“I was just a normal kid, not a monster. But that's what everyone called me.”
— Nick's internal struggle with his past actions and public perception.
Archivist's Choice
Breathing Underwater
Alex Flinn (2001)
Genre
Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
240 min
Key Themes
See below
Track Your Reading
Sign in to track this book
Beneath a veneer of perfection, a wealthy and popular teen grapples with his abusive father's legacy, threatening to drown his burgeoning love and his own identity in a cycle of inherited violence.
Synopsis
Sixteen-year-old Nick Andreas seems to have it all: popularity, good looks, and wealth. However, beneath the perfect facade, he lives in fear of his abusive father. When he meets and falls for Caitlin, he finds a confidante and believes his problems are over. Their relationship deepens as they share vulnerabilities, but as the pressure mounts, Nick's inherited anger and jealousy begin to surface. After a first physical incident, Nick apologizes, and they reconcile, but the cycle repeats with a second, more serious incident. The aftermath leads to legal action against Nick, and he is court-mandated to counseling. Through his journal entries, Nick reflects on his actions, confronts the truth about his abusive tendencies, and grapples with seeking forgiveness and breaking the cycle of violence he learned from his father.
Reading time
240 min
Difficulty
Medium
Pacing
Moderate
Mood
Dark, Reflective, Intense, Somber
✓ Read this if...
You are interested in a raw and honest portrayal of an abusive relationship from the abuser's perspective, exploring themes of inherited trauma and the struggle for redemption.
✗ Skip this if...
You prefer lighthearted romance or are sensitive to detailed descriptions of emotional and physical abuse.
Plot Summary
A Journal Begins: Court-Mandated Counseling
Sixteen-year-old Nick Andreas is introduced as a seemingly perfect, popular, and wealthy student at Seaview High. However, he is now facing legal repercussions and is mandated by the court to attend counseling and keep a journal. The journal entries are the primary narrative device, revealing Nick's internal struggles and his version of events. He initially resists the assignment, viewing it as a pointless exercise, but gradually begins to open up, hinting at a troubled past and a controlling, abusive father. His entries are filled with casual observations about school, friends like Tom and Joe, and his growing frustration with the court's requirements, all while subtly foreshadowing the central conflict that led him to this point.
The First Meeting: Nick and Caitlin
Nick details the arrival of Caitlin, a new student, at Seaview High. She is initially quiet and reserved, standing out from the more boisterous crowd. Nick is immediately drawn to her, finding her different and intriguing. He makes an effort to talk to her, and they quickly bond over shared interests and a sense of mutual understanding. Caitlin's vulnerability and genuine nature appeal to Nick, who is used to superficial relationships. Their connection feels immediate, making Nick believe he has found someone with whom he can truly be himself, a stark contrast to his carefully constructed public persona and the oppressive atmosphere at home.
A Budding Romance and Shared Vulnerability
As Nick and Caitlin's relationship deepens, they become inseparable. Nick finds himself falling deeply in love with Caitlin, who offers him a sense of peace and acceptance he's never known. He starts to confide in her about his emotionally abusive and manipulative father, Mr. Andreas, revealing the constant pressure, verbal assaults, and controlling behavior he endures at home. Caitlin is empathetic and supportive, becoming the only person Nick feels he can trust with this dark secret. This shared vulnerability strengthens their bond, and Nick sees Caitlin as his escape and his only hope for a different future, believing she understands his pain.
The Pressure Mounts and Nick's Jealousy
The abuse from Nick's father intensifies, making Nick increasingly volatile and stressed. This external pressure starts to manifest in Nick's behavior towards Caitlin. He becomes overly possessive and jealous, especially when Caitlin interacts with other boys, even innocently. He starts to question her loyalty, demand to know her whereabouts, and exhibit controlling tendencies, mirroring the behavior he despises in his own father. Caitlin notices this shift and becomes increasingly uncomfortable, but Nick, blinded by his own pain and fear, fails to recognize the severity of his actions, believing he is simply protecting their relationship.
The First Physical Incident
During a heated argument, fueled by Nick's jealousy and paranoia, he physically harms Caitlin. The specific incident is initially vague in Nick's journal, but it is implied to be a push or a shove that causes her to fall, or perhaps a grab that leaves a bruise. This act is a turning point, shocking both Nick and Caitlin. Nick is immediately remorseful and horrified by his own actions, realizing he has crossed a line. Caitlin is deeply hurt and scared, and though she initially tries to forgive him, the incident leaves a lasting scar on their relationship and introduces a new, terrifying dynamic.
Apologies and Reconciliation (Temporary)
Following the physical incident, Nick is consumed by guilt and shame. He apologizes profusely to Caitlin, promising it will never happen again and expressing deep regret. He attributes his behavior to the stress from his father and his fear of losing her. Caitlin, still in love with Nick and understanding of his difficult home life, wants to believe him and tries to move past the incident. They reconcile, but the trust between them has been irrevocably damaged. Caitlin remains wary, and Nick struggles internally with the realization that he is capable of such actions, fearing he is becoming like his father.
Escalation: The Second Incident
Despite Nick's promises, his controlling and abusive tendencies resurface and escalate. He becomes increasingly demanding, isolating Caitlin from her friends and monitoring her every move. During another argument, intensified by his paranoia and fear, Nick's violence erupts again, this time more severely than before. The journal entries indicate a more significant physical assault, leaving Caitlin visibly injured and deeply traumatized. This second incident shatters any remaining illusions Caitlin had about Nick's ability to change, and she is left with no choice but to confront the reality of their dangerous relationship.
The Aftermath and Legal Action
After the second, more severe incident, Caitlin decides she can no longer endure Nick's abuse. She reports him to the authorities, likely with the encouragement of her family or friends. This leads to Nick's arrest and the subsequent legal proceedings. He is charged with assault, and as part of his sentencing, he is ordered to attend counseling sessions and keep a journal, which forms the narrative of the book. Nick is initially in denial, feeling victimized and unable to fully grasp the gravity of his actions or the pain he inflicted on Caitlin, clinging to his own perspective of their relationship.
Counseling and Self-Reflection
As Nick continues his counseling sessions with Dr. Leighton and dedicates himself more seriously to his journal, he slowly begins a process of self-reflection. He starts to connect his own abusive behavior towards Caitlin with the emotional and verbal abuse he suffered from his father. He realizes the cycle of violence and control that he has inadvertently perpetuated. The journal becomes a tool for him to confront his denial, acknowledge his mistakes, and understand the psychological roots of his actions. This realization is painful but necessary for his growth and rehabilitation.
Facing the Truth and Seeking Forgiveness
Towards the end of his journal, Nick reaches a critical point of self-awareness. He fully accepts responsibility for the harm he inflicted on Caitlin, no longer blaming external factors or his father entirely for his own choices. He acknowledges the pain he caused and expresses genuine remorse. While he understands that he may never fully earn Caitlin's forgiveness or reconcile with her, he hopes that his journey of self-discovery and commitment to change will allow him to become a better person. The journal concludes with Nick expressing a desire for redemption and a commitment to breaking the cycle of abuse in his own life.
Principal Figures
Nick Andreas
The Protagonist
Nick transforms from a denial-ridden abuser to someone who acknowledges his actions, understands their roots, and commits to breaking the cycle of violence.
Caitlin
The Supporting
Caitlin moves from being a loving, understanding girlfriend to a traumatized victim who ultimately finds the strength to escape the abusive relationship and seek justice.
Mr. Andreas
The Antagonist
His character remains largely static, serving as the origin point for Nick's issues, though his abusive nature is increasingly exposed through Nick's reflections.
Dr. Leighton
The Supporting
Her arc is primarily functional, facilitating Nick's growth and understanding, remaining a consistent, guiding presence.
Tom
The Supporting
Tom's understanding of Nick's situation evolves from casual friendship to a strained awareness of Nick's legal troubles, though his knowledge of the abuse remains limited.
Joe
The Supporting
Joe's character remains static, serving as part of Nick's social backdrop.
Mrs. Andreas
The Mentioned
Her character remains static, largely absent from direct interaction within the narrative, but her passivity is a significant background element.
Judge
The Mentioned
The Judge's role is purely functional, initiating the plot's central device.
Themes & Insights
The Cycle of Abuse
This is the central theme of the novel, exploring how abuse can be perpetuated across generations. Nick, a victim of his father's emotional and verbal abuse, unconsciously replicates these patterns in his relationship with Caitlin. The book portrays how learned behavior, manipulation, and control can become ingrained, even in someone who despises such actions. Nick's journey through his journal is largely about recognizing and attempting to break free from this destructive cycle, acknowledging that being a victim does not excuse becoming an abuser.
“My dad's always telling me what to do, how to act, who to be. I guess I just thought I was doing the same with Caitlin, trying to make her perfect for me. But it wasn't perfect, was it?”
Identity and Self-Discovery
Nick's struggle to understand who he truly is, separate from his father's influence and his popular persona, is a key theme. He grapples with the terrifying realization that he has inherited more than just his father's looks and wealth—he has also inherited his capacity for control and abuse. The journal serves as a tool for Nick to peel back layers of denial and self-deception, ultimately leading him to confront his darker self and begin the arduous process of rebuilding a healthier identity based on accountability and self-awareness, rather than inherited trauma.
“I always thought I was different from him. Better. But when I saw the fear in her eyes, I saw him looking back at me.”
Love and Control
The novel explores the dangerous blurring of lines between love and control within a relationship. Nick genuinely loves Caitlin, but his love becomes intertwined with possessiveness, jealousy, and a desperate need to control her, mirroring his father's behavior. He mistakes control for care, believing he is protecting their relationship when, in reality, he is suffocating and harming Caitlin. The theme highlights how unchecked insecurities and learned abusive patterns can corrupt even genuine affection, turning a loving bond into a destructive one.
“I thought I was protecting her, protecting us. I didn't see that I was just trying to own her, like my dad owns everything around him.”
Accountability and Forgiveness
A major theme is Nick's journey towards accepting full accountability for his actions, rather than deflecting blame onto his father or circumstances. His journal entries chart his painful progression from denial to genuine remorse. The book also implicitly addresses the difficulty and complexity of forgiveness—both self-forgiveness and the possibility (or impossibility) of being forgiven by the victim. Nick ultimately recognizes that while understanding the roots of his behavior is important, it doesn't absolve him of responsibility, and true healing begins with taking ownership.
“It's easy to blame him. Too easy. But I was the one who hurt her. I chose to do that.”
The Power of Narrative and Self-Reflection
The entire novel is about the power of writing and self-reflection as a means of processing trauma and initiating change. Nick's court-mandated journal forces him to articulate his thoughts, feelings, and memories, which he initially resists. However, as he writes, he gradually uncovers truths he had suppressed or denied, leading to insights about his behavior and its origins. The act of writing becomes a therapeutic process, allowing him to gain perspective and begin the difficult work of self-awareness and healing.
“I hate this journal. But sometimes, when I write things down, it's like I see them clearly for the first time. Like I'm not just making excuses anymore.”
Plot Devices & Literary Techniques
First-Person Journal Narration
The entire story is told through Nick's private journal entries.
The novel is exclusively presented as Nick Andreas's journal, a requirement of his court-mandated counseling. This device provides an intimate, subjective, and often unreliable perspective on events. It allows readers direct access to Nick's internal thoughts, denial, rationalizations, and gradual self-awareness. The evolving tone and content of the entries reflect his psychological journey, from initial resistance and blame to eventual acceptance and remorse. It effectively immerses the reader in Nick's mind, creating empathy while also revealing the insidious nature of his abusive thought patterns.
Unreliable Narrator
Nick's perspective is initially biased and self-serving, revealing the truth gradually.
As the story unfolds through Nick's journal, he functions as an unreliable narrator, particularly in the early entries. He initially downplays his actions, rationalizes his behavior, and deflects blame, often portraying himself as a victim of circumstances or his father's influence. This unreliability forces the reader to critically evaluate his account and piece together the true nature of his actions against Caitlin. As Nick progresses in his counseling, his narration slowly becomes more honest and self-aware, reflecting his personal growth and the painful acceptance of his culpability.
Flashbacks and Memory Recall
Nick's journal entries often jump between the present and past events with Caitlin and his father.
Through his journal, Nick frequently recounts past events, detailing his relationship with Caitlin from its innocent beginnings to its violent end, and recalling specific instances of abuse from his father. These flashbacks are not always linear; they emerge as Nick processes his memories and makes connections during his counseling. This device allows the reader to witness the progression of the abuse in both Nick's past and his relationship with Caitlin, illustrating how his upbringing directly influenced his present actions and providing crucial context for his psychological state.
Symbolism of 'Breathing Underwater'
Represents Nick's feeling of suffocation and the struggle to survive emotional turmoil.
The title itself, 'Breathing Underwater,' serves as a powerful symbol. It represents Nick's constant feeling of being overwhelmed and suffocated by his father's abuse, his own internal turmoil, and the pressure to maintain a perfect facade. He feels like he's constantly struggling to stay afloat, unable to truly express himself or find relief. The phrase also metaphorically extends to Caitlin, who is similarly suffocated by Nick's controlling behavior. It encapsulates the emotional struggle for survival and the desperate need to find air and freedom in oppressive circumstances.
Critical analysis
Notable Quotes
“You can't just hit people because you're angry. There are consequences.”
— A lesson Nick slowly learns through therapy and experience.
“Sometimes the hardest thing to do is to forgive yourself.”
— Nick's journey towards self-forgiveness and moving past his mistakes.
“Love isn't supposed to hurt. It's supposed to make you feel safe.”
— Caitlin's realization about the nature of healthy relationships.
“It's not about being perfect. It's about being better than you were yesterday.”
— A recurring theme in Nick's therapy sessions, focusing on progress.
“The past is always there, but it doesn't have to define your future.”
— Nick grappling with his past actions and striving for a different future.
“Sometimes you have to break down to build yourself back up.”
— Reflecting on the emotional turmoil Nick experiences before true healing begins.
“People can change. If they really want to.”
— A hopeful message about the possibility of rehabilitation and personal transformation.
“Silence can be louder than any scream.”
— Referring to the unspoken pain and secrets that characters carry.
“You can't fix someone else until you fix yourself.”
— A realization about the importance of self-work before trying to help others.
“It's hard to breathe underwater, but sometimes you have to learn how.”
— The metaphorical title, referring to enduring difficult situations.
“Just because you're sorry doesn't mean you get to go back to how things were.”
— The reality of consequences and the permanence of some actions.
“Trust is something you earn, not something you demand.”
— Nick learning about rebuilding trust after his actions.
Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
10
Questions
~5
Minutes
?
Best Score
Key Questions (FAQ)
Breathing Underwater tells the story of sixteen-year-old Nick Andreas, who appears to have a perfect life but secretly endures abuse from his wealthy and respected father. His life takes a turn when he falls in love with Caitlin, who becomes his confidante, but Nick struggles with his own escalating anger and controlling tendencies, mirroring his father's behavior.
About the author
Alex Flinn is a best-selling author known for her captivating young adult fantasy novels. Her notable works include "Beastly," a modern retelling of Beauty and the Beast, and "Bewitching," which explores themes of magic and romance. Flinn's imaginative storytelling and relatable characters have earned her a dedicated readership in the fantasy genre.
