“Life is a series of adjustments. You just keep making them. You keep trying to improve things, or you keep trying to make them work.”
— Harry recounts a conversation with his mother about the struggles of life.
Archivist's Choice
May We Be Forgiven
A.M. Homes (2012)
Genre
Literary Fiction
Reading Time
16 hours
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
After his TV producer brother's rage upends his quiet life, a meek Nixon scholar finds himself on a darkly comic journey through the bizarre world of modern American family problems, changing unexpectedly amid the chaos.
Synopsis
Harry, a quiet Richard Nixon scholar, lives a predictable life until his volatile brother, George, a successful TV producer, attacks his wife, Jane, during a disastrous Thanksgiving. George is arrested and hospitalized. Jane leaves, and Harry becomes the primary caregiver for George and Jane's two children, Ashley and Nate, and their dog. Harry moves into George's suburban home, learning a new domestic routine of school runs, chores, and his niece and nephew's emotional needs. He also deals with the aftermath of the incident and George's mistress, Marina. Marina, initially a problem, eventually recovers and becomes a more stable person. Harry tries online dating, experiencing awkward encounters that show his inexperience with modern romance. As the children adjust and Harry accepts his role, George slowly recovers and is released. The novel ends with Harry's change from an isolated academic into the anchor of a new, unconventional family, finding purpose and connection in unexpected ways. It shows how resilient people can be and how family changes in America today.
Reading time
16 hours
Difficulty
Medium
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Darkly Comic, Satirical, Observational, Absurdist
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy dark humor, sharp social satire, and a deep dive into the absurdities of modern American life and family dynamics.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer straightforward, heartwarming family dramas or are sensitive to themes of violence and domestic dysfunction.
Plot Summary
The Thanksgiving Disaster
Harry Silver, a meticulous Richard Nixon scholar, and his wife, Jane, host Thanksgiving dinner. His charismatic but volatile brother, George, a successful television producer, arrives with his wife, Marina, and their two children, Ashley and Nate. The evening is tense, with sibling rivalry and George's anger. After small provocations, George explodes, attacking Marina and then Harry. The violence is shocking, especially for Harry, who has always lived an orderly academic life. This event changes Harry's life, pushing him into a chaotic new reality.
George's Arrest and Hospitalization
After the Thanksgiving assault, George is arrested and hospitalized in a psychiatric facility. His violent outburst is a severe mental break, and he is observed. This leaves Marina and her children, Ashley and Nate, without their main provider and with emotional trauma. Harry, still recovering from the attack and the sudden collapse of his brother's life, feels a reluctant responsibility towards Marina and the kids, despite his strained relationship with George. This unexpected turn forces Harry to face his old resentments and take on a role he never imagined.
Jane's Departure and Harry's Isolation
After George's breakdown, Harry's wife, Jane, reveals her long-standing affair with a colleague and announces she is leaving him. This second, equally devastating blow leaves Harry completely lost. His carefully built life, focused on academic pursuits and quiet domesticity, shatters. Alone in his house, Harry struggles to process the rapid traumatic events, feeling isolated and confused. He must reconsider his identity and purpose outside his marriage and his brother's shadow.
Assuming Responsibility for Marina and the Children
With George in the hospital and Jane gone, Harry becomes more involved in the lives of Marina, Ashley, and Nate. He visits George in the hospital, acting as a go-between for Marina. More importantly, he starts providing financial and emotional support to Marina and the children, moving into their house to help with household management and care for his niece and nephew. This unexpected role forces Harry out of his academic world and into the demanding realities of family life, a role he is unprepared for but determined to fulfill.
Navigating a New Domesticity
Living with Marina, Ashley, and Nate, Harry struggles to adapt to their household. He tries to bring order to their chaotic lives, helping with homework, meals, and childcare, often with awkward and funny results. He also tries to understand the complex emotions of his niece and nephew, who are dealing with their father's absence and their mother's distress. This period shows Harry's clumsy attempts at domesticity and his growing, though reluctant, affection for the children, as he slowly learns what it means to be a caregiver.
Marina's Grief and Recovery
While Harry focuses on the children, Marina deals with the aftermath of George's violence and the end of her marriage. She experiences deep grief and anger but slowly finds her footing. She seeks therapy and starts to rediscover her own interests and desires, separate from George. Her journey involves exploring her sexuality and seeking emotional connections, sometimes in unexpected ways. Harry sees her change, which in some ways mirrors his own changing understanding of life and relationships.
Harry's Forays into Online Dating
Encouraged by friends and his own loneliness, Harry cautiously tries online dating. His experiences are often comical and confusing, showing him the strange rituals and superficiality of modern connection. He meets a variety of eccentric people, highlighting his social awkwardness and his intellectual, rather than emotional, approach to intimacy. These encounters, though often unsuccessful, force Harry to confront his own desires and what he seeks in a relationship, moving him further from his previous isolated existence.
The Children's Adaptation and Growth
Ashley and Nate, initially traumatized and confused by their father's actions and absence, slowly adapt to their new family structure with Harry. Ashley, a perceptive and somewhat cynical teenager, navigates her adolescence and family complexities. Nate, younger and more vulnerable, finds stability in Harry. Harry's consistent, if sometimes clumsy, care helps them both process their grief and find a sense of normalcy amid the upheaval. Their growth shows Harry's changing capacity for love and responsibility.
George's Recovery and Release
After treatment, George is stable enough to be released from the psychiatric facility. His return home is tense and uncertain. He expresses remorse for his actions but struggles to fully rejoin the family he shattered. Harry, Marina, and the children must navigate their feelings towards George, balancing forgiveness with the lasting impact of his violence. This reunion forces them to face unresolved issues from their past and decide what kind of future, if any, they can build together.
A New Kind of Family
After George's return, the family does not simply go back to its old form. Instead, Harry, Marina, George, Ashley, and Nate create a new, unconventional family. Harry remains a central figure, having become an important part of the children's lives and a support for Marina. The boundaries of their relationships are redefined, moving beyond traditional expectations. They learn to co-exist, forgive, and find new ways to connect, showing the resilience and adaptability of human relationships in the face of great change.
Harry's Transformation and Acceptance
By the novel's end, Harry Silver is a vastly different man from the detached academic he once was. He has shed his rigid intellectualism and accepted the messiness of human connection and responsibility. He finds a deep sense of purpose and belonging in his unconventional family, having discovered his capacity for love, care, and even joy. His change is complete; he accepts his new role, not as a replacement for George, but as a vital and beloved member of a reformed family, finding forgiveness for himself and others.
Principal Figures
Harry Silver
The Protagonist
Harry transforms from a detached, self-absorbed academic into a compassionate, responsible caregiver, finding unexpected fulfillment in an unconventional family.
George Silver
The Antagonist/Supporting
George experiences a severe mental breakdown, leading to institutionalization, and then embarks on a difficult path of recovery and attempted reconciliation.
Marina
The Supporting
Marina evolves from a victim of abuse into a self-possessed woman who reclaims her life and identity, forming a new family structure.
Ashley
The Supporting
Ashley learns to cope with family trauma and adjust to a new family dynamic, finding a stable presence in Harry.
Nate
The Supporting
Nate finds a new sense of security and paternal guidance in Harry, adapting to his changed family structure.
Jane
The Mentioned/Supporting
Jane's arc is brief; she leaves Harry, catalyzing his isolation and subsequent transformation.
Themes & Insights
The Reinvention of the Family
The novel shows how traditional family structures can break apart and then re-form in unconventional, yet meaningful, ways. After George's breakdown and Harry's divorce, a new 'family' emerges: Harry, Marina, Ashley, and Nate. They deal with shared trauma, create new routines, and develop deep bonds that go beyond blood or marriage. Harry's change from a detached uncle to a devoted caregiver, and Marina's embrace of a new life with Harry's support, show this theme. Love and connection can create family where it's least expected, as when Harry awkwardly but diligently helps Nate with homework or comforts Ashley.
“What they were doing, what they had become, was a family. Not the family they had been, but a family nonetheless.”
Personal Transformation and Redemption
At its core, the book is a story of personal change, especially for Harry. Stripped of his marriage, his brother's sanity, and his academic comfort zone, Harry must confront his own emotional shortcomings and engage with life's messy realities. He goes from being emotionally distant and socially awkward to becoming a compassionate, responsible, and loving person. George's journey, though more difficult, also explores the possibility of redemption after serious mistakes. This is clear in Harry's clumsy but persistent efforts to care for Ashley and Nate, and his willingness to take on a role he never imagined, learning to forgive and connect.
“He had thought his life was over, but it was only just beginning.”
The Chaos and Absurdity of Modern Life
Homes satirizes contemporary American culture, highlighting its absurdities, from the superficiality of online dating to the passive-aggressive nature of institutions and the widespread use of technology. Harry's bewildered attempts to navigate dating apps, his interactions with various quirky characters, and the bureaucratic hurdles around George's mental health treatment all show this theme. The novel uses dark humor to expose the gap between people's desperate desire for intimacy and their often-ineffective ways of seeking it, showing the confusing world of 21st-century social interaction.
“Everyone was searching for something, a way to connect, a way to be seen. But mostly they just bumped into each other, like pinballs in a giant, absurd machine.”
Forgiveness and Acceptance
The title itself points to this central theme. The characters, especially Harry, must learn to forgive George for his violent actions, forgive themselves for past mistakes, and accept the unpredictable turns their lives have taken. Forgiveness is not a simple act but a complex, ongoing process, especially with deep-seated family trauma. It means letting go of expectations and embracing imperfect reality. Harry's eventual acceptance of his new, unconventional life and his growing understanding of George's vulnerabilities show this, as does Marina's journey to move past the trauma of her marriage.
“Forgiveness wasn't a single act, but a slow, persistent unfolding.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
Inciting Incident: The Thanksgiving Assault
George's violent outburst that shatters Harry's ordinary life.
The Thanksgiving dinner scene, where George violently attacks Marina and Harry, serves as the primary inciting incident. This explosive event immediately disrupts Harry's predictable academic existence, forcing him out of his comfort zone and setting in motion all subsequent plot developments. It's a sudden, shocking catalyst that propels Harry into a new reality where he must confront family responsibilities, personal trauma, and a complete re-evaluation of his life.
Fish Out of Water Protagonist
Harry's placement in unfamiliar domestic and social roles.
Harry Silver, a meticulous academic specializing in Richard Nixon, is inherently a 'fish out of water' when thrust into the chaotic domestic life of his brother's family and the bewildering world of modern dating. His intellectual and detached nature makes him comically ill-suited for these roles, highlighting his personal growth as he awkwardly but earnestly learns to navigate emotional connections, childcare, and social interactions. This device generates both humor and pathos, emphasizing his transformation.
Dark Humor and Satire
The use of comedic elements to critique contemporary society and human behavior.
A.M. Homes employs dark humor and biting satire to comment on modern American life, relationships, and institutions. Harry's awkward online dating experiences, his detached observations of therapy sessions, and the general absurdity of the situations he encounters provide comedic relief while simultaneously offering sharp critiques of societal norms, technology, and the search for connection in a fragmented world. This device allows the novel to tackle serious themes with a distinctive, often uncomfortable, wit.
Sibling Rivalry as a Catalyst
The long-standing tension between Harry and George as a driver of conflict.
The deep-seated sibling rivalry between Harry and George, simmering since childhood, is a crucial underlying force. George's jealousy of Harry's perceived intellectual superiority and Harry's resentment of George's charisma and success contribute to the volatile atmosphere that culminates in George's breakdown. This rivalry not only fuels the initial conflict but also shapes Harry's reluctance and eventual embrace of responsibility, as he grapples with his complex feelings towards his brother.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Sometimes you have to break things to fix them.”
— Harry contemplates the aftermath of his brother's accident and the changes in his own life.
“The past is never dead. It's not even past.”
— Harry reflects on the lingering presence of his past relationships and family dynamics.
“You don't know what you've got until it's gone. And then sometimes, you still don't know.”
— Harry muses on his lost marriage and the complexities of human appreciation.
“Everyone has a narrative, and it's always shifting, always being rewritten.”
— Harry considers the subjective nature of personal stories and how people perceive themselves and others.
“We are all just trying to make sense of the chaos, to find some order in the disorder.”
— Harry reflects on the human condition and the search for meaning amidst life's unpredictability.
“There are things you never recover from, and then there are things you simply learn to live with.”
— Harry grapples with the permanent impact of certain events versus the gradual acceptance of others.
“Family is a given. Everything else is a choice.”
— Harry considers the unchangeable nature of familial bonds versus the decisions made in other relationships.
“The greatest luxury is not having to explain yourself.”
— Harry fantasizes about a life free from judgment and the need for constant justification.
“Sometimes the best way to get over someone is to get under someone else.”
— A casual, somewhat cynical observation made by a character about moving on from relationships.
“You can't go home again, but you can always go somewhere else.”
— Harry ponders the impossibility of returning to a former state of being, but the possibility of new beginnings.
“Forgiveness is a complicated thing. It's not just about letting go; it's about understanding.”
— Harry reflects on the nuances of forgiveness, especially in the context of his brother's actions.
“We all make mistakes. The trick is to make new ones, not the same old ones.”
— Harry considers the iterative nature of human error and the potential for growth.
“The world keeps turning, whether you're ready or not.”
— Harry observes the unrelenting passage of time and events, regardless of personal readiness.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
The novel follows Harry, a quiet Nixon scholar, whose life is upended after his volatile brother, George, commits a horrific act. Harry is forced to take responsibility for George's family and navigate a chaotic new existence filled with unexpected relationships, legal battles, and personal transformation, all while grappling with the complexities of modern American life.
About the author
A.M. Homes is an American writer of fiction, known for her provocative and often transgressive novels. Her acclaimed works include 'The End of Alice,' 'May We Be Forgiven,' which won the Orange Prize for Fiction, and 'This Book Will Save Your Life.' Homes' writing is characterized by its unflinching exploration of identity, family, and societal norms.
