“The thing about being a grown-up is that you can have as many dogs as you like. Or cats. Or guinea pigs.”
— Caddy reflects on the advantages of adulthood.

Hilary McKay (2006)
Genre
Children's / Young Adult
Reading Time
180 min
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
Amid Valentine's Day chaos and graveyard meetings, the Casson siblings experience the joys and challenges of first love, as Caddy pursues a 'Real Thing' who isn't who anyone expects.
Rose Casson, the youngest and most artistic of the Casson children, carefully makes a Valentine's Day card for her boyfriend, Tom, who lives in New York. She uses special paper, glitter, and a tiny, hand-drawn map of their lives. Her mother, Eve, worries about their long-distance relationship, while her siblings, especially Caddy, tease her about her focus. Rose's efforts show her strong devotion to Tom, despite the distance and others' doubts. The card becomes a symbol of her hope and commitment, carefully prepared to be mailed across the ocean with her heartfelt message.
Indigo Casson, the oldest, faces a romantic challenge with Sarah, a girl he likes. He plans to ask her to the Valentine's Day disco, picking a song to dedicate to her and practicing what to say. His younger siblings, especially Rose, give unwanted advice, which only makes him more anxious. Indigo's attempts to seem cool often fail, leading to awkward moments. The disco is the main setting for his romantic hopes, and he struggles with shyness and fear of rejection, putting all his energy into making the night perfect for Sarah, despite his usual quiet nature.
Saffy Casson, known for being practical and artistic, agrees to an unusual Valentine's 'date' with Mark, which involves visiting a graveyard at night. During their outing, they see a large, red balloon that seems to follow them, creating a strange mood. The balloon later concerns Saffy, as she thinks it might relate to danger for her best friend, Sarah. Saffy's logical mind is challenged by the strange event, and she feels a growing unease, seeing the balloon as a warning or sign of coming trouble, especially for Sarah, whom she cares deeply about.
Caddy Casson, impulsive and dramatic, announces she has fallen in love at first sight with a new boy, whom she calls 'The Real Thing.' This puts her relationship with Michael at risk. She describes her new love with intense passion, completely forgetting her feelings for Michael. Her family reacts with a mix of frustration and worry, especially Rose, who likes Michael. Caddy's sudden crush causes Michael great emotional pain, as he is hurt by her apparent abandonment, while Caddy remains unaware in her new romantic bliss, convinced this is true love.
Michael, Caddy's long-term boyfriend, is heartbroken by her sudden crush on another boy. He struggles to understand Caddy's impulsive nature and the abrupt end of their relationship. He talks to Rose, sharing his pain and confusion. Rose, sympathetic to Michael, tries to comfort him and offer advice, while also feeling protective of her friend. Michael's distress highlights Caddy's often thoughtless behavior and the harm caused by her romantic whims. His reaction shows the deep emotions in their relationship before Caddy's sudden change of heart, leaving him to deal with his shattered expectations.
Concerned for Sarah, Saffy and Sarah actively look into the recurring red balloon. They follow its path to where it finally lands. Through their investigation, they discover the balloon is not a sign of doom but a message from a lonely child, tied to a heartfelt wish. This changes Saffy's view, turning the strange object into a symbol of innocence and hope. The experience strengthens Saffy and Sarah's bond as they work together to understand the mystery, showing Saffy's protective nature and Sarah's gentle spirit.
Caddy's intense crush on 'The Real Thing' begins to fade as his true character appears. He acts self-centered and dismissive, not the romantic ideal Caddy had imagined. Her family, especially Rose, sees Caddy's growing disappointment with a mix of 'I told you so' and quiet sympathy. Caddy's initial passionate statements slowly turn into doubt and disappointment. This experience teaches Caddy a harsh lesson, forcing her to see the difference between idealized love and reality, starting a period of thought about her impulsive romantic choices and their effect on others.
Deeply concerned for Michael and seeing Caddy's unpredictable behavior, Rose decides to get involved. She talks to Michael, offering comfort and reassurance, acknowledging his pain. She also tries to talk to Caddy, gently helping her see the results of her actions and the hurt she caused. Rose acts as a link between the two, trying to heal the emotional damage. Her efforts show her maturity and her role as a caring observer in the family, demonstrating her loyalty to her friends and her desire for fairness and understanding, even amidst her sister's self-absorbed romantic pursuits.
At the Valentine's Day disco, Indigo's carefully planned romantic gesture for Sarah does not go exactly as practiced, marked by his usual shyness and awkwardness. However, despite the small problems, he manages to spend time with Sarah, and they share some pleasant moments. While it is not the grand romantic success he imagined, Indigo achieves a small win by simply connecting with Sarah and showing his interest. This experience, though imperfect, is a step forward for Indigo in overcoming his social anxieties and pursuing his feelings, showing a quiet growth in his confidence and romantic efforts.
As the reality of her new love interest's flaws becomes clear, Caddy starts to feel genuine regret for how she treated Michael. The initial excitement of 'The Real Thing' fades, replaced by a painful awareness of her impulsiveness and the hurt she caused. She begins to think about Michael's steady affection and kindness, comparing it to the superficiality of her new crush. This realization marks a key moment for Caddy, as she moves from self-absorbed infatuation to a growing sense of responsibility and remorse, causing her to consider the true value of loyalty and real connection over passing passion.
Filled with remorse, Caddy tries to apologize to Michael. However, Michael, still deeply hurt, is not immediately open to her apologies. He struggles to trust her after her sudden abandonment and the pain she caused. Caddy faces the difficult truth that apologies do not instantly erase past wounds. This interaction forces Caddy to confront the full impact of her impulsive decisions and the effort needed to rebuild broken trust. Her attempts to reconcile show her growing maturity and her desire to correct her mistakes, even if forgiveness takes time and effort.
Throughout the various romantic problems, the Casson family, with their mix of chaos and affection, provides support. Eve and Bill, their parents, offer guidance and a stable home, even if their own artistic natures add to the family's quirks. Rose, Indigo, and Saffy each navigate their own romantic journeys, often giving advice (asked for or not) and emotional support to one another. Despite their arguments and individual pursuits, the Cassons' underlying bond remains strong, showing how family acts as a key anchor during emotional upheaval and personal growth, especially in matters of the heart.
The Protagonist
Caddy learns the painful lesson that true love involves more than just initial passion and that her impulsive actions can deeply hurt others. She begins to mature by acknowledging her mistakes and attempting to make amends.
The Protagonist/Supporting
Rose maintains her steadfast devotion to Tom, demonstrating the strength of her commitment despite geographical distance and family skepticism.
The Supporting
Michael experiences profound heartbreak and must learn to cope with Caddy's betrayal, ultimately demonstrating resilience.
The Protagonist/Supporting
Indigo makes small but significant strides in overcoming his shyness to connect with Sarah, showing growth in his confidence.
The Protagonist/Supporting
Saffy's logical perspective is challenged by the mysterious balloon, leading her to uncover a deeper, more emotional truth and strengthening her bond with Sarah.
The Supporting
Sarah is a constant, supportive presence, and her quiet nature allows others to project their hopes and fears onto her.
The Supporting
Eve continues to be the artistic, grounding force of the family, providing unconventional wisdom and love.
The Supporting
Bill remains a steady, supportive paternal figure amidst the family's romantic entanglements.
The Mentioned
Tom's presence is consistent as the object of Rose's affection, representing enduring love despite distance.
The Supporting
Initially idealized, his true, disappointing nature forces Caddy to confront her romantic delusions.
The book explores different kinds of love, comparing impulsive infatuation with steady affection. Caddy's 'love at first sight' for 'The Real Thing' is shown to be brief and shallow, hurting Michael, who represents a more loyal love. Rose's strong devotion to Tom, despite their long-distance relationship, shows commitment and patience. Indigo's shy, carefully planned pursuit of Sarah highlights the vulnerability and effort in new romance. The story suggests that true love needs more than just initial passion, emphasizing kindness, loyalty, and understanding, as seen in Michael's heartbreak and Caddy's later regret.
“Love isn't just a big bang, Caddy. It's... it's like a long, quiet river.”
This theme is mainly explored through Caddy and Rose. Caddy's impulsiveness drives her romantic choices, leading to dramatic statements and quick changes of heart, often without considering others' feelings, especially Michael's. Her journey makes her face the results of her actions. In contrast, Rose shows steadiness, keeping a committed long-distance relationship with Tom, demonstrating patience and loyalty. The story quietly favors constancy and thoughtful action over rash, emotional whims, suggesting that stability brings more genuine happiness and less pain.
“It was just a big, bright, shiny new thing, and Caddy always fell for those.”
Despite their individual quirks and romantic dramas, the Casson family offers strong, if sometimes chaotic, support. They tease, give unwanted advice, and occasionally frustrate each other, but they are there for one another. Rose comforts Michael, Saffy protects Sarah, and even Eve and Bill, absorbed in their art, provide a stable home. The family's interactions show how siblings handle each other's romantic troubles, offering comfort, perspective, and a sense of belonging, proving that even during personal turmoil, the family unit remains a key source of strength and understanding.
“Cassons always stuck together, even when they were driving each other completely mad.”
The book shows self-discovery through the young Cassons' romantic experiences. Caddy's disappointment with 'The Real Thing' forces her to confront her own romantic idealism and the consequences of her impulsive behavior, leading to a crucial step in her emotional maturity. Indigo's struggles with shyness and his attempts to connect with Sarah help him gain confidence. Saffy's investigation of the balloon changes her perspective from practical logic to understanding emotional truths. Each character's romantic adventure contributes to their personal growth, teaching them lessons about themselves, relationships, and the world.
“Sometimes you have to break your heart a little to find out what it really wants.”
Multiple first-person perspectives from the Casson siblings.
The story is told through the alternating first-person perspectives of Rose, Indigo, Saffy, and Caddy. This device allows the reader to experience the same events from different emotional and psychological viewpoints, deepening the understanding of each character's motivations and internal struggles. For example, Caddy's infatuation is described by her with passionate intensity, while Rose's perspective highlights the pain it causes Michael. This technique creates a rich, multi-layered narrative that showcases the individual personalities and relationships within the Casson family, making the story feel more intimate and comprehensive.
A mysterious object that serves as a symbolic catalyst for Saffy's storyline.
The red balloon initially appears as an ominous, unexplained presence following Saffy and Mark, creating an atmosphere of mystery and unease. Saffy interprets it as a bad omen for Sarah, driving her to investigate. Ultimately, the balloon is revealed to be a symbol of a child's wish and loneliness, transforming its meaning from foreboding to poignant. This device serves as a catalyst for Saffy's actions, leading her to a deeper understanding of empathy and challenging her initial logical, somewhat superstitious, interpretation of events. It adds a touch of magical realism and emotional depth to her narrative.
The romantic holiday frames the various love stories.
The entire narrative is set around Valentine's Day, providing a thematic backdrop for the exploration of love in its many forms. This holiday naturally amplifies the romantic anxieties and aspirations of the characters. Rose's elaborate card, Indigo's disco plans, Saffy's unusual date, and Caddy's dramatic declaration of new love all revolve around the expectation and symbolism of Valentine's Day. It creates a unified timeframe and heightens the emotional stakes for each character's romantic endeavors, making the themes of love, longing, and heartbreak particularly resonant.
“The thing about being a grown-up is that you can have as many dogs as you like. Or cats. Or guinea pigs.”
— Caddy reflects on the advantages of adulthood.
“It was impossible to be cross with Saffy for long. She was too small and too earnest and too Saffy.”
— A character's exasperation with Saffy quickly dissolves.
“Some secrets are like little birds, you hold them too tight and they die, too loose and they fly away.”
— Caddy contemplates the nature of keeping secrets.
“Being a bit of a mess was just part of being a Casson.”
— The Casson family's general disarray is acknowledged.
“Love was a complicated thing, like a very large, very untidy ball of wool.”
— Caddy's internal thought about the complexities of love.
“You couldn't make people happy if they didn't want to be happy.”
— A character's realization about trying to cheer someone up.
“The best kind of adventures were the ones you didn't plan for.”
— A reflection on unexpected events and their appeal.
“It was a truth universally acknowledged that if you wanted to find something, you should ask Saffy.”
— Saffy's reputation for finding lost items.
“Sometimes you just had to be brave, even if you didn't feel brave at all.”
— Caddy faces a daunting situation.
“The world was full of interesting things, if you just bothered to look.”
— A character's appreciation for everyday details.
“It wasn't a fairy tale, but it was a good story, and sometimes that was even better.”
— Caddy's perspective on the reality of her life and relationships.
“Grown-ups were always saying things like 'you'll understand when you're older,' which was never very helpful.”
— Caddy's frustration with common adult sayings.
“Even the most ordinary days could hold extraordinary moments.”
— A reflection on finding joy in the mundane.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.

Dan Gemeinhart
4.5

Kate O'Hearn
4.4

Jeanne Birdsall
4.4

Jen Wang
4.4

Wendelin Van Draanen
4.3

John Marsden
4.3

Chris Van Allsburg
4.3

Jennifer A. Nielsen
4.2