Ashley Poston (2017)
Genre
Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
360 min
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
A Starfield-obsessed food truck worker finds her Prince Carmindor at a cosplay convention, navigating fandom skepticism and the magic of a shared universe.
Seventeen-year-old Elle Wittimer lives in a cramped apartment above the Magic Pumpkin food truck, which she inherited from her late father. Her stepmother, Catherine, and stepsisters, Chloe and Caliope, treat her as a servant. They force her to work long hours and deny her access to her father's Starfield memorabilia, including his collection of DVDs and comics. Elle finds comfort in the Starfield fandom, a sci-fi series she and her father loved together. She learns about an ExcelsiCon cosplay contest for the new Starfield movie reboot. The grand prize is tickets to the exclusive ExcelsiCon Cosplay Ball and a meet-and-greet with the actor playing Prince Carmindor. Despite her stepfamily's objections, Elle secretly plans to enter, using her father's old Carmindor costume.
Darien Freeman, the teen actor cast as Prince Carmindor in the Starfield reboot, is filled with anxiety and self-doubt. The Starfield fandom has largely rejected him, calling him a talentless pretty boy who cannot do justice to their beloved character. His publicist, Frank, constantly manages his image, pushing him to maintain a specific persona that feels fake to Darien. He secretly wants to connect with genuine fans but feels trapped by his career and the negativity he receives online. He is preparing for ExcelsiCon, where he will make his first major appearance as Carmindor, dreading the fan backlash and the pressure to perform.
While working at the Magic Pumpkin, Elle's old phone malfunctions, sending a text to a random number. This number belongs to Darien Freeman, who feels overwhelmed by his career and the negativity. They begin an anonymous text conversation, with Elle identifying herself only as 'Geekerella' and Darien as 'Carmindor.' They share their frustrations and passions, finding a surprising connection and understanding. Elle confides her dreams of winning the cosplay contest and her love for Starfield, while Darien expresses his anxieties about the role and his desire to prove himself to the fandom, without revealing his true identity.
Elle spends her free time restoring her father's old Prince Carmindor costume for the ExcelsiCon contest. She cleans and repairs it carefully, putting her heart into every detail as a tribute to her father and her love for Starfield. Her stepsisters, Chloe and Caliope, also plan to enter the contest, hoping to use it to gain fame. They are jealous of Elle's talent and her connection to their father's legacy. They often try to sabotage her efforts, hiding her supplies, making snide remarks, and trying to discourage her from participating, seeing her as competition.
Catherine gets a prime vending spot for the Magic Pumpkin food truck at ExcelsiCon, which upsets Elle because it means more work during the convention she wants to enjoy. However, this also places Elle in the middle of the action, allowing her to experience the atmosphere and see the fandom firsthand. While working, she continues her anonymous text conversations with Darien, exchanging excited messages about the convention's energy. She observes Darien (unaware it is him) from a distance, noting his public appearances and the mixed reactions from fans, feeling a strange pull towards the actor she only knows as 'Carmindor' via text.
Dressed in her father's carefully restored Prince Carmindor costume, Elle enters the ExcelsiCon cosplay contest. She performs a heartfelt monologue, showing her deep love for Starfield and her father's memory, captivating the audience and judges. Her stepsisters' costumes are poor, but Catherine, always manipulative, tries to promote them. After her performance, Elle is happy but tired. As she tries to leave, Catherine confronts her, demanding she return to the food truck. In the rush, Elle accidentally leaves her phone behind, missing a crucial text from Darien asking to meet.
Darien, having seen a photo of Elle in her Carmindor costume and recognizing her distinct phone case from a previous encounter at the food truck, realizes that 'Geekerella' is Elle Wittimer. He is excited by the discovery and eager to meet her properly, texting her to arrange a meeting at the ExcelsiCon Ball. However, Catherine, having found Elle's phone, sees the message and, recognizing Darien's name, decides to interfere. She locks Elle in the food truck, preventing her from going to the ball and meeting Darien, hoping to use the situation for her own gain or to spite Elle.
Elle, determined not to miss her chance, manages to escape the locked food truck with the help of her friend Sage. She rushes to the ExcelsiCon Ball, arriving just as Darien is about to make a public appearance. She confronts him, feeling betrayed that he did not reveal his true identity, while he is relieved to finally meet her. Amidst the confusion and the presence of his publicist, Frank, Elle reveals herself as 'Geekerella' and challenges Darien to be authentic. Inspired by her courage, Darien publicly embraces his love for Starfield and his identity as 'Carmindor,' not just the actor, and shares a heartfelt moment with Elle.
The cosplay contest results are announced, and Elle is declared the winner, much to Catherine and her stepsisters' anger. The public reveal of Darien and Elle's connection creates excitement, with fans embracing their story. After the convention, Elle bravely decides to leave her stepfamily and the Magic Pumpkin food truck behind. Sage offers her a place to stay, and Elle begins to explore her options for college and pursuing her own dreams, free from Catherine's control. She realizes that her love for Starfield, shared with her father, has given her the strength to make her own path.
With things settled, Elle and Darien begin to openly explore their relationship. Darien finds new confidence in his role as Carmindor, inspired by Elle's genuine fandom. He starts to engage with fans on his own terms, showing his true passion for Starfield. Elle, meanwhile, starts college, pursuing her interest in writing and film. Their shared love for Starfield continues to be a main part of their connection, as they attend movie premieres, conventions, and simply enjoy watching the series together. They support each other in their individual journeys, proving that true connection goes beyond fame and superficiality.
The Protagonist
Elle transforms from a subservient, quiet girl into a confident young woman who embraces her identity and pursues her dreams. She learns to stand up against her oppressors and forge her own path.
The Protagonist
Darien evolves from an anxious, image-conscious actor to a confident individual who embraces his authentic self and his love for fandom, finding courage through his connection with Elle.
The Antagonist
Catherine remains a static character, her manipulative nature fully revealed but ultimately failing to achieve her goals as Elle escapes her control.
The Supporting
Chloe's character remains largely unchanged, serving as a foil to Elle's authenticity.
The Supporting
Caliope's character also remains static, highlighting the superficiality of her and her sister's ambitions.
The Supporting
Sage remains a steadfast friend, providing consistent support and encouragement to Elle throughout her journey.
The Supporting
Frank's character represents the forces of external pressure and control that Darien must overcome to find his authentic voice.
The Supporting
Gail remains a supportive and understanding presence in Darien's life.
The novel shows how fandom can be a strong source of connection, identity, and escape. For Elle, Starfield is a legacy from her father and a refuge from her stepfamily, giving her strength and purpose. For Darien, it is a source of anxiety due to fan expectations, but also his true passion. Their shared love for Starfield, initially through anonymous texts, forms the basis of their relationship, showing that real connection can grow from shared interests. The ExcelsiCon setting itself shows the inclusive nature of fandom, where people can truly be themselves.
“Fandom is a family, whether you're born into it or find your way there. And sometimes, the families you choose are the best ones of all.”
This theme explores the struggle between showing a public image and being one's true self. Darien constantly fights the 'heartthrob' persona his publicist, Frank, forces upon him, wanting to be recognized for his real love of Starfield and his acting talent. Elle, though not famous, also deals with this, having to hide her true self and passions from her stepfamily. Their anonymous text conversations allow them to be authentic without fear of judgment. The climax at the ExcelsiCon Ball sees both characters publicly choosing authenticity, with Darien embracing his inner geek and Elle revealing her identity.
“It's hard to be yourself when everyone expects you to be someone else.”
Elle's journey is about finding her voice and breaking free from her stepfamily's control. For years, she has been silenced and subservient. Her decision to enter the cosplay contest, to pursue her passion, and eventually to leave Catherine's house, are all acts of self-assertion. Similarly, Darien finds his voice when he publicly defies Frank's control and speaks from his heart about Starfield. Both characters learn that true freedom comes from within and requires the courage to stand up for one's own desires and beliefs.
“Sometimes all it takes is one person to believe in you, and then you start to believe in yourself.”
The novel is a modern retelling of Cinderella, skillfully putting classic fairy tale elements into a contemporary setting. Elle is the mistreated heroine, forced into servitude by her cruel stepmother and stepsisters. The Magic Pumpkin food truck is a 'pumpkin carriage,' while ExcelsiCon is the 'ball' where she hopes to meet her 'prince.' The anonymous text messages replace the magical helper, and the missing phone is the lost slipper. The story updates these elements with a focus on geek culture, self-empowerment, and the complexities of modern celebrity, offering a fresh view on a timeless story.
“Maybe fairy tales are just a warning. A warning to be brave, to be bold, to be yourself.”
The primary mode of communication between Elle and Darien, fostering intimacy and authenticity.
The anonymous text messages serve as the modern equivalent of the 'magical helper' or the 'fairy godmother' in the Cinderella story. They allow Elle and Darien to connect on a deeper, more authentic level without the biases of their real-world identities. This device enables them to share their true selves, their anxieties, and their passions, forming a genuine emotional bond that transcends fame and social status. It highlights the idea that true connection is about shared understanding, not superficial appearances, and builds tension as they get closer to meeting in person.
The central shared interest and a driving force for both protagonists.
Starfield, the fictional sci-fi series, functions as more than just a setting; it's a powerful plot device. For Elle, it's a tie to her deceased father and a source of strength, guiding her actions in the cosplay contest. For Darien, it's both his dream role and a source of immense pressure from a demanding fan base. The fandom's opinions, expectations, and culture drive much of the external conflict and character motivation. It acts as a common ground for Elle and Darien, bringing them together and providing a rich, relatable backdrop for their romance.
Elle's workplace and a symbol of her servitude and eventual escape.
The Magic Pumpkin food truck is a multifaceted plot device. It is Elle's 'hearth' and 'prison,' symbolizing her servitude under Catherine's thumb. It's where she spends countless hours working, often missing out on personal opportunities. However, it also becomes her means of transportation to ExcelsiCon, ironically bringing her closer to her dreams. The name itself is a clear nod to the Cinderella story, representing the humble origins from which Elle must escape. Its eventual abandonment signifies Elle's liberation and new beginning.
The central event that brings all characters together and serves as the 'ball' of the fairy tale.
ExcelsiCon, with its cosplay contest and ball, is the pivotal event where all the story's threads converge. It acts as the 'royal ball' from the Cinderella narrative, providing the setting for Elle's transformation and her eventual meeting with Darien. The contest is Elle's opportunity to shine and assert her identity, while the ball is Darien's chance to connect with 'Geekerella.' The convention setting allows for grand reveals, public declarations, and the resolution of key conflicts, providing a vibrant backdrop for the climax of the story.
“‘Cinderella’ is a story about a girl who, despite her circumstances, never stops believing in magic. And ‘Starfield’ is a story about a girl who, despite her circumstances, never stops believing in the stars.”
— Elle talking about the core themes of the Starfield franchise and how it relates to her own life.
“For a moment, I forget that I’m standing in a crowded convention center, and it’s just me and him and the stars.”
— Elle's first real conversation with Darien at the convention, a moment of connection.
“Sometimes the people who are the hardest to love are the ones who need it the most.”
— Chloe, Elle's stepmother, reflecting on her own struggles and relationship with Elle.
“Fandom is about being part of something bigger than yourself. It’s about finding your people.”
— Elle describing the essence of fandom and community.
“You can be a princess and a pilot, you know. They’re not mutually exclusive.”
— Darien encouraging Elle to embrace all aspects of herself and her dreams.
“It’s funny how a fictional story can feel more real than your own life sometimes.”
— Elle contemplating the impact of 'Starfield' on her life.
“Maybe the best way to get what you want is to stop trying so hard to be what everyone else wants you to be.”
— Darien's internal monologue about the pressures of fame and public image.
“Sometimes, the right thing to do is the hardest thing to do.”
— Elle making a difficult decision regarding the Starfield contest.
“A hero isn't someone who never falls, it's someone who always gets back up.”
— A 'Starfield' quote that resonates with Elle and her journey.
“There's a difference between being alone and being lonely.”
— Elle reflecting on her isolation but also her inner strength.
“The stars don’t care about your past, only your future.”
— A 'Starfield' mantra that offers hope and a fresh start.
“You can’t let other people’s expectations define you.”
— Darien's manager giving him advice about his career and personal life.
“It’s not about finding your prince charming; it’s about finding your own ship to fly.”
— Elle realizing her own agency and aspirations beyond romance.
“Sometimes, the smallest voice can make the biggest difference.”
— Elle's blog gaining unexpected attention and impact.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
