen through the town's suspicion of the werewolf pack, the biased police investigation into the murders of shapeshifters, and Gwen's constant fear of being discovered. 'Others' are marginalized and feared simply for existing, creating a climate where violence against them is often overlooked or excused. The serial killer's motives are rooted in this societal hatred, showing how prejudice can turn into deadly violence.
“Most Americans don’t exactly roll out the welcome mat for Others. In the small town of Klikamuks, Washington, coming out as a person with paranormal abilities means staring down the barrel of a shotgun.”
Identity and Self-Acceptance
Gwen's journey is central to identity and self-acceptance. For much of the story, she hides her true nature, wanting a 'normal' life with Zack while secretly desiring the freedom of her owl form. Her struggle reflects the internal conflict of accepting one's unique, often feared, identity. Tavian encourages her to accept and use her powers. By the end, Gwen must choose between hiding and fully embracing her 'Other' self, recognizing that true strength comes from authenticity, even when facing danger.
“Can she find the killer before he finds her, or will her secrets be the death of her?”
The Nature of Secrets and Their Consequences
Secrets drive the story, especially Gwen's shapeshifting ability. Her secret affects her relationships, particularly with Zack, and creates internal conflict. The novel shows how secrets, while offering temporary protection, can also isolate and endanger. The consequences of these secrets range from strained personal relationships to being unable to seek official help when 'Others' are murdered. Ultimately, the story suggests that while some secrets are needed for survival, being open can lead to greater strength and connection.
“She hasn’t even told the truth to her boyfriend, Zack, who she hopes will be the boy to take her virginity.”
Love and Loyalty in a Divided World
This theme explores the complexities of love and loyalty when individuals are separated by species and societal prejudice. Gwen's loyalty is divided between her human boyfriend, Zack, who represents normalcy but cannot understand her, and Tavian, who is an 'Other' and truly sees and accepts her. The novel questions if love can bridge such divides and what sacrifices are needed. It also examines loyalty within the 'Other' community, as different species (werewolves, shapeshifters, kitsune) must decide if they will unite against a common enemy or remain divided by their own biases.
“He knew her, truly knew her, in a way Zack never could.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The Hidden World
The existence of a secret supernatural society coexisting with oblivious humans.
The hidden world refers to the concealed existence of 'Others' – shapeshifters, werewolves, kitsune, and other paranormal beings – within human society. This device creates inherent tension, as the 'Others' must constantly guard their secrets from a prejudiced human populace. It establishes the stakes for Gwen's shapeshifting, making discovery a life-threatening risk. The hidden world allows for a rich fantasy setting while grounding the narrative in the relatable struggles of a marginalized group trying to survive unnoticed.
The Serial Killer
A mysterious antagonist systematically targeting 'Others', driving the plot's urgency.
The serial killer serves as the primary external conflict and a crucial plot device. Their systematic targeting of 'Others' creates immediate urgency and danger, forcing Gwen out of her passive existence and into action. The killer's unknown identity and specific motives (targeting certain 'Other' traits) provide a compelling mystery that propels the narrative forward. This device also serves to highlight the extreme prejudice faced by 'Others' and the inadequacy of human law enforcement.
Love Triangle
A romantic conflict between Gwen, her human boyfriend Zack, and the 'Other' Tavian.
The love triangle between Gwen, Zack, and Tavian is a classic romantic plot device. It symbolizes Gwen's internal conflict between her desire for a 'normal' human life (represented by Zack) and her true 'Other' identity and the acceptance she finds with Tavian. This device adds emotional depth and personal stakes to the narrative, as Gwen's romantic choices are intrinsically tied to her acceptance of self and her place in the supernatural world. It creates tension and forces Gwen to confront difficult choices about her future.
Shapeshifting
The supernatural ability to transform, serving as both a power and a perilous secret.
Shapeshifting is the central supernatural ability in the novel, primarily embodied by Gwen's transformation into an owl. This device functions as both a source of power and freedom for Gwen and a dangerous secret that could lead to her persecution. It allows for unique perspectives and reconnaissance during the murder investigation (e.g., Gwen flying as an owl). More profoundly, shapeshifting symbolizes Gwen's true identity and her struggle to embrace her unique nature in a world that fears it, making it a metaphor for self-acceptance.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Sometimes the greatest monsters are the ones we create ourselves.”
— Reflecting on internal struggles and self-blame.
“Love isn't about finding someone perfect, it's about finding someone who's perfect for you.”
— A conversation about romantic relationships.
“Every choice has a consequence, whether you see it immediately or not.”
— Discussing the ripple effect of decisions.
“The world doesn't care if you're ready; it keeps turning anyway.”
— Facing an inevitable challenge or change.
“True strength isn't about never falling, but about getting up every time you do.”
— A moment of encouragement after a setback.
“Sometimes the only way to move forward is to let go of the past.”
— Struggling with past regrets or attachments.
“Fear can be a powerful motivator, but it can also be a paralyzing cage.”
— Contemplating the nature of fear.
“It's easy to judge from the outside, but you never truly know what someone else is fighting.”
— A reminder about empathy and understanding.
“The most dangerous lies are the ones we tell ourselves.”
— Reflecting on self-deception.
“Hope is a fragile thing, but it's also the most powerful.”
— Finding a reason to continue in difficult times.
“Being different isn't a curse; it's what makes you unique.”
— A character embracing their individuality.
“Even in the darkest places, a flicker of light can still exist.”
— A moment of finding solace or a solution.
“Trust is earned, not given, and once broken, it's hard to mend.”
— Dealing with betrayal or a strained relationship.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
Gwen's central conflict is the dangerous secrecy surrounding her ability to transform into an owl. In Klikamuks, Washington, Others face intense prejudice and violence, making the revelation of her powers a potential death sentence. This fear prevents her from being truly open with anyone, including her boyfriend, Zack.
