“There was a reason he was alive. There was a reason he had survived. And it wasn’t just to be a good dad.”
— Main character Jake Gillen reflecting on his purpose after a traumatic event.
Archivist's Choice
Look Again
Lisa Scottoline (2009)
Genre
Thriller / Mystery
Reading Time
420 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
A journalist's world shatters when a 'Have You Seen This Child?' flyer reveals her adopted son is the spitting image of a missing boy, forcing her to investigate a truth that could cost her everything, including the child she loves.
Synopsis
Ellen Gleeson, a journalist, gets a 'Have You Seen This Child?' flyer with a boy identical to her adopted son, Will. Despite her initial denial, her instincts push her to investigate, fearing her adoption might be a lie. Her inquiry leads her to Dr. Reed, the adoption agency director, and then to the Maxwells, the biological parents of the missing child, Michael. Ellen uncovers a conspiracy: Dr. Reed arranged Michael's abduction and illegal adoption to the Gleesons, driven by a personal vendetta against the Maxwells. As Ellen gets closer to the truth, she becomes a target, facing danger and a difficult choice: return Will to his biological parents, losing the son she loves, or fight to keep him? Ellen confronts Dr. Reed, rescues Michael, and makes the heartbreaking decision to reunite Michael with the Maxwells. She and her husband then cope with the loss and plan to rebuild their family.
Reading time
420 min
Difficulty
Medium
Pacing
Fast
Mood
Suspenseful, Emotional, Heart-wrenching, Thought-provoking
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy thrillers with a strong emotional core and a focus on ethical dilemmas, especially concerning motherhood and adoption.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer thrillers without significant emotional melodrama or find plots involving child abduction too distressing.
Plot Summary
The Unsettling Flyer
Ellen Gleeson, an investigative reporter, is home with her five-year-old adopted son, Will, when she receives a 'Have You Seen This Child?' flyer. She dismisses it at first, but a closer look makes her heart stop: the boy in the photo, Michael, looks exactly like Will. The flyer states Michael was abducted three years earlier from a park. Ellen's maternal instincts clash with her journalistic curiosity. She knows her adoption of Will was legal, but the striking similarity between the two boys sparks a deep unease and an urgent need to investigate, despite the potential consequences for her family.
Initial Investigation and Denial
Ellen starts her investigation by discreetly researching the flyer. She learns Michael's parents are Caroline and David Maxwell. She also finds that Michael's abduction happened around the same time she adopted Will. She visits Allentown, pretending to work on a different story, trying to find information about the Maxwells or Michael's disappearance without revealing her true purpose. The more she digs, the more coincidences appear, making it harder to dismiss the possibility that Will could be Michael. She struggles with whether to pursue the truth or protect her family and the life she has built with Will.
The First Confrontation
Ellen's colleague and friend, Zack, notices her secretive behavior and unusual interest in a cold missing child case. He confronts her, and Ellen, overwhelmed, tells him her suspicions about Will and the flyer. Zack, initially doubtful and worried for Ellen's well-being, advises her to drop the investigation, fearing it will destroy her life and Will's. Their argument shows the immense pressure Ellen is under and her isolation in pursuing such a sensitive truth. Despite Zack's warnings, Ellen's resolve to uncover the truth only grows stronger.
Meeting the Maxwells
Using her journalistic cover, Ellen arranges to meet Caroline and David Maxwell. She carefully crafts her questions to learn about Michael's abduction, their family life, and specific details about Michael's appearance and mannerisms. The interview is emotional, as the Maxwells recount their heartbreak and ongoing pain. Ellen watches Caroline closely, noting her deep grief, but also a certain defensiveness. Ellen feels conflicted, sympathizing with their loss while dreading that their son might indeed be hers, making the situation even more agonizing.
The Adoption Agency and Dr. Reed
Ellen turns her attention to the adoption agency that handled Will's adoption. She asks for his original files, but the agency is unhelpful, citing privacy rules and missing records. She then tries to contact Dr. Reed, the lawyer who handled Will's adoption, but finds his office closed and his whereabouts unknown. The lack of transparency and missing documents raise Ellen's suspicions. She realizes someone might have deliberately hidden the paper trail, suggesting a deeper conspiracy beyond a simple mistake. This discovery strengthens her resolve, turning her investigation into a search for justice.
A Dangerous Discovery
Ellen's persistent digging uncovers a network of illegal adoptions run by Dr. Reed, the lawyer from Will's adoption. She finds evidence of fake birth certificates, forged documents, and a system designed to place children from vulnerable situations with unsuspecting adoptive parents for money. This confirms her worst fears: Will's adoption was not legal. She realizes Dr. Reed was part of a baby-selling ring, and her son was likely taken from his birth parents. This revelation is a devastating blow, confirming Will's true identity as Michael and exposing the dark side of the adoption system.
The Confrontation with Dr. Reed
Ellen, now with clear evidence, tracks down Dr. Reed. She confronts him, demanding answers about Will's true parents and the illegal adoption. Dr. Reed, cornered, first tries to deny everything, but Ellen's journalistic skills and evidence are too strong. The confrontation escalates, and Dr. Reed, desperate to protect his secrets, becomes threatening. He makes it clear that Ellen's life, and possibly Will's, is in danger if she continues to expose him. This encounter shows that Ellen is now not just a reporter, but a target.
The Truth About Michael's Abduction
Through her investigation, Ellen discovers that Michael Maxwell was not abducted by a stranger, but by his own father, David Maxwell, with Dr. Reed's help. David, facing financial problems and a failing relationship with Caroline, faked Michael's 'abduction' to collect insurance money and to sell Michael into an illegal adoption, believing it would be better for the child. This is a shocking twist, showing David Maxwell as a villain rather than a grieving father. Ellen realizes the depth of the deception and the cruelty involved in tearing a family apart for money.
A Mother's Dilemma
With the truth exposed, Ellen faces the hardest decision of her life: should she reveal everything and return Will to his biological mother, Caroline, or should she keep him, knowing the pain it would cause Caroline? The thought of losing Will is unbearable, but her journalistic ethics and moral compass push her to consider what is right. She sees Will, happy and thriving with her, and the thought of disrupting his life is agonizing. This internal struggle is the core of her conflict, highlighting the impossible choice between two kinds of love and two definitions of motherhood.
The Climax and Rescue
As Ellen prepares to expose the truth, Dr. Reed and his associates, realizing she is too close, try to silence her and get Will back. Ellen and Will are forced to run, leading to a tense and dangerous chase. With Zack's help, Ellen evades her pursuers, using her skills to anticipate their moves and protect Will. The chase ends in a desperate struggle, where Ellen fights for her life and Will's, showing a mother's fierce protective instinct. They narrowly escape, but the ordeal leaves them both shaken.
Justice and Reunion
After the harrowing escape, Ellen, with Zack's support, gives all the evidence to the authorities. Dr. Reed and David Maxwell are arrested and charged with kidnapping, fraud, and illegal adoptions. The truth about Michael Maxwell's abduction is made public. After much thought and emotional pain, Ellen makes the incredibly difficult decision to arrange a reunion between Will/Michael and Caroline Maxwell. It is a bittersweet moment, full of both joy and deep sadness, as Ellen deals with the loss of the son she raised but finds comfort in doing the right thing.
Moving Forward
Afterward, Ellen deals with the grief of letting Will go, but also a sense of peace, knowing she acted with integrity. She continues her career as an investigative reporter, now with a deeper understanding of human suffering and the complexities of justice. Will, now Michael, slowly bonds with Caroline, adapting to his new life while still remembering Ellen. The story ends with Ellen finding a path forward, forever changed by the experience, but also stronger from her courage and love. She stays in contact with Michael, ensuring he knows he has two mothers who love him.
Principal Figures
Ellen Gleeson
The Protagonist
Ellen transforms from a content adoptive mother to a woman torn between maternal love and moral duty, ultimately making the heartbreaking choice to reunite Will with his biological mother and finding a new sense of purpose.
Will Gleeson / Michael Maxwell
The Central Figure
Will's arc involves the revelation of his true identity and the traumatic transition from one loving home to another, ultimately beginning to adapt to his biological family.
Zack
The Supporting
Zack moves from a cautious friend to an indispensable and brave ally, risking his own safety to help Ellen and Will.
Caroline Maxwell
The Supporting
Caroline's arc begins in prolonged grief and ends with the miraculous reunion with her son, Michael, bringing a bittersweet closure to her suffering.
David Maxwell
The Antagonist
David's arc reveals his true villainous nature, moving from a seemingly grieving father to a criminal exposed and brought to justice.
Dr. Reed
The Antagonist
Dr. Reed's arc reveals him as the orchestrator of the illegal adoptions, culminating in his desperate attempts to silence Ellen and his eventual arrest.
Themes & Insights
The Nature of Motherhood and Love
The novel explores what it means to be a mother, questioning traditional ideas of biological versus adoptive bonds. Ellen's love for Will is unconditional, driving her to protect him at all costs, even risking her life. The difficult choice of returning Will to his biological mother, Caroline, highlights the complex nature of maternal love. The story suggests that motherhood is defined not by biology, but by the love, care, and sacrifice a woman makes for a child, as seen in Ellen's selfless decision for Will/Michael.
“She was his mother, not by blood, but by every beat of her heart, by every sleepless night, by every scraped knee she'd kissed better.”
Truth Versus Protection
A main theme is the conflict between Ellen's journalistic search for truth and her desire to protect her family. As a reporter, Ellen seeks facts, but the truth she uncovers could destroy her life and her son's. The novel asks if some truths are better left hidden to preserve happiness. Ellen constantly struggles with the moral implications of her investigation: should she expose the illegal adoption, knowing it means losing Will, or should she live a lie to keep him safe? Her final choice reflects a commitment to a higher moral truth, despite the personal cost.
“Sometimes the truth was a weapon, and she was afraid of what it would destroy.”
Justice and Corruption
The novel reveals corruption within the adoption system, where children are trafficked for money. Dr. Reed and David Maxwell represent those who exploit desperate situations and legal loopholes. Ellen's investigation becomes a quest for justice, not just for Michael/Will but for all children and families affected by such schemes. The theme highlights the importance of integrity and the power of an individual to fight against systemic wrongdoing. The eventual arrest of the culprits shows that justice, though difficult to achieve, can win.
“There was a darkness in the world, she realized, that preyed on the innocent, and she had stumbled right into its heart.”
Identity and Belonging
Identity is central to Will/Michael's character. He is a child with two names, two families, and a broken past. The story explores how such a revelation affects a young child and the complex process of forming a sense of self when one's origins are tangled in deception. For Ellen, her identity as a mother is challenged, forcing her to redefine what family means. The novel suggests that identity is not only tied to biological roots but also to the experiences, love, and relationships that shape a person.
“He was Will, her Will, but he was also Michael, a boy lost and found, and the two could not exist without tearing each other apart.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
The 'Have You Seen This Child?' Flyer
The catalyst that ignites Ellen's investigation and the central mystery.
This flyer serves as the inciting incident of the entire plot. Its arrival in Ellen's mail, featuring a boy identical to her adopted son, immediately creates the central conflict and dilemma. It acts as a direct link between Ellen's seemingly settled life and the hidden, traumatic past. The flyer is a physical manifestation of the truth Ellen desperately wants to ignore but cannot, compelling her to 'look again' and unravel the mystery, setting the entire suspenseful narrative in motion.
The Uncanny Resemblance
The striking physical similarity between Will and Michael, fueling Ellen's suspicions.
The near-identical appearance of Will and Michael is the primary driver of Ellen's suspicion and subsequent investigation. It's a visual, undeniable clue that Ellen, as a reporter, cannot dismiss as mere coincidence. This strong resemblance acts as a persistent, nagging doubt that overrides her desire for denial, pushing her to seek answers. It serves as a constant reminder of the potential truth, making the emotional stakes incredibly high and lending credibility to Ellen's otherwise improbable theory.
Investigative Journalism Skills
Ellen's professional abilities are crucial to uncovering the truth.
Ellen's background and training as an investigative reporter are essential plot devices. Her ability to research, interview, gather evidence, discern lies, and connect disparate pieces of information allows her to systematically unravel the complex web of lies and corruption surrounding Will's adoption. Without her professional skills, the truth might never have been uncovered. This device not only drives the plot forward but also provides a realistic framework for how such a complex mystery could be solved by an ordinary individual.
Missing/Falsified Documents
The deliberate obfuscation of records to hide the illegal adoption scheme.
The absence of complete adoption records and the presence of falsified documents at the adoption agency and from Dr. Reed are crucial plot devices. These irregularities immediately signal that something is amiss and confirm Ellen's suspicions of foul play. They create obstacles for Ellen's investigation, forcing her to dig deeper and more dangerously. This device highlights the systemic nature of the corruption and raises the stakes, indicating that powerful forces are trying to keep the truth buried.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“The truth was a weapon, and sometimes it was better to keep it sheathed.”
— Jake contemplating whether to reveal a dangerous truth he uncovered.
“Every secret had a shelf life. Eventually, it rotted.”
— Jake realizing the futility of trying to keep a major secret hidden.
“He was a reporter. His job was to find the truth, even when it was ugly. Especially when it was ugly.”
— Jake reminding himself of his journalistic principles amidst personal turmoil.
“You couldn't outrun your past, not really. It always had a way of catching up.”
— Jake feeling the weight of past decisions and events resurfacing.
“Fear was a powerful motivator, but it was also a terrible guide.”
— Jake grappling with his fears and trying to make rational decisions.
“Sometimes the people you trusted the most were the ones who could hurt you the deepest.”
— Jake's growing suspicion about someone close to him.
“The line between good and evil wasn't always clear. Sometimes it was a blur, or even invisible.”
— Jake observing the moral complexities of the characters and situations around him.
“He realized that sometimes, you had to break the rules to do the right thing.”
— Jake making a difficult ethical choice to protect his family.
“Love made you vulnerable, but it also made you strong.”
— Jake reflecting on his feelings for his family and how it impacts his actions.
“The quiet moments were often the most dangerous. That's when you let your guard down.”
— Jake experiencing a false sense of security before another threat emerges.
“He understood then that some truths were meant to stay buried, not for the sake of the living, but for the peace of the dead.”
— Jake contemplating the impact of revealing a truth on the memory of someone deceased.
“You could forgive, but you never truly forgot. The scars remained.”
— Jake dealing with the emotional aftermath of traumatic events.
“The most ordinary people could harbor the most extraordinary secrets.”
— Jake's realization about the hidden lives of seemingly normal individuals.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
Ellen receives a 'Have You Seen This Child?' flyer in the mail. Upon closer inspection, she notices that the boy in the photograph bears an uncanny resemblance to her adopted son, Will, which immediately raises her suspicions and prompts her to look into the matter.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
