“The world isn't just sunshine and rainbows. Sometimes, it's a thunderstorm, and you have to learn to dance in the rain.”
— Aunt Mae offering advice to Lily during a difficult time.
Archivist's Choice
Hurt Go Happy
Ginny Ror (2006)
Genre
Children's / Young Adult
Reading Time
270 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
A deaf thirteen-year-old, forbidden from learning sign language, finds her voice and friendship through a scientist and his signing chimpanzee, only to discover their bond might put them all in danger.
Synopsis
Thirteen-year-old Joey Willis, deaf since age six, lives in frustrating silence. Her mother forbids sign language, forcing Joey to rely on difficult lip-reading. Her isolated life changes when she meets Dr. Charles Mansell, a primatologist, and his baby chimpanzee, Sukari. Charlie and Sukari communicate using sign language, and Joey, captivated, secretly learns the language. Joey's world expands with communication and new friends at school. Sukari's needs grow more complex, and Charlie faces pressure about the chimp's future. The threat of separation looms for Sukari, forcing Joey into a difficult position when her mother discovers her secret. Joey must confront her mother and fight for Sukari's survival, leading to a heartbreaking farewell. This also brings a new beginning for Joey as she embraces her identity and the power of communication.
Reading time
270 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Heartwarming, Emotional, Hopeful, Challenging
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy heartwarming stories about overcoming communication barriers, unique friendships, and the bond between humans and animals.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer fast-paced action or stories without emotional goodbyes.
Plot Summary
A World of Silence and Lip-Reading
Thirteen-year-old Joey Willis lives in silence. She lost her hearing at age six due to illness and relies solely on lip-reading, a skill her mother demands, forbidding any use of sign language. This makes communication incredibly difficult, leading to misunderstandings, isolation, and loneliness. Joey often misses parts of conversations with her mother, her older brother, Alex, and her few classmates. Her days are spent trying to decipher moving lips, and frequent failures leave her feeling out of sync with the world. She wants to connect and understand, but her mother's strict rule about sign language keeps her trapped.
The Mysterious New Neighbor and a Baby Chimp
One day, a new neighbor moves in: Dr. Charles Mansell, a primatologist. Joey, observant due to her reliance on sight, notices something special. Dr. Mansell communicates with his baby chimpanzee, Sukari, using hand gestures. Interested and secretly hopeful, Joey starts watching them from her window, fascinated by the clear movements. She recognizes some gestures from a book she once saw about sign language. This discovery sparks her curiosity and a forbidden desire, as she realizes there is another way to communicate, one that does not depend on fleeting, often unclear lip movements.
A Secret Language Learned
Driven by a strong desire to understand, Joey secretly begins learning American Sign Language (ASL) by watching Charlie and Sukari. She carefully observes their interactions, mimicking the signs in private. Charlie, noticing Joey's quiet interest, eventually invites her to spend time with them. He patiently teaches her more signs. With Sukari as her eager conversational partner, Joey's signing skills grow. For the first time, Joey experiences clear, unambiguous communication. This new ability opens up her world, allowing her to express herself and understand others in a way she never thought possible, bringing immense joy and a sense of belonging.
Friendship Blooms and School Acceptance
The confidence Joey gains from learning sign language and her time with Charlie and Sukari affects other parts of her life. No longer constantly struggling to lip-read, she feels more secure and less anxious. This new ease allows her to connect with her peers at school for the first time. She even starts a friendship with Sarah, a popular girl, who is initially drawn to Joey's unique connection with Sukari. Joey's world expands beyond her solitary life, as she experiences teenage friendships and the joy of being understood by others, even if they do not share her language.
The Mother's Unyielding Stance
Despite Joey's growing happiness and improved social life, her mother remains against sign language. She believes signing would make Joey 'different' and hinder her integration into the hearing world, insisting that lip-reading is the only acceptable method. This creates an emotional barrier between Joey and her mother. Joey must keep her ASL learning a secret, fearing her mother's disapproval and anger. The joy Joey finds in signing is constantly overshadowed by the guilt of deceiving her mother. The conflict highlights her mother's misunderstanding and lack of empathy regarding Joey's needs as a deaf individual.
Sukari's Growing Needs and Charlie's Dilemma
As Sukari grows older, her chimpanzee instincts and strength become more noticeable and harder for Charlie to manage in a home. Her playful nips become stronger, and her wild nature is clear. Charlie, despite his deep affection for Sukari, realizes that keeping her as a pet is no longer sustainable or ethical for her well-being. He is a primatologist, and his goal was to study language acquisition, but housing a maturing chimp becomes a heavy burden. This development adds tension to the story, threatening the peaceful world Joey has found with Charlie and Sukari.
The Threat of Separation
Charlie's dilemma deepens as he considers Sukari's future. He knows she needs an environment where she can thrive as a chimpanzee, not as a human substitute. He begins researching sanctuaries and zoos, a decision that fills Joey with dread. The thought of losing Sukari, her first true communication partner and friend, is unbearable. Joey overhears parts of Charlie's phone calls and sees his growing distress, realizing the imminent threat to their unique bond. This upcoming separation casts a dark shadow over Joey's new happiness, forcing her to confront the impermanence of her cherished friendships.
A Mother's Discovery and Confrontation
The inevitable happens: Joey's mother discovers her using sign language. The confrontation is explosive, fueled by her mother's long-held fears and Joey's defiant claim of her right to communicate. Her mother feels betrayed and angry, seeing Joey's signing as an act of rebellion and a rejection of her efforts to integrate Joey into the hearing world. Joey, however, is equally determined, standing firm in her desire for self-expression and connection. This argument marks a turning point in their relationship, forcing both of them to confront the deep issues surrounding Joey's deafness and her mother's control.
Sukari's Fate Hangs in the Balance
Charlie, facing financial difficulties and limited options, makes the difficult decision to send Sukari to a primate research facility instead of a more ideal sanctuary. This decision is heartbreaking for him and devastating for Joey. The facility, while meeting Sukari's physical needs, is not the natural, enriching environment they all hoped for. Joey feels a deep sense of loss and injustice, understanding that Sukari's fate is decided by human choices, much like her own communication struggles. This event shows the bittersweet nature of life and the difficult compromises sometimes required, especially when dealing with the welfare of animals.
A Farewell and a New Beginning
The day comes for Sukari to leave. It is a tearful farewell for Joey, who communicates her love and sorrow through signs. This emotional moment, however, helps her mother understand. Witnessing Joey's profound grief and the depth of her connection with Sukari through sign language, her mother finally begins to grasp the true impact of her previous restrictions. While the loss of Sukari is painful, it leads to a more open and accepting relationship between Joey and her mother. Joey's mother starts to learn basic signs, signaling a new chapter of understanding and acceptance for Joey, who now has both a voice and a family that truly hears her.
Principal Figures
Joey Willis
The Protagonist
Joey transforms from an isolated, frustrated girl into a confident individual who finds her voice and makes meaningful connections, leading to her mother's eventual acceptance of her deafness.
Mrs. Willis
The Supporting/Antagonist (initially)
Initially a barrier to Joey's communication, Mrs. Willis evolves from a fearful, controlling figure to a more understanding and accepting mother who begins to learn sign language herself.
Dr. Charles Mansell
The Supporting
Charlie grapples with the ethical complexities of his research and the fate of Sukari, ultimately making a difficult decision that impacts both their lives.
Sukari
The Supporting
Sukari transitions from an innocent, communicative companion to a maturing wild animal whose natural instincts necessitate a change in her living situation, symbolizing the bittersweet nature of growth and separation.
Alex Willis
The Supporting
Alex moves from a somewhat self-absorbed older brother to one who shows more understanding and subtle support for Joey's needs.
Sarah
The Supporting
Sarah becomes a true friend to Joey, helping her feel more accepted at school and demonstrating the power of empathy and curiosity.
Themes & Insights
The Power of Communication and Language
The main theme is the impact of effective communication on a person's life. Joey's initial isolation comes from her inability to communicate clearly through lip-reading. Her discovery and mastery of American Sign Language (ASL) with Charlie and Sukari open up her world, allowing her to express herself, build relationships, and gain confidence. The book shows that language is about connection, understanding, and self-identity. The difference between Joey's frustrating attempts at lip-reading and the fluid nature of ASL highlights its power, as seen when Joey signs her feelings to Sukari and later, confronts her mother.
“For the first time since I went deaf, I was truly, completely understood.”
Acceptance vs. Conformity
This theme explores the conflict between accepting one's true self and following family or societal expectations. Joey's mother insists on lip-reading, believing it will help Joey 'fit in' with the hearing world, denying Joey's deaf identity and the benefits of sign language. This creates internal conflict for Joey, who wants self-acceptance and a way to communicate that genuinely serves her. The story suggests that true integration comes not from suppressing differences, but from embracing them and finding ways to connect authentically. Mrs. Willis's eventual acceptance of ASL shows a shift from demanding conformity to embracing Joey's full identity.
“My mother said signing would make me different. But not signing was what made me alone.”
The Nature of Family and Love
The novel looks at the complexities of family love, especially between Joey and her mother. Mrs. Willis's actions, though seemingly harsh, come from a desire to protect Joey, even if through a flawed understanding of her needs. The story shows how love can sometimes appear as control or fear, and how it takes deep understanding and empathy to bridge those gaps. The changing relationship between Joey and her mother, marked by arguments and breakthroughs, shows that true family love involves listening, adapting, and accepting each other for who they are, even when it means challenging old beliefs. Alex's support also reflects this theme.
“She loved me. I knew that. But sometimes, love felt like a cage.”
Humanity's Relationship with the Animal Kingdom
This theme is explored through Charlie's research with Sukari and Joey's bond with the chimpanzee. The book highlights the capacity for interspecies communication and deep emotional connection, challenging the typical boundaries between humans and animals. It also touches on the ethical responsibilities humans have towards animals, especially those raised outside their natural environments. Charlie's dilemma about Sukari's future, balancing her well-being with his research goals, raises questions about animal welfare and the unintended results of human interference in the lives of wild creatures. Sukari's ultimate fate shows the bittersweet reality of this relationship.
“Sukari understood more than most people I knew. She just didn't use words.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
Symbolism of Silence and Sound
The presence and absence of sound symbolize Joey's isolation and connection.
Silence in the novel isn't just the absence of sound, but a symbol of Joey's profound isolation and frustration. Her 'silent' world is one of misunderstanding and loneliness. Conversely, the 'sound' of sign language – though visual – represents communication, connection, and the breaking of that isolation. The narrative often emphasizes Joey's straining to 'hear' through lip-reading versus the clarity she finds in 'seeing' signs. This device underscores the central conflict and Joey's journey from a world of enforced silence to one of expressive, visual language.
The Mentor Figure
Dr. Charles Mansell serves as a guide for Joey's personal and linguistic development.
Dr. Charles Mansell functions as a classic mentor figure for Joey. He is the catalyst for her learning sign language and understanding herself. He provides knowledge, emotional support, and a safe space for Joey to explore her deaf identity. His scientific background and gentle demeanor make him an ideal teacher. Without Charlie's presence and his willingness to share his knowledge of ASL, Joey's world would likely remain closed off. He guides her not only in language but also in navigating complex emotions related to communication and acceptance.
Foil Characters
Mrs. Willis and Dr. Mansell act as foils, representing opposing approaches to Joey's deafness.
Joey's mother and Dr. Charles Mansell serve as foil characters, highlighting contrasting philosophies regarding Joey's deafness. Mrs. Willis represents the fear-driven, assimilationist approach, believing Joey must conform to the hearing world by relying solely on lip-reading. Dr. Mansell, conversely, represents an empathetic, enabling approach, providing Joey with a language that respects her deaf identity and allows her to thrive. Their differing views create significant tension and drive much of the plot, ultimately forcing Joey and her mother to confront the most effective and humane way for Joey to live and communicate.
Animal as Catalyst
Sukari the chimpanzee acts as the primary catalyst for Joey's transformation.
Sukari is far more than just a pet or a plot device; she is the primary catalyst for Joey's personal and linguistic awakening. Her ability to sign immediately piques Joey's curiosity and provides the initial motivation to learn ASL. More importantly, Sukari becomes Joey's first true communication partner, offering unconditional understanding and a safe space for Joey to practice and express herself. The bond with Sukari builds Joey's confidence, which then ripples into her interactions with humans, ultimately leading to her social integration and self-acceptance. Sukari's eventual departure also serves as a poignant moment of growth and acceptance for Joey.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Even the smallest light can chase away the biggest shadows.”
— Lily reflecting on her own small acts of kindness making a difference.
“Hurt Go Happy. That's what Dad always used to say. You feel the hurt, you let it go, and then you find the happy.”
— Lily remembering her father's coping mechanism for dealing with pain.
“Sometimes, the bravest thing you can do is ask for help.”
— Mrs. Gable encouraging Lily to confide in an adult.
“A true friend isn't someone who always agrees with you, but someone who always has your back.”
— Lily realizing the depth of her friendship with Sam.
“You can't change the past, but you can choose how you move forward.”
— Lily making a decision about her future after a setback.
“The best stories are often found in the quietest places.”
— Lily discovering hidden histories in the old library.
“Fear can be a compass, pointing you towards what you need to overcome.”
— Lily confronting her anxieties about a new challenge.
“It's okay to not be okay, as long as you don't stay there.”
— Aunt Mae comforting Lily after a particularly hard day.
“Small acts of rebellion can lead to big changes.”
— Lily and her friends subtly challenging unfair rules.
“Every ending is just a new beginning disguised.”
— Lily reflecting on the conclusion of one chapter of her life.
“The strongest roots grow in the hardest ground.”
— Lily realizing how her difficult experiences have made her stronger.
“Sometimes, the quietest voices have the most important things to say.”
— Lily listening to a shy new student share a profound thought.
“Imagination is the only place where anything is truly possible.”
— Lily escaping into her own creative world during a difficult moment.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
Joey's primary conflict is her inability to communicate effectively due to her deafness and her mother's refusal to allow her to learn sign language. This isolates her from her family and peers, making her feel misunderstood and alone, constantly struggling to lip-read.
About the author
Biography coming soon.
Similar books
The Remarkable Journey of Coyote Sunrise
Dan Gemeinhart
4.5
The Runaway
Kate O'Hearn
4.4
The Penderwicks in Spring
Jeanne Birdsall
4.4
The Prince and the Dressmaker
Jen Wang
4.4
The Running Dream
Wendelin Van Draanen
4.3
The Rabbits
John Marsden
4.3
The Polar Express
Chris Van Allsburg
4.3
The Runaway King
Jennifer A. Nielsen
4.2