“The thing about happily ever afters is that they’re not an ending, they’re a beginning.”
— After the main conflict, on the nature of enduring happiness.
Archivist's Choice
Maybe This Time
Jennifer Crusie (2011)
Genre
Fantasy / Mystery / Romance
Reading Time
340 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
A woman escaping her ex-husband gets tangled in a funny, ghost-filled adventure with his magically mischievous wards, forcing her to face both supernatural hauntings and the lingering feelings from their past.
Synopsis
Andie Miller is ready to marry her fiancé and leave her ex-husband, North Archer, behind. However, North asks her a final favor: he needs Andie to temporarily care for his two recently orphaned cousins, Carter and Alice. These children have already driven away three nannies with their strange behavior. Andie reluctantly agrees, only to find the children's inherited house is not just messy but also deeply unsettling, with a cold housekeeper and odd occurrences. Her fiancé suspects North is trying to win her back, a feeling fueled by Andie's own dreams and North's lingering presence in her thoughts.
As supernatural events increase, Andie realizes ghosts torment the children. She gathers a group of experts, including a doubtful parapsychologist, an annoyed medium and her Tarot-card reading mother, and even North's vengeful ex-mother-in-law. Amidst exorcism attempts, family secrets, and rising ghostly activity, North reappears, rekindling old feelings and complicating Andie's life. Andie must face the spirits, protect the children, and decide if she can escape her past or if a future with North is what she needs.
Reading time
340 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Humorous, Quirky, Romantic, Lighthearted, Supernatural
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy a humorous blend of romance, mystery, and the supernatural with quirky characters and a second-chance love story.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer serious ghost stories, dislike romantic comedy tropes, or find supernatural elements clashing with humor off-putting.
Plot Summary
A Final Favor and a Haunted House
Andie Miller wants to move on and marry her fiancé, Fred. However, seeking closure with her ex-husband, North Archer, leads to an unexpected request. North, a successful but distant lawyer, needs help with his two newly orphaned cousins, ten-year-old Carter and six-year-old Alice. Their parents died in a car crash. The children have driven off three nannies and live in a rundown Victorian house in Salem, Massachusetts, with a stern housekeeper, Mrs. Klink. Despite her doubts and Fred's suspicions, Andie, known for handling tough situations, agrees to care for the children, hoping it will be her last interaction with North.
First Impressions and Unsettling Discoveries
Arriving at the imposing Archer family estate, Andie immediately notices the house's heavy atmosphere and the children's odd behavior. Carter is quiet and withdrawn, while Alice has violent tantrums and talks about an 'invisible friend.' Mrs. Klink, the housekeeper, is cold and unhelpful. Andie finds the children's rooms messy and the whole house neglected. Strange things start happening: objects move, cold spots appear, and an unsettling feeling fills the air. Andie quickly realizes the children's problems are more than typical rebellion; she suspects a supernatural influence.
Fred's Jealousy and North's Brief Appearance
Fred, Andie's fiancé, visits the house, showing clear jealousy and suspicion of North's motives. He believes North is using the children to win Andie back and tries to persuade her to leave. Andie, despite her growing doubts about Fred's understanding, insists on staying to help the children. North makes a brief, business-like appearance, assessing the situation with his usual distance. His presence, though short, stirs old feelings for Andie, making her question her resolve to move on. His calm nature contrasts with the house's chaos, yet he offers little practical help, leaving Andie to manage.
Supernatural Manifestations Escalate
As Andie settles in, the paranormal activity in the house increases. Objects fly, doors slam, and unsettling voices are heard. Alice's 'invisible friend' becomes more demanding and aggressive, making her behavior more violent. Andie has vivid, disturbing dreams about North, blurring her past and the current haunting. She begins to suspect the children are not just misbehaving but are being tormented or possessed by a malevolent entity. Mrs. Klink remains unhelpful, hinting at dark secrets in the house's past. Andie realizes she needs more than childcare skills for this situation.
A Team of Eccentric Experts
Realizing the situation is beyond her, Andie seeks professional help. She enlists Dr. Ben Carter, a doubtful parapsychologist, who arrives with equipment but little confidence. He, in turn, brings in Ruby, a cynical medium, and her practical, Tarot-card-reading mother, Mrs. DeSantos. This unusual team investigates the hauntings, their methods often clashing but slowly revealing the spirits' nature. Andie finds herself caught between science and spiritual belief, trying to manage the children, the house, and now a group of ghost hunters, all while the poltergeist activity continues.
Ex-Mother-in-Law and Family Secrets
Adding to the chaos, North's mother, Mrs. Archer, arrives unannounced. A woman with strong opinions and a firm will, she immediately takes charge, much to Andie's annoyance. Mrs. Archer, still upset about Andie's divorce from North, makes her disapproval clear. However, her presence also starts to uncover old family secrets. She reveals details about the Archer family's history and the house's previous residents, including a tragic love story and the deaths of Carter and Alice's parents, which she suggests may not have been accidental. Her insights provide important clues to the haunting, suggesting a deeper, personal connection to the spirits.
The Ghosts' Identity and Motives
Through Dr. Carter's research, Ruby's medium abilities, and Mrs. DeSantos's intuition, the team identifies the main spirits haunting the house: a young woman named Sarah and her lover, a stable boy. Their tragic story unfolds: Sarah was pregnant with the stable boy's child, but her aristocratic family, especially a cruel uncle, disapproved. They arranged for the stable boy's murder and Sarah to be locked away, where she later died, possibly by suicide or neglect. The spirits are angry and seek justice, their malice directed at anyone connected to the Archer family and those who remind them of their oppressors. Carter and Alice are caught in the middle of this vengeful haunting.
North's Return and Rekindled Feelings
Just as the supernatural drama peaks, North Archer returns, no longer able to ignore the rising chaos. His arrival affects Andie greatly, reigniting their complex emotions. He witnesses the paranormal activity, forcing him to face the reality of the hauntings and his own doubts. As they work together to protect the children and understand the spirits, the old connection between Andie and North becomes clear. Their shared past and the intense present circumstances draw them closer, making Andie question her engagement to Fred and her future plans. North, too, seems to be rethinking his detached approach to life and his relationship with Andie.
Confronting the Malevolent Spirit
The team, now including North and Mrs. Archer, plans to deal with the spirits. They understand that Sarah's spirit, fueled by betrayal and revenge, is the main source of the poltergeist activity and the children's torment. They believe that by acknowledging her pain and giving her some justice, they might help her move on. This involves finding the exact details of her death and the stable boy's murder, and possibly finding a way to symbolically correct the wrongs done to them. The plan requires everyone to work together, putting aside personal differences and fears to bring peace to the house and its living residents.
The Exorcism and Resolution
In a final confrontation, the team performs an exorcism, not with traditional religious rites, but by acknowledging the spirits' suffering and giving them a symbolic resolution. They uncover evidence of the stable boy's burial site and Sarah's true fate, bringing the truth to light. The spirits, especially Sarah, finally find peace and leave the house. Carter and Alice are visibly free from their influence, their behavior returning to normal. The house, too, feels lighter. The experience forces North and Andie to confront their feelings for each other, leading to a reconciliation. Fred is left behind, unable to compete with the renewed connection forged through the supernatural events.
A New Family and Future
With the hauntings resolved, Andie and North fully reconcile, realizing they still love each other and belong together. They decide to marry and raise Carter and Alice as their own. The children, now happy and settled, finally have a stable, loving home. The house, once a place of torment, becomes a home filled with warmth and laughter. The paranormal investigators leave, having a lasting impact on Andie and North. The experience has not only brought them back together but has also given them a new purpose and a family they never expected, showing that sometimes, going home again can be different.
Principal Figures
Andie Miller
The Protagonist
Andie evolves from someone trying to escape her past into someone who embraces it, finding love and purpose in unexpected places and forming a new family.
North Archer
The Love Interest / Supporting Protagonist
North learns to open up emotionally, shed his skepticism, and embrace a life beyond logic, ultimately reconciling with Andie.
Carter
The Supporting
Carter transitions from a traumatized, haunted child to a happy, secure boy once the spirits are appeased and he finds a stable family.
Alice
The Supporting
Alice is freed from spiritual influence, transforming from a tormented child into a joyful and loving member of a new family.
Fred
The Supporting / Minor Antagonist
Fred serves as a foil for North, his character arc illustrating why he is not the right partner for Andie, leading to their inevitable breakup.
Mrs. Klink
The Supporting / Minor Antagonist
Mrs. Klink remains a static, unhelpful figure, serving primarily to heighten the mystery and difficulties Andie faces.
Dr. Ben Carter
The Supporting
Dr. Carter gradually gains confidence in his field, witnessing undeniable proof of the supernatural and contributing scientifically to the resolution.
Ruby
The Supporting
Ruby uses her abilities to help resolve the haunting, reaffirming her role and purpose despite her initial weariness.
Mrs. DeSantos
The Supporting
Mrs. DeSantos consistently provides guidance and wisdom, helping to steer the investigation towards a successful resolution.
Mrs. Archer
The Supporting
Mrs. Archer softens her stance towards Andie as they work together, ultimately accepting her back into the family.
Themes & Insights
The Power of Forgiveness and Redemption
The novel explores how unresolved past issues, both human and ghostly, can affect the present. The spirits of Sarah and her lover are trapped by their desire for justice and revenge, showing how destructive unforgiveness can be. Forgiveness, here, is not just about clearing the guilty but allowing the wronged to find peace. Andie and North must also forgive each other for past hurts to move forward. The haunting ends not through violence, but through understanding and acknowledging the spirits' suffering, allowing them to find peace and move on.
““Sometimes,” Ruby said, “the dead just want to be heard. To have their story told.””
Finding Home and Family
A main theme is the search for belonging and what makes a family. Andie starts by trying to escape her past and create a traditional family with Fred. However, she finds true family and home not in a planned future, but in the unexpected chaos of the haunted house with North, Carter, and Alice. The children are literal orphans seeking a home, and the spirits are symbolic orphans, wanting recognition and peace. The novel suggests that home is not just a place but a feeling of security, love, and acceptance, built through shared experiences and commitment, regardless of traditional ties.
““Home isn’t a place, it’s a feeling. And sometimes, it’s the last place you expect to find it.””
Reconciling Past and Present
The story revolves around the characters' struggle to reconcile their pasts with what they want now. Andie is affected by her divorce from North and her lingering feelings for him. North is similarly affected, though he tries to hide it. The house itself shows an unresolved past, with the vengeful spirits representing unfinished business from history. The novel argues that real progress comes from facing and understanding the past, rather than trying to bury it. For Andie and North, this means acknowledging their shared history and the reasons for their breakup before they can build a new future.
““You can’t outrun your past, Andie. It always catches up, one way or another.””
Skepticism vs. Belief
The story constantly plays with the tension between rational thought and supernatural belief. North represents the rational mind, initially dismissing the hauntings as absurd. Fred shows a more ordinary, dismissive skepticism. Andie, while practical, is open-minded. Dr. Carter is a scientist trying to measure the unmeasurable, while Ruby and Mrs. DeSantos embrace the spiritual. The increasing paranormal events force even the most skeptical characters to face the limits of their understanding, showing that some truths exist beyond normal explanation. The novel ultimately suggests keeping an open mind, where logic and intuition can exist together.
““There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy.””
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The Haunted House
A dilapidated Victorian mansion serving as both setting and a character itself.
The Archer family estate is more than just a backdrop; it functions as a primary plot device. Its imposing architecture, decrepit state, and isolated location immediately establish a gothic atmosphere, foreshadowing the supernatural events. The house physically embodies the unresolved past, holding the secrets of the Archer family and the trapped spirits. Its physical deterioration mirrors the emotional decay within the family and the children. The escalating paranormal activity within its walls drives much of the plot, forcing characters to confront their fears and the reality of the unseen.
The Children as Catalysts
Carter and Alice, the orphaned children, serve as the initial reason for Andie's involvement and the focus of the haunting.
Carter and Alice are crucial catalysts for the entire plot. Their orphaned status and subsequent difficult behavior are the initial reason North seeks Andie's help, drawing her into the haunted house. More importantly, they are the primary targets and victims of the malevolent spirits, making their well-being the central motivation for Andie and the paranormal team. Their vulnerability and the influence the spirits have over them underscore the urgency and danger of the situation, forcing the adults to act and eventually resolve the haunting.
The Ex-Husband Scenario
The presence of North, Andie's ex-husband, creates romantic tension and forces her to confront unresolved personal history.
North's role as Andie's ex-husband is a classic romance plot device. It immediately establishes a history and unresolved emotional baggage between the protagonists, providing a strong undercurrent of romantic tension. His request for her help, and his subsequent presence in the house, forces Andie to confront her lingering feelings, compare him to her fiancé, Fred, and re-evaluate her choices. This device allows for a 'second chance at love' narrative, complicated by past hurt and present circumstances, making their reconciliation more meaningful.
The Ensemble of Eccentric Experts
A diverse group of paranormal investigators providing varied perspectives and comic relief.
The introduction of Dr. Ben Carter, Ruby, and Mrs. DeSantos creates an ensemble cast of 'experts.' This device serves multiple functions: it introduces different approaches to the supernatural (scientific, intuitive, spiritual), which allows for a comprehensive investigation of the haunting. Their clashing personalities and unique methods provide comic relief amidst the tension. More importantly, each character contributes a vital piece to solving the mystery of the ghosts, making their combined efforts essential for the plot's resolution and the ultimate exorcism of the spirits.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Love isn't a fairy tale. It's a choice. And sometimes it's a fight.”
— When the protagonist is struggling with the reality of her magical romance.
“Magic is just science we don't understand yet.”
— A character explaining the practical side of their magical abilities.
“Sometimes the biggest mysteries are the ones you find inside yourself.”
— The protagonist reflecting on her personal growth and self-discovery.
“A good story never really ends; it just waits for you to pick it up again.”
— A character discussing the enduring nature of narratives and their impact.
“You can't outrun destiny, but you can choose how you meet it.”
— When the characters are facing an inevitable magical prophecy.
“The past isn't a prison, it's a foundation. You build on it, you don't live in it.”
— A character offering advice on moving past old hurts and mistakes.
“Sometimes the most extraordinary things happen in the most ordinary places.”
— Reflecting on the magical elements appearing in a mundane setting.
“Trust is a two-way street, especially when one of you can turn into a cat.”
— A humorous take on the challenges of trust in a magical relationship.
“You don't need a magic wand to change your life. You just need a little courage and a lot of heart.”
— The protagonist realizing her own internal strength.
“Every secret has a cost, and some costs are higher than others.”
— As characters uncover hidden truths and face consequences.
“Being strong doesn't mean you don't get scared. It means you do it anyway.”
— A character encouraging another to face their fears.
“Sometimes the best way to find what you're looking for is to stop looking so hard.”
— When the protagonist is obsessively searching for a solution.
“A little chaos keeps things interesting, especially when love is involved.”
— A lighthearted reflection on the tumultuous but exciting nature of their romance.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
Andie Miller is trying to move on with her life, marry her fiancé, and gain closure with her ex-husband, North Archer. Her plans are derailed when North asks her to care for two orphaned children, Carter and Alice, who have proven difficult for previous nannies, drawing her back into his orbit and a mysterious old house.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
