“New York was a city of love and despair, of hope and broken dreams, a city where anything was possible and nothing was certain.”
— Early description of New York City's allure and danger for the young protagonists.

Anna Godbersen (2010)
Genre
Historical Fiction / Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
7-8 hours
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
In the dangerous summer of 1929, three young women chase their dreams and confront the dark secrets of New York's Jazz Age elite, where fame, fortune, and family ties have deadly consequences.
Letty Larkspur and Cordelia Grey, friends from a small Midwestern town, arrive in New York City in the summer of 1929. Letty wants to become a Broadway star and immediately seeks auditions, quickly seeing the competition. Cordelia is on a personal quest: to find her father, the businessman and party host, Senator Donal, whom she has never met. They settle into a modest boarding house, with Letty's first attempts at show business proving harder than she thought, while Cordelia begins her discreet inquiries into her father's whereabouts and reputation.
Cordelia's search for Senator Donal leads her to a lavish party he hosts. There, she meets Astrid Donal, a glamorous socialite who is, to Cordelia's surprise, her half-sister. Astrid is engaged to Charlie, a charming young man who is also Cordelia's older brother, though he doesn't recognize her right away. Cordelia is swept into Astrid's glittering, privileged world, a contrast to her own humble background. She observes the social dynamics and the superficiality of the wealthy elite, all while trying to navigate her new family connections and their secrets, especially about her father's true character.
Letty continues to face problems in her pursuit of a Broadway career. After many failed auditions and the harsh realities of the theater world, she is disheartened. However, her beauty catches the eye of Mrs. Van de Meer, a wealthy and influential socialite. Mrs. Van de Meer takes a liking to Letty, offering her a place to stay and introducing her to a more exclusive, though morally questionable, circle of New York society. Letty sees this as a chance to network and gain an advantage, unaware of the potential conditions of such generosity and the compromises she might have to make.
Astrid's seemingly perfect life is marked by deep family secrets and the fragile health of her mother, Mrs. Donal. Her mother suffers from an illness that often leaves her confused and prone to revealing fragmented truths about the past. Astrid protects her mother and tries to keep up the appearance of a happy, respectable family, especially as her engagement to Charlie approaches. She knows about her father, Senator Donal's, affairs and the true circumstances of Cordelia's birth, which she wants to keep hidden from Charlie and the public.
Charlie, despite his charming manner and privileged background, has a gambling addiction. His debts have grown, leading him into dealings with unsavory characters in the city's criminal underworld. He tries to keep his financial problems a secret from Astrid and his family, fearing it will jeopardize his engagement and reputation. His desperation grows, pushing him to consider risky schemes to repay what he owes, which puts him in a dangerous position with loan sharks who are losing patience.
As Cordelia spends more time with Astrid and observes Senator Donal, she begins to understand the truth about her family. She learns that her mother was an actress who had an affair with Senator Donal, resulting in her birth. She also discovers the senator's manipulative nature and how much Astrid's mother has been affected by his actions. The full weight of her father's infidelity and the secrecy around her existence becomes clear, challenging her ideas of family and showing the darker side of the glamorous world she has entered.
Under Mrs. Van de Meer's patronage, Letty gets access to exclusive parties and influential figures, helping her secure a role in a Broadway chorus line. However, this success comes with a price. She is pressured to attend private gatherings, where she is expected to entertain powerful men. Letty struggles with her conscience, torn between her ambition and her fading innocence. She begins to understand the darker side of the entertainment world and the sacrifices many young women make to achieve their dreams, feeling trapped by her circumstances.
Astrid and Charlie's lavish engagement party is a focal point for the converging storylines. All the main characters are present: Cordelia, observing the dynamics; Letty, feeling out of place despite her new connections; Astrid, trying to stay composed amidst her family's secrets; and Charlie, increasingly desperate over his debts. The atmosphere is charged with unspoken truths and simmering resentments. Subtle glances, hushed conversations, and strained interactions hint at the coming unraveling of their lives, setting the stage for a dramatic climax.
Following the engagement party, Charlie mysteriously disappears. His absence causes immediate panic and suspicion, especially among his family and Astrid. It quickly becomes clear that his disappearance is linked to his gambling debts and the dangerous individuals he owed money to. The police are involved, and investigations begin, but there are few immediate answers. The event casts a dark shadow over the Donal family and Astrid, threatening to expose all the secrets they have worked to conceal, and leaving Cordelia worried about her brother's fate.
The investigation into Charlie's disappearance grows, drawing scrutiny to Senator Donal and his family. As secrets begin to unravel, Cordelia, Astrid, and Letty become more involved in the drama. Cordelia, driven by concern for her brother, actively seeks information, often putting herself in danger. Astrid tries to protect her family's reputation while also fearing for Charlie's life. Letty, privy to some of the city's darker corners, can potentially offer clues. The search exposes betrayals, illegal dealings, and the true extent of Senator Donal's manipulative nature.
The search for Charlie takes a tragic turn when a body is discovered. The news sends shockwaves through the Donal family and their social circle. The identity of the victim and the circumstances of their death are initially a mystery, leading to widespread speculation and fear. The discovery confirms the dangerous undercurrents of the glamorous world the characters inhabit and raises the stakes significantly, turning the narrative from a search for a missing person into a murder investigation, implicating several characters in a web of deceit and potential culpability.
The discovery of the body leads to intense confrontations between the main characters. Accusations fly, long-held secrets are finally revealed, and loyalties are tested. Cordelia, Astrid, and Letty are at the center of a dramatic unraveling, each forced to confront their own involvement and the choices they've made. The true culprit is exposed, revealing a surprising betrayal and the devastating consequences of ambition, greed, and deception in the glittering, yet cutthroat, world of 1929 New York. The climax forces each character to face the harsh realities of their individual journeys.
After the revelations and the tragedy, the surviving characters are left to pick up the pieces of their shattered lives. Cordelia, having found her family and lost it in a way, must come to terms with the complex legacy of her father and brother. Astrid faces the ruin of her family's reputation and the loss of her fiancé, forcing her to re-evaluate her life and priorities. Letty, having seen the dark side of ambition, must decide if the price of stardom is worth the sacrifices. The friends, though changed, look towards an uncertain future in a city that has both given them dreams and taken so much away.
The Protagonist
Letty transforms from a naive dreamer into a more jaded, yet resilient, young woman who understands the true cost of ambition.
The Protagonist
Cordelia evolves from a hopeful seeker of family to a disillusioned but stronger individual, having confronted painful truths about her origins.
The Supporting
Astrid's carefully constructed world crumbles, forcing her to shed her facade and face the harsh realities of her family's legacy.
The Supporting
Charlie's arc is tragic, as his hidden vices lead to his downfall and ultimately, his demise.
The Antagonist
Senator Donal's carefully constructed empire begins to crumble as his past catches up to him, exposing his true nature.
The Supporting
Mrs. Van de Meer remains a static character, serving as a catalyst for Letty's moral dilemmas and exposure to the city's darker side.
The Supporting
Mrs. Donal's arc highlights the silent suffering and psychological toll of living with a powerful, deceitful spouse.
The Supporting
Officer Miller's arc is defined by his determined pursuit of justice, ultimately uncovering the truth behind the central mystery.
The novel explores how the pursuit of dreams and social standing can lead characters to make moral compromises. Letty's desire for Broadway stardom drives her into Mrs. Van de Meer's questionable patronage, where she sacrifices her innocence for opportunity. Charlie's ambition to maintain his lavish lifestyle fuels his gambling addiction, leading to his downfall. The Donal family, particularly Senator Donal, shows how unchecked ambition for power and reputation can corrupt individuals and destroy families, as seen in his manipulation and deceit.
“New York was a city of glittering promises, but it demanded a steep price for admission.”
The story relies on the presence of secrets and deception within the glamorous world of 1929 New York. Cordelia's very existence is a secret, hidden by Senator Donal. Astrid struggles to maintain the appearance of her 'perfect' family, concealing her father's affairs and her mother's illness. Charlie's gambling debts are a closely guarded secret that ultimately leads to tragic consequences. These hidden truths create tension, drive the plot, and ultimately unravel the characters' lives, showing the destructive power of prolonged deceit.
“In a city built on appearances, the truth was the most dangerous currency of all.”
The book portrays the glamour of the Roaring Twenties – the lavish parties, flapper fashion, and Broadway lights – but contrasts this with the harsh realities beneath the surface. Letty experiences the cutthroat nature of show business and the exploitation of young women, while Cordelia discovers the moral decay and manipulation within the elite Donal family. The novel suggests that the 'bright young things' often hide unhappiness, moral compromises, and dangerous secrets behind their glittering facades, showing that appearances can be deceiving.
“The city glittered like a jewel, but beneath its polished surface lay a thousand sharp edges.”
Family relationships are central to the plot, exploring themes of belonging, loyalty, and betrayal. Cordelia's search for her father reveals a family fractured by infidelity and deceit, with Senator Donal betraying both his wife and his children through his actions and secrets. Astrid's loyalty to her family is challenged by the truths she must hide. Charlie's actions, driven by personal weakness, ultimately betray the trust of his loved ones. The novel examines how family bonds can be both a source of strength and deep pain, especially when trust is broken.
“Sometimes, the people closest to you held the sharpest knives.”
An object or character that drives the plot forward.
Cordelia's quest to find her estranged father, Senator Donal, serves as a primary MacGuffin. While Senator Donal is a character, his initial role is less about his direct actions and more about being the catalyst for Cordelia's journey into New York's high society. Her search for him introduces her to Astrid, Charlie, and the Donal family's secrets, directly initiating the central conflict and intertwining the lives of the main protagonists. The mystery surrounding him propels the early plot, even as his character gains more active agency later.
The audience knows more than the characters.
Dramatic irony is used effectively, particularly in scenes involving Charlie and his gambling debts. The reader is often aware of Charlie's precarious financial situation and the dangerous individuals he owes money to, while Astrid and the Donal family remain largely oblivious to the full extent of his problems. This creates tension and foreshadows his eventual disappearance and tragic fate, enhancing the reader's sense of dread as they watch the characters unknowingly move towards disaster.
Hints or clues that suggest future events.
The novel employs extensive foreshadowing to build suspense. Mrs. Donal's fragmented statements about the past and her husband's affairs subtly hint at the deep-seated family secrets that will later be revealed. Charlie's increasingly desperate behavior and hushed conversations about money foreshadow his eventual disappearance and the dire consequences of his gambling. Letty's early encounters with the darker side of Broadway society foreshadow the moral compromises she will be forced to make, creating a sense of inevitability and growing tension throughout the narrative.
New York City as a symbol of dreams and danger.
New York City itself functions as a powerful symbol throughout the novel. Initially, it represents opportunity, glamour, and the fulfillment of dreams for Letty and Cordelia. Its glittering facade, lavish parties, and Broadway stages symbolize aspiration and excitement. However, as the story progresses, the city also comes to symbolize danger, corruption, and the harsh realities beneath the surface. It is a place where dreams can be realized but also shattered, and where innocence can be lost, reflecting the duality of the Jazz Age itself.
“New York was a city of love and despair, of hope and broken dreams, a city where anything was possible and nothing was certain.”
— Early description of New York City's allure and danger for the young protagonists.
“She wanted to be a star, not just another face in the crowd. She wanted to shine.”
— Letty's ambition and desire for fame as she arrives in New York.
“Love wasn't a choice, not really. It was a current that swept you away, whether you wanted to go or not.”
— Implied reflection on the powerful, almost fated nature of romance in the story.
“The city had a way of chewing you up and spitting you out, if you weren't careful.”
— Octavia's pragmatic view of New York's harsh realities.
“Every secret was a weight, and the more you carried, the heavier you became.”
— A character's internal struggle with hidden truths.
“He lived for the thrill, for the moment right before everything changed.”
— Percival's adventurous and somewhat reckless personality.
“Sometimes the brightest lights cast the darkest shadows.”
— A commentary on the hidden downsides of fame and glamour.
“They were all chasing something, a dream, a person, a feeling they couldn't quite name.”
— General observation about the motivations of the young characters in the city.
“A lie could be beautiful, if it was told with enough conviction.”
— A cynical view on deception and its power to persuade.
“The past was never truly gone; it just waited for its moment to reappear.”
— The lingering influence of past events on the characters' present.
“She wore her confidence like a shield, but he could see the cracks beneath.”
— An insight into a character's outward demeanor masking inner vulnerability.
“To be truly free, you had to be willing to lose everything.”
— A profound statement on the cost of ultimate freedom.
“The jazz played on, a wild, mournful symphony of longing and joy.”
— Description of the pervasive atmosphere of 1920s New York.
“Sometimes, the only way to find yourself was to get utterly, gloriously lost.”
— A character embracing the unpredictable journey of self-discovery.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.