“I was never going to be the girl who waited for someone to save her. I was going to be the girl who saved herself.”
— Summer's internal monologue about her resilience and independence.

Penelope Douglas (2017)
Genre
Thriller / Fantasy / Mystery / Science Fiction
Reading Time
9-10 hours
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
A woman with a hidden past becomes entangled in a dangerous game of cat and mouse with a man seeking a mysterious twelfth floor in an abandoned hotel, all while struggling with an undeniable attraction that could betray her deepest secret.
Kai Mori is released after three years in prison for a crime committed with his friends Michael Crist, Damon Torrance, and Will Grayson III (the Horsemen). His immediate goal is to find a secret twelfth floor within The Pope, an abandoned hotel that holds dark memories for him and his friends. He believes Banks, the daughter of the hotel's former owner and a girl he knew in childhood, knows its location. Kai confronts Banks, now an adult and still affected by their past. He begins to manipulate and pressure her, believing she knows more about the hotel and a mysterious person they are all searching for.
Banks is haunted by her past interactions with the Horsemen, especially Kai, who used to terrorize her emotionally and physically during their Devil's Night games. She carries the burden of her father's secrets about The Pope hotel and the disappearance of another boy, Alex. Despite her fear and resentment towards Kai, she feels an undeniable, intense attraction to him, a feeling she has had since childhood. This internal conflict makes her vulnerable to Kai's demands and psychological games, as she tries to protect herself while being drawn into his dangerous world.
With Kai's return, the Horsemen — Kai, Michael, Damon, and Will — are reunited. They resume their Devil's Night games, a series of elaborate pranks and psychological warfare designed to push their targets to their limits. This time, Banks is their main focus. They believe she has important information about the hidden twelfth floor of The Pope and Alex's whereabouts. The games become a cat-and-mouse chase, with the Horsemen invading Banks's personal space, testing her resolve, and forcing her to confront the traumatic events of her past.
As the Devil's Night games intensify, the mystery of Alex's disappearance unfolds. Alex was a boy trapped in The Pope hotel years ago. Banks slowly reveals memories and knowledge about Alex, her father's involvement, and the hotel's secrets. Kai, driven by a need for answers and revenge, pushes her relentlessly. Together, they start piecing together the events that led to Alex's vanishing, realizing that the hotel's hidden twelfth floor is a place of dark significance where Alex was held captive and abused.
Under immense pressure and a growing sense of trust towards Kai, Banks finally leads him to the twelfth floor of The Pope hotel. This hidden floor is a prison where Alex was held captive and subjected to horrific abuse by Banks's father, Mr. Moretti, and his associates. The discovery is a shocking revelation, confirming the Horsemen's suspicions and validating Banks's traumatic memories. The floor shows the depravity that occurred within the hotel's walls, shedding light on the true nature of the 'ghost' they've been seeking.
The discovery of the twelfth floor forces Banks to confront the truth about her father, Mr. Moretti. She realizes he was not only aware but actively involved in Alex's abduction and abuse. This revelation shatters her perception of her father and her family, adding to her trauma. She grapples with the betrayal and the knowledge that her own home, the hotel, was a place of unspeakable horrors, orchestrated by the man who was supposed to protect her. This truth fuels her determination to seek justice for Alex and come to terms with her own role in keeping the secret, however unintentional.
The 'ghost' of the twelfth floor is Alex himself, who, after years of captivity and torture, escaped and reinvented himself. He is, in fact, Damon Torrance, one of the Horsemen. Damon orchestrated his own 'disappearance' and return to seek vengeance on his abusers, including Banks's father. His manipulative and cruel personality stems directly from his traumatic past. His presence among the Horsemen was a long-term strategy to infiltrate and destroy the lives of his tormentors, using his friends as unwitting pawns in his plan for retribution.
The revelation that Damon is Alex, and that he has been manipulating them, creates significant conflict among the Horsemen. Kai, Michael, and Will must re-evaluate their friendship with Damon and the nature of their Devil's Night games. They grapple with the moral implications of Damon's vengeful plan and their own roles in unwittingly helping him. While they understand his desire for revenge, they are disturbed by his extreme methods and deception, leading to tension and a fracturing of their bond. They must decide whether to continue supporting Damon or to find their own path to justice.
Throughout the escalating conflict and revelations, Banks and Kai's relationship deepens. Their initial dynamic of fear and manipulation transforms into a complex mix of understanding, protection, and intense passion. Kai, initially cold and distant, reveals his vulnerabilities and true feelings for Banks, which he has suppressed for years. Banks, in turn, finds solace and strength in Kai, recognizing that his harsh exterior hides a protective and caring man. Their shared trauma and mutual pursuit of justice forge a strong bond, leading to a powerful and intimate connection that transcends their past. They find a unique form of healing and acceptance in each other.
With the truth exposed, the Horsemen, now including Banks, pursue the remaining individuals involved in Alex's abuse. They use their resources and knowledge of the criminal underworld to track down those responsible, including corrupt officials and other associates of Banks's father. The confrontations are brutal and uncompromising, as they seek to deliver their own justice. This collective pursuit of vengeance strengthens their bond, even as they navigate the moral ambiguities of their actions, ensuring that all those who harmed Alex face retribution.
After intense confrontations and the delivery of justice to Alex's abusers, the immediate threat subsides. Banks and Kai, changed by their experiences, begin to forge a new path together. They acknowledge the darkness they've faced and the scars they carry, but also the strength and love they've found in each other. Banks starts to heal from her past trauma, while Kai finds a sense of purpose and belonging he never thought possible. Their relationship, forged in fire, becomes a foundation for a future where they can finally find peace and happiness, though still shadowed by Devil's Night.
The Protagonist
Banks transforms from a fearful, secretive young woman into a strong, self-aware individual who confronts her past and embraces her love for Kai.
The Protagonist/Love Interest
Kai evolves from a hardened, vengeful man focused solely on retribution to someone who embraces love and finds a deeper purpose beyond his past trauma.
The Antagonist/Supporting
Damon's arc is one of revelation, moving from a perceived antagonist to a tragic figure seeking justice, while struggling with the moral cost of his vengeance.
The Supporting
Michael grapples with the moral implications of their actions, ultimately choosing a path that seeks justice while maintaining his loyalty to his chosen family.
The Supporting
Will evolves from a silent observer to a more active participant in seeking justice, while still retaining his thoughtful and empathetic nature.
The Antagonist
Mr. Moretti's arc is one of exposure and eventual downfall, as his long-hidden crimes are brought to light and he faces retribution.
The novel explores how long-held secrets and unaddressed trauma corrupt individuals and relationships. Banks's father's secrets about Alex and the twelfth floor poison her family and the entire hotel, creating an atmosphere of fear and guilt for Banks. The Horsemen, especially Kai and Damon (Alex), are shaped by their own traumas and secrets, leading to destructive behaviors and a twisted sense of justice. The Devil's Night games are a manifestation of their inability to process their past, perpetuating a cycle of pain. Healing begins by exposing these secrets and confronting the trauma, as Banks and Kai eventually do.
““Some things are meant to stay buried. And some secrets are meant to die with you.””
A central theme is the blurred line between seeking justice and enacting vengeance. Damon, as Alex, is driven by a powerful desire for retribution against his abusers, which manifests in manipulative and often cruel actions. The Horsemen, initially seeking justice for their own perceived wrongs, are drawn into Damon's extreme quest for revenge. The novel questions whether their methods, however satisfying, truly are justice or simply perpetuate violence. Banks struggles with this, torn between her desire for the perpetrators to pay and her moral reservations about the Horsemen's vigilante approach. Ultimately, the characters must navigate this moral grey area to find a resolution.
““There’s a difference between justice and vengeance, Little One. And sometimes, it’s a line so thin you can’t tell which side you’re on.””
Despite the dark and violent backdrop, the novel explores how love can emerge and thrive amidst trauma and chaos. The intense, complex relationship between Banks and Kai is a prime example. Their bond is forged through shared pain, mutual understanding, and a willingness to confront their darkest selves together. Kai's protective instincts and Banks's resilience create a powerful connection that allows them to find solace and a path towards healing. Their love is gritty and hard-won, suggesting that even in the deepest shadows, genuine connection can offer hope and a chance for redemption.
““You were always mine, Banks. Even when I hated you, you were always mine.””
Memory, both repressed and resurfacing, is crucial in uncovering the truth. Banks has fragmented, traumatic memories of the hotel and Alex that she has suppressed due to their horrifying nature and her father's manipulation. The Horsemen's own memories of Alex's disappearance drive their quest. The novel shows how denial can protect individuals from unbearable truths, but also how these truths inevitably resurface, demanding to be acknowledged. Recalling and piecing together these memories is essential for the characters to understand their past, solve the mystery, and begin their journey towards healing and closure.
““The past never really dies. It just hides, waiting for the right moment to claw its way back out.””
A central setting that symbolizes hidden secrets, corruption, and past trauma.
The abandoned Pope hotel is more than just a setting; it's a character in itself, embodying the story's central mystery and the dark history of the Moretti family. The mythical 'twelfth floor' serves as the ultimate MacGuffin, driving the Horsemen's quest and representing the deepest, most horrific secret. Its hidden nature symbolizes the repression of trauma and the lengths people go to conceal their crimes. The hotel's decaying state mirrors the moral decay of those involved in Alex's abuse, and its eventual discovery is the key to unlocking the entire plot.
A series of elaborate, psychologically manipulative games used to uncover truths and exert control.
The Devil's Night games are a recurring plot device, serving multiple functions. They are a means for the Horsemen to exert control, test boundaries, and psychologically torment their targets, particularly Banks. More importantly, they are a twisted method of investigation, designed by Damon (Alex) to push Banks into revealing the secrets she holds about The Pope and Alex's disappearance. The games create suspense, highlight the characters' dark pasts, and showcase the intricate, often cruel, dynamics within the Horsemen and their interactions with Banks.
The use of hidden identities to facilitate manipulation and reveal shocking twists.
The most significant instance of this device is Damon Torrance's true identity as Alex. This revelation is a major plot twist that fundamentally changes the reader's understanding of the story and the characters' motivations. This device allows for an intricate web of manipulation and deception, as Alex, under the guise of Damon, orchestrates events from within the Horsemen. It underscores themes of hidden trauma, revenge, and the lengths to which a person will go to reclaim their life and exact retribution, making the audience question perceptions and allegiances.
Fragments of past events that slowly reveal the truth about Alex and The Pope hotel.
The narrative frequently employs flashbacks and the gradual surfacing of repressed memories, particularly from Banks's perspective. These fragments of the past are crucial for piecing together the mystery of Alex's disappearance and the atrocities committed in The Pope. The slow, often disorienting, revelation of these memories builds suspense and allows the reader to experience Banks's journey of discovery and healing. It highlights the psychological impact of trauma and the difficulty of confronting painful truths that have been buried for years.
“I was never going to be the girl who waited for someone to save her. I was going to be the girl who saved herself.”
— Summer's internal monologue about her resilience and independence.
“Some darknesses are too deep to ever truly escape. They just learn to hide better.”
— Reflecting on the lingering effects of past trauma and secrets.
“The past isn't a place you can visit. It's a weight you carry.”
— Discussing the inescapable burden of past events.
“Fear can be a weapon, but only if you learn to wield it.”
— Summer's realization about using her vulnerabilities as strengths.
“We're all broken, just in different places. The trick is finding someone whose broken pieces fit with yours.”
— A reflection on finding connection and understanding despite flaws.
“Sometimes the most dangerous things are the ones that look the most innocent.”
— A warning about appearances being deceiving in the hidden world.
“You can't outrun your demons, but you can learn to dance with them.”
— Coping with internal struggles and past trauma.
“Love isn't always gentle. Sometimes it's a storm, tearing everything apart before putting it back together stronger.”
— Describing a tumultuous and intense romantic relationship.
“The truth is rarely simple, and never easy.”
— Unraveling complex mysteries and hidden motives.
“There are no heroes and villains, only people making choices with the cards they're dealt.”
— A nuanced perspective on morality and human actions.
“Some scars never fade, they just become part of who you are.”
— Accepting the lasting impact of painful experiences.
“Silence can be louder than any scream when it hides a secret.”
— The oppressive weight of unspoken truths and hidden information.
“We were all just trying to survive the monsters, both outside and within.”
— Reflecting on the internal and external struggles faced by the characters.
“Sometimes the only way out is through the fire.”
— Facing difficult challenges head-on to overcome them.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.