“I'm not sure what I'm more afraid of: the dates themselves or the fact that my family thinks this is a good idea.”
— Sophie expresses her anxiety about her family setting her up on ten blind dates after a breakup.

Ashley Elston (2019)
Genre
Young Adult / Romance
Reading Time
270 min
Key Themes
See below
Sign in to track this book
After a hard breakup, Sophie navigates a chaotic Christmas in Louisiana. Her eccentric family sets up ten mismatched blind dates, making her rethink love when her ex returns and new feelings start.
Seventeen-year-old Sophie Gracin is excited for Christmas break. She plans to spend it with her boyfriend, Griffin, while her parents are busy with her pregnant older sister, Chelsea, in Louisiana. Sophie imagines romantic time alone with Griffin, finally away from her overprotective parents. However, just before she leaves for Louisiana, Griffin unexpectedly breaks up with her, saying he needs space and freedom before college. Devastated, Sophie has to go to her grandparents' house in Louisiana, where her large, boisterous Italian family has gathered for the holidays. Her nonna, seeing Sophie's sadness, creates a plan: Sophie will go on ten blind dates, each set up by a different family member, over the next ten days.
Sophie's first date is set up by her sweet cousin, Sara. She goes to a secret, exclusive house party where she meets Zach, a charming college student. The date is fun, showing her a different social scene. But it ends suddenly when Zach has to leave for a family emergency. The second date, arranged by her Aunt Patrice, is a disaster. Sophie plays Mary in a living nativity scene, paired with a short, awkward boy named Noah and a screaming baby. The experience is embarrassing but also funny, showing the varied and often strange nature of her family's matchmaking.
Date number three is a chaotic ice-skating trip set up by her Uncle Joe. Sophie is paired with a boy more interested in showing off than talking to her, making for a clumsy and forgettable time. Her fourth date, arranged by her cousin Gina, is a charity event. Here, she is surprisingly paired with Zach again, the same guy from her first date. They have a more relaxed and enjoyable conversation, with Zach explaining why he left abruptly before. This second meeting with Zach sparks an interest in Sophie, making her wonder if the blind date plan might actually work.
Date number five, set up by her Grandpa Gracin, is a movie night with a boring boy who spends the whole time on his phone. Sophie realizes she is not enjoying the process. The sixth date, arranged by her Grandma Gracin (Nonna), is a cooking class. Here, she is paired with a boy named Wilder. Though he seems reserved at first, Wilder is kind, and they have a pleasant time learning to cook. Sophie starts to feel a real connection, enjoying his quiet humor and thoughtful way, which further complicates her feelings.
Just as Sophie begins to enjoy the blind dates and develop feelings for Zach and Wilder, Griffin unexpectedly shows up in Louisiana. He says he regrets breaking up with her, claiming he made a mistake and wants her back. Griffin's sudden return confuses Sophie. She still has some feelings for him, but she has also enjoyed the freedom and new experiences the blind dates have brought, and she is starting to like Zach and Wilder. Her family, especially her Nonna, tells her to consider her options carefully, warning her not to rush back to Griffin just because he is familiar.
While Griffin tries to win her back, Sophie continues her blind dates. Date number seven, set up by her Uncle Tony, is a bowling outing with a competitive and slightly arrogant guy. The date shows her the different types of people she is meeting. Date number eight, arranged by her Aunt Rose, is a visit to a local library with a quiet, intellectual boy named Ethan. This date is engaging, as Ethan shares her love for books, and they have an interesting conversation, showing Sophie another kind of companionship beyond typical romance.
Date number nine, set up by her brother, is a casual family gathering. It is not much of a date but shows the importance of family in her life. The tenth and final date is set up by her mother. It turns out her mother, knowing Sophie's true feelings, has arranged for her to meet with Wilder again. This second focused interaction with Wilder confirms Sophie's growing affection for him. However, a problem arises when Sophie learns that Wilder is actually Chelsea's ex-boyfriend from years ago, making him off-limits due to family history and the perceived awkwardness.
On Christmas Eve, the pressure increases as Griffin makes a big gesture, trying to win Sophie back for good. Sophie is torn between her past relationship with Griffin, the exciting possibility with Zach, and the genuine, unexpected connection she feels with Wilder, despite the family issues. The family's blind date experiment has made her rethink what she wants in a partner and for herself. She realizes that her relationship with Griffin had become stale and that she has grown much through the blind date experience, finding confidence and clarity.
Sophie finally talks to Griffin, telling him she cannot go back to their old relationship because she has changed and realized they are no longer right for each other. She also has an honest conversation with Wilder about their complicated situation, acknowledging her feelings for him while understanding the family history. While she does not immediately start a relationship with Wilder due to the family dynamics and Chelsea's past, she leaves the door open for a future. The experience has taught her to be more independent and to trust her own judgment, leading to a more self-assured Sophie ready for new beginnings.
Christmas Day arrives with Chelsea giving birth to her baby, bringing joy and new life to the family gathering. Sophie, having made her decisions, feels a sense of peace and clarity. She has learned about love, family, and self-discovery. While her romantic future with Wilder is uncertain due to his past with Chelsea, there is a clear mutual attraction and a hint of a future. Sophie realizes that the blind dates were not just about finding a new boyfriend, but about finding herself and understanding what she truly wants in a relationship and in life. She embraces her independence and the love of her family, looking forward to the future with hope.
The Protagonist
Sophie transforms from a heartbroken and dependent girlfriend into an independent young woman who understands her own desires and stands up for herself.
The Supporting
Griffin attempts to revert to his past relationship with Sophie but ultimately faces her rejection as she moves on.
The Supporting
Nonna consistently guides Sophie through her heartbreak, helping her to understand her own value and desires.
The Supporting
Wilder emerges as a strong contender for Sophie's affections, despite the obstacles of his past relationship with her sister.
The Supporting
Zach provides an appealing, less complicated romantic option for Sophie, helping her realize she can move on from Griffin.
The Supporting
Chelsea experiences the birth of her first child, bringing new life and a focal point for the family's celebration.
The Supporting
Aunt Patrice remains a constant source of eccentric humor and family involvement.
The Supporting
Sara consistently offers friendship and support to Sophie throughout her dating adventures.
This theme is about Sophie's self-discovery after her breakup. The blind dates, arranged by her family, push her out of her comfort zone. She re-evaluates what she wants in a partner and for herself. She learns to trust her instincts, recognize her own worth, and understand that her identity is not only tied to her relationship status. The process helps her mature and gain confidence in making her own decisions about her future.
“Maybe it wasn't about finding the perfect guy. Maybe it was about finding myself.”
Sophie's large, Italian family is important in the novel. While their involvement can be overwhelming, their love and support help Sophie through her heartbreak. Each family member's way of setting up a date shows their personality and their shared wish for Sophie's happiness. The family provides support, humor, and a constant feeling of belonging, even when Sophie feels lost.
“Sometimes, the people who know you best are the ones who can surprise you the most.”
The novel explores different parts of love and relationships, making Sophie look past her comfortable, long-term relationship with Griffin. Through the blind dates, she meets various people and dynamics, learning that attraction can appear in unexpected ways. This theme shows that true connection is not always immediate or perfect, and sometimes, a familiar love can stop you from growing. It also covers the complexities of new love interests and past relationships.
“The truth was, I wasn't just looking for someone new. I was looking for something new inside myself.”
Sophie initially wants freedom from her parents, but her breakup with Griffin pushes her into a different kind of independence. The blind dates, though family-driven, empower her to make her own choices about who she wants to be with and what she values. She learns to be self-reliant, make difficult decisions, and define her own path, rather than being influenced by outside pressures or past comfort. Her journey is about accepting a more independent and self-reliant future.
“I realized that freedom wasn't just about being away from my parents. It was about being free to be myself.”
A structured narrative device for Sophie's journey of self-discovery.
This is the central plot device, a literal challenge set by Nonna for Sophie to go on ten blind dates, each arranged by a different family member. It provides a clear structure for the narrative, with each date serving as a distinct mini-adventure that introduces new characters, comedic situations, and opportunities for Sophie's growth. The sequential nature of the dates allows Sophie to progressively learn more about herself and what she desires in a relationship, while also providing opportunities for recurring characters like Zach and Wilder to reappear.
A source of both comedic chaos and unwavering support.
Sophie's large, opinionated, and loving Italian family acts as a collective plot device. They are the driving force behind the blind dates, each member bringing their own personality to their matchmaking attempts, leading to varied and often hilarious outcomes. The family provides constant comedic relief through their antics and meddling, but also acts as a strong support system, offering advice, comfort, and a sense of belonging that helps Sophie navigate her heartbreak and self-discovery. Their strong presence underscores the theme of family importance.
A romantic obstacle that adds tension and challenges Sophie's choices.
The revelation that Wilder, one of Sophie's most promising blind dates, is her older sister Chelsea's ex-boyfriend, serves as a significant romantic plot device. This complication creates immediate tension and conflict, making any potential relationship with Wilder taboo and difficult. It forces Sophie to confront not only her feelings for Wilder but also her loyalty to her sister and the unspoken rules of her family. This device elevates the romantic stakes and forces Sophie to make a more mature and complex decision about her heart.
“I'm not sure what I'm more afraid of: the dates themselves or the fact that my family thinks this is a good idea.”
— Sophie expresses her anxiety about her family setting her up on ten blind dates after a breakup.
“Sometimes the best things happen when you least expect them.”
— Sophie reflects on an unexpected positive outcome from one of her blind dates.
“Family can be your biggest support system and your biggest headache, all at the same time.”
— Sophie muses on the chaotic yet loving nature of her large family during the dating experiment.
“It's not about finding the perfect person; it's about finding the person who's perfect for you.”
— Sophie learns a lesson about love and compatibility through her diverse dates.
“A little chaos never hurt anyone. In fact, it might just lead you to where you're supposed to be.”
— Sophie embraces the unpredictable nature of her dating adventures.
“You can't plan for everything. Sometimes you just have to go with the flow.”
— Sophie advises a friend or reflects on her own need to control situations.
“Love isn't always a grand gesture. Sometimes it's in the small, quiet moments.”
— Sophie realizes this during a simple, heartfelt interaction on a date.
“Being yourself is the best way to find someone who truly appreciates you.”
— Sophie learns to be authentic rather than trying to impress her dates.
“Holidays are about family, even when they're driving you crazy.”
— Sophie comments on spending the Christmas season with her meddling relatives.
“Every date is a story waiting to be told, and I'm the author of my own.”
— Sophie adopts a positive, narrative-driven perspective on her dating experiences.
“It's okay to be scared. It means you're about to do something brave.”
— Sophie encourages herself or someone else to face fears, like going on blind dates.
“The heart wants what it wants, even if it doesn't make sense to anyone else.”
— Sophie reflects on following her feelings despite external opinions.
“Laughter is the best medicine, especially when your love life is a disaster.”
— Sophie finds humor in the awkward or failed moments of her dates.
“Sometimes you have to get lost to find yourself.”
— Sophie discovers more about her own desires and identity through the dating process.
“Home isn't just a place; it's the people who make you feel like you belong.”
— Sophie appreciates her family's love and support during her romantic ups and downs.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.