“Sometimes you have to let go of the familiar to find something truly extraordinary.”
— Emily reflects on leaving home and the comfort of the Blackfin to go to the Arctic.

Liz Kessler (2012)
Genre
Fantasy / Children's / Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
288 min
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
A half-mermaid embarks on a dangerous Arctic quest to stop King Neptune's storm-causing nightmares, uncovering stolen memories and a royal secret in an alpine lake where reflections show what might be.
The story begins with Emily Windsnap experiencing strange and violent storms affecting both the human and mermaid worlds. These storms are not natural; they come from Neptune, King of the Sea's, nightmares, which he believes warn of great danger. Worried by these signs, Neptune calls Emily and her boyfriend, Aaron, to his palace. He reveals he has been having recurring, terrifying dreams about a forgotten secret and a threat from the far north. He gives them a secret mission: to travel to the Land of the Midnight Sun, an uncharted Arctic region, to investigate the source of these disturbances and stop the threat before it endangers his kingdom.
Emily and Aaron, with special cold-resistant suits and a magical compass, start their difficult journey to the Arctic. The waters become colder and more dangerous, filled with icebergs and strong currents. They meet unusual marine life adapted to the cold and navigate challenging underwater places. The magical compass guides them through the icy maze, hinting at a hidden destination. During their journey, they discuss Neptune's dreams and the possible dangers, strengthening their bond and their determination to find the truth behind the unsettling disturbances affecting the sea.
After days of travel through the frozen north, the compass leads Emily and Aaron to a hidden passage beneath an old glacier. This passage opens into a large, enclosed alpine lake, surprisingly protected from the harsh weather. The lake's waters are eerily still and have a strange reflective quality. As they explore, they notice that their reflections in the water do not always show their current selves but sometimes shift, hinting at other possibilities or forgotten versions of themselves. This strange event immediately tells them that this place has powerful, unusual magic, unlike anything they have seen before.
Inside the alpine lake, Emily and Aaron discover a hidden underwater village inhabited by merpeople different from any they have met. These villagers, led by the mysterious Elder Willow, are fascinated by the lake's unique reflective properties. They spend their days looking into the water, where their reflections show not what is, but what could be – alternative lives, missed chances, or possible futures. This obsession keeps them from living fully in the present, creating a sad and unchanging atmosphere in the community. Emily and Aaron watch their strange customs, trying to understand this powerful, alluring magic.
Through talks with Elder Willow and other villagers, Emily and Aaron gradually uncover the truth. The magical reflections in the lake are not natural; they are powered by stolen memories. These memories, taken from individuals across the mermaid world, are somehow sent into the lake, creating the vivid 'what if' scenarios. More troubling, they learn that many of these stolen memories belong to Neptune himself. The villagers explain that these memories were stolen long ago to prevent a great sorrow or a difficult truth from being remembered, hinting at a deep, hidden secret involving the King of the Sea.
As Emily and Aaron look deeper, the full extent of Neptune's dark secret is revealed. They discover that many years ago, Neptune had a twin brother, Oceanus, who was also a powerful merman. Due to a tragic misunderstanding or perhaps a deliberate act of manipulation by a jealous rival, Oceanus was wrongly accused of a crime against the sea kingdom. Neptune, in his grief and confusion, decided to banish or even imprison his own brother. To cope with the immense guilt and sorrow, and perhaps at the urging of advisors, Neptune had his memories of Oceanus stolen and suppressed, effectively erasing his brother from his mind and the kingdom's history.
The true cause of the unsettling storms and Neptune's nightmares is Oceanus, Neptune's long-lost twin brother. Oceanus, unjustly imprisoned or banished for decades, has been slowly regaining his strength and manipulating the stolen memories within the alpine lake. His bitterness and desire for revenge have grown over the years, appearing as powerful emotional disturbances that ripple through the ocean, causing the strange storms. He has been using the lake's magic to project his anger and sorrow, hoping to destabilize Neptune's reign and force his brother to remember the injustice he suffered. Oceanus is now ready to confront Neptune and reclaim what he believes was taken from him.
Emily and Aaron realize they must bring Neptune and Oceanus together to resolve the conflict. They communicate with Oceanus, explaining the consequences of his actions and the suffering his anger is causing. At the same time, they send a message back to Neptune, urging him to come to the alpine lake and face his past. A tense and emotional confrontation happens between the two brothers. With Emily and Aaron's help, Neptune's stolen memories return, filling him with the truth and the pain of his past actions. This leads to a difficult but necessary reconciliation, as Neptune finally understands the injustice done to his brother and expresses his deep regret.
With the truth revealed and a fragile reconciliation happening, Emily and Aaron work to reverse the magic of the stolen memories. They help release the stored memories from the lake, allowing them to return to their rightful owners, including Neptune. As the memories are restored, the lake's reflective magic changes, becoming a place of true reflection and healing rather than one of illusion and longing. The strong emotional residue from Oceanus's anger disappears, and the storms across the ocean begin to calm. The two brothers, though still bearing the scars of their past, begin the long process of rebuilding their relationship and healing the rift that had separated them for so long.
With the stolen memories returned and the lake's magic restored to its natural, helpful state, the villagers of the alpine lake are no longer trapped by their reflections of 'what could be.' They begin to look forward, embracing their present lives and finding new purpose in their community. Elder Willow thanks Emily and Aaron for their courage and wisdom, acknowledging the profound change they brought. Emily and Aaron, having successfully completed their mission, return home, changed by the experience. They think about the importance of truth, memory, forgiveness, and the lasting power of family, knowing that even the most painful pasts can lead to healing and reconciliation.
The Protagonist
Emily grows in wisdom and understanding of complex emotional truths, learning that even powerful leaders can make mistakes and that forgiveness is crucial for healing.
The Supporting
Aaron deepens his understanding of complex family dynamics and the weight of past decisions, reinforcing his role as a steadfast and insightful partner.
The Supporting
Neptune undergoes a profound transformation, confronting and accepting his past mistakes, leading to personal healing and reconciliation with his long-lost brother.
The Antagonist/Supporting
Oceanus moves from vengeful anger to a path of healing and reconciliation, finding peace after confronting his brother and receiving an apology.
The Supporting
Elder Willow shifts from guardian of a stagnant truth to an advocate for healing and change within her community, facilitating the return of memories.
The Mentioned
N/A (character is not present)
This theme explores how memories, both individual and shared, shape identity, relationships, and reality. Neptune's choice to suppress his memories of Oceanus causes decades of suffering for both brothers. The alpine lake, powered by stolen memories, shows how forgetting can create false realities and prevent healing. Restoring these memories is key for reconciliation and understanding, highlighting that facing painful truths from the past is essential for moving forward. The villagers' obsession with 'what could be' also shows how dwelling on absent memories can prevent living in the present.
“''Sometimes, the hardest truths are the ones we hide even from ourselves, and those are the truths that cause the most damage in the end.''”
The main conflict is the broken relationship between Neptune and his twin brother, Oceanus. A past betrayal, caused by misunderstanding and perhaps manipulation, led to Oceanus's banishment and Neptune's memory suppression. The story emphasizes the deep impact of family conflicts and the wounds they can cause. Emily and Aaron's mission is ultimately about helping reconciliation, showing that even after decades of estrangement and bitterness, forgiveness and understanding are possible, though often difficult. It highlights that family bonds, even when broken, can be mended.
“''A brother's bond is not easily broken, even by a king's decree or the mists of forgotten time. It merely waits for the light of truth to shine upon it once more.''”
The alpine lake and its reflective properties are a strong metaphor for escapism. The villagers, captivated by reflections of 'what could be,' cannot fully engage with their present lives. This obsession creates a stagnant, sad society, showing how dwelling on illusions or alternative realities can prevent growth and true happiness. Oceanus also uses this illusionary power to project his anger and sorrow, further showing how unchecked emotional escapism can appear in destructive ways. The story advocates for facing reality, even when difficult, rather than seeking comfort in illusions.
“''To live in the 'what could be' is to deny the 'what is,' and in that denial, true life slips away.''”
Oceanus's actions are driven by a desire for justice for the wrong done to him. His bitterness and quest for revenge appear as destructive storms, showing the negative consequences of holding onto grievances. The story explores the tension between seeking retribution and the path of forgiveness. While Oceanus's pain is real, the story ultimately argues that true healing comes not from vengeance, but from understanding, apology, and the difficult act of forgiveness. Emily and Aaron help guide both brothers towards a resolution that prioritizes healing over continued conflict, demonstrating the transforming power of letting go.
“''Justice can soothe the wound, but only forgiveness can truly mend the heart.''”
A mystical artifact that guides Emily and Aaron to their destination.
The magical compass serves as a plot device to propel Emily and Aaron to the remote and hidden alpine lake. It doesn't point north, but rather to the source of Neptune's distress, acting as a magical homing device. This device allows the narrative to bypass extensive geographical navigation, focusing instead on the journey's challenges and the eventual discovery of the lake. It also adds an element of mystery and destiny, suggesting that their path is preordained to uncover Neptune's secret.
A body of water that shows 'what could be' rather than 'what is,' powered by stolen memories.
The alpine lake's unique reflective properties are a central plot device. It acts as the physical manifestation of the story's core themes: memory, illusion, and regret. The reflections allow the narrative to explore alternative realities and the consequences of past choices, particularly Neptune's. By being powered by stolen memories, it provides a tangible link to Neptune's forgotten past and Oceanus's suffering, serving as both the source of the problem and the key to its resolution. It's a magical mirror into characters' inner lives and the story's central conflict.
Recurring, powerful dreams that manifest as storms, signaling a deep-seated problem.
Neptune's nightmares serve as the initial inciting incident for the entire plot. These aren't just ordinary dreams; they are so potent that they physically affect the ocean, creating destructive storms. This device immediately establishes a sense of urgency and mystery, signaling that a powerful, unresolved issue is at play. The nightmares are a direct link to Neptune's suppressed memories of Oceanus, providing a symbolic representation of his subconscious struggle and the impending revelation of his past actions. They are the 'symptoms' that lead Emily and Aaron to diagnose the underlying 'illness'.
The magical removal and storage of memories, primarily Neptune's, to suppress painful truths.
The concept of stolen memories is a crucial plot device, driving the central mystery and conflict. It explains why Neptune is unaware of his brother and why the lake has its peculiar powers. This device allows for a dramatic reveal of Neptune's past actions and the injustice done to Oceanus. It highlights the dangers of suppressing difficult truths and the emotional cost of such an act. The restoration of these memories is the turning point for reconciliation, demonstrating the power of truth in healing deep wounds and resolving long-standing conflicts.
“Sometimes you have to let go of the familiar to find something truly extraordinary.”
— Emily reflects on leaving home and the comfort of the Blackfin to go to the Arctic.
“The world is full of magic, Emily. You just have to know where to look.”
— Captain Grimsby offers advice to Emily as she embarks on her new journey.
“Even in the darkest of nights, there is always a glimmer of light to guide you.”
— Emily experiences the long Arctic night and finds hope.
“Friendship isn't about being the same, it's about accepting each other's differences.”
— Emily considers her diverse group of friends on the ship.
“True courage isn't the absence of fear, but the triumph over it.”
— Emily faces a challenging situation, despite her apprehension.
“Some secrets are meant to be discovered, not kept.”
— Emily uncovers clues about the mysterious Land of the Midnight Sun.
“The sea always has a way of showing you what you truly need.”
— Emily feels a strong connection to the ocean and its guidance.
“Love isn't always grand gestures; sometimes it's the quiet understanding between two people.”
— Emily observes the subtle interactions between certain characters.
“You can't control the tides, but you can learn to sail with them.”
— Emily learns to adapt to unpredictable circumstances in the Arctic.
“Every journey leaves a mark on your heart, shaping who you become.”
— Emily reflects on her experiences and how they've changed her.
“The greatest adventures often begin with a single, unexpected invitation.”
— Emily remembers the letter that started her Arctic voyage.
“Home isn't just a place; it's the people you share it with.”
— Emily thinks about her friends and family, even while far away.
“Even the smallest creature can play a vital role in a grander scheme.”
— Emily realizes the importance of every member of the expedition.
“There's a rhythm to the world, if you just stop and listen.”
— Emily finds peace and understanding in the natural world of the Arctic.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.