“When Hitler came to power I was in the bath.”
— Ruth Becker's opening line, reflecting on the moment she learned of Hitler's rise.

Anna Funder (2011)
Genre
Literary Fiction / Historical Fiction
Reading Time
7-8 hours
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
Four German exiles in 1930s London risk everything to expose the Nazi threat, only to discover that tyranny reaches far beyond their borders, testing their courage and loyalty.
The novel begins in present-day Sydney, Australia. An elderly Ruth Wesemann, now Ruth Becker, hears that her old friend Ernst Toller has died. This news brings back memories of her youth in Germany. She begins to tell her story to an interviewer, recalling the politically active time of the Weimar Republic. Ruth remembers her cousin Dora Fabian, a strong and engaging woman who introduced her to radical intellectual and political groups in Munich and Berlin. Ruth's narration shows her as a survivor dealing with her past, especially the sacrifices and betrayals she saw during the rise of Nazism.
Ruth's flashback goes to Munich in 1923, where she visits her older cousin Dora Fabian, a captivating and independent woman already involved in left-wing politics. Through Dora, Ruth enters a world of political action, intellectual debate, and bohemian life. She meets Hans Wesemann, a young journalist and fellow socialist, and falls in love. Together, they join the anti-fascist movement, participating in protests and discussions, fueled by the unstable political climate after World War I. This time marks Ruth's political awakening and the start of her lifelong fight against injustice, greatly influenced by Dora's radical ideas and Hans's idealism.
Years later, Ruth and Hans are married and living in Weimar Berlin, a city close to political collapse. Dora is also in Berlin, involved with Ernst Toller, a poet and former revolutionary leader. The four friends are a close group, keenly aware of the growing Nazi threat. They continue their anti-fascist work, writing articles, organizing, and speaking out against Hitler's party. However, the political situation quickly worsens, and Hitler's election as Chancellor in January 1933 changes their lives instantly. Their idealism is broken by the new regime's brutal reality, forcing them to face the immediate danger to their lives and their cause.
With Hitler in power, Ruth, Hans, Dora, and Ernst become immediate targets. They are forced to flee Germany, going to London as political refugees. In England, they join a network of German exiles, including other anti-Nazis. Despite the difficulties of exile and the British authorities' doubts, Dora, with her courage and strategic mind, plans a daring mission. She, Hans, and Ruth start gathering information on Nazi activities, smuggling it out of Germany and trying to warn the British government about the true extent of Hitler's aggressive plans and the regime's brutality, which they believe the West underestimates.
Dora Fabian becomes the main person in their intelligence work in London. She makes contacts, including a German double agent, and works to expose Nazi spy rings in Britain. Her goal is to gather clear evidence that the Nazis are not just a German problem, but a threat to European peace and British security. Ruth, often anxious, helps Dora in her secret activities, typing reports and acting as a lookout. Hans, a journalist, uses his skills to spread their findings where he can, facing constant frustration from the British press's unwillingness to publish their warnings. Their work is dangerous, as they are always aware of the Gestapo's reach, even in England.
Their anti-Nazi operations begin to fall apart. Hans Wesemann, despite warnings, is tricked into returning to Germany, believing he can gather information or rescue a contact. This is a trap by Nazi agents. He is captured, imprisoned, and tortured. His disappearance and the lack of news about him devastate Ruth and the group. This event is a turning point, showing the extreme personal cost of their resistance and the Nazi regime's widespread reach. Ruth is left to deal with the painful uncertainty of her husband's survival.
After Hans's capture, Dora becomes more determined but also more paranoid and isolated. She suspects betrayal within the exile community and feels the Gestapo's pursuit growing. Despite the risks, she continues her intelligence work, driven by duty and a desire for revenge for Hans. However, the British authorities, though initially tolerant, become wary of her radical politics and unusual methods. Her apartment is a center of secret activity, but also a place of great tension, as she feels constantly watched and threatened. Ernst Toller tries to support her, but even he struggles to break through her growing isolation and sense of coming doom.
The peak of their London ordeal is the discovery of Dora Fabian and her friend Mathilde Wurm's bodies in Dora's apartment. The official verdict is suicide, but Ruth, and many others, suspect Nazi agents. The circumstances are suspicious: a locked room, gas poisoning, and a note that seems unlike Dora. This double tragedy shatters the remaining hope of the exile group. For Ruth, it is a deep personal loss and a reminder of their enemy's brutality. The deaths silence one of the most effective anti-Nazi voices in London, leaving Ruth with a sense of injustice and a lifelong burden of grief and unanswered questions.
Ernst Toller is deeply affected by Dora's death, dealing with guilt over not being able to protect her and growing despair about their failed efforts. A sensitive man, the weight of political failures and personal losses takes a heavy toll on him. He continues to write and speak against Nazism, but his spirit is broken. He eventually leaves London, seeking refuge in other countries, including the United States, where he continues to advocate for peace. His journey shows the wider spread of German intellectuals and artists who became stateless and disillusioned, haunted by the regime they had fought against.
After the devastating events in London, Ruth eventually moves to Australia, leaving Europe's political unrest behind. She rebuilds her life, raises her children, and finds some peace, but her past trauma remains. The memories of Hans, Dora, Ernst, and the horrors of Nazi Germany are never truly forgotten. The novel returns to present-day Sydney, where Ruth, as an old woman, is finally ready to tell her full story. Her narration is an act of remembrance, a testament to her friends' bravery, and a way to ensure their sacrifices are not forgotten. She carries history's weight, a silent witness to a time of resistance and its tragic results.
The Protagonist
From a politically awakened young woman to a traumatized survivor, Ruth's arc is about bearing witness and finding the courage to articulate her painful past.
The Supporting
From a revolutionary idealist to a desperate but determined resistance fighter, her arc ends in tragic martyrdom.
The Supporting
From a hopeful activist to a tragic victim of Nazi brutality, his arc underscores the personal cost of resistance.
The Supporting
From a revolutionary poet to a disillusioned exile, his arc reflects the profound despair of those who failed to stop Nazism.
The Supporting
Her arc is brief but tragic, a testament to the indiscriminate danger faced by anti-Nazis in exile.
The Mentioned
To receive and document Ruth's testimony, ensuring the story is preserved.
The Mentioned
To provide crucial, though risky, intelligence to the anti-Nazi exiles.
The novel explores courage in the face of great evil. Characters like Dora Fabian show almost reckless bravery, risking their lives to expose Nazi crimes and warn an indifferent world. Ruth, though more careful, shows her own quiet courage by helping Dora and by telling her friends' stories. The theme highlights the moral need to resist injustice, even when the odds are impossible, and the personal cost of such defiance. Their acts of resistance, though often unsuccessful, show the human spirit's ability to resist.
“"The world needed to know. It needed to know what was coming. And we were the only ones who could tell them."”
Betrayal appears in many ways in the story: Germany's betrayal by its own people under Nazism, the betrayal of trust within the exile community, and the British government's perceived inaction. Hans's capture is a direct result of betrayal, and Dora's death is strongly suspected to be a Nazi operation. The characters feel deep disappointment as their warnings are met with doubt and indifference, and their hopes for a better Germany are crushed. This theme shows the damaging psychological impact of constant danger and the loss of trust.
“"We had been so certain of the truth, so certain that if we just presented the facts, people would see. We were wrong."”
The entire story is framed by Ruth remembering and telling her past. As an elderly woman, she feels a responsibility to tell the lives and sacrifices of her friends, especially Dora and Hans, whose stories might otherwise be forgotten. The novel emphasizes the importance of historical memory, particularly when official histories might overlook those who resisted. Ruth's narration is an act against erasing these lives, showing the power of individual memory in shaping how we understand history.
“"I was the one who survived. And with survival comes a duty. To remember. To tell."”
The characters, especially Hans and Dora, are driven by strong beliefs in justice, socialism, and the power of truth. However, the novel clearly shows the high price of such beliefs when facing a brutal, totalitarian regime. Their commitment leads to exile, danger, torture, and eventually death for many. The British authorities' practical refusal to fully believe or act on their warnings further highlights the conflict between ideals and political realities. The story explores how strong belief can lead to great sacrifice and heartbreak when faced with an unyielding and evil force.
“"We believed in words, in reason. They believed in force. And force always wins, in the end, doesn't it?"”
The experience of exile is central to the characters' lives. Stripped of their homeland, citizenship, and often their jobs, they struggle to find new identities in a foreign land. London offers refuge but is not home, and they face suspicion, bureaucracy, and indifference. The constant threat of the Gestapo means they can never truly feel safe. This theme explores the psychological toll of displacement, the longing for a lost country, and the burden of carrying a past that their new surroundings misunderstand or ignore. Their identity becomes tied to their resistance.
“"We were ghosts, haunting the streets of a city that didn't want to see us. German ghosts."”
An elderly Ruth in present-day Sydney recounts her past in Weimar and wartime Europe.
The novel employs a dual timeline, alternating between the elderly Ruth in present-day Sydney and her vivid recollections of her youth in Germany and her time in exile in London during the 1920s and 1930s. The present-day frame narrative, triggered by the news of Ernst Toller's death, allows Ruth to reflect on her experiences with the wisdom and sorrow of hindsight. This structure creates suspense, as the reader knows the tragic outcome for many characters, but not the specific details, and deepens the emotional impact by contrasting the vibrant past with the reflective present.
The entire story is filtered through the subjective memories and interpretations of Ruth Wesemann.
The entire novel is narrated in the first person by Ruth Wesemann. This provides an intimate and deeply personal perspective on the tumultuous historical events. Ruth's voice is both a witness and a participant, allowing the reader to experience the fear, love, hope, and despair directly through her eyes. Her subjective memory shapes the narrative, creating a sense of authenticity and vulnerability. It also raises questions about the reliability of memory and the way individuals construct their personal histories, especially when dealing with trauma and loss.
Real historical figures (Dora Fabian, Hans Wesemann, Ernst Toller) are dramatized as key characters.
Anna Funder meticulously researches and incorporates real historical figures into her fictional narrative. Dora Fabian, Hans Wesemann, and Ernst Toller were actual anti-Nazi activists and intellectuals. By weaving their documented lives and actions into Ruth's fictionalized account, the novel blurs the lines between history and fiction, lending authenticity and weight to the story. This device allows Funder to explore the personal lives, motivations, and emotional struggles of these figures, humanizing the historical record and making the past more immediate and relatable for the reader.
A pervasive atmosphere of distrust and fear permeates the lives of the exiles.
From the moment the characters flee Germany, an intense atmosphere of suspicion and paranoia becomes a constant presence. The exiles are aware of Nazi spies and agents operating in London, leading to constant vigilance, distrust even among their own ranks, and the fear of betrayal. This device creates a palpable sense of tension and danger throughout the narrative, culminating in the suspicious deaths of Dora and Mathilde. It effectively conveys the psychological toll of living under constant threat and highlights the insidious reach of totalitarian regimes.
“When Hitler came to power I was in the bath.”
— Ruth Becker's opening line, reflecting on the moment she learned of Hitler's rise.
“We are all refugees from our own pasts.”
— Ruth reflecting on the displacement and loss experienced by the characters.
“To remain silent and indifferent is the greatest sin of all.”
— Dora Fabian's belief in the moral imperative to resist tyranny.
“Memory is a tricky thing. It is not a fixed record, but a story we tell ourselves.”
— Ruth contemplating the unreliable nature of her recollections.
“We were the lucky ones. We got out.”
— Ruth acknowledging the survival of some while many others perished.
“The world is divided into those who watch and those who act.”
— Dora's philosophy on political engagement and resistance.
“Love in a time of danger is a different kind of love.”
— Reflecting on the relationships formed under the threat of persecution.
“We carried our country in our hearts, because we could not carry it in our suitcases.”
— Describing the emotional burden of exile for German dissidents.
“Fear is a habit. Courage is a choice.”
— A thought on overcoming the paralyzing effects of fear under oppression.
“The past is not dead. It is not even past.”
— Echoing Faulkner, Ruth on how history continues to influence the present.
“We wrote our protests on the air, and the wind took them away.”
— Metaphor for the futility and necessity of resistance efforts in exile.
“To forget is to betray.”
— The moral duty to remember those who suffered and resisted.
“In the end, all we have are the stories we leave behind.”
— Ruth on the importance of narrative and testimony for future generations.
“The body remembers what the mind tries to forget.”
— On the physical and psychological scars of trauma and exile.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.