“Every choice you make, no matter how small, branches off into an infinite number of possibilities.”
— The core concept of the multiverse and parallel lives is introduced to Hadley.
Archivist's Choice
In Some Other Life
Jessica Brody (2017)
Genre
Fantasy / Science Fiction / Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
9-10 hours
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
After a devastating betrayal, a girl's wish to rewrite her past at an elite private school comes true, only for her to discover that even the road not taken has its own heartbreaks and hidden truths.
Synopsis
Kennedy Rhodes faces a big decision: accept a scholarship to the elite Windsor Academy or stay at Northwood High for her boyfriend, Ben. She chooses Ben, but three years later, her world shatters when she finds Ben cheating with her best friend. Devastated, Kennedy wishes she had chosen Windsor. A head injury transports her into an alternate reality where she *did* attend Windsor Academy. Here, she is popular, has a new boyfriend, and a seemingly perfect life, but she is haunted by fragmented memories of her 'original' life and a growing sense of unease. As she navigates this new reality, she uncovers secrets about Windsor, her new friends, and even Ben, who exists in this timeline but is a stranger. Kennedy learns that a mysterious 'switcher' might be behind her altered life, and she must decide whether to fight her way back to her original, flawed existence or embrace the seemingly perfect, yet unfamiliar, life she now inhabits, confronting the true meaning of happiness and the impact of her choices.
Reading time
9-10 hours
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Intriguing, Romantic, Reflective, Hopeful
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy 'what if' scenarios, alternate realities, and a blend of romance and self-discovery with a YA focus.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer hard science fiction over soft fantasy elements, or dislike love triangles and high school drama.
Plot Summary
The Crossroads Decision
Three years before the main events, fifteen-year-old Kennedy Rhodes is at a crossroads. She has been accepted into the prestigious, arts-focused Windsor Academy, a dream opportunity for her artistic ambitions. However, she also has a crush on the popular football player, Jake Shelby, who attends her local public school, Northwood High. Driven by her feelings for Jake and a desire for a 'normal' high school experience with her best friend, Lauren, Kennedy declines Windsor and chooses Northwood. This decision makes her Jake's girlfriend and Lauren's inseparable companion.
The Crushing Betrayal
Three years after her decision, Kennedy's seemingly perfect life shatters. She walks in on her long-term boyfriend, Jake Shelby, kissing her best friend, Lauren, in Jake's bedroom. The betrayal is devastating, as both people she trusted most have conspired against her. Overwhelmed by shock, anger, and sadness, Kennedy flees, her world crumbling. This moment of heartbreak and regret triggers a desperate wish for a different life, specifically the one she might have had if she had chosen Windsor Academy.
A Life Rewritten: Windsor Kennedy
Distraught and disoriented after the confrontation, Kennedy runs into the street and is hit by a car. She wakes up in a hospital, but something is different. Her parents tell her she has been unconscious for a day, and she is confused when they talk about her 'roommate' and 'classes at Windsor.' To her astonishment, she is in an alternate reality where she *did* choose Windsor Academy three years ago. In this life, she is a talented art student, shares a room with a girl named Emily, and has no memory of Jake or Lauren as significant figures in her life.
Navigating the New Reality
Kennedy, now 'Windsor Kennedy' in her internal monologue, struggles to navigate this foreign existence. Her art skills are far more advanced, she has a different group of friends, and her personality seems more confident and outspoken. She learns she is part of a close-knit group that includes Emily, a quirky aspiring filmmaker, and a charming, intelligent boy named Ben, who seems to have a history with her. The absence of Jake and Lauren is jarring, but she tries to piece together the details of this new life, including her academic commitments and social standing, all while feeling like an imposter.
The Northwood Connection
While at a local diner, Kennedy spots a girl who looks exactly like her, but with a different demeanor and style. This is 'Northwood Kennedy,' the version of herself who chose Northwood High. The encounter is brief and confusing, but it confirms to Windsor Kennedy that her original life still exists somewhere. Later, she learns about 'parallel lives' from a mysterious book she finds, hinting that her current situation might be more than a dream or hallucination. She becomes determined to understand how she got here and if she can return.
Ben's Role and the Journal
As Kennedy spends more time with Ben in the Windsor reality, she is drawn to his kindness, intelligence, and genuine interest in her art. He becomes a confidant, and she starts to develop feelings for him, complicating her desire to return to her original life. She also discovers a hidden journal in her Windsor room, detailing the thoughts and feelings of 'Windsor Kennedy' leading up to the choices she made. This journal provides insights into the motivations and personality of her alternate self, revealing a Kennedy who prioritized her artistic dreams.
The Paradox of Perfection
Initially, Kennedy sees her Windsor life as the 'perfect' alternative, free from the heartbreak of Jake and Lauren. However, as she looks deeper, she uncovers its own complexities. She learns that 'Windsor Kennedy' struggled with immense pressure to succeed in art, felt isolated from her family due to her boarding school life, and had her own romantic complications, particularly a past heartbreak involving Ben. She realizes that no life is without its challenges, and her initial idealized view of Windsor life begins to crumble.
Seeking the 'Switcher'
Through cryptic messages and further research, Kennedy discovers 'Switchers' — individuals who can move between parallel lives, often triggered by moments of intense regret or desire. She suspects the car accident might have been her trigger. Driven by a longing for her original life, or at least a clearer understanding of her situation, she seeks information about how to control this ability or, ideally, reverse it. Her quest leads her to believe there is a specific method or person who can help her navigate these alternate realities.
The Choice Revisited
Kennedy eventually meets a figure who explains her predicament and the concept of 'choice points' — moments where a significant decision branches into different realities. She understands that her initial choice to stay at Northwood and her subsequent regret after the betrayal were powerful enough to send her to the Windsor reality. She is given the opportunity to make a conscious choice: embrace her Windsor life, try to return to her original Northwood life, or explore yet another path. This forces her to deeply analyze what truly makes her happy and fulfilled.
The Confession and the Realization
Kennedy confesses her true situation to Ben, who, despite his initial shock, is understanding and supportive. This moment solidifies her feelings for him. She realizes that while she was initially driven by regret, both lives have shaped her. The betrayal in her Northwood life, while painful, taught her resilience, and her Windsor life allowed her to embrace her artistic passion and discover a new kind of love. She understands that true happiness is not about finding the 'perfect' life, but about making choices that align with her authentic self and taking ownership of her path.
Embracing a New Path
After much introspection and guidance, Kennedy makes a conscious decision not to simply return to her old life or stay in the Windsor one out of obligation. Instead, she chooses a path that synthesizes the lessons learned from both realities. She decides to pursue her artistic dreams while also prioritizing genuine connection and self-worth. This decision shows her growth from a reactive individual to an empowered one, taking control of her destiny rather than being swayed by regret or idealized notions of what 'could have been.' She chooses to create her own best life, rather than simply wishing for a different one.
Principal Figures
Kennedy Rhodes
The Protagonist
From a regretful, heartbroken girl wishing for a do-over, Kennedy evolves into a self-aware, empowered young woman who understands that happiness comes from within and from making conscious choices aligned with her true self.
Jake Shelby
The Antagonist/Catalyst
Jake's character remains static, serving primarily as a plot device to trigger Kennedy's emotional crisis and subsequent journey of self-discovery.
Lauren
The Antagonist/Catalyst
Lauren's character, like Jake's, remains largely static, serving as a catalyst for Kennedy's emotional trauma and the subsequent plot.
Ben
The Supporting/Love Interest
Ben's arc is less about personal change and more about supporting Kennedy's growth, ultimately finding a renewed connection and potential future with her.
Emily
The Supporting
Emily's arc is primarily to be a supportive friend and provide exposition about the Windsor reality.
The Switcher/Guide
The Mentioned/Supporting
This character's arc is limited to their role as a mentor or guide for Kennedy.
Themes & Insights
The Power of Choice and Regret
The novel explores how decisions shape our lives and how regret can be a powerful force. Kennedy's initial choice between Windsor and Northwood, driven by a desire for romance and normalcy, sets the stage. Her regret after the betrayal is the catalyst for her shift into an alternate reality. The story argues that while regret can offer a chance for introspection, true empowerment comes from making conscious choices in the present, rather than dwelling on 'what ifs.' Her journey forces her to actively choose her path, rather than passively accepting one.
“Sometimes, the only way to figure out what you truly want is to see what you could have had.”
Identity and Self-Discovery
Kennedy's journey through parallel lives is a quest for self-identity. She encounters two distinct versions of herself — the Northwood Kennedy who prioritized relationships and the Windsor Kennedy who pursued art. By inhabiting both lives, she learns different facets of her personality, talents, and desires. She grapples with who she 'truly' is, whether it is defined by her choices, her relationships, or her passions. The experience allows her to synthesize these different selves, leading her to a more integrated and authentic understanding of who she wants to be, independent of external circumstances.
“Maybe the real me wasn't in either life. Maybe the real me was somewhere in between, still figuring things out.”
The Illusion of the 'Perfect' Life
Initially, Kennedy sees her Windsor life as the 'perfect' alternative, free from the heartbreak of her original reality. However, as she integrates into it, she discovers that even this seemingly ideal life has its own set of pressures, challenges, and past heartbreaks (e.g., 'Windsor Kennedy's' artistic struggles and past with Ben). This theme highlights that no life is without its difficulties, and happiness is not about finding a flawless existence, but rather about how one navigates the inevitable ups and downs. It challenges the common human tendency to idealize paths not taken.
“There was no perfect life. Just different choices, different problems.”
Love, Betrayal, and Forgiveness
The story begins with a deep betrayal from both Kennedy's boyfriend and best friend, which causes immense emotional pain and fuels her desire for a different life. This experience forces her to confront the nature of trust and the devastating impact of its breach. As she navigates her new reality, she finds a different kind of love with Ben, one built on mutual respect and understanding. Ultimately, the theme extends to self-forgiveness and accepting that past hurts, while real, do not have to define one's future choices.
“Betrayal wasn't just losing someone. It was losing a piece of yourself, too.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
Parallel Worlds/Alternate Realities
The central conceit of the story, allowing the protagonist to experience the consequences of a different life choice.
This device is the core of the narrative, enabling Kennedy to literally step into a reality divergent from her own due to a past decision. It allows the author to explore the 'what if' scenario, presenting a direct comparison of two potential life paths. It serves as a powerful tool for character development, as Kennedy gains perspective on her choices and values by living through their different outcomes. The existence of these parallel worlds is initially presented as a mysterious event, later explained by the concept of 'Switchers' and 'choice points,' grounding the fantastical element within the story's rules.
The 'Switcher' Mechanism
The explanation for how individuals can move between parallel lives, often triggered by intense regret.
This device provides the pseudo-scientific or fantastical framework for Kennedy's predicament. It explains that moments of profound emotional intensity, particularly regret, can act as a trigger for a person to 'switch' into a parallel life where a different choice was made. This mechanism not only justifies the plot's fantastical premise but also emphasizes the thematic importance of regret and choice. By introducing the idea that one can learn to control or understand this switching, it gives Kennedy agency in her journey, moving her from being a passive recipient of circumstances to an active participant in her destiny.
The Journal
A diary written by 'Windsor Kennedy' that provides insight into her life and motivations.
The discovery of 'Windsor Kennedy's' journal is a crucial expository device. It allows 'Northwood Kennedy' to access the inner thoughts, feelings, and experiences of her alternate self without direct interaction. This provides vital background information about the Windsor reality, its characters, and the pressures 'Windsor Kennedy' faced. More importantly, it helps 'Northwood Kennedy' understand the motivations behind her alternate self's choices, fostering empathy and a deeper understanding of the complexities of that life, thereby challenging her initial idealized view of it.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“What if the life you're living right now isn't the only one you're meant to have?”
— Hadley grapples with the idea of other versions of herself living different lives.
“Sometimes the biggest what-ifs aren't about the choices you made, but the ones you didn't.”
— Reflecting on missed opportunities and unspoken feelings.
“Love isn't about finding the perfect person; it's about seeing an imperfect person perfectly.”
— Hadley's evolving understanding of love and relationships across different realities.
“Every version of you is still you. Just a different shade, a different path.”
— Realizing that her core identity persists despite different life circumstances.
“There's a fine line between fate and the choices we make to create our own destiny.”
— Debating the influence of predetermined paths versus free will.
“You can't live a full life if you're always wondering about the lives you didn't choose.”
— Learning to embrace the present and the path she is on.
“Sometimes the greatest adventures are the ones you never planned for.”
— Hadley's unexpected journey through parallel lives.
“The heart has a way of knowing what it wants, even when the mind is confused.”
— Her feelings for Caleb remain consistent across different realities.
“Maybe true happiness isn't about having everything, but appreciating what you have in the life you're in.”
— Coming to terms with her current reality after experiencing others.
“It's not about finding the 'right' life, but making the life you have right.”
— A profound realization about agency and satisfaction.
“Every 'what if' is a ghost of a possibility, a whisper of a different future.”
— Contemplating the endless array of unchosen paths.
“You can't change the past, but you can always choose how you move forward.”
— Emphasizing personal growth and resilience despite past decisions.
“The magic isn't in escaping your life, but in finding the magic within it.”
— Hadley's ultimate understanding after her journey through the multiverse.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
The book follows Kennedy Rhodes, who, after discovering her long-term boyfriend is cheating, wishes she had made a different choice three years prior. She then experiences an alternate reality where she accepted an elite private school admission instead of staying for her high school boyfriend, exploring the 'what if' of her past decision.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
