“I’m not a cheerleader. I’m a cowgirl.”
— When her crush, Brian, first sees her and assumes she's a cheerleader.
Archivist's Choice
Dairy Queen
Catherine Gilbert Murdock (2006)
Genre
Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
275 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
A Wisconsin farm girl from a quiet family wants to play football and finds an unexpected connection with a rival team's star quarterback.
Synopsis
Fifteen-year-old D. J. Schwenk faces a summer of quiet and stress on her family's dairy farm. Her best friend, Amber, is distant, her younger brother, Curtis, does not speak, and her parents struggle with money and secrets. Her two older brothers, college football stars, are away and do not communicate. D. J. finds an opportunity when Brian Nelson, the star quarterback of the rival high school team, needs a trainer for the summer. As she works with Brian, an unlikely friendship grows into romance, and D. J. starts to speak up. She trains hard, finding her own athletic ability, while also trying to uncover her family's secrets and fix broken relationships. This leads to a talk with her father about her desire to try out for the high school football team, which he strongly opposes. Brian admits his feelings and offers support, while Curtis finally starts to speak again. D. J. makes up with her family, sharing her goals and helping them face their own problems. The book ends with D. J. trying out for the football team and her family attending the first game, showing a new start of openness and communication for the Schwenk family.
Reading time
275 min
Difficulty
Easy
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Heartwarming, Authentic, Reflective, Hopeful
✓ Read this if...
You enjoy coming-of-age stories about finding your voice, sports-themed romance, and realistic depictions of rural life.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer high-stakes fantasy or sci-fi, or dislike stories with a focus on family drama and internal struggles.
Plot Summary
Summer of Silence and Strain
Fifteen-year-old D.J. Schwenk lives on a dairy farm in rural Wisconsin, taking on much of the farm work and caring for her younger brother, Curtis. Her older brothers, Win and Bill, are away at college on football scholarships, and her mother works two jobs. Her father, a former football star, is often critical. D.J.'s best friend, Amber, has been distant, making D.J. feel more alone. The summer begins with D.J. feeling overwhelmed and unheard, her days a routine of farm chores and caring for Curtis, who has stopped speaking. She also deals with her father's quiet disappointment in her, especially regarding her perceived lack of athletic talent compared to her brothers.
An Unexpected Opportunity
A surprising event occurs when Brian Nelson, the star quarterback from Hawley, a rival school, approaches D.J. Her older brother, Win, had told Brian that D.J. was a good trainer, a skill she learned helping her brothers. Brian's coach has ordered extra training, and he reluctantly agrees to work with D.J. This unexpected partnership at first makes D.J. resentful, as Brian represents everything she is not – popular, athletic, and from a rival town. Their interactions are awkward, but a hesitant connection starts to form as they spend more time together on the farm.
Training and Trust
As D.J. trains Brian, she sees his surprising dedication. Their sessions, initially stiff, slowly become more natural. D.J. pushes Brian hard, using her knowledge of football and her brothers' training routines. During these sessions, Brian sees D.J.'s life on the farm, witnessing her strength and toughness. He also notices the quiet struggles within her family, especially Curtis's silence. Through their shared physical effort and growing familiarity, the initial tension between them eases into a comfortable understanding. D.J. starts to appreciate Brian's quiet strength and his real interest in her, despite their rivalry.
Unveiling Family Secrets
While training with Brian, D.J. begins to put together pieces of her family's past. She learns that her mother was a talented athlete in her youth, good at basketball, but gave up her dreams when she became pregnant with Win. This discovery helps D.J. understand her mother's quiet sacrifices and her current exhaustion, working two jobs to support the family and her sons' college tuition. The discovery also gives D.J. a new way to see her father's expectations and her own growing athletic goals, adding more depth to her understanding of her family and herself.
The Football Team Audition
Inspired by her growing confidence and her mother's past, D.J. secretly decides to try out for the Red Bend high school football team. This is a significant act of defiance against her father's unspoken rule that football is for boys and his sons. She practices in secret, using the skills she developed training Brian. The decision comes from a desire to prove herself, not just to her father, but to herself, and to challenge the strict gender expectations placed on her. Her tryout is a quiet but strong statement of her growing self-assertion, showing her physical ability and determination.
Confrontation and Consequences
D.J.'s secret tryout is discovered by her father, leading to a heated talk. Her father is angry, feeling betrayed and that she is making a joke of the family's football history. He forbids her from playing, emphasizing his traditional views and his disappointment. This argument brings many unspoken tensions to the surface, especially D.J.'s feelings of being ignored compared to her brothers. The conflict highlights the deep-seated issues within the Schwenk family, forcing D.J. to stand her ground and state her desires, even with her father's disapproval.
Brian's Confession and Support
During a training session, Brian talks to D.J. about his own family issues, revealing that his father is an alcoholic and often absent. This shared vulnerability deepens their connection, as D.J. realizes that Brian, despite his outward confidence, has his own problems. Brian consistently supports D.J.'s decision to play football, encouraging her to follow her dreams regardless of her father's objections. His steady belief in her gives D.J. much-needed outside validation and strengthens her resolve to defy gender expectations and make her own way, reinforcing their growing bond.
Curtis's Breakthrough
One day, while D.J. is working on the farm, Curtis, who has not spoken for months, finally speaks. His breakthrough is a direct result of D.J.'s patient care, her understanding of his non-verbal cues, and her constant presence. This moment is very important for D.J., showing a major success in her role as his caregiver and a healing in their sibling relationship. Curtis's return to speech represents the wider idea of finding one's voice, mirroring D.J.'s own journey towards self-expression and communication within her family and the wider world.
Reconciliation and Revelation
D.J.'s mother, encouraged by D.J.'s courage, finally confronts her husband about his rigid expectations and his treatment of D.J. She reveals her own past sacrifices and the dreams she gave up, making her husband understand the impact of his actions. This confrontation is a key moment, as it forces her father to admit his mistakes and the pain he has caused. The family starts to communicate more openly, breaking years of unspoken resentments. This new honesty allows for reconciliation and a more balanced dynamic within the Schwenk household, with D.J.'s mother finding her own voice.
The First Game
Despite her father's initial opposition, D.J. joins the Red Bend football team. Her first game is a big occasion, symbolizing her success over challenges and societal expectations. Her family, including her father, attends the game, showing their growing understanding and support. Brian Nelson is also there, cheering her on. D.J. plays well, showing her abilities and earning the respect of her teammates and her family. This game is not just about football; it is about D.J. finding her place, speaking her truth, and being celebrated for who she is, not just who others expect her to be.
Principal Figures
D.J. Schwenk
The Protagonist
D.J. transforms from a quiet, burdened girl to a confident young woman who speaks her mind, pursues her passions, and redefines her place within her family and community.
Brian Nelson
The Supporting/Love Interest
Brian evolves from a reluctant training partner to a trusted friend and romantic interest, revealing his own vulnerabilities and becoming a steadfast source of encouragement for D.J.
Mr. Schwenk (Dad)
The Antagonist/Supporting
He begins as a rigid, traditional figure who suppresses D.J.'s ambitions but gradually learns to accept and support her choices, softening his stance and fostering better communication within the family.
Mrs. Schwenk (Mom)
The Supporting
She evolves from a silent, sacrificing figure to a more assertive and vocal supporter of D.J., ultimately confronting her husband and revealing her own past dreams.
Curtis Schwenk
The Supporting
Curtis begins as a selectively mute child, symbolizing the family's communication issues, and eventually finds his voice, representing a step towards healing and openness.
Amber
The Supporting/Mentioned
Amber's character serves as an external conflict for D.J., reflecting the pain of a dissolving friendship and D.J.'s growing realization that she needs to prioritize herself.
Win Schwenk
The Mentioned
Win remains a static, off-stage character whose achievements highlight D.J.'s struggles with identity and her father's expectations.
Bill Schwenk
The Mentioned
Bill, like Win, serves as a static character whose athletic success contributes to D.J.'s internal and external conflicts.
Themes & Insights
Finding Your Voice
A main theme is D.J.'s journey from quiet observation to speaking her mind. At first, D.J. keeps her thoughts and feelings to herself, struggling to talk with her family and friends. Her training with Brian, her decision to try out for football, and her eventual talks with her father all show her steps toward saying what she wants and asserting who she is. This theme is also seen in Curtis's silence and his eventual return to speech, representing a wider family healing through communication. The story emphasizes that real strength comes from speaking one's truth.
“When you don’t talk, there’s a lot of stuff that ends up not getting said.”
Challenging Gender Roles
D.J. lives in a world where her father sticks to traditional gender roles, celebrating his sons' football skills while ignoring D.J.'s athletic interests. Her decision to try out for the high school football team directly challenges these expectations, questioning the idea that certain sports or roles are only for boys. The discovery of her mother's own suppressed athletic past further highlights the historical limits placed on women. D.J.'s journey supports the idea that people should be free to follow their passions regardless of what society or family expects based on gender.
“I was going to play football. It was stupid and impossible and my dad would kill me, but I was going to do it.”
Family Dynamics and Communication
The novel explores the complexities of family relationships, especially the unspoken tensions and communication problems within the Schwenk household. The father's demanding nature, the mother's quiet sacrifices, and Curtis's mutism all come from a lack of open talk. D.J.'s journey of self-discovery forces the family to face these issues, leading to difficult but necessary conversations. The gradual shift toward honesty and understanding, especially in the talks between D.J., her mother, and her father, shows how powerful real communication is in fixing family problems.
“It was amazing how much stuff you could say without actually saying anything at all.”
Identity and Self-Discovery
D.J. spends much of the novel feeling defined by her family's farm, her brothers' achievements, and her father's expectations. Her journey is about actively seeking and asserting her own identity. Through her hard farm work, her tough training with Brian, and her brave decision to play football, D.J. discovers her own strength, abilities, and desires. She learns to value herself not for who she is expected to be, but for who she truly is, separate from her family's past. This theme is about finding one's true self amid outside pressures.
“I wasn't just D.J. Schwenk, the girl who worked the farm. I was D.J. Schwenk, the girl who could do anything.”
The Weight of Expectations
D.J. carries the heavy weight of her father's expectations, which mostly focus on her brothers' athletic skills and a traditional future for her. These unspoken demands contribute to her initial silence and feelings of not being good enough. Her mother also bears the weight of past expectations, having given up her own dreams. The novel explores how these pressures can shape and sometimes stifle people, but also how challenging them can lead to freedom and personal growth. D.J.'s success is in her ability to shed these imposed burdens and make her own way.
“My dad had always wanted sons. He just hadn't wanted me to be one of them.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
First-Person Internal Monologue
D.J.'s unvoiced thoughts and observations provide deep insight into her character and struggles.
The entire novel is narrated from D.J.'s first-person perspective, frequently delving into her internal monologues. These unvoiced thoughts are crucial because D.J. is a character who struggles to speak her mind externally. Her internal commentary reveals her sharp observations, her dry wit, her insecurities, her frustrations with her family, and her burgeoning feelings for Brian. This device allows the reader to intimately understand D.J.'s journey of finding her voice, as we see her process her experiences and emotions before she is able to articulate them aloud.
Selective Mutism
Curtis's inability to speak serves as a powerful symbol of the family's communication breakdown.
Curtis's selective mutism is a significant plot device. It acts as a physical manifestation of the unspoken tensions and emotional burdens within the Schwenk family. His silence highlights the lack of open communication between D.J.'s parents and D.J.'s own struggles to express herself. Curtis's eventual return to speech is a major turning point, symbolizing the family's healing process and D.J.'s success in fostering a more communicative and supportive environment, not just for him, but for herself and her mother as well. It underscores the theme of finding one's voice.
The Dairy Farm Setting
The physical demands and isolation of the farm mirror D.J.'s internal burdens and provide a space for growth.
The dairy farm setting is more than just a backdrop; it is integral to D.J.'s character and the story's themes. The constant, physically demanding work on the farm shapes D.J.'s strength, resilience, and work ethic, but also contributes to her isolation and the feeling of being trapped. The farm is a place of hard labor and tradition, mirroring the traditional expectations placed upon D.J. However, it also becomes the unexpected training ground for Brian and a place where D.J. finds solace and a sense of purpose, representing both her burden and her strength.
The Rival Quarterback (Brian Nelson)
An external catalyst that forces D.J. out of her shell and into self-discovery.
Brian Nelson, as the rival quarterback whom D.J. is tasked with training, serves as a crucial external catalyst. His presence disrupts D.J.'s isolated routine and forces her into an uncomfortable, yet ultimately transformative, interaction. Brian's observations of D.J. and her life, his quiet support, and his own vulnerability help D.J. to see herself differently and to open up. He is the person with whom D.J. first practices communicating and expressing her true self, making him instrumental in her journey of finding her voice and challenging expectations.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“Sometimes you just have to do what needs to be done, even if it’s gross.”
— Dealing with farm chores like cleaning out the barn.
“Being a dairy queen isn’t about wearing a crown. It’s about knowing your cows.”
— Explaining her family's dairy farm heritage and her role.
“He looked at me like I was a puzzle he wanted to solve.”
— Mandy's perception of Brian's initial interest in her.
“Football is like chess, only with more grunting.”
— Mandy observing and trying to understand football strategy.
“You can’t just quit when things get hard. That’s not how anything good ever gets done.”
— Her father's advice about perseverance, applicable to both farm and life.
“I didn’t know you could feel so much for someone who was mostly just a pain in the butt.”
— Reflecting on her complicated feelings for Brian.
“Some things just stick with you, whether you want them to or not.”
— Thinking about past events and their lasting impact.
“There's a difference between being strong and being stubborn.”
— Her internal struggle with her own personality traits.
“You can’t always control what happens to you, but you can control how you react.”
— A lesson learned through various challenges she faces.
“It’s not about being perfect. It’s about trying.”
— Her approach to learning new things, like football, and life in general.
“The quietest people often have the loudest thoughts.”
— Mandy, being a quiet observer, reflects on her own inner world.
“Sometimes the best way to figure things out is just to keep doing them.”
— Her practical approach to problem-solving and understanding her feelings.
“Love isn't always easy, and it doesn't always make sense.”
— Coming to terms with the complexities of her relationship with Brian.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
At the start of the book, D.J. Schwenk is struggling with her family's failing dairy farm, the absence of her older brothers who are pursuing college football, and her own quiet, internal nature. She feels overlooked and burdened by responsibilities, especially with her father injured and her mother working multiple jobs, leaving her to manage much of the farm work and her younger siblings.
