“There are some things in this world you just can't change, no matter how badly you want to.”
— Clara reflecting on the unchangeable aspects of her life and destiny.

Cynthia Hand (2013)
Genre
Fantasy / Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
9-10 hours
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
A part-angel torn between two loves and a looming destiny, Clara must accept her supernatural fate to protect those she cares about, even if it means betrayal and sacrifice.
After Jeffrey's death and realizing her angel-blood destiny puts Tucker Avery in danger, Clara Gardner decides to move to California with her mother, Angela, and brother, Jeffrey (who is now a ghost). She hopes the distance will protect Tucker, though it breaks both their hearts. In California, Clara starts a new school, tries to live a 'normal' life, and focuses on her visions and the coming fight with the Black Wings. However, the move does not bring peace; the fallen angel, Zola, who attacked her before, quickly appears, reminding her that her destiny and its threats cannot be avoided.
Just as Clara gets used to her new life, Christian Prescott, the powerful angel-blood boy from her very first vision, shows up again. He is also in California, at the same school. His presence immediately brings back the complicated feelings Clara has for him, feelings she had tried to hide for Tucker. Christian, still in love with Clara, believes they are meant to be together and wants them to explore their connection. This rekindling of their relationship fulfills Clara's initial vision, where she saw herself with Christian, leading to an inner conflict as she balances her love for Tucker and her strong pull toward Christian, who is deeply tied to her angel-blood destiny.
Clara's brother, Jeffrey, who died and came back as a ghost, goes with them to California. He struggles with his new ghost life, unable to touch the physical world and feeling alone. Clara tries to help him find peace, but it is hard. Meanwhile, Clara and Angela find a hidden community of angel-bloods in California, led by Mrs. Abernathy. This community gives Clara new friends and a better understanding of her heritage and the Black Wings. She trains with them, learning to improve her powers and prepare for the war, finding a sense of belonging she had not felt since leaving Wyoming.
Despite Clara's efforts to protect him by leaving, Tucker Avery surprises her by coming to California. He refuses to accept their breakup and wants to win her back, believing their love is strong enough for any danger. Tucker's arrival makes Clara's already complicated emotions even more confused. She is torn between her deep, lasting love for Tucker and her growing connection with Christian, who represents her destiny. Tucker's presence also puts him back in danger, a risk Clara tried hard to prevent, making her feel guilty and responsible for the dangers he now faces by being near her.
The Black Wings, led by Zola, start to increase their attacks, making it clear that Clara is their main target. They show a growing understanding of her abilities and weaknesses, and their methods become more aggressive and personal. These attacks force Clara and the other angel-bloods to stay alert, showing the urgency of their mission. Zola's taunts and direct fights reveal that the Black Wings are not just trying to destroy angel-bloods but have a larger, darker plan to upset the balance between heaven and earth. The threat becomes more real, pushing Clara to face her destiny directly.
With Mrs. Abernathy and other experienced angel-bloods guiding her, Clara trains hard. She learns to better control her visions, improve her fighting skills, and use her unique angel-blood abilities, especially her rare power to 'burn' fallen angels. This training is important for her survival and for her role in the coming war. As she gets stronger, Clara begins to accept her destiny, understanding that she cannot escape it and must use her power to protect those she loves and fight for good. This time marks a big change in her character, moving from hesitant to determined.
As the final battle nears, Clara uncovers a shocking betrayal from someone she trusted within the angel-blood community. This betrayal creates doubt and fear in her, making her question who she can truly rely on. The traitor's identity is a painful discovery, forcing Clara to face the dark side of her world and the sacrifices needed. This act of treachery adds another layer of difficulty to her struggles; she must not only fight the enemy but also deal with the wounds caused by those she thought were on her side. It shows the high stakes and unclear morals of the war.
The expected war between the angel-bloods and the Black Wings finally happens. The battle is fierce and destructive, with both sides losing many. Clara, Christian, Tucker, and the other angel-bloods fight bravely, using all their training and powers. The battle's location is chosen for its spiritual energy, raising the stakes. Clara is at the front, using her unique abilities against the most powerful fallen angels. The fight is not just physical; it is a clash of ideas and destinies, with the future of humanity and the balance of the spiritual world at risk. Sacrifices are made, and the lines between good and evil blur.
At the peak of the battle, Clara faces Zola and the true leader of the Black Wings. She realizes that her unique power and the prophecy about her mean she must make a great sacrifice to end the war. This choice involves her own life and the lives of those she loves. She must decide whether to use her full power, even if it means losing everything dear to her. The decision is agonizing, weighing her love for Tucker and Christian against her duty to protect the world. Her sacrifice is central, showing her growth from a hesitant girl to a powerful, selfless hero.
After the devastating battle and Clara's sacrifice, the war with the Black Wings ends. The immediate aftermath is filled with loss and sadness, but also a sense of hard-won peace. Clara, having fulfilled her destiny, is in a new, changed state, forever altered by the events. The surviving characters must now rebuild and find new paths. Relationships are redefined, and the future, though no longer under the constant threat of the Black Wings, is still uncertain. Clara, though changed, finds a new purpose and understanding of her place in the world, embracing a future without limits.
The Protagonist
Clara transforms from a hesitant, torn teenager into a selfless hero who fully embraces her destiny, making the ultimate sacrifice for the greater good.
The Supporting
Tucker evolves from a protective boyfriend to a man willing to face supernatural dangers for love, accepting Clara's extraordinary life.
The Supporting
Christian remains a steadfast and powerful ally, accepting Clara's ultimate choice and continuing to fight for the angel-blood cause.
The Supporting
Angela continues to be a pillar of strength and guidance, supporting Clara through her ultimate sacrifice and continuing to lead the angel-bloods.
The Supporting
Jeffrey struggles with his ghostly existence, eventually finding a measure of peace or purpose in his unique state.
The Antagonist
Zola remains a consistent and powerful antagonist, ultimately defeated by Clara's sacrifice.
The Supporting
Mrs. Abernathy provides essential guidance and support, helping Clara embrace her destiny.
The main theme is Clara's struggle to balance her angel-blood destiny with her wish for a normal life and the freedom to choose her own path. Her visions constantly draw her to Christian and the supernatural world, while her love for Tucker represents a choice for normalcy. The story explores whether destiny is fixed or if people can change it through their choices. Clara's final decision to make a big sacrifice, while fulfilling a prophecy, is shown as an act of free will, showing her control within her predetermined role. This is clear in her initial hesitation to use her powers versus her eventual acceptance and action in the final battle.
““Maybe destiny is not about what we're meant to do, but what we choose to do when faced with what we're meant to do.””
Love, in its various forms—romantic, family, and selfless—is a strong force and a reason for sacrifice. Clara's love for Tucker makes her leave him to protect him, a painful sacrifice. Her love for Christian is linked to her destiny, suggesting a different kind of sacrifice. In the end, her love for all humanity and her family drives her to make the ultimate sacrifice in the final battle, putting the greater good before her own happiness. The book explores the idea that true love often requires selflessness and a willingness to face pain or loss for others, showing how much love affects individual choices and outcomes.
““Sometimes the greatest love is not in holding on, but in letting go.””
Clara deals with her identity as a part-angel, feeling stuck between the human and supernatural worlds. She wants to belong, struggling to find her place in either world. Moving to California and connecting with a new angel-blood community helps her understand and accept her unique background, giving her a sense of belonging she had not fully felt before. Jeffrey's struggle as a ghost further highlights the theme of identity, as he deals with no longer being fully human or fully part of the living world. The journey shows how accepting who you truly are, even if it is extraordinary, is important for finding peace and purpose.
““We are not just human, and we are not just angel. We are something in between, and that is our strength.””
The clear battle between the angel-bloods (good) and the Black Wings (evil) forms the core of the story. However, the story also looks at moral uncertainty, especially with the discovery of betrayal within the angel-blood ranks. This betrayal forces Clara to question who she can trust and shows that evil can appear even in seemingly good communities. The Black Wings' reasons, though destructive, are shown with some complexity, suggesting that their fallen state comes from a feeling of unfairness. The story explores the constant fight between light and darkness, and the hard choices needed to keep balance.
““The line between good and evil is not always as clear as we wish it to be. Sometimes, it runs right through the middle of a human heart.””
Clara's prophetic glimpses into the future and past.
Clara's visions serve as a primary plot device, guiding her actions and foreshadowing major events. They are often fragmented and cryptic, forcing Clara (and the reader) to interpret their meaning, which sometimes leads to misdirection or delayed understanding. The visions connect her to Christian and her destiny, and also warn her of impending dangers. They are both a blessing and a curse, providing vital information but also burdening Clara with the knowledge of future suffering or difficult choices. They drive the overarching prophecy and the urgency of her mission.
Clara's romantic dilemma between Tucker and Christian.
The love triangle between Clara, Tucker, and Christian is a major source of internal and external conflict. It represents Clara's struggle between a normal human life (Tucker) and her destined supernatural path (Christian). This device creates emotional stakes, complicates her decisions, and highlights the sacrifices she must make. It also serves to develop the characters, revealing their values and loyalties. The resolution of the love triangle is deeply intertwined with Clara's acceptance of her destiny and the ultimate sacrifices she makes.
The antagonistic fallen angels, serving as the primary external threat.
The Black Wings are the main antagonists, a group of fallen angels determined to disrupt the balance between worlds and destroy angel-bloods. They provide the central conflict and drive the plot forward through their escalating attacks and sinister plans. Their existence forces Clara to embrace her powers and fulfill her destiny. They represent the ultimate evil Clara must overcome, symbolizing the forces of chaos and destruction that threaten the world. Their relentless pursuit and growing power create a sense of urgency and danger throughout the narrative.
Jeffrey's return as a ghost, impacting Clara's emotional state and the plot.
Jeffrey's resurrection as a ghost is a unique plot device that adds a layer of emotional complexity and a constant reminder of the stakes. His spectral presence allows him to observe events and sometimes provide warnings, but his inability to fully interact with the world emphasizes the profound consequences of supernatural intervention. It fuels Clara's guilt and her desire to protect those she loves, and his journey to find peace runs parallel to Clara's own struggles with her identity and destiny. It also introduces an element of the ethereal and the blurring of life and death.
“There are some things in this world you just can't change, no matter how badly you want to.”
— Clara reflecting on the unchangeable aspects of her life and destiny.
“Sometimes the hardest thing to do is to let go of what you thought was real.”
— Clara grappling with new revelations and the shifting reality around her.
“Love isn't always about happily ever after. Sometimes it's about making the best of what you have, even if it's not perfect.”
— Clara's evolving understanding of love and relationships amidst difficult circumstances.
“The past isn't just something you remember. It's something you carry with you, always.”
— Clara realizing the lasting impact of past events and choices.
“Every choice has a consequence, and some consequences are harder to live with than others.”
— Clara facing the aftermath of significant decisions she has made.
“Sometimes you have to break a few rules to do what's right.”
— Clara contemplating defying authority for a greater good.
“You can't save everyone, no matter how much you want to.”
— Clara's painful realization about the limits of her power and ability to help others.
“Hope is a dangerous thing. It can keep you going, but it can also break your heart.”
— Clara reflecting on the double-edged nature of hope during challenging times.
“What if the very thing you're running from is the one thing you're meant to be?”
— Clara questioning her identity and destiny.
“Sometimes the greatest strength is knowing when to ask for help.”
— Clara learning to rely on her friends and allies.
“The world isn't black and white. There are shades of gray everywhere, and sometimes the lines are impossible to see.”
— Clara's growing understanding of moral complexity.
“Even when everything feels lost, there's always a flicker of light, if you just know where to look.”
— Clara finding resilience and optimism in dark moments.
“Family isn't always blood. It's the people who stand by you, no matter what.”
— Clara appreciating the bonds she has formed with her chosen family.
“True power isn't about what you can do. It's about what you choose to do.”
— Clara's final realization about the nature of her angelic abilities and free will.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.